Manchester United beaten by Aston Villa at the death as Bruno Fernandes misses late penalty

© Getty Images

Kortney Hause’s 88th-minute header won the game for Aston Villa

– Getty Images

Perhaps Cristiano Ronaldo will be Manchester United’s penalty-taker now. Perhaps Ole Gunnar Solskjaer will have a different lament about spot-kicks.

The United manager had been complaining about the penalties his side were denied. United duly got one when substitute Edinson Cavani glanced on Bruno Fernandes’ cross and the ball hit Kortney Hause’s hand. Not, perhaps, the clearest of decisions, but Mike Dean gave it and United, trailing 1-0 in injury time, welcomed it.

Yet the ball was gathered not by Ronaldo but by Fernandes. Usually such a superb taker of spot-kicks, he ballooned his effort into the Stretford End.

And so United’s summer transfer business brought a victory at Old Trafford. Just not Ronaldo and not for them. With Axel Tuanzebe, borrowed from United, ineligible to face his parent club, Hause came into the Aston Villa team. Charged more with stopping Ronaldo and co, he charged forward to head in Douglas Luiz’s late corner.

In the process, Villa replaced Pep Guardiola’s Barcelona as the last team to keep a clean sheet against a Manchester United side including Ronaldo. This was a day, a performance and a result that made it feel far less likely that United will displace Guardiola’s Manchester City as champions.

There was no lack of effort, or indeed efforts, from United, who chalked up 28, but this was still an illustration of their shortcomings: in midfield, predictably, and at the back, while Solskjaer may now find himself short of stoppers, with Luke Shaw and Harry Maguire going off injured. The Villa rearguard were overworked at times, but if Ronaldo was expected to remedy one of United’s problems – an occasional capacity to slip up at home against their supposed inferiors – and if Villa were his favourite opponents in his first spell at Old Trafford, this amounted to a frustrating afternoon for him.

For the first time since his valedictory cameo for Juventus, he left the pitch without a goal. He was the least effective of United’s front four but if Ronaldo retains a capacity to overshadow everyone around him, misses have been a problem for Solskjaer’s side in successive games and with very different forward lines: first West Ham and then Villa left Old Trafford without being breached.

© Provided by The Independent Bruno Fernandes’ added-time penalty was fired high over the Villa crossbar (REUTERS)

Mason Greenwood proved the brightest of the United attackers in open play, looking at home in exalted company alongside the Old Trafford Galacticos. He was elusive and electric, gliding past defenders, twice testing Emi Martinez. Fernandes flashed a shot over after 90 seconds and, prefacing the penalty drama, was allowed to take a free-kick before Ronaldo – he hit the ball, as did his older compatriot later – but he had free rein over set-pieces from the flanks, and they were when he almost unlocked Villa.

Martinez parried Maguire’s firm header while Paul Pogba headed wide after Raphael Varane had flicked on Fernandes’ corner. Pogba brought menace at times, threatening a breakthrough with a loping run and rising shot in the second half.

But while United had mustered 15 attempts before the break, they lost their way for 20 minutes after it, losing momentum in the process. And while Villa had fewer attacks, they arguably had more fine chances.

Well-coached, ambitious and enterprising, they could attribute their first wonderful opening to Dean Smith’s 3-5-2 formation as United were outflanked. One raiding wing-back, Matty Cash, surged to the byline to pick out the other, Matt Targett but, from four yards, he lofted a shot over the bar. Given the wayward nature of the effort, Targett scarcely felt a case of nominative determinism.

© Provided by The Independent United coach Ole Gunnar Solskjaer consoles Fernandes at full-time (Getty Images)

United displayed the wrong sort of creativity when Maguire’s poor pass meant a stretching David de Gea could only find Ollie Watkins with his attempted clearance. The goalkeeper recovered to block the striker’s shot, and denied the lively Watkins again in the second half, while Ezri Konsa had been left unmarked to head over from three yards.

It was a warning United did not heed when Hause was allowed to meet another McGinn corner. Then came United’s chance to equalise.

Summing up their day, they missed it.

From news to politics, travel to sport, culture to climate – The Independent has a host of free newsletters to suit your interests. To find the stories you want to read, and more, in your inbox, click here.

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


TNT's Pogoy thankful for winning, finally, against San Miguel in playoffs; Reyes 'privileged' to coach against SMB

Photo: PBA Images Game 7 was a sweet victory for RR Pogoy. Pogoy, who waxed hot with 27 points on four-of-six shooting from the three-point area, said that this was ... Read more »

Super Tekla admits feeling hurt after getting mistaken for shoplifter

Super Tekla Super Tekla admitted that he felt hurt when he was mistaken for a shoplifter after buying something in a convenience store. In Aubrey Carampel’s report for “24 Oras ... Read more »

David Amess stabbing — latest: MPs may get police protection, as Nandy ‘no longer feels safe' in constituency

© UK Parliament/AFP via Getty Images david amess LIVE – Updated at 13:56 Police have been given six more days to question the man suspected of murdering Tory MP Sir ... Read more »

Getting a COVID-19 test in NYC was easy and took no time at all - proof that when they're properly funded, government services run more efficiently than their privately-run counterparts.

© Samantha Lee/Insider Massive government funding kept America from falling apart during the pandemic. Samantha Lee/Insider The US instituted unprecedented welfare programs during the pandemic. People have suddenly realized what ... Read more »

Everton vs West Ham, live! How to watch, score, updates TV, odds, prediction

© Provided by NBC Sports Everton vs West Ham is a ridiculously even Premier League clash on Sunday (start time 9am ET on NBCSN and online via as Rafael ... Read more »

The Gondoliers review – a picture-postcard Gilbert and Sullivan from Scottish Opera

Photograph: Jane Barlow/PA After the pandemic-related hiatus, there was a definite air of celebration as Scottish Opera returned to the Theatre Royal for its first live performances in its home ... Read more »

17 US missionaries kidnapped in Haiti, religious group says

A group of U.S. missionaries and their family members was kidnapped in Haiti on Saturday as they were leaving an orphanage, according to Haitian officials. The group of up to ... Read more »

Tributes to ‘caring and funny' dad killed in house explosion as family reveal cause of blast will take WEEKS to find out

TRIBUTES have been paid to a “caring and funny” dad in his 50s who died in an explosion at his family home. Carl Whalley died in the blast at the ... Read more »

22 Years Of Togetherness: Madhuri Dixit And Dr. Nene's Lesser Known Love Story

Bollywood’s Dhak Dhak Girl, Madhuri Dixit has been married to Dr. Shriram Nene for over two decades now. The couple celebrates 22 years of their togetherness this year with a ... Read more »

On rich, famous ‘cockroaches' and tax evasion

© Provided by Al Jazeera Demonstrators take part in a protest against Brazil’s Economy Minister Paulo Guedes after revelations in the Pandora Papers about his offshore bank accounts, in Brasilia ... Read more »

Coronavirus: 1,380 new cases of Covid-19 confirmed in Ireland

© Leah Farrell via Deputy Chief Medical Officer Dr Ronan Glynn PUBLIC HEALTH OFFICIALS have confirmed 1,380 new cases of Covid-19 in Ireland. As of 8am today, 459 Covid-19 patients ... Read more »

Sir David Amess: Conservative MP's murder could put people off a career in politics, warns expert

People who aspire to be an MP may be discouraged from the career following the murder of Sir David Amess, experts fear. Many may believe the role “seems frankly too ... Read more »

Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz's ‘America First' fundraising committee is running out of money

© AP Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz It was a troubled tour from start to finish. Controversial US representatives Marjorie Taylor Greene and Matt Gaetz, who represent Georgia and ... Read more »

David Amess killing latest: MPs discuss security arrangements following death

© Photograph: Kirsty O’Connor/PA Flowers and tributes at the scene near Belfairs Methodist Church in Eastwood Road North, Leigh-on-Sea, Essex, where Conservative MP Sir David Amess died after he was ... Read more »

Almost 350 pubs have closed down since pandemic began

Some 349 pubs have closed since the start of the pandemic with industry representatives warning of the ongoing crisis facing the sector amid doubts about October 22 seeing full restrictions ... Read more »

Enforce preventive detention safeguard cleared in 1978: Dulat, Shyam Saran, 98 others tell govt

© Provided by The Print New Delhi: A group of 100 former civil servants, including IAS, IPS and IFS officers, has written an open letter to Union Law Minister Kiren ... Read more »

Woman finds more than 90 rattlesnakes under her home in US

This picture shows a group of venomous Northern Pacific rattlesnakes which were extracted from a under a home in Santa Rosa, California. (Image courtesy: Associated Press) Al Wolf is used ... Read more »

Three Ole Gunnar Solskjaer replacements ruled out as Man Utd told "not to panic"

Gary Neville has ruled out three potential replacements for Ole Gunnar Solskjaer as he urged Manchester United “not to panic”. There are calls for the Old Trafford boss to be ... Read more »

Cameron Norrie hopes Nadal and Federer experience provides springboard to emulate Raducanu

Cameron Norrie hopes he can build on the best year of his professional career and use it as a springboard to enjoy some Grand Slam success in 2022. The Briton ... Read more »

Sir David Amess reported 'upsetting' threat to police before death

© Provided by Daily Mail MailOnline logo Sir David Amess received an ‘upsetting’ threat in the days before he was fatally stabbed inside a church at a constituency surgery in ... Read more »

Wegen neuen WM-Plänen: Jetzt geht auch das IOC gegen die Fifa auf die Barrikaden

© imago images/AAP Jetzt geht auch das IOC gegen die Fifa auf die Barrikaden Das Internationale Olympische Komitee (IOC) steht den Plänen des Fussball-Weltverbandes FIFA für eine Männer-WM im Zwei-Jahres-Rhythmus ... Read more »

Guy Parmelin ruft zur Vorbereitung auf Strom-Mangellage auf

© KEYSTONE/PETER KLAUNZER Im schlimmsten Fall könnte der Schweiz ab 2025 zu wenig Strom zur Verfügung stehen. Wirtschaftsminister Guy Parmelin ruft im Rahmen einer Kampagne Unternehmen auf, sich auf eine ... Read more »

Eyeing Russia, US defense chief heads to Black Sea region

US Defense Secretary Lloyd Austin headed to the Black Sea region Sunday aiming to shore up alliances with countries pressured by Russia and show gratitude for their contributions to the ... Read more »

What do African Americans owe America?

I gave an interview recently that involved, among other things, the subject of gratitude and debt. A listener emailed me afterward, asking this: “Against the backdrop of claims for reparations, ... Read more »

An exclusive interview with the brave & beautiful Esme Chapman

© Motivate Publishing Esme Chapman October’s – ‘The Renegade Issue’ – Download Now Esme Rose Chapman is a tough cookie. Illustrator, model and daughter of MATCHESFASHION Founders Ruth & Tom Chapman, ... Read more »

Love Has Won: Bodycam footage released of moment police find mummified cult leader

Bodycam footage has been released showing the moment the mummified corpse of the Love Has Won cult leader was discovered by police. The Saguache County Sheriff’s Department released the video ... Read more »

MPs back Southend-on-Sea bid for city status to honour David Amess

Photograph: Tony O’Brien/Reuters Politicians from all sides of the political spectrum have joined a campaign to make Southend-on-Sea a city, in honour of the local MP Sir David Amess who ... Read more »

China condemns U.S., Canada for sending warships through Taiwan Strait

The guided-missile destroyer USS Dewey (DDG 105) transits the Pacific Ocean while participating in Rim of the Pacific (RIMPAC) exercise 2018 BEIJING/TAIPEI (Reuters) -The Chinese military on Sunday condemned the ... Read more »

The One Diet That Will Slim Down Your Waistline

© Provided by Eat This, Not That! eating protein Lose Your Gut! Blast Your Belly! The New Secrets to Flat Abs Fast! Who can resist reading about the latest technique that promises… ... Read more »

Bank of India cuts interest rates on home, vehicle loans, check latest rates

© Provided by Zee News New Delhi: Following in the footsteps of the State Bank of India (SBI) and Bank of Baroda, the Bank of India on Sunday, October 17, ... Read more »

We were taken aback by the protests; introduced changes in a single shot: Urban Company's Abhiraj Bhal

© Provided by Business Today We were taken aback by the protests; introduced changes in a single shot: Urban Company’s Abhiraj Bhal Putting the partner protests behind through the ‘well-received’ ... Read more »

Amazon Great Indian Festival: Top offers on external hard drives you can check out

Amazon’s Great Indian Festival sale is currently live, the American e-commerce giant is offering some great deals and discounts on products across categories, including external hard drives. In this digital ... Read more »

IT dept detects tax evasion worth crores after raids on two business entities

© Provided by Zee Business The Income Tax Department has detected tax evasion worth crores of rupees after it raided a group engaged in digital marketing and another entity engaged ... Read more »

Hands off our fuel! Sunak facing new £1.50 petrol tax headache as cost of living soars

A report by the Centre for Policy Studies also urges the Chancellor to freeze alcohol duty ahead of the upcoming spending review as a pack of lager faces a 36p ... Read more »

Browns vs. Cardinals odds, prediction: Arizona will suffer first loss

The Wildcat returns for his 25th season in the Bettor’s Guide. Cat’s record in print stands at 652-561 (53.8 percent) against the spread. Sunday CLEVELAND BROWNS (-3) over Arizona Cardinals: ... Read more »

Umno Sabah sedia terima semula bekas pemimpin parti itu, kata setiausaha eksekutif

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Awang Lakat (tengah) ketika melawat seorang warga emas yang uzur di Kampung Tenembak, di Kuala Penyu, semalam. KUALA PENYU: Setiausaha Eksekutif Umno Sabah, Awang ... Read more »

Covid-19 or flu? UAE doctor says patients should be tested for both

© Provided by The National Nurses with Seha prepare flu vaccines. Experts have urged employers to have their staff vaccinated. Sammy Dallal / The National As the influenza season approaches, ... Read more »

Gitex 2021: Hi-tech cameras will detect cyclists without helmets on Dubai bike tracks

© Provided by The National The Evoteq AI cycle safety technology on display at the RTA stand at Gitex, at the World Trade Centre in Dubai. Photo: The National Cameras ... Read more »

RM396.5 juta: Risda jayakan misi Pekebun Kecil Makmur

© Provided by Sinar Harian KUALA NERANG – Kementerian Pembangunan Luar bandar (KPLB) menyalurkan peruntukan RM396.5 juta kepada Pihak Berkuasa Kemajuan Pekebun Kecil Perusahaan Getah (Risda) setakat Oktober 2021 bagi ... Read more »

WRC points leader Ogier fined for traffic offence

© Toyota Racing Sébastien Ogier, Julien Ingrassia, Toyota Gazoo Racing WRT Toyota Yaris WRC The Toyota driver overtook a vehicle while using the hard shoulder during a road section on ... Read more »