Nurses and other medical workers clash over Nursing Act

Nurses and other medical workers clash over Nursing Act

Members of the Korea Nurses Association stage a rally in front of the National Assembly, calling for the legislation of the Nursing Act, Nov. 23. Korea Times photo by Bae Woo-han

By Lee Hyo-jin

Controversy is deepening among different groups of medical staff over legislation of the Nursing Act, a law that stipulates the role and duties of licensed nurses.

The Korean Nurses Association (KNA), a group representing 460,000 nurses nationwide, has been calling for the legislation, insisting that the enactment will lay the groundwork for the improvement of nurse-related policies, which will improve their working conditions and resolve a chronic manpower shortage in the field.

However, other medical workers, such as doctors, care workers at nursing homes, assistant nurses and paramedics fiercely oppose the legislation, as they believe that the law will only benefit nurses and create confusion in the public healthcare system.

The Nursing Act, proposed by Rep. Kim Min-seok of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea, along with two other similar bills, proposed by Rep. Seo Jeong-suk and Rep. Choi Yeon-suk of the main opposition People Power Party, is currently being discussed in the National Assembly.

Attention is being paid to whether the bills will be passed amid the ongoing disputes between the various groups of medical workers.

The KNA argues that the 460,000 licensed nurses across the country ― a figure that amounts to triple the number of doctors ― have long been suffering from poor working conditions due to the absence of a separate law stipulating the specific roles and duties of professional nurses.

Currently, the legal role of a nurse is stipulated in the Medical Services Act. But according to the nurses’ group, due to ambiguities in the law, many nurses are forced to perform duties outside their job descriptions, often leading to overwork and difficulty in providing quality care for patients.

According to the association, in Korea, each nurse takes care of 11 to 18 patients, approximately double the average of nurses in OECD countries, which stands at six to eight.

For this reason, the nurses have been calling for a separate law defining the legal role of a nurse, citing the growing importance of professional nurses for Korea’s aging society and in the pandemic era.

Nurses and other medical workers clash over Nursing Act

A coalition of medical groups opposing the legislation of the Nursing Act holds a press conference in front of the National Assembly, Nov. 22. Yonhap

“The Nursing Act must be passed in order to ensure safe and stable working conditions. The law does not aim to benefit only nurses, but to enhance public safety and guarantee quality care for patients,” Shin Kyung-rim, head of the KNA, said during a rally in front of the National Assembly, Nov. 23.

“Currently, 90 countries, including the United States, Japan, China and Taiwan, have Nursing Acts. The 460,000 nurses and 120,000 students at nursing schools across the country will continue to fight for the legislation,” she said, urging lawmakers to pass the bill.

On the other hand, other medical groups strongly oppose the legislation.

A coalition of 10 such groups, including the Korea Medical Association, Korea Care Association, Korean Dental Association and the Korean Licensed Practical Nurses Association, held a press conference, Nov. 22, demanding that lawmakers retract the proposed bill.

Doctors worry that the law may allow nurses to intervene in the duties of physicians. The current medical law stipulates that nurses should provide care to patients by “assisting” doctors. But the amendment says that nurses should perform their duties “in accordance with the patients’ needs.”

“The Nursing Act includes clauses that will benefit only the nurses. And this law will not only affect the nurses, but also doctors and other practitioners, resulting in confusion at healthcare sites,” said Lee Pil-soo, head of the Korea Medical Association, the largest doctors’ group representing 140,000 members.

The doctors also expressed concerns that the bill, if passed, may create the legal basis for nurses to open their own clinics.

Assistant nurses and care workers at nursing homes, for their part, believe that the legislation will put the nurses in a higher position than them, leading to situations in which they will have to take orders from nurses.

News Related


Federation of Banks chief warns of cyber risks amid digitalization

Korea Federation of Banks (KFB) Chairman Kim Gwang-soo speaks during an online conference held at the KFB headquarters in Seoul, Thursday. Yonhap Kim asks presidential candidates to rectify ‘uneven playing ... Read more »

Gov't standard for vaccine completion confusing

Medical workers check COVID-19 self-test kits at a public health center in Anseong, 77 kilometers south of Seoul, Wednesday, a day before the introduction of new quarantine rules, under which ... Read more »

Patent trolls target Samsung Electronics

Tech giant urged to enhance in-company patent management, sign cross-licenses. By Baek Byung-yeul Samsung Electronics has increasingly become a target for non-practicing entities (NPEs), also known as patent trolls, who ... Read more »

Guidelines for financial platform businesses

FSS Governor Jeong Eun-bo speaks at a meeting with representatives of financial platform businesses held in Seoul, Wednesday. Jeong said that supervision guidelines for financial platform businesses will be set ... Read more »

Omicron surge sparks distrust in vaccine

A monitor at the disaster control center in Songpa District Office in Seoul shows an all-time high of 13,012 new daily COVID-19 infections for Tuesday. Yonhap By Lee Hyo-jin Korea ... Read more »

Inflation concern looms large

A traditional market in Daegu is crowded with shoppers this week, with days remaining before the Lunar New Year long weekend, which runs from Jan. 31 to Feb. 2. Yonhap ... Read more »

Small investors deserting local stock market

Retail investors stage a protest in front of the building of the Korea Exchange in Seoul, Jan. 18, calling for the resumption of drugmaker SillaJen stock trading. Yonhap By Lee ... Read more »

Krafton employees hit by plunging stock price

Krafton Founder and Chairman Chang Byung-gyu speaks during the firm’s online IPO press conference last summer. Courtesy of Krafton Employee stock ownership: not always a jackpot By Anna J. Park ... Read more »

Daewoo E&C, HDC unprepared for industrial accident law

Daewoo E&C CEO nominee Baek Jung-wan, left, and HDC Hyundai Development Company CEO Yu Byoung-gyu / Courtesy of each company By Park Jae-hyuk Daewoo E&C and HDC Hyundai Development Company ... Read more »

More new businesses allowed under KCCI's 'Sandbox' initiatives

KCCI office in Seoul / Korea Times file By Kim Hyun-bin The Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry’s (KCCI) “Sandbox Support Center” is starting to expand its presence, helping more ... Read more »

Korea to invest W9tr to speed up digital transformation

Science and ICT Minister Lim Hye-sook speaks in a pangovernmental meeting of the Korean Digital New Deal at the Korea Chamber of Commerce and Industry in Seoul on Wednesday. (Ministry ... Read more »

Lee Jae-myung calls to end mudslinging in presidential race

Lee Jae-myung, presidential nominee of the ruling Democratic Party of Korea, speaks Wednesday during a press conference held in Yeouido, western Seoul. (Joint Press Corps)The ruling Democratic Party’s presidential nominee ... Read more »

Seoul advises Korean nationals in 15 Ukraine regions to leave

Members of Ukrainian forces and volunteer soldiers train in a city park in Kyiv. (AP-Yonhap)South Korean government advised its nationals residing in 15 regions in Ukraine to leave amid heightened ... Read more »

Court grants injunction to call off one-on-one debate between Lee, Yoon

Presidential candidate Ahn Cheol-soo of the minor opposition People’s Party attends a party event on Wednesday. (Yonhap)The planned televised debate between the two leading presidential candidates has been called off, ... Read more »

Lee vows to push for 4 1/2-day workweek

Lee Jae-myung, the presidential nominee of the ruling Democratic Party, greets supporters in Gwangmyeong, Gyeonggi Province, on Tuesday. (Yonhap)Ruling party presidential candidate Lee Jae-myung said Wednesday he will push to ... Read more »

LGES, GM to build $2.6 billion EV battery plant in Michigan

LG Energy Solution (LGES) Head of Advanced Automotive Battery Division Kim Dong-myung, left, and General Motors Chair and CEO Mary Barra pose at the Michigan State Capitol in Lansing, Tuesday ... Read more »

Moon hopes for free trade deal with Mexico

This photo shows President Moon Jae-in speaking to his aides at a meeting at Cheong Wa Dae in Seoul on Jan. 10, 2022. (Yonhap)President Moon Jae-in expressed hope Wednesday for ... Read more »

S. Korea's AI defense technologies catching up with US equivalents: report

This photo released by the Korea Research Institute for Defense Technology Planning and Advancement on Wednesday, shows the cover of a new blueprint offering the development strategy of AI technology ... Read more »

Court grants Ahn's request to stop TV debate between Lee, Yoon

From left: Yoon Suk-yeol, Lee Jae-myung and Ahn Cheol-sooA court on Wednesday ruled in favor of minor party presidential candidate Ahn Cheol-soo in a lawsuit he filed to stop TV ... Read more »

Hanwha heir aims to build solar energy ecosystem

By Kim Hyun-bin Hanwha Group has been working to create a comprehensive solar energy ecosystem to transform the conglomerate into a renewable energy powerhouse in the increasingly environment-conscious business world, ... Read more »

NSC discusses measures over risk of Russia-Ukraine conflict

A view of Cheong Wa Dae in Seoul (Yonhap)The presidential National Security Council (NSC) has discussed tensions between Russia and Ukraine, including how the crisis will affect South Korea’s economy ... Read more »

Kakao Games invests $20 million in US game developer Frost Giant Studios

Kakao Games headquarters in Pangyo, Gyeonggi Province / Courtesy of Kakao Games South Korean game developer Kakao Games Corp. said Wednesday it has invested $20 million in U.S.-based independent game ... Read more »

Future of beauty and fragrance is at SCAD

Meloney Moore, Associate dean, School of Business Innovation of the Savannah College of Art and Design (SCAD) / Courtesy of SCAD For more than 40 years, the Savannah College of ... Read more »

Moon to preside over COVID-19 response meeting amid rapid spread of omicron

People wait in line to get tested for COVID-19 at a makeshift testing booth set up at a parking lot of the Jamsil Olympic Stadium in Seoul’s eastern district of ... Read more »

Yoon leads Lee 44.7% to 35.6%: poll

This compilation image shows (from L to R) presidential candidates Lee Jae-myung, Yoon Suk-yeol, Sim Sang-jeung and Ahn Cheol-soo. (Yonhap)Main opposition presidential candidate Yoon Suk-yeol is leading his ruling party ... Read more »

N. Korea's agricultural ministry elevated to state commission amid food shortages

(Yonhap)North Korea has decided to upgrade its agricultural ministry to a state commission, according to Pyongyang’s media Wednesday, as the country has tapped agricultural development as one of its top ... Read more »

[Contribution] Future of Chinese growth and implications for Korea

Pushan Dutt By Pushan Dutt When economists talk of growth miracles, they refer to countries that grew rapidly and caught up with the level of the development of the U.S. ... Read more »

US remains prepared to engage in dialogue with N. Korea: State Dept.

US Department of State spokesperson Ned Price is seen answering a question in a press briefing at the department in Washington on Tuesday in this image captured from the department’s ... Read more »

Korea's daily COVID-19 cases exceed 13,000 for first time

A health worker wearing protective gear holds plastic gloves for visitors at a temporary screening clinic for the coronavirus in Seoul, Jan. 25. AP-Yonhap South Korea’s daily coronavirus cases have ... Read more »

Doubts grow over Glenwood PE's exit from PI Advanced Materials

Glenwood Private Equity CEO Lee Sang-ho, left, and PI Advanced Materials CEO Kim Tae-lim By Park Jae-hyuk Glenwood Private Equity is facing growing skepticism over its forthcoming divestment from PI ... Read more »

IMF revises down economic growth outlook for Korea to 3 percent in 2022

In this September 2018 file photo, the International Monetary Fund (IMF) logo is displayed outside their headquarters building in Washington, U.S. Reuters-Yonhap By Yoon Ja-young The International Monetary Fund (IMF) ... Read more »

LG Energy Solution, GM to build $2.1 bil. battery factory in US

LG’s headquarters in Seoul / Yonhap Korean battery maker LG Energy Solution (LGES) said Tuesday it will together spend $2.1 billion with U.S. General Motors Co. to build another electric ... Read more »

Kyuhyun tells 'Love Story' with his voice

By Dong Sun-hwa Kyuhyun of K-pop act Super Junior poses during an online media event, Tuesday. Courtesy of Label SJ Kyuhyun of K-pop act Super Junior said he has never ... Read more »

Gov't warns daily cases may soar to 30,000 in early February

People wait in line for diagnostic tests at a COVID-19 testing station in Songpa District, Seoul, Tuesday. Yonhap Gov’t to phase in new response measures today to curb Omicron By ... Read more »

Seohyun of Girls' Generation makes film debut in sexy Netflix rom-com

A scene from the Netflix film, “Love and Leashes” / Courtesy of Netflix By Kwak Yeon-sooSeohyun, an actress and member of K-pop act Girls’ Generation, said she wanted to explore ... Read more »

Banks drop street-level branch locations to cut costs

Customers sit at a branch of a KB Kookmin Bank branch in Seoul. Yonhap By Anna J. Park While about 70 or 80 percent of banks’ suburban branches used to ... Read more »

LG, Samsung, SK up efforts to secure supply of battery materials

By Baek Byung-yeul LG Energy Solution, Samsung SDI and SK Innovation are actively responding to increasing prices of raw materials for electric car batteries as supply chain disruptions induced by ... Read more »

Seoul stocks dip to nearly 14-month low

A currency trader watches monitors at the foreign exchange dealing room of the KEB Hana Bank headquarters in Seoul, Jan. 25. Korean stocks tumbled to an almost 14-month low Tuesday ... Read more »

Korean economy expected to weather fallout of Omicron

Asia’s fourth-largest economy expands at fastest pace in 11 years By Yi Whan-woo The Korean economy is expected to continue its recovery in the first quarter of 2022 despite the ... Read more »

Hyundai Engineering IPO aims to expand green energy business

Hyundai Engineering CEO Kim Chang-hag By Lee Kyung-min Hyundai Engineering, the construction affiliate of Hyundai Motor Group, will accelerate its green energy transition by venturing into new high-tech energy businesses ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic