2 Tricks and a Treat for Gene Therapy Investors

Asia's Tech News Daily

The biotech sector has lagged the market since the start of 2021, with the iShares Biotech ETF up less than 3% compared to the 17% gains seen by the S&P 500 over the same time frame. This year has been especially tough on the gene therapy market.

© Provided by The Motley Fool 2 Tricks and a Treat for Gene Therapy Investors

While some companies produced lackluster results, others had clinical trials placed on hold, causing the sector to lag the market. Let’s examine two ghastly gene therapy performers this year and one for investors to take a closer look at.

© Getty Images. People working in a lab.

Scary competition for Editas

Late last month, Editas (NASDAQ: EDIT) provided a lukewarm update on its lead CRISPR-editing treatment for a genetic disease called LCA10 that causes rapid vision loss. Unfortunately, the treatment, EDIT-101, provided no benefit at the low range of dosing and only modest results in the middle range. In fact, only two of three patients in the middle dose cohort saw any evidence of improvement.

Chief Medical Officer Lisa Michaels said, “these encouraging results provide a proof of concept,” which is at least partially true as the results were encouraging, but not the stellar efficacy investors were hoping for from gene therapies. Unfortunately, her additional comments may have spooked investors: “At the end of the day, I’ll be honest with you … this trial has been going on for so long and we haven’t been communicating.” Yikes. Not exactly the reason you want to see a press release. It’s no wonder shares have been down over 45% for investors year to date.

Beyond this scary data, there are also competitors with better data that are already in phase 2/3 trials for the same disease process. Granted, the RNAi-based treatment from ProQR Therapeutics (NASDAQ: PRQR) will likely require injections into the eye twice a year, forever. While admittedly a one-and-done gene therapy injection would be ideal, right now it does not look like EDIT-101 can deliver those results anytime soon. And ProQR’s treatment has thus far delivered robust vision improvements in clinical trials. With top-line data for ProQR’s phase 2/3 trial for LCA10 due in the first half of 2022, there may not be any market left by the time Editas knows if its treatment even works well enough to sell.

Skip the CRISPR house this Halloween

CRISPR Therapeutics (NASDAQ: CRSP) had investors seeing ghosts when it released data last week from its CAR-T treatment, CTX110, sending the stock down more than 10% on Wednesday from its price at the start of the month. In an ongoing phase 1 study for large B-cell lymphoma (LBCL), CTX110 demonstrated impressive safety data, with no evidence of serious forms of an inflammatory reaction called cytokine release syndrome. Unfortunately, only 21% of LBCL patients experienced a complete response at six months. Back in December, Gilead‘s (NASDAQ: GILD) Yescarta demonstrated a 74% complete response rate in first-line therapy for LBCL, with 9% experiencing a grade 3 or higher cytokine release syndrome. Though not a true apples-to-apples comparison, CRISPR will have an uphill battle going against not only multiple positive data sets for Yescarta with significantly better response rates but also years of clinician experience with the Gilead treatment.

While CRISPR did have promising data for its gene therapy for sickle cell disease earlier this year, investors should still proceed with caution. The gene-editing company has only treated seven sickle cell patients to date, with only two patients having been monitored for over a year. Compare this to competitor Bluebird Bio (NASDAQ: BLUE), which has treated 47 sickle cell patients with up to three and a half years of follow-up and has also reported fantastic results. Not only is CRISPR at least two years behind, but it will only take 40% of the profits from its sickle cell therapy due to its partnership with Vertex Pharmaceuticals. Then there is the issue of reimbursement — Bluebird Bio is having difficulty getting paid for its already-approved gene therapies, which may signal trouble for the entire field.

All gene therapy roads go through Repligen

The gene therapy market has at times been a ghost town, riddled with clinical trial holds. In extreme cases like Audentes Therapeutics, which was acquired by Astellas Pharma, its therapy may never see daylight after multiple patient deaths were linked to its treatment. The good news is that there are many talented people working on gene therapy from many angles. And Repligen (NASDAQ: RGEN) helps supply the manufacturing side of the gene therapy delivery systems.

This biotech company sells the instruments and associated disposables that are needed for the production of biologic drugs. The $3.7 billion addressable market ranges from the equipment needed for the creation of monoclonal antibodies to COVID-related vaccines and gene therapy. This pick-and-shovel biotech is an agnostic supplier of necessary products needed to construct both today’s and tomorrow’s cutting-edge treatments.

Being an agnostic supplier, no matter which company produces a gene therapy that comes to market, Repligen shares in that win. Having two-thirds of its revenue coming from clinical trials, should some of these treatments eventually make it to market, Repligen could crush future earnings. With full-year 2021 guidance for 71%-76% revenue growth on top of 2020’s 36% revenue growth, the future looks sweet for this $13.8 billion biotech equipment supplier. It has a proven track record too, already up over 40% year to date and over 800% over the last five years.

What’s in your Halloween basket?

The market may be recognizing that the competition is far ahead of Editas and CRISPR Therapeutics, sending shares down 45% and 35% year to date, respectively. While ProQR looks enticing, Repligen has the ability to add to its growth no matter which therapy comes out ahead, plus it is already profitable. Investors looking for exposure to the gene therapy market without hitching their wagon to one or two lead compounds may want to consider adding the biotech equipment manufacturer to their watch list.

SPONSORED:

10 stocks we like better than Repligen

When our award-winning analyst team has a stock tip, it can pay to listen. After all, the newsletter they have run for over a decade, Motley Fool Stock Advisor, has tripled the market.*

They just revealed what they believe are the ten best stocks for investors to buy right now… and Repligen wasn’t one of them! That’s right — they think these 10 stocks are even better buys.

See the 10 stocks

 

*Stock Advisor returns as of September 17, 2021

 

Patrick Bafuma has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool owns shares of and recommends CRISPR Therapeutics, Editas Medicine, Repligen, and Vertex Pharmaceuticals. The Motley Fool recommends Bluebird Bio and Gilead Sciences. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.

 

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Franklin leads South Alabama over Southern Miss 85-55

MOBILE, Ala. (AP) — Javon Franklin had a career-high 22 points as South Alabama routed Southern Miss 85-55 on Wednesday night. Franklin was perfect from the floor, making 10 of ... Read more »

Williamson leads Loyola Chicago past Indiana St. 88-76

CHICAGO (AP) — Lucas Williamson had 20 points as Loyola Chicago beat Indiana State 88-76 on Wednesday night. The game marked the first Missouri Valley Conference matchup of the season ... Read more »

Williams leads N. Illinois over E. Illinois 55-45

DEKALB, Ill. (AP) — Keshawn Williams had a career-high 24 points as Northern Illinois beat Eastern Illinois 55-45 on Wednesday night. Trendon Hankerson had 15 points for Northern Illinois (2-5), ... Read more »

Davis leads SMU over UNLV 83-64

DALLAS (AP) — Kendric Davis had 18 points and eight assists and Michael Weathers posted 14 points, nine rebounds and six assists as SMU topped UNLV 83-64 on Wednesday night. ... Read more »

Davison powers No. 23 Wisconsin past Georgia Tech 70-66

ATLANTA (AP) — Brad Davison scored nine straight points midway through the second half and finished with 27, leading No. 23 Wisconsin to a 70-66 win over Georgia Tech on ... Read more »

No. 5 UCLA beats Colorado 73-61 in Pac-12 opener

LOS ANGELES (AP) — Tyger Campbell scored 21 points and No. 5 UCLA recovered after blowing most of a 17-point, first-half lead to beat Colorado 73-61 on Wednesday night in ... Read more »

Brewer scores 22 to lead FIU past Florida Gulf Coast 77-61

MIAMI (AP) — Tevin Brewer had 22 points as Florida International won its seventh consecutive game, defeating Florida Gulf Coast 77-61 on Wednesday night. Isaiah Banks had 16 points and ... Read more »

Domask sparks Southern Illinois past Evansville 54-52

EVANSVILLE, Ind. (AP) — Marcus Domask buried a jumper with 3 seconds left in the game and finished with 22 points to lift Southern Illinois over Evansville 54-52 in a ... Read more »

Major League Baseball owners lock out players, starting the sport's 1st work stoppage in 26 years

IRVING, Texas (AP) — Major League Baseball owners lock out players, starting the sport’s 1st work stoppage in 26 years. Read more »

Hightower leads Winthrop past Hartford 82-75

ROCK HILL, S.C. (AP) — Cory Hightower had 19 points and 13 rebounds to carry Winthrop to an 82-75 win over Hartford on Wednesday night. Hightower made 4 of 6 ... Read more »

Reeves carries Illinois St. past Missouri St. 79-74 in OT

NORMAL, Ill. (AP) — Antonio Reeves had 22 points as Illinois State edged past Missouri State 79-74 in overtime on Wednesday night. Josiah Strong added 21 points for the Redbirds, ... Read more »

Richardson scores 17, Oregon holds off UC Riverside 71-65

EUGENE, Ore. (AP) — Will Richardson scored 17 points and Oregon held off UC Riverside for a 71-65 victory on Wednesday night. The game was tied at 58 with 7:34 ... Read more »

Almonacy carries Appalachian State past Boyce 90-29

BOONE, N.C. (AP) — Michael Almonacy posted 11 points as Appalachian State routed Boyce 90-29 on Wednesday night. CJ Huntley had 10 points for Appalachian State (5-4). Christopher Mantis added ... Read more »

Michigan prosecutor says she may charge Oxford High School shooter's parents, too

A Michigan prosecutor charged a 15-year-old Oxford High School sophomore with terrorism, first-degree murder, assault, and gun possession charges on Wednesday, and said she would try him as an adult ... Read more »

Johnson leads Mercer past Kennesaw State 73-71

KENNESAW, Ga. (AP) — Jalen Johnson had 18 points as Mercer edged past Kennesaw State 73-71 on Wednesday night. Felipe Haase and Neftali Alvarez added 16 points each for the ... Read more »

McCoy carries Boston University past George Washington 56-54

WASHINGTON (AP) — Javante McCoy scored 17 points and his two foul shots with 1:31 to play sent Boston University past George Washington 56-54 on Wednesday night. Neither team scored ... Read more »

Carlos Santana has 'unscheduled heart procedure,' cancels Las Vegas shows for rest of year

LOS ANGELES — Carlos Santana has successfully undergone a heart procedure and is canceling several Las Vegas shows planned for December. In a video message released Wednesday on social media, ... Read more »

AP: Notre Dame defensive coordinator Marcus Freeman emerges as top head coach candidate to replace Brian Kelly

Notre Dame is working on a deal to promote defensive coordinator Marcus Freeman to head coach to replace Brian Kelly, a person with knowledge of the situation told the Associated ... Read more »

Williams scores 14 to lead Troy over Rust College 81-48

TROY, Ala. (AP) — Desmond Williams had 14 points as Troy routed Rust College 81-48 on Wednesday night. Duke Deen pitched in with 10 points and seven assists for Trojans ... Read more »

Carter Jr. lifts Navy past William & Mary 75-56

ANNAPOLIS, Md. (AP) — John Carter Jr. scored 16 points and grabbed six rebounds and Navy topped William & Mary 75-56 on Wednesday night. Jaylen Walker scored 15 points and ... Read more »

U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin says China's pursuit of hypersonic weapons “increases tensions in the region”

SEOUL, South Korea — U.S. Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin says China’s pursuit of hypersonic weapons “increases tensions in the region.” Read more »

Smollett defense set to cross-examine star state witness

The Associated PressAbimbola Osundairo, walks through the lobby of the Leighton Criminal Courthouse courtroom after a lunch break in the trial of actor Jussie Smollett Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021, in ... Read more »

Michigan teen, 15, charged in Oxford High School shooting

The Associated PressThis booking photo released by the Oakland County, Mich., Sheriff’s Office shows Ethan Crumbley, 15, who is charged as an adult with murder and terrorism for a shooting ... Read more »

Q&A: Korean star Gianna Jun on acting goals and aging well

The Associated PressThis image released by iQiyi shows Gianna Jun as Seo Yi-gang in a scene from “Jirisan.” South Korean superstar Gianna Jun portrays a mountain ranger dealing with natural ... Read more »

After delay, NASA astronauts set for spacewalk to replace faulty space station antenna

By Steve Gorman (Reuters) – Two NASA astronauts were set to embark on a spacewalk on Thursday to replace a faulty antenna on the International Space Station (ISS), after a ... Read more »

Greensburg man jailed, accused of leading police on 108 mph pursuit

Dec. 2—A Greensburg man accused of leading police on a seven-mile, high-speed chase that started in in the city and ended near Murrysville was arrested after an officer recognized his ... Read more »

Tate leads Norfolk State past UNC Wilmington 74-69

WILMINGTON, N.C. (AP) — Dana Tate Jr. came off the bench to score 17 points and lead Norfolk State to a 74-69 victory over UNC Wilmington on Wednesday night. Jalen ... Read more »

Pepper scores 30 to lead UC Davis over Pacific 63-57

DAVIS, Calif. (AP) — Elijah Pepper poured in 30 points as UC Davis defeated Pacific 63-57 on Wednesday night. Ezra Manjon had 14 points for the Aggies (3-3). Aaron Murphy ... Read more »

Balanced attack propels Dayton past Alabama State 93-54

DAYTON, Ohio (AP) — Toumani Camara scored 16 points as Dayton romped past Alabama State 93-54 on Wednesday night. Kobe Elvis and Malachi Smith added 15 points each for the ... Read more »

Major League Baseball's collective bargaining agreement expires, allowing 1st work stoppage since 1995

IRVING, Texas (AP) — Major League Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement expires, allowing 1st work stoppage since 1995. Read more »

MLB lockout is on after collective bargaining agreement expires, owners agree to freeze out players

With Major League Baseball’s collective bargaining agreement with the MLB Players’ Association expiring at midnight Wednesday evening, the league’s 30 owners voted to lock out players beginning Thursday, creating the ... Read more »

North Alabama beats Mississippi Valley St. 72-58

FLORENCE, Ala. (AP) — Payton Youngblood posted 13 points as North Alabama topped Mississippi Valley State 72-58 on Wednesday night. Pape Momar Cisse had 12 points for North Alabama (4-3). ... Read more »

Jurors find Lima man guilty of aggravated burglary

Dec. 2—LIMA — An Allen County jury late Tuesday returned a verdict of guilty against Christian Jara Coronado on charges of aggravated burglary. The first-degree felony charge included a specification ... Read more »

Suspect in multiple catalytic converter thefts arrested by Olmsted County deputies

Dec. 2—A dropped cell phone has led law enforcement to “one of the two top catalytic converter thieves” in the area. Olmsted County Sheriff's Office Capt. James Schueller said a ... Read more »

Man in custody for attempted murder found dead by hanging

Dec. 2—A Linda man in-custody for the alleged attempted murder of his mother-in-law on Friday was discovered hanging and unresponsive in his cell around 1 a.m. Wednesday, according to a ... Read more »

UN projects soaring humanitarian needs in world in 2022

1 / 7UN Humanitarian OperationsFILE – Senait Ambaw, right, who said her home had been destroyed by artillery, leaves by foot on a path near the village of Chenna Teklehaymanot, ... Read more »

EC man sentenced in connection with chase, jail assault

Dec. 2—ALTOONA — An Eau Claire man will spend 30 months on probation in connection with a high-speed chase on an Altoona highway and for breaking a bone in another ... Read more »

Ed McClanahan, Kentucky author and 'Merry Prankster,' dies at 89: 'A pillar in the community'

LEXINGTON, Ky. — Ed McClanahan, a Kentucky author, teacher and friend of counterculture icon Ken Kesey, died Saturday at his home in Lexington, according to his wife. He was 89. ... Read more »

Dodgers bring back Chris Taylor for $60M over 4 years

LOS ANGELES (AP) — The Los Angeles Dodgers are bringing back versatile All-Star Chris Taylor, agreeing to a $60 million, four-year deal with a club option Wednesday night. The 31-year-old ... Read more »

Asian markets mixed after Wall St decline, virus unease

The Associated PressA man wearing a face mask walks past a bank’s electronic board showing the Hong Kong share index in Hong Kong, Thursday, Dec. 2, 2021. Asian stock markets ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic