What the new greenwashing guidelines could mean for fashion brands

© Getty Images/iStockphoto iStock-140388836.jpg

From the start of next year fashion brands face finding themselves in breach of the law if they engage in

Following its early 2021 findings that 40 per cent of green claims made online could be misleading consumers, the Competition and Markets Authority (CMA) has published the “Green Claims Code”. Based upon existing consumer protection legislation, and applicable to “advertisements, product labelling and packaging or other accompanying information… even product names” the Code is designed to help businesses comply with the law and reduce the risk of misleading shoppers.

Brands now have a so-called bedding-in period until 2022, upon which time the CMA will carry out a full review of misleading claims made both on and offline. While any products and services carrying green claims will be affected, the CMA is to prioritise the industries which consumers are most concerned about, and the fashion and textiles industry sits at the top of the list.

The Code may be formed around the 2008 Consumer Protection from Unfair Trading Regulations, but no specific guidelines pertaining to green claims have existed until now. That’s why shoppers are treated to window displays dedicated to “sustainable collections”, or Instagram posts about fashion brands being “earth-friendly”, “responsible”, or “better for the planet” with very little information or proof to back those claims up.

“Stakeholder demand has ensured that there is a checklist of things that organisations must demonstrate that they are working towards if they are to be deemed sustainable, but so many are undermining this by using misleading terminology and imagery in what they present to the public,” says Tiffany Kelly, co-founder of retail platform Beyond Bamboo.

Until fashion brands are actively measuring and disclosing their impacts in a reliable and transparent way, they must be held accountable for any communications about sustainability

Ruth MacGilp, Communications and Content Manager at Fashion Revolution

A quick sweep of UK retailer websites reveals that examples of this aren’t hard to find. “Making sure [cotton] is sourced in a more environmentally sustainable way”; “…ensuring 100% of products and packaging are made from more sustainable or recycled materials”; and “…we’re endeavouring to make a positive change by using materials that are more sustainably sourced,” were among the statements made by prominent British brands to prove their commitment to environmentally friendly business practices.

Such statements seem impressive on the surface, but they leave questions unanswered. How are they making sure it’s sustainably sourced? What do they mean by sustainably sourced? What exactly counts as a more sustainable material?

“Until fashion brands are actively measuring and disclosing their impacts in a reliable and transparent way, they must be held accountable for any communications about sustainability,” says Ruth MacGilp, Communications and Content Manager at Fashion Revolution. “We need legislation that upholds efforts like these to prevent greenwashing… with penalties for unsubstantiated claims by big brands.”

“For consumers to have the best chance of knowing the clothes they buy align with their values, we need to be confident that companies are telling the truth about their products and processes,” MacGilp continues. And thanks to the new guidelines, knowing what’s true and what’s greenwashing should be much easier.

The six principles of the Green Claims Code are: claims must be truthful and accurate, claims must be clear and unambiguous, claims must not omit or hide important relevant information, comparisons must be fair and meaningful, claims must consider the full life cycle of the product or service, and claims must be substantiated.

Greenwashing erodes consumer trust and means that genuinely sustainable brands struggle to be heard

Tiffany Kelly, co-founder of retail platform Beyond Bamboo.

They may sound like baseline expectations, but they stand to tear apart the way brands are currently talking about sustainability. Claims such as “we are working to become more sustainable” will no longer cut the mustard unless they are substantiated with evidence of exactly how that will happen. Using vague descriptions such as “organic cotton jeans” will no longer do either. Brands will be expected to make clear exactly what percentage of the fibre is organic cotton, and what the make-up of the rest of the fabric is.

Claims of a product being “greener” than an unnamed comparison are out, and the use of broad terms such as “sustainable” or “eco-friendly” are also up for scrutiny as the CMA says they are “likely to be seen as suggesting that a product, service, process, brand or business as a whole has a positive environmental impact.” And if a business can’t prove that’s the case, they risk enforcement from bodies including the CMA and the ASA that may involve court proceedings and paying redress to affected consumers.

Until now, brands have been able to use a single eco-friendly collection or the presence of recycled materials within a small percentage of their products as a shroud, drawing attention away from overproduction, fossil fuel fabrics and rampant waste. They’ve been able to leverage tokenistic efforts as proof they’re sustainable from top-to-bottom. But the newly laid out expectations for evidence-based claims, clear language, meaningful comparisons, and full life cycle considerations will expose which brands are really doing the work and which are merely greenwashing as a PR exercise.

“Greenwashing erodes consumer trust and means that genuinely sustainable brands struggle to be heard,” says Kelly. “We need to make conscious consumerism as easy and authentic as possible for our customers. They need to be able to trust that what we say is true.”

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


We Just Got Our First Look At 'Riverdale' Season 6—And It Includes *That* 'Sabrina' Crossover

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd If there’s one thing certain in life, it’s that change is a given—’Riverdale’ is certainly seeing to that. Season 6 of the popular ... Read more »

Kate laughs off royal mix-up made by Dec Donnelly who confuses her with the Queen

The Duchess of Cambridge has laughed off a major mix-up by television host Declan Donnelly moments before taking to the stage to present a keynote speech. Donnelly, who is best ... Read more »

A Vermont high school turned its football halftime show into a drag pageant featuring nearly 30 students and faculty members

© Fritz Senftleber via AP People participate in the “drag ball” halftime show at Burlington High School on Friday, Oct. 15, 2021 in Burlington, Vt. Fritz Senftleber via AP A ... Read more »

What's Really Going on Between Khloe Kardashian and Tristan Thompson After Attending Kourtney's Proposal

Who better to accompany you to your sister’s elaborate marriage proposal than your ex? When Travis Barker popped the question to Kourtney Kardashian in Montecito, Calif., on Oct. 17, they ... Read more »

Peter Andre reveals he's the 'most ill I've been in three years'

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Peter Andre’s daughter Princess voiced her concerns for him on Instagram on Tuesday night after he told her he feels the ‘most ill ... Read more »

Isabel II recusa nomeação de "Idosa do Ano" por acreditar que não cumpre critérios

© TVI24 Isabel II recusa nomeação de “Idosa do Ano” por acreditar que não cumpre critérios A rainha Isabel II rejeitou ser nomeada “A Idosa do Ano” por uma revista ... Read more »

I Really Need Others to See the Cuteness That Is Naomi Osaka's 3D Teddy Bear Manicure

© Getty I Really Need Others to See the Cuteness That Is Naomi Osaka’s 3D Teddy Bear Manicure Naomi Osaka continues to serve up beauty inspiration. Fresh off a US ... Read more »

Manhunt underway in Utah to find local radio personality's killer

© Martha Black A picture of Gaby Ramos rests on a makeshift memorial inside her Taylorsville, Utah, home. – Martha Black When Gabriela Sifuentes Castilla, better known as Gaby Ramos, ... Read more »

Manchester airport's Terminal 2 reopens after reports of suspicious package

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Xinhua/Rex/Shutterstock Manchester airport’s Terminal 2 is to reopen after a police investigation found “no security threat” following reports of a suspicious package. The terminal ... Read more »

6 truques geniais para desamassar roupas – sem ferro de passar

© Fornecido por Decor Style Não há maneira mais rápida de cometer uma gafe de moda do que ir a um evento, trabalho ou uma entrevista de emprego com uma ... Read more »

Fine Gael MEP calls for EU to suspend its funding for Poland

The EU should suspend its funding to Poland until it addresses its rule of law issues, according to a Fine Gael MEP. Sean Kelly said Poland needs to get its house in order before ... Read more »

Aldi Australia launches most luxurious Christmas range EVER

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Aldi Australia is preparing to release its ‘most luxurious Christmas range ever’, with prices starting from just $3.99 Launching on October 27, the ... Read more »

These Breathable Joggers Are So Soft, I Might Leave Leggings Behind for Good

© Provided by Real Simple vuoriclothing.com Even before working from home became my new normal, I had a comfort-first mentality. My former uniform of flowy dresses and black tights was ... Read more »

Get Popular Board Games, Play-Doh & More Up to 40% Off As Part of Amazon's Epic Daily Deals

© Adobe; Amazon. Design: Ashley Britton/SheKnows. Amazon has announced that Hasbro Gaming is on sale for its Epic Daily Deals (for today only). When Amazon kicked off these Epic Daily ... Read more »

GBBO fans applaud Matt Lucas as he catches Giuseppe's falling Showstopper: 'Not on my watch!

The Great British Bake Off fans were left applauding Matt Lucas on Tuesday’s episode as he managed to catch Giuseppe’s falling showstopper before it hit the floor. During the latest ... Read more »

The Best Hair Masks Amazon Has To Offer To Keep Your Hair Silky Smooth & Healthy

© Provided by Refinery29 Chillier weather is drying on our skin, from our feet to our faces. Carrying around hand creams and switching our moisturizers for a thicker formula is ... Read more »

Ex-GOP senator leaving party, challenging Oklahoma governor

© Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. Election 2022 Oklahoma Governor – Copyright 2017 The Associated Press. All rights reserved. The first GOP candidate to challenge Oklahoma Gov. ... Read more »

Bec Hewitt celebrates Ava's milestone

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd Dancing With The Stars finalist Bec Hewitt has made a rare post to pay tribute to her daughter Ava, and she has grown ... Read more »

The Queen turns down ‘Oldie Award'

© Provided by Are Media Pty Ltd Queen Elizabeth II has gracefully declined an Oldie Award at 95-years-old, saying she doesn’t feel old enough to accept it. The monarch was ... Read more »

Kobe Bryant's widow could be made to take psych test in lawsuit over leaked crash photos

Vanessa Bryant could be asked to take a psych test in her lawsuit against Los Angeles County over photos taken by the first responders to her husband Kobe’s death. First ... Read more »

Facebook agrees to settle US discrimination lawsuit by paying fine

© AFP via Getty Images Facebook CEO Mark Zuckerberg – AFP via Getty Images Facebook is paying a $4.75 million fine and up to $9.5 million to eligible victims to ... Read more »

Covid live: no contingency measures for UK despite high deaths; Pfizer jab 93% effective in keeping children out of hospital

© Photograph: Neil Hall/AFP/Getty Images An intensive care medic in Cambridge as UK reports highest daily deaths since March. LIVE – Updated at 22:04 UK reports further 223 deaths but ... Read more »

Pro-Trump senators hid from Democrats in closet during Capitol riot, Tommy Tuberville says

© Getty Images Senator Tommy Tuberville says he and other Republicans hid in a closet on 6 January – Getty Images As the US Capitol was under siege on 6 ... Read more »

Renewed appeal for info on murder of Paul Quinn in Monaghan ahead of 14th Anniversary of his killing

Gardaí are issuing a renewed appeal for information surrounding the murder of Paul Quinn in Monaghan in October 2007. Paul Quinn was murdered on October 20, 2007, in the Tullyvanus ... Read more »

Families say they were given few details of incineration of babies' organs

Five grieving families have come forward claiming they only found out that their late babies’ organs had been incinerated along with clinical waste in Belgium after watching an RTÉ exposé. ... Read more »

Ask a Beauty Editor: How to Tell if You Have Congested Skin—Plus the Best Products for Clogged Pores

© Provided by Real Simple Getty Images Ever wanted to pick the brain of a beauty editor? Or get beauty product recommendations from someone who has tried them all? You’ve ... Read more »

12 Cozy Amazon Holiday Home Goods The Internet Should Know About

The word “cozy” gains superpowers starting in the month of September and it doesn’t lose its seasonal spark until around springtime. So it’s only natural to want to stock up ... Read more »

Noel Fielding withdraws from Bake Off as viewers left concerned by absence: 'Hope he's ok'

Noel Fielding and Matt Lucas returned to the Great British Bake Off tent for German Week on Tuesday evening. Alongside judges Prue Leith and Paul Hollywood, the remaining bakers were ... Read more »

Royal Opera House to review classic works as it makes overture to Black Lives Matter

© Alastair Muir Turandot performed at the Royal Opera House – Alastair Muir For centuries the spectacle of opera has transported audiences from Mozart’s Ottoman seraglios to Bizet’s Spanish bullrings. ... Read more »

Celine Dion delays Las Vegas concerts due to medical issue

© Provided by Cover Media Celine Dion Celine Dion has delayed her upcoming Las Vegas shows as a result of “severe and persistent muscle spasms”. The Canadian superstar had been ... Read more »

Nphet member Professor Philip Nolan appointed head of Science Foundation Ireland

Professor Philip Nolan has been appointed Director General of Science Foundation Ireland (SFI). The former president of Maynooth University, whose 10 year term ended last month, is a key figure ... Read more »

7 sofás modernos que farão você repensar toda a sua sala de estar

Se você é do tipo que gosta de design dinamarquês, provavelmente o seu forte é móvel moderno. Os sofás modernos elevam toda a sala de estar com suas linhas elegantes, ... Read more »

Surf nas Maldivas: resort tem duas ilhas com ondas próprias

As Maldivas, além de terem visuais espetaculares, são um ótimo destino para uma surf trip. O Niyama Private Islands é um resort de luxo que tem suas próprias ondas quebrando ... Read more »

Gambling addict who defrauded a woman and a charity of €30,000 is jailed

© Leah Farrell via RollingNews.ie A GAMBLING ADDICT who defrauded a woman and a charity of €30,000 by claiming to need it for medical expenses has been jailed for two-and-a-half ... Read more »

Atletico Madrid vs Liverpool result: Mohamed Salah sets another record as Reds hold on for victory

© Getty Images GettyImages-1347556200.jpg Mohamed Salah set yet another goalscoring record as Liverpool recovered from squandering a two-goal lead to beat 10-man Atletico Madrid 3-2 on a wild Champions League ... Read more »

Wexford school which moved to remote learning due to dozens of Covid cases to reopen its doors after Department request

A Wexford primary school that closed for in-person teaching due to a number of Covid-19 cases has reversed its decision and will reopen on Wednesday. This is the result of ... Read more »

UEFA Champions League 2021/22 results: UCL fixtures, groups, latest standings after matchday 3

© POOL/AFP via Getty Images ChampionsLeaguetrophy.jpg The Champions League action returns after the international break this week as the group stage reaches its halfway point. Manchester City got their campaign ... Read more »

Watch Blue Ivy barge in on Jay-Z and Beyoncé's romantic date night in their latest Tiffany & Co. campaign video

© Provided by INSIDER Jay-Z and Beyoncé’s eldest daughter Blue Ivy makes a cameo in their advertisement for Tiffany & Co. Tiffany & Co. Tiffany & Co. released the latest ... Read more »

Good mood food: Can changing what you eat help boost your spirits?

Lockdown has been a hard slog – and when takeaways returned at level 3, they came as a welcome relief from meal planning. And many of us will be turning ... Read more »

Record number of unruly airline passengers continues to rise

© AFP via Getty Images Passengers deplane from a Southwest Airlines flight from Las Vegas at Hollywood Burbank Airport in Burbank, California, October 10, 2021. – AFP via Getty Images ... Read more »