Missouri Withheld Data Showing Effectiveness of Mask Mandates

Asia's Tech News Daily

A shopper wears a face mask inside a store in St. Louis, July 27, 2021. (Whitney Curtis/The New York Times)

Mask mandates were effective as the delta variant of the coronavirus was driving a surge in COVID-19 cases across Missouri, according to an analysis that the state’s Department of Health and Senior Services conducted in early November.

But the state did not immediately share that data with the public. Instead, the information was released Wednesday, a month later, because of a public records request by The Missouri Independent, a nonprofit news organization that reported the findings, and the Documenting COVID-19 project at the Brown Institute for Media Innovation.

The records include an email dated Nov. 3 from the director of Missouri’s Health Department to a staff member in the governor’s office. The email included two graphs that compared the rates of reported COVID cases and deaths in parts of Missouri with and without mask mandates.

The director, Donald Kauerauf, said in the email that there were many variables to account for when assessing the impacts of requirements“>mask requirements in Missouri this year, but that the analysis ultimately showed that such requirements were effective.

“I think we can say with great confidence reviewing the public health literature and then looking at the results in your study that communities where masks were required had a lower positivity rate per 100,000 and experienced lower death rates,” Kauerauf wrote.

The analysis compared the reported case and death rates in the parts of the state without mask requirements to rates in St. Louis, St. Louis County, Kansas City and Jackson County, where mask mandates had been in place.

The study looked at the period from April to October, when the delta variant was driving an increase in coronavirus infections worldwide.

During that time frame, there were 15.8 cases per day for every 100,000 residents, on average, in the areas that required masks, compared with 21.7 cases per 100,000 residents in unmasked communities, according to The Missouri Independent’s analysis of the data. Regions without mask requirements recorded 1 death per 100,000 residents every 3.5 days, compared with 1 death per 100,000 residents every five days where masks were required, the Independent said.

Gov. Mike Parson, a Republican, has said he supports wearing masks to slow the spread of COVID, but he has repeatedly spoken out against mask requirements. In July, he said on Twitter that issuing mask mandates while a vaccine is available eroded public trust. “The vaccine is how we rid ourselves of COVID-19, not mask mandates that ignore common sense,” Parson wrote.

In a statement posted on Twitter on Thursday, Parson reiterated his opposition to mask mandates and said the requirements “infringe on our personal liberties.”

“Director Kauerauf has consistently and publicly stated that mandates are not the answer to Missouri’s COVID-19 outbreak,” Parson wrote. “They do not work and can have collateral health consequences.” The governor’s statement did not explain why his office chose not to publish the analysis it had requested.

Parson’s office and the state health department did not immediately respond to requests for comment Thursday.

In Missouri, new cases have risen from a daily average of about 1,000 in early November to more than 2,000 this month, and hospitalizations are up 32% over the past 14 days, according to a New York Times database. More than 15,540 people have died from COVID in Missouri, according to the database.

In late November, a circuit court judge in Missouri ruled that public health orders issued by local health departments to prevent the spread of the coronavirus violated the state’s constitution.

Mask are still required, however, in St. Louis and St. Louis County. Kansas City ended its requirement on Nov. 5, and the legislature in Jackson County voted to end its mask requirement in early November.

Nick Dunne, a spokesperson for St. Louis Mayor Tishaura Jones, said city officials believed St. Louis’ mask mandate was still legal, despite the circuit court order. In response to the state health department’s analysis, Dunne said, “It tells us what public health experts have been telling us all along, which is that masks are an effective tool for reducing community transmission of the COVID-19 virus.”

In November 2020, Missouri’s hospitals asked Parson to issue a statewide mask order as hospital administrators struggled to find beds for COVID patients.

Dave Dillon, a spokesperson for the Missouri Hospital Association, said Thursday that because vaccines were available and there were now more options for treating COVID, the request for a statewide mask order was “an artifact.”

Dillon said the association still encouraged people to use masks and follow social distancing guidelines. “Since we’re still in COVID-19 response — with a growing positivity rate and hospitalization numbers — our position will evolve as the science and public health guidance evolves,” Dillon said in an email.

Across the country, four states and several counties and cities have mask mandates. On Thursday, President Joe Biden extended until mid-March a requirement that travelers wear masks on airplanes, trains and buses, and in airports and transit stations as part of a broader strategy to combat COVID. These measures come as scientists and public officials prepare for a possible increase in coronavirus cases during the winter and seek more information about a new variant, known as omicron.

© 2021 The New York Times Company

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

BRIT Awards to launch public vote for four new genre categories this week

A public vote for The BRIT Awards with Mastercard’s four new genre categories will open on Thursday (20.01.22). © Bang Showbiz The BRIT Awards to launch public vote for new ... Read more »

Britney Spears', Jamie Spears' lawyers square off as disability rights advocates push for reform

SACRAMENTO, Calif. — Disability rights activists and advocates for Britney Spears backed a California proposal Wednesday to provide more protections for those under court-ordered conservatorships, while promoting less-restrictive alternatives. Their ... Read more »

Harrison Burton is eager, ready to earn his keep at NASCAR's top level

Only a few months into his new role, Harrison Burton has hit the ground running. Tabbed as the latest wheelman for the iconic Wood Brothers Racing team in the NASCAR ... Read more »

2022 NASCAR Cup Series: A look at the full 36-race schedule, including two new stops

© Provided by CBS Sports With the sport of stock car racing going through a period of major change, the 2022 NASCAR Cup Series will hardly resemble anything that had ... Read more »

Third-generation driver Tommy Catalano looks ahead to full-time Mods season with familiar mindset

Tommy Catalano‘s family has been racing since the early 1960s. Some 60 years later, that tradition will continue as Tommy Catalano brings the family’s No. 54 car back to the ... Read more »

The Plaid Pieces We're Suddenly Obsessed With After Watching Euphoria's Latest Ep

Plaid isn’t a print a we usually find ourselves drawn to, but here in lies the sartorial stronghold of Euphoria. If you found yourself searching for patterned pieces while tuning ... Read more »

Valerien Ismael drops Daryl Dike hint ahead of potential West Brom start

Daryl Dike is eyeing a full West Bromwich Albion debut when Peterborough United visit The Hawthorns on Saturday. More than 2,600 travelling Albion supporters got their first glimpse of January ... Read more »

Is Logan Paul vs. Hasbulla the next big fight of 2022?

© Provided by Sporting News In 2021, Logan Paul fought legendary boxer Floyd Mayweather in the ring, going the distance with him. This year, he has been challenged by another ... Read more »

Steven Gerrard likes Aston Villa grand plan as fresh Luis Suarez update emerges

Good morning and welcome to our Aston Villa coverage on Thursday, January 20, 2022. Here’s a round-up of the latest Villa news from BirminghamLive… Gerrard ‘impressed’ by exciting plan for ... Read more »

Hong Kong is mass-culling 2,000 hamsters and making owners hand over their pets amid fears that they might pass COVID-19 to people

© Arterra/Universal Images Group via Getty Images Hong Kong plans to cull around 2,000 hamsters, and is requesting that the city’s residents hand over their pets, amid fears that the ... Read more »

Jabber Jaws: Boughner on defense, power play

© Photo by Kavin Mistry/NHLI via Getty Images Timo Meier’s five-goal night was a historic achievement none of us will be forgetting anytime soon. While goal-scoring was the focus of ... Read more »

Rep. Henry Cuellar says he'll 'cooperate with any' probe amid reports of FBI raid at Texas home

© Provided by NBC News A Democratic House member said he will “fully cooperate in any investigation” amid reports that the FBI raided his Texas home Wednesday. Rep. Henry Cuellar, ... Read more »

4 takeaways from the NY attorney general filings on the Trump Organization, including accusations of inflated property values and refusals to cooperate

© Provided by Business Insider Then-President Donald Trump speaks in the Diplomatic Room of the White House on Thanksgiving on November 26, 2020 in Washington, DC. Erin Schaff/Getty Images The ... Read more »

'Tala'vision': how the ISIS TV ban inspired this Jordanian-German Oscar-shortlisted film

In late 2015, ISIS banned televisions across its territories, denouncing the medium as an instrument for corrupting people’s minds and spurring dissent. The ban was by no means extraordinary. By ... Read more »

A man set himself on fire after a matchmaking agency refused to arrange a marriage for him

© Avid_creative The local authorities in Jeju East, South Korea, said that the man doused himself in gasoline and set himself ablaze with a lighter during a dispute with an ... Read more »

Man scammed mask buyers, then used money to flee to Batam to marry pregnant lover

SINGAPORE — A man who cheated seven individuals into thinking he had surgical masks to sell via Carousell withdrew the money transferred to him and fled to Batam to be ... Read more »

2 Marines Killed, 17 Injured in North Carolina Military Vehicle Crash; Fellow Marine Charged

© iStock/Getty A U.S. Marine has been charged in the death of two other Marines following a rollover crash in North Carolina that caused soldiers to be ejected from a ... Read more »

Sony HT-S40R Sound System Brings Surround Sound To Home Theatres With Minimal Wires

© Provided by Geek Culture When it comes to sound, for many, there can be no compromise. Sony is expanding its range of audio solutions with the HT-S40R. It is ... Read more »

NHL releases schedule update for postponed games

© Provided by NBC Sports The NHL announced on Wednesday a revised second half schedule now that players will not be participating in the 2022 Winter Olympics in Beijing. When ... Read more »

Watch Spurs vs. Thunder: TV channel, live stream info, start time

© Provided by CBS Sports Apr 9, 2019; Cleveland, OH, USA; NBA referee Brent Barnaky (36) makes a call in the second quarter of a game between the Cleveland Cavaliers ... Read more »

LAUSD: About a quarter of students absent this week

© David Crane/Los Angeles Daily News/TNS Students greet each other after arrival at Olive Vista Middle School in Sylmar, CA Tuesday, January 11, 2021. Tuesday was the first day back ... Read more »

Garmin’s Fenix 7 Series And Epix 2 Smartwatches Can Run For A Supposed 3.5 Weeks Per Charge

© Provided by Geek Culture Garmin‘s smartwatches have always been an exquisite blend of style and substance. Despite information on the Garmin Fenix 7 series being leaked since December 2021, ... Read more »

Cohen's crew: Parents fundraise for son, others with epilepsy

Stevenson Ranch resident Alison Gampe has spent the last six years fighting for her son Cohen after he was diagnosed with intractable epilepsy at just 6 months old.  A disorder that ... Read more »

Capitals’ Orlov suspended 2 games; Ehlers out at least 3 games

© Provided by NBC Sports Capitals defenseman Dmitry Orlov has been suspended two games for kneeing Nikolaj Ehlers of the Jets Tuesday night. Late in the third period of Washington’s ... Read more »

Rain and floods spark black mould warning as victims beg for national standard

© Provided by ABC Health Close up look at black mould on a wall after floods in a caravan park at North Haven April 2021 (ABC Mid North Coast: Wiriya Sati) ... Read more »

(KEMAS KINI) Wakil rakyat pembangkang ‘hilang' ketika bencana banjir, kata Ismail

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Perdana Menteri Ismail Sabri Yaakob berkata, susulan banjir besar melanda negeri itu secara mengejut, beliau mempengerusikan beberapa siri mesyuarat peringkat negeri yang sepatutnya bukan ... Read more »

Multiple dunks punctuate a wild finish between LSU and Kentucky

© Provided by For The Win A lot can happen in the final seconds of a college basketball game, and the No. 16 Kentucky Wildcats and No. 21 LSU Tigers ... Read more »

Auburn vs. Georgia odds, line, spread: 2022 college basketball picks, Jan. 19 predictions from proven model

© Provided by CBS Sports Mar 20, 2019; Salt Lake City, UT, USA; General overall view of a basketball approaching the rim and net before the first round of the ... Read more »

Pristine coral reef unblemished by warming oceans found off Tahiti

PARIS (Reuters) – Scientists have discovered a pristine, 3-km (1.8-mile) long reef of giant rose-shaped corals off the coast of Tahiti, in waters thought to be deep enough to protect ... Read more »

Brenden Aaronson linked with Leeds; Salzburg reportedly rejects $20M bid

Red Bull Salzburg has rejected a bid of almost $20 million from Premier League side Leeds United for United States men’s national team player Brenden Aaronson, according to The Athletic. ... Read more »

Transfer news: Christian Eriksen to Brentford, Diego Costa to Arsenal

The latest transfer news in the Premier League focuses on two superb players potentially returning with Diego Costa to Arsenal and Christian Eriksen to Brentford among the latest reports. Both ... Read more »

Ossoff and Collins clash over her past support for voting rights legislation

© Al Drago/Pool via Associated Press/Greg Nash Ossoff and Collins clash over her past support for voting rights legislation Freshman Sen. Jon Ossoff (D-Ga.), who has kept a low profile ... Read more »

Eltern von Otto Warmbier erhalten Mini-Entschädigung aus Nordkorea

Es ist nur ein Bruchteil von dem, was ein Gericht Cindy und Fred Warmbier zugesprochen hatte. Ihr Sohn, Otto Warmbier, war 2016 in Nordkorea verhaftet worden. Später verstarb er – ... Read more »

Endrick, just 15 years old, scores wild bicycle kick from outside 18 (video)

A very young player has scored a golazo in Brazil, which we believe means that a robot lifts Florentino Perez onto a private jet and instantly races him to South ... Read more »

Farrell savours 'nice blend' in Irish Six Nations squad

© Paul Faith Ireland head coach Andy Farrell says there is a nice blend of experience and fresh talent in his Six Nations squad Ireland head coach Andy Farrell said ... Read more »

Every Pair of Sneakers From Keds, Sperry + More Is 50% Off at This Online Sale

© Provided by Spot.ph PHOTO BY Markdown Madness Website ILLUSTRATION War Espejo © Provided by Spot.ph PHOTO BY Markdown Madness Website ILLUSTRATION War Espejo (SPOT.ph) We’re more than halfway through the ... Read more »

Army Corps to spend $732M on Mississippi River lock upgrade

ST. LOUIS — The U.S. Army Corps said it will spend $732 million to expand a lock and dam system to help barges more efficiently transport millions of tons of ... Read more »

Maude and Iris Apatow starred in Knocked Up as kids. This is their lives now.

In 2007, we watched Maude and Iris Apatow make their on-screen debut in Knocked Up, before reprising their roles again in the 2012 film, This is 40. In This is 40, they ... Read more »

Sanya Lopez shares behind the scenes photos of 'First Lady' taping

IG: Sparkle Who’s excited for “First Lady,” the sequel series to “First Yaya”? Sanya Lopez just took over Sparkle GMA Artist Center’s Instagram account and shared some photos from their ... Read more »

Dan Andrews announces MAJOR change to school for millions

Victoria’s Premier Dan Andrews has declared that he will not shut down schools as the state pushes forward with a new Covid-19 strategy.  Mr Andrews has been working closely with ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic