Remarks by 9 justices indicate how they lean on abortion

This artist sketch depicts Center for Reproductive Rights Litigation Director Julie Rikelman speaking to the Supreme Court, Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021, in Washington. Seated to Rikelman's right is Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar. Justices seated from left are Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh, Associate Justice Elena Kagan, Associate Justice Samuel Alito, Associate Justice Clarence Thomas, Chief Justice John Roberts, Associate Justice Stephen Breyer, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch and Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett. (Dana Verkouteren via AP)
1 / 3Supreme Court AbortionThis artist sketch depicts Center for Reproductive Rights Litigation Director Julie Rikelman speaking to the Supreme Court, Wednesday, Dec. 1, 2021, in Washington. Seated to Rikelman’s right is Solicitor General Elizabeth Prelogar. Justices seated from left are Associate Justice Brett Kavanaugh, Associate Justice Elena Kagan, Associate Justice Samuel Alito, Associate Justice Clarence Thomas, Chief Justice John Roberts, Associate Justice Stephen Breyer, Associate Justice Sonia Sotomayor, Associate Justice Neil Gorsuch and Associate Justice Amy Coney Barrett. (Dana Verkouteren via AP)

WASHINGTON (AP) — The Supreme Court on Wednesday heard arguments in which the court was asked to overturn a nationwide right to abortion that has existed for nearly 50 years.

The fate of the court’s 1973 Roe v. Wade decision legalizing abortion throughout the United States and its 1992 ruling in Planned Parenthood v. Casey, which reaffirmed Roe, probably won’t be known until late June.

But during nearly two hours of arguments conservative justices indicated they had questions about the court's current abortion framework. The justices were being asked to overrule the two seminal decisions in the context of a Mississippi law that bans abortion after 15 weeks. The court's Roe and Casey precedents say a state can regulate but not ban abortion before the point of viability, at about 24 weeks. All six conservative justices, including three appointed by former President Donald Trump, indicated they would uphold Mississippi’s law.

In their writings and statements before Wednesday, Justice Clarence Thomas had been the only justice to call openly for overruling Roe and Casey.

Here are some of the things the justices said during arguments:

CONSERVATIVES:

Chief Justice John Roberts called a 15-week ban “not a dramatic departure from viability.” He said: “If you think … that women should have a choice to terminate their pregnancy, that supposes that there is a point at which they’ve had the fair choice, opportunity to choice, and why would 15 weeks be an inappropriate line? Because viability, it seems to me, doesn’t have anything to do with choice. But, if it really is an issue about choice, why is 15 weeks not enough time?”

Justice Clarence Thomas suggested the right to abortion appears nowhere in the Constitution: “If we were talking about the Second Amendment, I know exactly what we’re talking about. If we’re talking about the Fourth Amendment, I know what we’re talking about because it’s written. It’s there. What specifically is the right here that we’re talking about?”

Justice Samuel Alito said people on both sides of the abortion issue have said the court's viability line “really doesn't make a lot of sense.” He suggested a woman still “has the same interest in terminating her pregnancy after the viability line has been crossed.” He added: “The fetus has an interest in having a life, and that doesn’t change, does it, from the point before viability to the point after viability?”

Justice Neil Gorsuch asked what the court should do if it were to “reject the viability line.” “Do you see any other intelligible principle that the court could choose?” he asked the Biden administration's top Supreme Court lawyer, who was arguing that Mississippi's ban should be struck down.

Justice Brett Kavanaugh suggested overruling precedent has been an important part of the court's history: “If you think about some of the most important cases, the most consequential cases in this court’s history, there’s a string of them where the cases overruled precedent.” Kavanaugh cited cases that extended rights beyond where they were previously, including those that outlawed segregation and said gay couples have a right to marry. “If we think that the prior precedents are seriously wrong, if that, why then doesn’t the history of this court’s practice with respect to those cases tell us that the right answer is actually a return to the position of neutrality and — and not stick with those precedents in the same way that all those other cases didn’t?”

Justice Amy Coney Barrett suggested that so-called safe haven laws in all 50 states that allow mothers to relinquish parental rights mean women can’t be forced into motherhood. She asked about states “requiring the woman to go 15, 16 weeks more” past the point of viability “and then terminate parental rights at the conclusion.” ”Why didn’t you address the safe haven laws and why don’t they matter?” she asked a lawyer arguing against Mississippi's ban.

LIBERALS:

Justice Stephen Breyer said that where the court is overturning a watershed case like Roe it “better be damn sure” before doing so. He quoted the Casey case about the dangers of overruling precedent, saying: “To overrule under fire in the absence of the most compelling reason, to reexamine a watershed decision, would subvert the court’s legitimacy beyond any serious question.”

Justice Sonia Sotomayor said reversing Roe and Casey would damage the court. She asked: “Will this institution survive the stench that this creates in the public perception that the Constitution and its reading are just political acts?”

Justice Elena Kagan said of the current case: “I guess what strikes me when I look at this case is that, you know, not much has changed since Roe and Casey, that people think it’s right or wrong based on the things that they have always thought it was right and wrong for.” Since Roe, however, there's been “50 years of water under the bridge, 50 years of decisions saying that this is part of our law, that this is part of the fabric of women’s existence in this country.”

News Related

OTHER NEWS

RHP Tropeano gets minor deal with Rangers, invite to camp

ARLINGTON, Texas (AP) — Right-hander Nick Tropeano has agreed on a minor league contract with the Texas Rangers, a deal the team said Wednesday includes an invitation to major league ... Read more »

Glass Animals' 'Heat Waves' and its long, 'strange' journey to the top of the charts

Late January is hardly the time you’d expect a song called “Heat Waves” to top the charts. But that’s precisely what’s happened for British psychedelic pop band Glass Animals, whose ... Read more »

Longtime MLB manager Jim Leyland's 'heart aches' for Barry Bonds after Hall of Fame miss

Before Jim Leyland joined the Detroit Tigers for eight years at the end of his managerial career, he managed 11 seasons for the Pittsburgh Pirates, two for the Florida Marlins ... Read more »

Dozens of guns among Los Angeles train loot: police

© Patrick T. FALLON An average of 90 containers a day are being vandalised in Los Angeles County Dozens of guns have been stolen from freight trains that have been ... Read more »

ANC's Days of Zondo: Ramaphosa's ‘task team' faced with a task from hell

This ANC task team certainly has the complicated task of guiding the party’s response to the Zondo report. The party is likely to be fundamentally split on how it should ... Read more »

Bank of Canada keeps benchmark rate unchanged despite inflation

© Nicholas KAMM The timing and pace of Canadian interest rate increases will be guided by the rate of inflation, according to the country’s central bank The Bank of Canada ... Read more »

Tesla's Elon Musk Outlines Ambitious Future, but No New Models This Year

© Tesla The Cybertruck, Roadster, and Semi will continue to be developed in 2022, but Tesla will prioritize reaching full self-driving that’s better than a human. During an earnings call ... Read more »

Russia sparks panic by sending fake signals that warplanes are about to attack Ukraine

RUSSIA sparked panic by sending fake signals that its warplanes were taking off to attack Ukraine, it was revealed yesterday. Vladimir Putin’s boffins are believed to have placed military jet ... Read more »

My girlfriend had drunk sex with a woman but said it's not really cheating

DEAR DEIDRE: MY girlfriend admitted she slept with another woman when she was drunk. She says it meant nothing and that she loves me, but I’m not sure I believe ... Read more »

Justice Stephen Breyer will weigh these key SCOTUS cases before he retires

Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer only has a few months left on the bench, as he reportedly plans to retire at the end of this term, but before he steps ... Read more »

President Biden, it's you – not Republicans – who's bereft of ideas

Former Secretary of State Mike Pompeo argues Joe Biden‘s cheap rhetoric is emblematic of his unwillingness to obtain advice from anyone beyond his handlers. AP Mr. President, you asked in ... Read more »

Australia news live update: 59 Covid deaths in Victoria, NSW and Queensland; Central Land Council calls for regional NT lockdown

LIVE – Updated at 00:10 Follow all the day’s news live.   00:10 These are the 15 school pop-up vaccination sites opening this weekend ahead of the school year. Another ... Read more »

2 jailed on drug trafficking charges

Jan. 26—Two Decatur residents were in Morgan County Jail after local authorities seized more than 1.5 pounds of cocaine and other drugs during a traffic stop in Decatur on Tuesday, ... Read more »

Supreme Court denies stay for Oklahoma death row inmates

Jan. 26—An Oklahoma death row inmate is set for lethal injection Thursday after the nation's top court denied his emergency stay. Donald Grant is scheduled to die at 10 a.m. ... Read more »

Record number of Black and Asian students accepted at top UK universities

Photograph: Chris Ison/PA Black and Asian students won places at prestigious UK universities at record levels in 2021, alongside increasing numbers of students from all backgrounds, and the chief executive ... Read more »

Canucks hire Swedish-born Patrik Allvin as general manager

VANCOUVER, British Columbia (AP) — Jim Rutherford says there are some big decisions looming for the Vancouver Canucks, but the team’s president of hockey operations has crossed one large task ... Read more »

Today in History for January 27th

Highlights of Today in History: , Soviet troops liberate concentration camps; Paris peace accords are signed; Astonauts die on Apollo one;Wolfgang Amadeus Mozart born;Composer Jerome Kern born Read more »

Italian soccer referee ‘locked up at home' after revenge porn claim

View this post on Instagram A post shared by Diana Di Meo (@dianadimeo_) Diana Di Meo, a 22-year-old soccer referee from Pescara, Italy, is not leaving the house after explicit ... Read more »

I'm a stripper & OnlyFans model – mum tells me to spend my cash but I save it all, I get a thrill from my bank balance

AN ONLYFANS model has revealed she works seven days a week on her X-rated content – but doesn't spend her earnings. Natasha Cheri Boyd, from Glasgow, turned to the adult ... Read more »

How to add extensions to Chrome to enhance your browsing experience

© Shutterstock/Evan Lorne How to add extensions to Chrome to enhance your browsing experience You can add extensions to Chrome using the web browser’s store. Chrome is compatible with thousands ... Read more »

Home and Away's Ryder Jackson receives death warning in new clip

Home and Away spoilers follow for Australian and UK viewers. Home and Away returns to screens in Australia next week, and will air the next part of Ryder Jackson’s burial ... Read more »

Tottenham could face Traore competition as 'Barcelona eye Wolves ace'

Barcelona are reportedly eyeing a January deal for Wolves winger Adama Traore – but a potential move depends heavily on the future of Ousmane Dembele. Xavi is desperate to strengthen ... Read more »

College student accused of selling dozens of loaded guns to undercover NYPD cop

He went from getting A’s — to facing Class B felonies. A Tennessee college student — who once made the dean’s list — was arrested in New York for allegedly ... Read more »

Brussels to sue Britain for Brexit trade deal breach in bonkers row over wind farms

BRUSSELS will sue Britain for a breach of the Brexit trade deal in a bonkers row about wind farms, The Sun can reveal. France and Spain are spearheading an “envious” ... Read more »

George Osbourne warns Boris Johnson he could be finished if he goes ahead with controversial National Insurance tax rise

GEORGE Osborne has warned Boris Johnson he could be finished if he goes ahead with his controversial National Insurance tax rise. In a withering attack, he said the PM should ... Read more »

N.Korea fires 'projectile' in sixth launch this month, S.Korea says

© Reuters/Denis Balibouse FILE PHOTO – A North Korean flag flies on a mast at the Permanent Mission of North Korea in Geneva By Josh Smith SEOUL (Reuters) -Nuclear-armed North ... Read more »

Seven scramblers and a quad bike seized in garda operation

© Gardaai The vehicles were seized during searches this morning. GARDAÍ HAVE SEIZED seven scrambler motorbikes and a quad bike in a planned operation in Dublin. The seizures were in ... Read more »

Husband, 71, knifed his wife, 74, to death and called cops to confess killing the tragic mum-of-two

A HUSBAND who knifed his wife to death as she lay in bed told cops he'd “had enough” after killing the mum-of-two. David Maggs, 71, admitted to fatally stabbing his ... Read more »

How the West is squaring up to Putin's war machine with ‘thousands of troops', javelin missiles & F-16 fighter jets

WESTERN countries are squaring up to Vladimir Putin's war machine with “thousands of troops” and an impressive arsenal featuring javelin missiles and F-16 fighter jets. Fears of a Russian invasion ... Read more »

9 Chilling Things Nostradamus Predicted For 2022

Nostradamus is renowned for the accuracy of his predictions that date from centuries back. His forecasts are prophecies and are said to announce huge worldwide changes that will impact the ... Read more »

What's plan B if the government can't attract investors willing to fund Sizewell C?

© Provided by The Guardian Photograph: Michael Brooks/Alamy A sum of £100m is peanuts in the expensive world of nuclear power stations, so regard the business secretary Kwasi Kwarteng’s funding ... Read more »

Two men in hospital with gunshot wounds following shooting near Wigan

© Peter Byrne Greater Manchester Police were called by the ambulance service at around 5.45pm on Wednesday (Peter Byrne/PA) Two men are in hospital after a double shooting in a ... Read more »

My wheelie bin was eaten by lorry – the council didn't bother to tell me & now I have to wait 6 weeks for a replacement

A COUPLE have been left furious after their wheelie bin was eaten by a lorry and the council didn't bother to tell them. The homeowners in Stockton, County Durham, faced ... Read more »

Savvy shopper spots Heroes and Celebration tubs on sale at Co-op for just £1.25

PILES of chocolate tubs were spotted at Co-op for just £1.25, an incredible discount of almost 70%. Large 650g-sized tubs of Celebrations, Heroes and Quality Street were snapped and posted ... Read more »

Face mask rules in supermarkets explained as Plan B restrictions end – what you need to know

SUPERMARKETS are set to allow customers to shop without a mask as Plan B restrictions end. Government rules which made face coverings compulsory in supermarkets in England come to an ... Read more »

Golden asteroid worth $10,000QUADRILLION will be probed by Nasa

NASA is getting ready to probe a massive asteroid that contains so many precious metals it's worth more than our global economy. The US space agency's asteroid probe will depart ... Read more »

Seoul: N Korea fires projectile in 6th launch this month

The Associated PressFILE – In this photo provided by the North Korean government, North Korean leader Kim Jong Un attends a meeting of the Central Committee of the ruling Workers’ ... Read more »

US Supreme Court declines to halt pending Oklahoma execution

The Associated PressFILE – This undated photo provided by the Oklahoma Department of Corrections shows Donald Anthony Grant. A federal appeals court in Denver has rejected a request from two ... Read more »

Lonza fährt Pharma-Produktion in Visp hoch: Wallis wird zur Apotheke für die ganze Welt

Lonza hat im Oberwallis einen beispiellosen Boom ausgelöst. Der Chemie- und Pharmakonzern produziert in Visp VS Hunderte Millionen Impfdosen für Moderna. Doch das Pandemie-Ende scheint greifbar. Ist damit auch der ... Read more »

No, Joe Biden isn't nominating Kamala Harris to SCOTUS

The Washington math goes like this: © ROBERTO SCHMIDT/AFP/Getty Images US President Joe Biden delivers remarks on the passage of the Bipartisan Infrastructure Deal and the rule that will allow ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic