Auckland school management board slammed by Auditor-General after paying $450k of public money to themselves

Asia's Tech News Daily

Auckland school management board slammed by Auditor-General after paying $450k of public money to themselves

The Auditor-General has slammed the members of a school board who paid $450,000 to themselves – and have been unable to say what it was spent on, who authorised it or how the fee was determined.

An inquiry was launched after it was discovered that the Combined Establishment Board of South Auckland Middle School and Middle School West Auckland paid the management fees to the Villa Education Trust in 2018.

However, the school’s appointed auditor noted that the trustees of the board were also the trustees of the Trust and “effectively decided to pay money to themselves”, Auditor-General John Ryan said.

“We found the members of the Establishment Board failed to recognise that a conflict of interest arose when they effectively decided to pay money to themselves.

“This meant the Board took no steps to manage the conflict,” he said.

Alwyn Poole founded South Auckland Middle School and Middle School West Auckland and organised all students at both schools in “villas” of 60 children, each with a class of about 15 students in each of the year levels 7 to 10.

The partnership schools were bulk-funded, enabling Poole and his wife Karen, the Villa Education Trust’s chief executive, to hire more teachers by spending less on property and administration.

However, Ryan found the $450k monies were for administration and management services required for the former charter schools to open as designated character state schools.

“The trustees were, effectively, wearing two hats,” Ryan said.

“The shared membership was a potential conflict of interest that became an actual conflict when the Establishment Board considered engaging Villa Education Trust.

“In a situation like this, we expect a public organisation to recognise the conflict and put a process in place to manage it.”

The Establishment Board, like any public organisation, was accountable to the public and Parliament for how it has spent the public money entrusted to it, he said.

However, since then the board has still been unable to provide the auditor general “with sufficient assurance about the circumstances in which the fee was determined and paid, and about what exactly has been provided in exchange”.

“I expect more from a public organisation spending public money.

“The circumstances of this payment create a perception of a lack of integrity. Acting with integrity, and being seen to act with integrity, are fundamental to maintaining the public’s trust and confidence in public organisations and in the public sector as a whole.”

From the time of the 2018 audit and throughout the inquiry, there also appears to have been a lack of appreciation by the Establishment Board of the position it was in when it became a state school, or of the expectation when spending public money to properly account for that money.

When carrying out the 2018 audit, the schools’ appointed auditor had been unable to obtain sufficient, appropriate evidence to determine how much of the payment was valid expenditure.

“Information about how the fees were determined, agreed, paid, and managed, and what was received for the payment, should have been available to our auditor when asked for in the first instance.

“That information is part of orthodox procurement and contract management and should be properly documented.

“If that information was prepared and made available, it might not have been necessary for us to carry out all the work involved in this case to find out the circumstances of a payment like this.”

Ryan encouraged public organisations to read his office’s good practice guide on managing conflicts of interest.

“This provides guidance on identifying and managing conflicts of interest, so the public can have confidence that people making decisions and spending public money are doing so in the public interest.”

Ryan also found that, while the Board had valid reasons to engage Villa Education Trust for the work, the board did not follow good procurement practice:

• There was no formal agreement between the board and the Trust, and no scope of work before the $450,000 was invoiced and approved for payment,

• There was no evidence to show how the board determined what services it was paying for, assessed the appropriateness of the fees, or actively managed the services that were delivered,

• There is no documentary record of who approved the expenditure as being valid or authorised the invoices for payment, and whether they had the appropriate authority to do so.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Kiwi tradies' online marketplace Builderscrack acquired by Australian company

New Zealand’s leading tradie marketplace Builderscrack has been acquired by Australia’s hipages Group Holdings Limited. The 100 per cent acquisition of MyQuote Limited, trading as Builderscrack, is for A$11.8m in ... Read more »

Auckland Council employee reported to police over alleged credit card and expenses fraud

A staff member at Auckland Council has been reported to the police for fraud after allegedly misusing a credit card and fiddling expenses to the value of $8000. General manager ... Read more »

SPCA appealing for information after two cats shot in Whanganui

The SPCA is seeking information from the public after two cats were shot in Whanganui. Both incidents occurred on Wednesday, December 1, in the Aramoho area. In the first incident, ... Read more »

No reprieve for guinea pig, chicken-killing husky on Auckland's dog 'death row'

Aspen the husky, a dog who was ordered destroyed after he killed two other pets on Auckland’s North Shore in quick succession, has been denied a reprieve from a High ... Read more »

Focus: Business NZ refuses to take part in creation of Fair Pay Agreement

Workplace Relations and Safety Minister Michael Wood spoke about Business New Zealand's refusal to take part in the creation of Fair Pay Agreements. Video / Mark Mitchell Read more »

Employers could lose out after Business NZ walked away from agreements - Michael Wood

Workplace Relations Minister Michael Wood has fired back at Business NZ for pulling out of the fair pay agreement (FPA) process today, saying it is not needed to make the ... Read more »

Jacinda Ardern calls out commenter on Facebook live

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern calls out commenter on Facebook live. Video / Jacinda Ardern Read more »

Forestry on farms fires up speakers at Dunedin debate

Is forestry a threat to rural communities or an opportunity too good to refuse? About 70 people attended the panel debate “Plantation forestry – threat or opportunity?” in Dunedin last ... Read more »

Covid-19: Omicron hits the vaccinated, but illness 'mostly mild' in US so far, says CDC chief

More than 40 people in the United States have been found to be infected with the Omicron variant so far, and more than three-quarters of them had been vaccinated, the ... Read more »

Smoking ban: Fears Smokefree 2025 legislation could stoke growing black market

Critics say plans to outlaw smoking for future generations will likely fuel an already-growing black market for cigarettes and more support is needed for people to transition to vaping. Meanwhile ... Read more »

Covid-19: Rapid antigen testing to be free for some domestic travellers over summer

By RNZ Free Covid-19 rapid antigen testing will be available for domestic travellers throughout Aotearoa from mid-December. The announcement on antigen testing becoming available was initially made last month, but ... Read more »

Finland PM Sanna Marin apologises for nightclubbing after Covid contact

The world’s youngest Prime Minister has apologised for going clubbing after coming into contact with a Covid case. Finland PM Sanna Marin issued a statement after a night out in ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Marlborough Wine and Food Festival cancelled

Marlborough’s premier wine event, Marlborough Wine & Food Festival, has been deemed too risky to go ahead and cancelled by organisers amid Covid-19 fears. The festival was moved to Renwick ... Read more »

How to stay safe this summer

Road safety charity Brake is appealing to partygoers and organisers to ensure everyone in their group gets to and from celebrations safely over the festive season and summer. With the ... Read more »

Whangārei big cat park: Tickets for sale ahead of public opening

Big cats at the Kamo Wildlife Sanctuary are roaring back to life and the public can finally walk through the gates from Tuesday next week. Ticket sales for the opening ... Read more »

Jennifer Aniston gives a look into her personal life in most candid interview in years

The iconic actress Jennifer Aniston has opened up to The Hollywood Reporter and shared some very personal revelations from her time in the film industry. Most well known for her ... Read more »

Marlborough cancels Wine and Food Festival to save vintage

Next year’s Marlborough’s annual Food & Wine festival has been cancelled, as grape growers decide the gathering poses too much risk to our region’s wellbeing. Roughly 6000 were expected to ... Read more »

Herald afternoon quiz: December 9

Test your brains with the Herald’s afternoon quiz. Be sure to check back on nzherald.co.nz for the morning quiz tomorrow. To challenge yourself with more quizzes, CLICK HERE. Read more »

Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern shuts down Facebook commenter during live video

It’s been a long year and it seems everyone’s patience is wearing a little thin. Prime Minister Jacinda Ardern snapped at a Facebook user during a livestream yesterday, reminding people ... Read more »

Covid 19 Delta outbreak: Selwyn teen's life in limbo as she waits for vaccine pass exemption

West Melton teenager Daisy Meyers is being excluded from her sporting life as she awaits a vaccine pass exemption. The 16-year-old’s father, Darren Meyers, was on the phone to health ... Read more »

Property report: Rural market going from strength to strength

Content brought to you by PGG Wrightson Real Estate The Country’s Jamie Mackay is joined by PGG Wrightson’s General Manager for Rural Real Estate, Peter Newbold, to take a look ... Read more »

Farmer shareholders vote in favour of Fonterra's planned revamp of capital structure

By RNZ Fonterra farmer shareholders have voted overwhelmingly in support of a plan to revamp the co-operative’s capital structure. It is one of the biggest votes in the co-operative’s history. ... Read more »

Tauranga grocer David Stewart speaks out after list of employee rules goes global

A Kiwi greengrocer’s instructions for new employees has gone global after a disgruntled dad shared a portion of them online – but the man behind the list says the international ... Read more »

Toddler dies, baby fighting for life after 'botched circumcision' at Australian medical centre

A 2-year-old boy has tragically died after what was apparently a botched circumcision at a medical clinic in Western Australia. The boy’s baby brother also needed life-saving surgery after undergoing ... Read more »

SwiftMantis's latest Palmerston North mural brightens Deerstalkers Hall

The royal red stag looks as if it’s about to leap off the wall and trot up Thomson St in search of fresh fern. But the deer really lives on ... Read more »

Ashhurst Images calendar a fundraiser for village causes

Lord Henry would no doubt be impressed and perhaps would hang the calendar in his study. While Henry Ashhurst, after whom the village is named, is no longer around, the ... Read more »

Charges against former Lake Alice staff member 'better than nothing' says survivor

It finally feels as though Lake Alice survivors are being listened to after a former staff member was charged, says one former patient. Selwyn Leeks is a 92-year-old with dementia. ... Read more »

Kāpiti's NZ Native Oils: Created from a mix of personal experience and study

Maria Brocklebank has used a fusion of personal experience and study in aromatherapy and herbal medicines to create natural skincare products. She talks to Rosalie Willis about turning it into ... Read more »

Afghanistan response: Government denies being 'late to the table' but accepts housing Afghans an issue

The Government has today defended its response to the fall of Afghanistan back into Taliban hands, repeatedly raising “complexities”, while also citing the 900-plus people who have made it to ... Read more »

Waipukurau woman's memories spark nostalgia

Former Waipukurau resident Helen Buxton (née Hubbard) took up writing at 75, and after going on a writing course she wrote 17 stories to be given to her grandchildren. Helen ... Read more »

Three strikes case: Repeat prison murderer Siuake Lisiate avoids life without parole

A longtime prisoner who has participated in the murders of two fellow inmates – as well as stabbing a third man over 40 times during a failed hit at the ... Read more »

Smoking ban: Fears Smokefree 2025 legislation could lead to black market

Critics say plans to outlaw smoking for future generations will likely lead to a black market for cigarettes and more support is needed for people to transition to vaping. Meanwhile ... Read more »

Covid 19 Australia: Deputy PM Barnaby Joyce tests positive in Washington DC

Australia’s Deputy Prime Minister Barnaby Joyce said today he’d tested positive for Covid-19 while travelling in Washington DC. Joyce, who is fully vaccinated, said in a Facebook post that he’d ... Read more »

Long-awaited Kaitaia Water Project ready for May 2022

The long-awaited Kaitāia Water Project is on track to be completed by May next year, according to an FNDC spokesperson. The Kaitāia Water Project is the delivery of a new ... Read more »

California prepares for more out-of-state abortion patients

As the Supreme Court weighs whether to curtail abortion rights, Planned Parenthood Northern California is preparing for a possible surge in women coming across borders to have the procedures done. ... Read more »

No lack of eager midwifery students at Ara despite nationwide shortage

Despite a shortage of midwives nationwide, there’s no lack of eager students. Ara Institute of Canterbury only has 47 places in its first-year midwifery course, yet has received 105 applications. ... Read more »

Waikato Regional councillors censure chairman over racist comments, tell him to perform better

Waikato Regional Council chairman Russ Rimmington has been formally chastised by his council for racist comments and told he needs to better perform on their behalf. Rimmington has come under ... Read more »

Plans for 5000-home, carless South Auckland community run into road block

By Justin Latif, Local Democracy Reporter It could become the template for how to create a low emission, eco-friendly neighbourhood, but first developers will have to convince politicians such a ... Read more »

Pair in court after gun-wielding man interrupts Hamilton police during arrest, helps woman escape patrol car

Two people have been charged after an incident in Hamilton yesterday where a man threatened police with a pistol as he helped a woman escape arrest. At about 3.30am yesterday ... Read more »

Musician gets a kick from playing to Norsewood audiences

Percussionist Jeremy Fitzsimons enjoys playing for silent movie audiences. “It’s a real buzz playing for the audience. “They react to the screen live and we feed off that laughter. “We ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic