(EDITORIAL from Korea Herald on Jan. 13)

Asia's Tech News Daily

Misguided innovation
Unprecedented stock option exercises by Kakao Pay executives raise ethical questions

The dispute over the mass stock selling by Kakao Pay executives continues to reverberate, suggesting the depth of the problems with their technically legal yet governance-wise irresponsible decision that was fairly “innovative” — so much so that authorities are expected to use the scandal to ratchet up regulations against online startups.

Kakao Pay, a mobile payment unit of Kakao, which operates the country’s dominant mobile messenger Kakao Talk, was once touted as a shining example of fintech innovation. But its public image plunged to a nadir with the controversial exercise of stock options by Kakao Pay chief Ryu Young-joon and seven other executives on Dec. 10.

By selling around 440,000 shares, they received nearly 90 billion won (US$75.6 million), about half of which was pocketed by Ryu.

The top managers of Kakao Pay tried to justify their moves by saying that the options were exercised through after-hours block trading and there was no violation of the law.

Their excuses for taking such huge profits failed to calm nervous shareholders, as the stock dumping led to a steep slide in share prices of not only Kakao Pay but its affiliates.

Kakao Pay CEO Ryu withdrew from the procedure to become the co-CEO of Kakao, amid a firestorm of criticism from the company’s labor union, lawmakers and retail investors.

Why was the backlash so fast and furious? The main reason is that Ryu and other executives made a fatal mistake of ignoring one of the unwritten yet fundamental principles of responsible executives.

Given that Kakao Pay managed to get listed on the local stock market in November last year through an initial public offering, the mass stock option exercises by top managers in the following month are widely seen as unprecedented and, more importantly, a result of their greed to reap quick profits at the expense of investors.

For a fintech company like Kakao Pay, such concerted move raised questions about whether its parent Kakao can maintain proper corporate governance, at a time when the latter’s rapid expansion by gobbling up smaller startups invited both public criticism and regulators’ attention.

If Kakao’s management failed to see what would result from exercising the stock option, it implies it is utterly incompetent. If Kakao okayed the move with the full knowledge of its potential impact, it suggests its governance system is deeply flawed, if not near-absent. Either way, the latest incident illustrates how a legally legitimate yet ethically questionable corporate act could backfire, setting off a chain of ripple effects.

Aside from the ethical dispute, the scandal has brought about three regrettable outcomes. First, the incident confirms that when corporate greed breeds misdeeds, it is almost always individual investors who suffer the most. Worries remain about Kakao’s other affiliates such as Kakao Mobility and Kakao Entertainment that are pushing for IPOs.

Second, regulators have been given a great excuse to put up more regulations against startups, citing poor governance. This could reverse years of demand for authorities to loosen regulations.

Third, the scandal sets a bad example by sending a misguided signal to other startups that are equally keen to take quick profits as long as methods are technically legal.

Corporate greed is nothing new, but what happened at Kakao Pay is uber-inventive in a way that shocks shareholders with plunging stock prices and hard-working startups with extra regulations.

To prevent future fly-by-night practices, financial authorities should tighten up IPO screening for tech firms and Kakao must take all possible steps to overhaul its malfunctioning governance rules.
(END)

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

OPEC maintains forecast for oil demand growth of 4.2 mln bpd in 2022

In 2022, demand is expected to increase to 100.8 mln bpd Read more »

New business residents plan to invest almost $328 million in Arkhangelsk Region

The new residents plan to organize more than 2,000 jobs Read more »

Germany interested in cooperation on renewable energy with Russia, top diplomat says

The German foreign minister noted that Russia has a huge potential in the field of green hydrogen Read more »

Nord Stream 2 politicizing is counterproductive, Lavrov says

Earlier, the German Federal Network Agency said that it suspended the process of Nord Stream 2 AG certification as an independent gas pipeline operator Read more »

Meta Platforms appeals turnover-based fine worth $24.8 mln — court

The court is to consider the company’s complaint on February 15 Read more »

Kremlin urges not to believe speculation about alleged sanctions against Russian banks

Dmitry Peskov also recalled that representatives of the SWIFT system had previously said that it was virtually impossible to disconnect Russia from it Read more »

Russian Railways to use extra locomotives on Baikal-Amur Mainline — company

Shipments of goods in Russia gained 5% from the start of January Read more »

Cabinet decides to postpone Russian Investment Forum from February to later dates, says PM

The forum was cancelled in 2020 and 2021 due to the coronavirus pandemic Read more »

Hyundai, Kia sales in Europe exceed 1 mln units in 2021

SEOUL, Jan. 18 (Yonhap) — Hyundai Motor Co. and its affiliate Kia Corp.’s sales jumped 21 percent on-year to exceed 1 million units in Europe last year on environment-friendly models, ... Read more »

(2nd LD) S. Korea aims to minimize market impact of extra budget-related bond sale: official

(ATTN: ADDS more info in para 8) SEOUL, Jan. 18 (Yonhap) — South Korea plans to sell similar amounts of state bonds over periods in a bid to minimize its ... Read more »

TikTok posts feedback form under ‘localization' law, says Russian regulator

Under the law, overseas Internet companies with a daily audience exceeding 500,000 users must open their authorized representative offices in Russia Read more »

S. Korea aims to minimize market impact of extra budget-related bond sale: official

SEOUL, Jan. 18 (Yonhap) — South Korea plans to sell similar amounts of state bonds over periods in a bid to minimize its impact on the government bond market as ... Read more »

Lottery sales hit all-time high in 2021 amid COVID-19 pandemic

SEOUL, Jan. 18 (Yonhap) — Lottery sales in South Korea rose 10.3 percent on-year to reach an all-time high last year amid the COVID-19 pandemic, data showed Tuesday. Sales of ... Read more »

Yandex, KT Corporation to launch robotic couriers in Seoul

South Korea is the first East Asian market where Yandex autonomous delivery robots will start operating Read more »

Unit 2 of Belarusian NPP to be launched in February — Rosatom

Director General of Russia’s state-run nuclear corporation Alexey Likhachev said that right now, the colleagues are waiting for a permission to switch to minimum controlled reactor power Read more »

MOEX index up 0.32% to 3,571.89 points at trade start

The price of WTI crude oil futures went up by 1.27% Read more »

Dollar grows to 76.13 rubles on Moscow Exchange

The euro slides to 86.55 rubles Read more »

Construction of El Dabaa NPP in Egypt to begin in July - Rosatom

The El Dabaa nuclear power plant will be the first nuclear power plant in Egypt Read more »

Brent oil reaches $87 per barrel on ICE for first time since 2014

The price of $87 per barrel was last registered in October 2014 Read more »

Russia's turnover-based fines for Google, Meta amount to 5% of income

The judge sees no grounds to impose a penalty below the statutory minimum Read more »

Export cargo loading on Russian Railways' network up 3.2% to record 490 mln tonnes in 2021

Over the past decade export railway shipments added one quarter Read more »

Liquified petroleum gas to be sold based on local authorities' requests in Kazakhstan

The energy ministry is authorized to distribute liquified petroleum gas on the domestic market outside the electronic trading platform for those new categories of entities Read more »

Moldova and Gazprom plan to update gas supplies contract - Moldovan deputy PM

Moldovagaz and Gazprom signed a five-year contract on gas supplies in October 2021 Read more »

EAEU members to draft proposals on amendments to International Health Regulations

The parties discussed the current epidemiological situation in view of the Omicron coronavirus strain spreading worldwide Read more »

Govt reaps over Rs 6,600 crore as dividend from dozen CPSEs

Representational image. The government has received about Rs 6,600 crore as dividend tranches from a dozen Central Public Sector Enterprises (CPSEs), including GAIL, NMDC and Power Grid. “Government has received ... Read more »

Container terminal to be built in Caspian seaport — governor

According to Igor Babushkin, the terminal will be developed in two stages and will support transshipment of eight million tonnes of cargo by the end of 2030 Read more »

Nord Stream 2 not fully compliant with European law — Germany's Foreign Minister

The certification process has been suspended therefore, Annalena Baerbock noted Read more »

Taste of the Arctic gastronomy festival in Murmansk attracts more than 6,000 people

The festival opened in Murmansk on Friday, January 14 Read more »

Nord Stream 2 certification should not be politicized by German regulators — MFA

It was noted that the gas pipeline should fully comply with European law for the positive conclusion to be given by the German regulator Read more »

"Oh, God! Where am I?" About the ‘solo-traveling legend' who crossed Taimyr on her own

A TASS correspondent, Vera Kostamo, joined the crew of Mikhail Somov research/survey vessel to cover the seventh voyage in 2021 to its final destination - to the Wrangel Island, and back Read more »

Global unemployment will total 207 mln people in 2022, 21 mln more than in 2019 — UN

According to the report, countries with high per capita incomes show a stronger recovery in the labor market, while the situation in the countries with lower middle incomes is worse Read more »

Aeroflot to fully resume flights to Kazakhstan starting January 22

Flights to Aktau and Shymkent will be operated once a week Read more »

Moneycontrol Pro Panorama | China's growth sprint showing signs of fatigue

(Image: Reuters) Dear Reader, The Panorama newsletter is sent to Moneycontrol Pro subscribers on market days. It offers easy access to stories published on Moneycontrol Pro and gives a little ... Read more »

Hainan culture and tourism sphere fully recover from 2021 pandemic – media

According to the Hainan Daily, 81 million tourists visited the island Read more »

Decarbonization may shift focus of geological exploration to search for gas — Rosgeo CEO

Sergey Gorkov noted that exploration itself has a minimal carbon footprint Read more »

Finance chief rejects ruling party's call to expand extra budget

SEOUL, Jan. 17 (Yonhap) — Finance Minister Hong Nam-ki on Monday opposed the ruling party’s call to increase the size of the government-proposed extra budget. The finance ministry is working ... Read more »

Additional rate hike adding to woes of young, low-income borrowers

Bank of Korea headquarters in central Seoul / Korea Times file By Yi Whan-woo An additional hike in key interest rate as hinted by Bank of Korea (BOK) chief is ... Read more »

Rio De Janeiro to invest 1% of treasury in cryptocurrency

Paes plans to establish tax incentives and discounts for those who pay with bitcoin.  Rio de Janeiro will invest one percent of its Treasury in cryptocurrencies to turn the city ... Read more »

Australian economic resilience points to higher wages, lower prices, more jobs

Wages are finally expected to grow faster than prices next year but there are som industries that will benefit more than others. A new report by Deloitte said Australia was ... Read more »

Finance chief calls for stern actions against property-related tax evasion

SEOUL, Jan. 17 (Yonhap) — Finance Minister Hong Nam-ki called Monday for stern actions against tax evasion related to real estate deals as he renewed the government’s commitment to stabilizing ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic