A US small-town mayor sued the oil industry. Then Exxon went after him

Asia's Tech News Daily

Serge Dedina is a surfer, environmentalist and mayor of Imperial Beach, a small working-class city on the California coast.

He is also, if the fossil fuel industry is to be believed, at the heart of a conspiracy to shake down big oil for hundreds of millions of dollars.

Imperial Beach, California

ExxonMobil and its allies have accused Dedina of colluding with other public officials across California to extort money from the fossil-fuel industry. Lawyers even searched his phone and computer for evidence he plotted with officials from Santa Cruz, a city located nearly 500 miles north of Imperial Beach.

The problem is, Dedina had never heard of a Santa Cruz conspiracy. Few people had.

“The only thing from Santa Cruz on my phone was videos of my kids surfing there,” Dedina said. “I love the fact that some lawyer in a really expensive suit, sitting in some horrible office trying to find evidence that we were in some kind of conspiracy with Santa Cruz, had to look at videos of my kids surfing.”

That’s where the laughter stopped.

The lawyers found no evidence to back up their claim. But that did not stop the industry from continuing to use its legal muscle to try to intimidate Dedina, who leads one of the poorest small cities in the region.

The mayor became a target after Imperial Beach filed a lawsuit against ExxonMobil, Chevron, BP and more than 30 other fossil-fuel companies demanding they pay the huge costs of defending the city from rising seas caused by the climate crisis.

Imperial Beach’s lawsuit alleges the oil giants committed fraud by covering up research showing that burning fossil fuels destroys the environment. The industry then lied about the evidence for climate change for decades, deliberately delaying efforts to curb carbon emissions.

The city’s lawsuit was among the first of a wave of litigation filed by two dozen municipalities and states across the US that could cost the fossil-fuel industry billions of dollars in compensation for the environmental devastation and the deception.

Dedina says his minority majority community of about 27,000 cannot begin to afford the tens of millions of dollars it will cost to keep at bay the waters bordering three sides of his financially strapped city. The worst of recent storms have turned Imperial Beach into an island.

One assessment calculated that, without expensive mitigation measures, rising sea levels will eventually swamp some of the city’s neighbourhoods, routinely flood its two schools and overwhelm its drainage system.

Imperial Beach’s annual budget is $20m. Exxon’s chief executive, Darren Woods, was paid more than $15m last year.

“We don’t have a pot to piss in in this city. So why not go after the oil companies?” he said. “The lawsuit is a pragmatic approach to making the people that caused sea level rise pay for the impacts it has on our city.”

Interactive

That’s not how Exxon, the US’s largest oil company, saw it. Its lawyers noted that Imperial Beach filed its case in July 2017, at the same time as two California counties, Marin and San Mateo. The county and city of Santa Cruz followed six months later with similar suits seeking compensation to cope with increasing wildfires and drought caused by global heating.

Exxon alleged that the sudden burst of litigation, and the fact that the municipalities shared a law firm specialising in environmental cases, Sher Edling, was evidence of collusion.

Exxon filed lawsuits claiming the municipalities conspired to extort money from the company by following a strategy developed during an environmental conference at the Scripps Institution of Oceanography in La Jolla, 25 miles north of Imperial Beach, nine years ago.

The meeting, organised by the Climate Accountability Institute and the Union of Concerned Scientists, produced a report outlining how legal strategies used by US states against the tobacco industry in the 1990s could be applied to cases against fossil fuel companies.

Dedina was also targeted by one of the US’s biggest business groups at the forefront of industry resistance to increased regulation to reduce greenhouse gases, the National Association of Manufacturers, and a rightwing thinktank, the Energy & Environment Legal Institute.

The manufacturing trade group was behind the efforts to obtain data from Dedina’s phone and documents in 2018. In its public disclosure request to the mayor’s office, NAM called Imperial Beach’s lawsuit “litigation based on political or ideological objections more appropriately addressed through the political process”.

Exxon is attempting to use a Texas law that allows corporations to go on a fishing expedition for incriminating evidence by questioning individuals under oath even before any legal action is filed against them. The company is trying to force Dedina, two other members of Imperial Beach’s government, and officials from other jurisdictions, to submit to questioning on the grounds they were joined in a conspiracy against the oil industry.

“A collection of special interests and opportunistic politicians are abusing law enforcement authority and legal process to impose their viewpoint on climate change,” the oil firm claimed. “ExxonMobil finds itself directly in that conspiracy’s crosshairs.”

Related: How cities and states could finally hold fossil fuel companies accountable

A Texas district judge approved the request to depose Dedina, but then a court of appeals overturned the decision last year. The state supreme court is considering whether to take up the case.

The target on Dedina is part of a wider pattern of retaliation against those suing Exxon and other oil companies.

In an unusual move in 2016, Exxon persuaded a Texas judge to order the attorney general of Massachusetts, Maura Healey, to travel to Dallas to be deposed about her motives for investigating the company for alleged fraud for suppressing evidence on climate change. The judge also ordered that New York’s attorney general, Eric Schneiderman, be “available” in Dallas on the same day in case Exxon wanted to question him about a similar investigation.

Healey accused Exxon of trying to “squash the prerogative of state attorneys general to do their jobs”. The judge reversed the deposition order a month later and Healey filed a lawsuit against the company in 2019, which is still awaiting trial.

But similar tactics persuaded the US Virgin Islands attorney general to shut down his investigation of the oil giant.

Patrick Parenteau, a law professor and former director of the Environmental Law Center at Vermont law school, said the attempt to question Dedina and other officials is part of a broader strategy by the oil industry to counter lawsuits with its own litigation.

“These cases are frivolous and vexatious. Intimidation is the goal. Just making it cost a lot and be painful to take on Exxon. They think that if they make the case painful enough, Imperial Beach will quit,” he said.

If the intent is to kill off the litigation against the oil industry, it’s not working. Officials from other municipalities have called Exxon’s move “repugnant”, “a sham” and “outrageous”, and have vowed to press on with their lawsuits.

Dedina described the action as a “bullying tactic” by the oil industry to avoid accountability.

“The only conspiracy is [that] a bunch of suits and fossil-fuel companies decided to pollute the earth and make climate change worse, and then lie about it,” he said. “They make more money than our entire city has in a year.”

The city’s lawsuit claims it faces a “significant and dangerous sea-level rise” through the rest of this century that threatens its existence. Imperial Beach commissioned an analysis of its vulnerability to rising sea levels which concluded that nearly 700 homes and businesses were threatened at a cost of more than $100m. It said that flooding will hit about 40% of the city’s roads, including some that will be under water for long periods. Two elementary schools will have to be moved. The city’s beach, regarded as one of the best sites for surfing on the California coast, is being eroded by about a foot a year.

Imperial Beach sits at the southern end of San Diego bay. Under one worst-case scenario, the bay could merge with the Tijuana River estuary to the south and permanently submerge much of the city’s housing and roads.

The city has received some help with creating natural climate barriers. The Fish and Wildlife Service restored 400 acres of wetland next to the city as a national wildlife refuge which also acts as a barrier to flooding, and is expected to restore other wetlands together with the Port of San Diego. A grant is paying for improved equipment to warn of floods.

But that still leaves the huge costs of building new schools and drainage systems, and adapting other infrastructure. Dedina said that without the oil companies stumping up, it won’t happen.

“People ask, how did you go against the world’s largest fossil fuel companies? Isn’t that scary? No. What’s scary is coastal flooding and the idea that whole cities would be under water,” said the mayor.

“Honestly, bring it on. I can’t wait to make our case. I can’t wait to take the fight to them because we have nothing to lose.”

This story is published as part of Covering Climate Now, a global collaboration of news outlets strengthening coverage of the climate story

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

EXCLUSIVE: Hitesh Bharadwaj on Iss Mod Se Jaate Hain & Akshita Mudgal: ‘Has been amazing shooting with her'

© Provided by Pinkvilla Hitesh Bharadwaj and Akshita Mudgal starrer Iss Mod Se Jaate Hain was unveiled yesterday on Zee TV, and in an exclusive conversation with Pinkvilla recently Hitesh ... Read more »

Super League 2022 top tryscorer odds as Wigan Warriors man tipped to shine

Wigan Warriors full-back Bevan French is the bookmakers’ favourite to top the Super League tryscoring charts next year. French struggled for game time last season as injury restricted him to ... Read more »

Air Quality Commission Cracks Whip, Orders Closure of NCR Industries Not Running on Clean Fuel

© Provided by News18 Air Quality Commission Cracks Whip, Orders Closure of NCR Industries Not Running on Clean Fuel Even as the air quality in the national capital saw a ... Read more »

On PM Modi's ‘Laal Topi' Jibe, Akhilesh Yadav Says It's ‘Red Alert' For BJP Ahead of UP Polls

© Provided by News18 On PM Modi’s ‘Laal Topi’ Jibe, Akhilesh Yadav Says It’s ‘Red Alert’ For BJP Ahead of UP Polls Samajwadi Party chief and former chief minister of ... Read more »

Jennifer Lawrence calls her red carpet appearance for Don't Look Up premiere an 'out of body' experience

© Provided by Pinkvilla Jennifer Lawrence has returned to the red carpet with her upcoming movie Don’t Look Up‘s New York City premiere. During her conversation with E!, the pregnant ... Read more »

Ralf Rangnick plays down repeating Thomas Tuchel's Champions League achievement at Man United but insists they're 'ambitious'... as he confirms outcasts Dean Henderson and Donny van de Beek WILL play against Young Boys

Rangnick insists it is 'too early' to know if United can win the Champions LeagueThe German was asked if it was possible to match Thomas Tuchel's superb startTuchel won the Champions League in his first six months as Chelsea managerBut Rangnick has played down repeating that effort while in charge of UnitedRangnick also confirmed Van de Beek and Henderson would get their chance Read more »

Robert Lewandowski plays down reports in Spain of a rift with Lionel Messi over the Ballon d'Or, insisting he was 'touched' by the seven-time winner's speech claiming Lewandowski should be given the 2020 honour

Robert Lewandowski has played down reports of a rift with Lionel MessiMessi, 34, usurped Lewandowski, 33 to win his seventh Ballon d'Or in France The Argentine said that his Polish rival ought to be awarded the 2020 prizeHowever, reports in Poland claimed that the striker felt they lacked sincerity Lewandowski has told Sportsmail that Messi's sentiments were 'touching'  Read more »

Heroics against Barcelona, a stoppage-time Merseyside derby winner and triggering that bizarre West Brom celebration: Liverpool 'legend' Divock Origi is king of the late show after saving them AGAIN

Divock Origi netted a last-gasp winner for Liverpool against Wolves on SaturdayThe Belgian has a history of scoring crucial goals throughout Jurgen Klopp's timeA stoppage-time goal vs West Brom in 2015 triggered an odd team celebration2019 Champions League triumph can be remembered for special Origi momentsThe 26-year-old has proven his worth to the Reds again despite barely starting   Read more »

Army conducts helicopter-borne insertion exercise in higher reaches of Kashmir Valley

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: The Army on Tuesday conducted a helicopter-borne exercise in the higher reaches of the Kashmir Valley to practice inserting a task ... Read more »

Liverpool line-ups as Naby Keita and Joe Gomez decisions made for AC Milan

‘Joe Gomez and Naby Keita on the bench’ Paul Gorst: The luxuries of taking care of business early means Jurgen Klopp can rest and rotate tonight as Liverpool take on ... Read more »

TMC plans to meet Shah, demand compensation for Nagaland victims, repeal of AFSPA

© Provided by The Times of India NEW DELHI: Trinamool Congress MPs will be seeking an appointment with home minister Amit Shah to demand compensation for the victims of the ... Read more »

Leicester Tigers CEO Andrea Pinchen: ‘People looked at me in a strange way'

Andrea Pinchen knows she is not everyone’s identikit view of a leading Premiership rugby union figure. “Let’s not beat around the bush,” says Leicester’s chief executive, reflecting on her lesser-spotted ... Read more »

Rangnick hires Armas as coach | Van de Beek to face Young Boys

Ralf Rangnick has confirmed coach Chris Armas and sports psychologist Sascha Lense will join his setup at Manchester United, while both Donny van de Beek and Dean Henderson are set ... Read more »

Newswrap, Dec 7: Katrina Kaif & Vicky Kaushal will go to Maldives for honeymoon, Tejas release date out & more

© Provided by Pinkvilla Katrina Kaif and Vicky Kaushal wedding: Couple to go to Maldives for honeymoon:   Vicky Kaushal and Katrina Kaif are all set to exchange wedding vows ... Read more »

Emi Martinez proves Lionel Messi right in huge Aston Villa moment

Emiliano Martinez was a teammate of Lionel Messi’s in the summer and was a key reason arguably the greatest footballer of all time was able win his first major international ... Read more »

Nicola Sturgeon Asks Scots To Work From Home Until At Least Mid-January

(Photo: RUSSELL CHEYNE via Getty Images) Nicola Sturgeon has said people in Scotland should be encouraged to work from home until at least the middle of January, amid fears about ... Read more »

Can you play split screen in Fortnite Chapter 3?

© Provided by Dot Esports Following the release of Fortnite Chapter Three, season one over the weekend, numerous players on console noted a change to the game’s functionality. Unlike previous ... Read more »

How to Get the Bullseye Handgun in Call of Duty: Warzone Pacific Season 1

The Legendary “Bullseye” Handgun is up for grabs in Warzone Pacific, but how do you get it? Season 1 of Call of Duty: Warzone Pacific is almost here. This fresh ... Read more »

Prince Charles ‘deeply shocked & hurt' by Harry and pair have barely spoken in 8 months

PRINCE Charles and son Harry have “barely spoken” in the last eight months and relations between them are “at an all-time low”, The Sun can reveal. The Prince’s personal attacks ... Read more »

Nasdaq jumps over 1% at open as tech stocks roar back

Wall Street‘s main indexes opened sharply higher on Tuesday as technology firms bounced back on easing concerns around the Omicron variant, while Intel jumped after plans to take its self-driving ... Read more »

Leah Croucher – Old photo of ‘figure in black' found on phone could hold key to unlock mystery of teen's disappearance

AN old photograph showing a figure in black which was found on a mobile phone could provide new clues to the mystery disappearance of teenager Leah Croucher. Leah vanished on ... Read more »

Latest Covid travel rules for the 10 most popular holiday destinations from UK

Photograph: Matthew Horwood/Alamy Spain Spain has banned all non-vaccinated Britons from entering the country. The ban is expected to last until at least 31 December, at which point the rules ... Read more »

Driver, 19, crashed while filming TikTok car-surfing video leaving pal with broken SKULL and brain bleed

A TEENAGE driver crashed her car while filming a TikTok car-surfing stunt that left her friend with a broken skull and brain bleed. Natasha Graham, 19, had just passed her ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity cyclone challenge could be AXED over fears Storm Barra will freeze water and turn it into a death trap

I’M A Celebrity bosses are worried that the legendary CelebrityCyclone will have to be abandoned over fears it will freeze over. The task sees the stars attempting to grab stars ... Read more »

‘Landlord' slammed for renting out room for £700 with outrageous conditions including showering at ‘agreed times'

A live-in-landlord has been slammed for her spare room advert that says a tenant may only shower “during agreed times”. The bedroom at the Southside property in Glasgow, Scotland, was ... Read more »

Red list countries: Which destinations are on the list and do I still have to quarantine?

Nigeria has been added to the UK's red list today, due to the new Omicron Covid variant. The country joins ten other African countries that were placed on the list ... Read more »

Hlongwa, other tender fraud suspects not a flight risk, says magistrate

© YouTube screengrab. FILE: A YouTube screengrab of Brian Hlongwa. JOHANNESBURG – The magistrate in the case of former Gauteng Health MEC Brian Hlongwa said he is satisfied the eight ... Read more »

Mob burns man alive after rumours of blasphemy

© Provided by CapeTalk An angry mob in Pakistan murdered a Sri Lankan man accused of blasphemy by beating him and burning him alive, sparking protests in both countries. Several ... Read more »

National Assembly debates land expropriation without compensation bill

© https://www.123rf.com/photo_150548893_view-of-an-empty-country-highway-road-in-south-african-farmlan… Image: © Michael Turner/123rf.com CAPE TOWN – The National Assembly has started debating whether to adopt the 18th Constitutional Amendment Bill to allow for land expropriation without compensation. ... Read more »

Matric 2021 exams end with no major incidents reported

© Provided by Daily News DURBAN – The Department of Basic Education (DBE) said it was pleased that the National Senior Certificate (NSC) final exams had come to an end ... Read more »

WhatsApp updates its disappearing messages: what you need to know

© Gabby Jones Once a user has activated the new WhatsApp delete function, it will only affect new one-on-one chats. Bloomberg WhatsApp is updating its disappearing messages function to allow ... Read more »

Review: Boy band drama meets romance in ‘If This Gets Out'

The Associated PressThis cover image released by Wednesday Books shows “If This Gets Out,” a novel by Sophie Gonzales and Cale Dietrich. (Wednesday Books via AP) “If This Gets Out” ... Read more »

Ashton entered the world bruised, swollen and riddled with cancerous tumours, sick with a cruel disease that affects only one in five million babies. Here is the sign doctors missed... and how he survived

Baby Ashton was born bruised and swollen in a Sydney hospital last NovemberNewborn was later diagnosed with congenital Acute Myeloid Leukaemia (AML)His parents were told he had little chance of surviving chemotherapy treatmentsLittle Ashton continues to grow stronger every day and celebrated first birthday Read more »

These 'super elegant and comfortable' patterned tights will elevate your party look this Christmas - and they're on sale for under £20

Products featured in this Mail Best article are independently selected by our shopping writers. If you make a purchase using links on this page, MailOnline may earn an affiliate commission.  ... Read more »

Belgian health workers rally to oppose mandatory vaccines

BRUSSELS — Thousands of Belgian health care workers rallied Tuesday in Brussels to oppose mandatory COVID-19 vaccines and to demand better working conditions as a surge in new cases weighs ... Read more »

Tanya Plibersek opens up about when the fate of the government hung on her pregnancy and how far Australia has to go in making workplaces fair for women

In 2010, then Liberal leader Tony Abbott would not say if he'd grant her a 'pair' Plibersek is frustrated more progress has not been made for women in politicsHer husband is the Secretary of the NSW Department of Premier and Cabinet Read more »

US trade deficit narrows in October as exports rebound

The Associated PressIn this April 9, 2021 photo, cargo containers are shown stacked near cranes at PortMiami in Miami. The U.S. trade deficit narrowed to $67.1 billion in October, after ... Read more »

We've let our CAR industry die, make Hills Hoists in CHINA... and replaced quality Aussie-made machines with foreign JUNK... Now we've stopped making the fuel ingredient that keeps Australia moving: Here's why YOU need to be worried

The last Australian-made Holden Commodore manufactured in October 2017 The last train made in Newcastle for Sydney's rail network rolled off line in 2014Commuters now catch trains made in China, South Korea instead of Newcastle Incitec Pivot in November said it would stop making diesel additive in Brisbane  Read more »

Protester charged with trying to intimidate judge in Daunte Wright trial

Cortez Rice was among a group of protesters outside a high-rise condo where they believed Judge Regina Chu lived. Waukesha County Sheriff’s Depa A Minnesota Black Lives Matter protester has ... Read more »

The unlikely Cardiff team of kids, semi pros and Wales stars cobbled together to play the European champions

Cardiff have been explaining just how they have managed to piece together a team to take on holders Toulouse in Saturday’s Champions Cup opener at the Arms Park. They are ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic