Less comedy, more dhamma

Less comedy, more dhamma

Phra Maha Praiwan Worawano (left) Phra Maha Sompong Talaputto (right)

A couple of weeks ago, two well-known monks — Phra Maha Sompong Talaputto and Phra Maha Praiwan Worawano — held a livestream talk show on social media that attracted 200,000 viewers. The chat led to several debates between their supporters and opponents since it was different from typical dhamma talks or dhamma preaching. The two monks used several teenage slang expressions and joked with their viewers who commented via the live chat. While Phra Maha Sompong focused on delivering his own jokes like a standup comedian, Phra Maha Praiwan, who knew many teenage expressions, giggled uncontrollably throughout the show. He was criticised for not being not calm or having self-control as a monk should.

Phra Maha Praiwan started livestreaming solo in order to communicate with his followers on Facebook several months ago. Later, Phra Maha Sompong joined his show and it went viral. Using social media and slang to communicate with young followers is a good way to make dhamma more accessible, comprehensible and interesting. However, throughout the two-hour show, neither monk provided much information about dhamma. It was more like a comedy show.

The two monks are known for their criticism of the government. Due to their criticism, Phra Maha Praiwan was warned by the National Office of Buddhism that his political comments were inappropriate. The Committee of the Sangha Supreme Council of Thailand also stated that Phra Maha Sompong’s political comments were inappropriate and it was not the duty of a monk to make political comments. I agree that it is not the duty of a monk to get involved in politics and it is not appropriate for monks to participate in protests. However, criticising the government for corruption should not be forbidden. As monks encourage people to do good deeds, pointing out inappropriate or suspicious actions taken by the government should not be against Buddhism.

After the two monks’ livestream was brought to the spotlight, I became curious about them and watched their livestreams and talk shows. On several TV shows, Phra Maha Sompong usually delivers jokes more than preach about Buddhism. The most inappropriate show by Phra Maha Praiwan was Phra Maha Praiwan Unboxed, which involved him opening packages to show what was inside and read the names of senders or stores on packages. The show had nothing to do with dhamma. Phra Maha Praiwan often gives thanks to his fan club on YouTube for their offerings and provides free advertisements to stores that send him freebies. When people criticised this inappropriate behaviour, the monks’ followers defend them or tell the opposition to mind their own business.

Even though I felt offended by Phra Maha Sompong’s jokes and comical exchanges and Phra Maha Praiwan’s unreasonable giggling and irrelevant show, I found many of Phra Maha Praiwan solo shows to be interesting, especially when he answered questions from his followers. His answers enabled them to know more about Buddhism from a different perspective.

One video popular among the youth tackles the issue of gratitude. Phra Maha Praiwan provided insight in a thread on the forum Pantip in which one woman asked why she had never gone far in life. The woman said she had supported herself since she was 18. She gave half of her salary to her parents but they always asked her for more money and had never cared about her health or her life. Her question came from the belief in Thai society that gratitude to parents is a good deed and anyone who takes care of their parents will be successful. Many monks also compare parents to an arhat or enlightened Buddhist monk, which means that parents are moral people and children must be grateful to their parents.

Phra Maha Praiwan did not answer the question directly. Instead, he pointed out that not every parent behaves like an arhat or enlightened Buddhist monk. To make children feel grateful, parents should take responsibility for their children. Many followers were satisfied with the monk’s comment since most children are taught to treat their parents well but cannot question whether their parents treat them properly or not. Some of the followers even said the video made them more interested in Buddhism.

After the two monks met with the House Committee on Religion, Art and Culture about their livestreams, Phra Maha Sompong said he will tone down the jokes and provide more religious content. In their recent livestream, the two monks taught viewers that they do not have to spend money in order to make merit since making merit includes not just donations but also observing religious precepts and meditation. They also asked viewers to meditate with them for five to seven minutes at the end of the show.

Even though the monks now provide more useful content, their show still contains some inappropriate behaviour. In a country that is full of monks who ask for donations, sell amulets and other sacred charms or give hints to winning lottery numbers, respectable monks are rare to find. One of the show’s good points is that it inspired some young people to become more interested in Buddhism but I hope that young people can find more serious teachings from other sources. There are other monks who can preach in an interesting and lively way without inappropriate jokes, nonstop giggling and acting like a YouTuber instead of a monk.

Suwitcha Chaiyong is a feature writer for the Life section of the Bangkok Post.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Pheu Thai's popularity still high in Northeast: poll

A recent opinion survey by the National Institute of Development Administration, or Nida Poll, found the opposition Pheu Thai Party is still popular in the Northeast although many voters are ... Read more »

Co-payment most popular of all Covid relief measures: poll

A woman sells noodles at a fresh market in Bangkok with a “co-payment” sign pasted on her vending cart. The phase 3 co-payment programme was approved by the cabinet on ... Read more »

Revered Dutch conductor Bernard Haitink dies aged 92

LONDON (AFP, NYTIMES) – Bernard Haitink, widely considered one of the greatest conductors of his generation, has died in London at the age of 92, his management agency said. The ... Read more »

DN is now 15 years old, and we'd like to know what you think

Happy birthday to us DutchNews.nl was founded in 2006 to provide an English summary of the main Dutch news in English, which was emailed as a PDF to 800 people! ... Read more »

Car rams into lorry's rear, driver killed

SAMUT PRAKAN: A man was killed after a car he was driving rammed into the rear of a six-wheel lorry parked on a road side in Bang Phli district on ... Read more »

Are you in the right career? Ask yourself these questions

Dorie Clark, author of “The Long Game: How to Be a Long-Term Thinker in a Short-Term World.” We spend our days replying to emails, going to meetings, checking off to-do ... Read more »

Co-payment most popular of all Covid relief measures: Suan Dusit Poll

People find the co-payment programme, one of the measures taken by the government to cushion impacts from Covid-19, most favourable to them, according to the result of an opinion survey ... Read more »

9,351 new Covid cases, 56 more deaths

Health workers vaccinate people against Covid-19 at Wat Bang Phli Yai in Bang Phli district, Samut Prakan. The government reserved 1,500 doses of vaccine for Thais and migrant workers on ... Read more »

Crevice kill unwinds, valiant act, swollen manhood

Stuffed in a hole The stench of rotting flesh gave away a carefully concealed murder in Kanchanaburi where the body was stuffed in a mountain crevice and entombed with a ... Read more »

Subsidies shore up SMEs ahead of Nov 1

More than 5,000 small and medium-sized enterprises (SMEs) joined a government subsidy programme to help them retain employees on the first day of registration on Wednesday, said Labour Minister Suchart ... Read more »

Thamanat stands by poll exposing some MPs as 'unpopular'

Thamanat Prompow, secretary-general of the ruling Palang Pracharath Party (PPRP), has defended a popularity poll conducted by his faction last week which gave discouraging results for some party MPs. Thamanat: ... Read more »

Ex-actress Yvonne Lim and family wore full PPE for flight back to Taipei

SINGAPORE – Former Mediacorp actress Yvonne Lim and her family, including two young children, wore full protective gear for their flight back to Taipei, where they are based. Lim, 45, ... Read more »

Actress Gong Li reportedly renouncing Singapore citizenship

SINGAPORE – Actress Gong Li is said to be giving up Singapore citizenship, after reportedly being blacklisted by the Chinese government for holding a foreign passport. The 55-year-old is allegedly ... Read more »

Clusters prompt Nov 1 fears Calls to delay reopening in Chiang Mai, Hua Hin

Chiang Mai has reported a rise in its daily Covid-19 caseloads fuelled by the recent detection of new infection clusters. Meanwhile, a similar surge in infections in Hua Hin and ... Read more »

Two nabbed for betting websites

Gambling website rap crime: Two women were nabbed and charged with running gambling websites during a police raid on a condominium in Huai Khwang district yesterday. Only one of the ... Read more »

'Limit the entry curbs' Simpler reopening needed to pull tourists, city traders say

bright lights beckon: The Giant Swing illuminates as dusk falls around one of Bangkok’s landmarks. Preparations have begun for the reopening of tourism on Nov 1. Nov 1 marks the ... Read more »

Govt talks up new, 'more efficient' Thailand Pass

The Foreign Affairs Ministry is rolling out a campaign to promote the use of the new Thailand Pass system which will replace certificates of entry (COE) for visitors to Thailand ... Read more »

Moderna jabs set for Nov 5

ZP Therapeutics, a division of Zuellig Pharma and the official partner of Moderna in Thailand, has confirmed the first shipment of 560,000 doses of the Moderna vaccine will arrive in ... Read more »

Director 'gutted' by death of cinematographer in accidental shooting involving actor Alec Baldwin

Joel Souza (left) was hit in the shoulder when actor Alec Baldwin discharged the prop gun that killed ccinematographer Halyna Hutchins (right). SANTA FE, NEW MEXICO (REUTERS) – The movie ... Read more »

Long-weekend crowds throng Sangkhla Buri Site of famous wooden bridge in Kanchanaburi busy again after months in the Covid doldrums

Tourists throng Saphan Mon, the country’s longest wooden bridge in Sangkhla Buri district of Kanchanaburi on Saturday. (Photo: Piyarat Chongcharoen) KANCHANABURI: Tourists flocked to Sangkhla Buri on Saturday, with most ... Read more »

Krispy Kreme BOGO: 'Krispy Skreme' offering Halloween-themed buy-one-get-one deal and freebie

Krispy Skreme? The doughnut chain has a temporary name change for Halloween and special treats. Krispy Kreme has a BOGO doughnuts deal. Buy a dozen, get second for $1 Saturdays ... Read more »

Moderna shots to arrive in 2 weeks

A healthcare worker holds a vial of the Moderna vaccine at a pop-up vaccination site operated by SOMOS Community Care in Manhattan in New York City on Jan 29 this ... Read more »

Ubolratana Dam discharges stepped up Water volume in reservoir reaches 111% of capacity at biggest irrigation dam in Northeast

The Ubolratana Dam, the largest irrigation dam in the Northeast, currently holds 2.7 billion cubic metres of water, or 111% of its capacity. (Photo: Chakrapan Natanri) KHON KAEN: Authorities on ... Read more »

How Russia built its digital Iron Curtain 'Black boxes' installed at telecom providers give authorities sweeping powers to block, filter and slow down websites

An image of President Vladimir Putin appears on a video screen on the outskirts of Moscow. (Sergey Ponomarev/The New York Times) Russia’s boldest moves to censor the internet began in ... Read more »

Three killed, 2 hurt in Korat road accident

Rescue workers retrieve victims from a drowned pickup truck in a roadside canal in Non Daeng district, Nakhon Ratchasima, early Saturday morning. (Photo supplied: Prasit Tangprasert) NAKHON RATCHASIMA: Three people ... Read more »

Three Korat villages under lockdown

Access to Khuem Muang village Moo 13 in Bua Yai district of Nakhon Ratchasima is blocked after a Covid-19 cluster was found. (Photo: Prasit Tangprasert) NAKHON RATCHASIMA: Three villages in ... Read more »

Booker 2021: Social media and the sublime in Patricia Lockwood's debut

Patricia Lockwood meditates in her debut novel, No One Is Talking About This, on social media addiction. No One Is Talking About This By Patricia Lockwood Bloomsbury/Paperback/210 pages/$26.95/Available here 4 ... Read more »

Booker 2021: Richard Powers' Bewilderment pleads for the earth

Richard Powers returns to the Booker shortlist with his 13th novel, Bewilderment. Bewilderment By Richard Powers Hutchinson/Paperback/278 pages/$30.94/Available here 4 out of 5 Acclaimed eco-fiction author Richard Powers, 64, has ... Read more »

Booker Prize shortlist spans social media and climate crisis

(Clockwise from left) American author Richard Powers, American writer Maggie Shipstead, and Somali-British author Nadifa Mohamed. From an aviatrix lost to history to climate crisis anxiety, the novels shortlisted for ... Read more »

Booker 2021: The Promise is a bleak take on South Africa's fault lines

Damon Galgut’s The Promise tells the story of a white South African family living on a farm outside Pretoria. The Promise By Damon Galgut Chatto & Windus/Paperback/304 pages/$30.94/Available here 3 ... Read more »

Democrats Weigh Tax Alternatives to Fund $2 Trillion Package Sen. Kyrsten Sinema objected to any increases in top marginal rates on corporations, individuals or capital gains

Senator James Lankford, a Republican from Oklahoma, left, speaks with Senator Kyrsten Sinema, a Democrat from Arizona before a Senate Finance Committee hearing Tuesday in Washington, D.C. Democrats worked to ... Read more »

Prop gun in Alec Baldwin accidental movie set shooting had live rounds: Police

SANTA FE (REUTERS) – Alec Baldwin was handed what was described as a safe “cold gun” on the set of his movie “Rust”, but the prop gun contained live rounds ... Read more »

9,742 new Covid cases, 74 deaths

People view the Bangkok skyline from the King Power Mahanakhon skyscraper in Bangkok on Friday. The country will open for more tourists from Nov 1 as the Covid-19 situation improves. ... Read more »

Migration of minnows expected

Major political parties are expected to welcome MPs from a number of minnows after the Constitutional Court ruled this week that Paiboon Nititawan can retain his parliamentary status after dissolving ... Read more »

Global shares gain as China property jitters ease

Recap: Global shares advanced to record a third straight week of gains yesterday as worries over the Chinese property market eased, despite growing concerns that persistent inflation could trigger a ... Read more »

Tero Sabuy combines partners' strengths

Mr Marcar (left) and Mr Chookiat mark the launch of the “Tero Sabuy” joint venture. Tero Entertainment and Sabuy Technology has entered into a joint venture, Tero Sabuy, with the ... Read more »

XPG preps B10m for digital deals Company insists it won't speculate on cryptocurrencies

A representation of the virtual cryptocurrency Bitcoin is seen in this picture illustration taken on Tuesday. XSpring Capital Plc (XPG) has invested 10 million baht in digital assets to explore ... Read more »

aCommerce listing seen spicing up the market This 'e-commerce enabler' is helping a slew of international brands to navigate the region's complex logistics networks. By William Hicks

The fulfillment centre at aCommerce. Amidst a flagging economy and an increasingly desperate pandemic situation, Thai investors are seeking initial public offerings emblematic of the new Covid economy — companies ... Read more »

Banks Q3 profit hit by pandemic's impact

Commercial banks posted combined net profit decline for the third quarter of this year, compared with the previous quarter, mainly impacted by higher numbers of new Covid-19 cases and the ... Read more »

Three headwinds for the global economy

In the past few months or so, several headwinds have emerged in the world economic arena. We have seen a sharp increase in commodity prices, including natural gas, crude oil, ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic