Online abuse: Banning anonymous social media accounts is not the answer

Asia's Tech News Daily

anonymous social media accounts, Online abuse, social media accounts, anonymous accounts, online anonymity

In the wake of the tragic death of the member of parliament for Southend West, David Amess, fellow MPs have been talking about how to best protect both politicians and the public from abuse and harm.

This has included a strong focus on enacting laws designed to halt online abuse, even though police have not linked Amess’s killing to this issue directly.

There have been suggestions that such abuse can be attributed, at least in part, to online anonymity – that is, the fact many social media users set up their accounts using aliases, and without images that reveal who they are, in order to conceal their identity.

Speaking on Sky News, Home Secretary Priti Patel indicated there was a need to address anonymous accounts. Asked if she would consider legislation to remove the right to anonymity on social media, Patel responded:

I want us to look at everything. And there is work taking place already […] But we can’t carry on like this.

I spend too much time actually with communities who have been under attack basically, who have had all sorts of postings put online, and it’s a struggle to get those postings taken down. We want to make some big changes on that.

The idea has since gained traction, with other MPs calling for a ban on anonymous social media accounts as a way to mitigate online abuse.

Yet while it’s clear there is a need to address how we engage with and on social media, removing anonymity isn’t going to solve the problems of online abuse. In fact, removing the right to anonymity online could cause harm to many users, especially those from marginalised groups.

Anonymity as a form of protection

While there are many examples of people using anonymous social media accounts to abuse others online, it’s equally clear that anonymity can be a lifeline to many users and communities. Posting anonymously can allow people to protect themselves – to openly discuss and deal with complex topics safely. It can allow people to speak out about abuse, and seek information.

For example, social media users in LGBTQIA+ communities have spoken about the importance of online anonymity as a way to negotiate discussions of sexuality safely, where disclosing their name might put them at significant risk of abuse and harm online and offline.

Some said anonymity allowed them to access valuable information online as they navigated their own identities.

In my own research for my 2020 book about social media design and identity, my participants talked about the many ways in which they felt anonymity helped them to develop a sense of community.

One participant discussed how social relationships were formed via comment boards with others using pseudonyms: “I know some really personal stuff about all of them, apart from the fact that I don’t know their names.”

While respondents did talk about incidents of abuse online from anonymous users, it was clear that equally, anonymity provided pathways to building communities and support networks.

An insistence on real names can present barriers and challenges to already marginalised communities and users for whom “real names” are a complex issue. These include gender non-conforming users, drag queens, Native Americans and survivors of abuse.

Anonymity can be used to abuse “othered” groups such as women, LGBTQIA+ people and Muslims.

However, research shows that people using their real names perpetrate abuse and bullying too.

On social media we continue to see users willing to say abusive things and share dangerous content with their full names, job titles and information on display.

Banning anonymous social media profiles therefore isn’t going to address the root of the hate we see online, be that directed at marginalised communities or at MPs.

Research shows Black and Asian female MPs face the most abuse aimed at female MPs online, suggesting the issue of anonymity is perhaps not the root cause of abuse, but a way for deeper social issues to manifest online. Katrin Tiidenberg and Emily van der Nagel write in their book Sex and Social Media:

Whether anonymous or not, people look at existing posts and comments for cues regarding what is allowed in a particular online space and behave accordingly. It’s not simply a matter of anonymous people being up to no good: platform design and moderation has a lot to do with what kinds of behaviours are allowed, and thrive, on social media.

I would agree with this, and call on platforms to take more responsibility for the communities they foster, and the voices and discourses they emphasise and minimise online.

While it’s refreshing to see politicians’ desire to tackle online abuse, banning anonymity isn’t the answer. Anonymity can be a vital lifeline for already marginalised communities, and removing it could inadvertently harm the very communities MPs seek to protect.

(This article is syndicated by PTI from The Conversation)

[Harry T Dyer is Lecturer in Education, University of East Anglia Norwich (UK)]

Internet Explorer Channel Network
Asia's Tech News Daily
News Related

OTHER NEWS

Australian parliament: 1 in 3 experience sexual harassment, report finds

28 recommendations were made based on the findings, including greater gender balance among both lawmakers and their staff, new alcohol policies and the creation of a new human resources office to deal with complaints. Read more »

Mobile-first bootstrapped start-up AppyHigh 's monthly users grow 10x during pandemic

© Provided by Business Today Mobile-first bootstrapped start-up AppyHigh ‘s monthly users grow 10x during pandemic Mobile-first tech start-up AppyHigh has said that its monthly active users (MAUs) has grown ... Read more »

IPL Retention Live Updates: RCB to Retain Mohammed Siraj; KL Rahul Likely to Leave Punjab Kings

© Provided by News18 IPL Retention Live Updates: RCB to Retain Mohammed Siraj; KL Rahul Likely to Leave Punjab Kings IPL 2022 Retention DEADLINE Day: The Indian Premier League is ... Read more »

Strictly's Amy Dowden MOVES IN with celeb partner Tom Fletcher and wife Giovanna after being rushed to hospital

STRICTLY Come Dancing's Amy Dowden has MOVED IN with her celebrity partner Tom Fletcher and wife Giovanna after she was rushed to hospital with a Crohn's flare-up. The pair were ... Read more »

RBI Retail Direct Scheme: All you need to know - Expert explains

© Provided by Zee Business On Nov 12, 2021, the Reserve Bank announced the activation of the RBI Retail Direct Scheme. The Scheme was launched  in virtual mode by the ... Read more »

Ian Bell joins Hobart Hurricanes as assistant coach

© Cricket Australia/Getty Images Ian Bell was a Big Bash winner with Perth Scorchers in 2016-17 © Cricket Australia/Getty Images Ian Bell was a Big Bash champion with Perth Scorchers ... Read more »

Is ‘Vaccine Inequality' Responsible for New Covid Variant Omicron? Here's What WHO Has to Say

© Provided by News18 Is ‘Vaccine Inequality’ Responsible for New Covid Variant Omicron? Here’s What WHO Has to Say In October 2020, as scientists around the world raced to develop ... Read more »

Delnaaz Irani on her role in Kabhi Kabhie Ittefaq Sey: Going to play the character I always wanted to

© Provided by Pinkvilla Former ‘Bigg Boss’ contestant and popular TV actress Delnaaz Irani talks about playing a non-comic character in the upcoming show ‘Kabhi Kabhie Ittefaq Sey’. She says ... Read more »

Neha Pendse Celebrates Her Birthday With Her Close Friends At Her Own Restaurant!

© Provided by Lehren Neha Pendse Celebrates her birthday with her close friends at her own restaurant! The talented and beautiful actress Nehha Pendse who essays the role of Anita ... Read more »

Myanmar court postpones Aung San Suu Kyi verdict

A Myanmar court on Tuesday postponed its verdict in the trial of ousted leader Aung San Suu Kyi. © AP Myanmar’s ousted leader Aung San Suu Kyi – AP The ... Read more »

Bigg Boss Telugu 5: After Ravi's shocking elimination, Priyanka Singh dumps THIS contestant

© Provided by Pinkvilla After Anchor Ravi’s elimination from ‘Bigg Boss Telugu 5’, the housemates are still in a shock, as it was least expected that Ravi would get out ... Read more »

Ileana D'Cruz in red bikini is living her best life in Maldives. See pic

Ileana D’Cruz is on a Maldives holiday. Ileana D’Cruz is a complete beach baby. The actress took out some time from her work schedule and jetted off to the Maldives. ... Read more »

SEC Championship game line, betting angles: This is Georgia's year

Georgia linebackers Nakobe Dean (left) and Quay Walker (right) USA TODAY Sports Amid the madness and the losses and the chaos of a beautiful Saturday in college football emerged one ... Read more »

Don't turn Notre Dame into ‘politically correct Disneyland', say renovation critics

Plans to modernise the visitor experience at Paris’s Notre Dame cathedral have been criticised by traditionalists who fear the monument is set to become a “politically correct Disneyland”. © Getty ... Read more »

Nutritionist on why you must not cut out fat from your daily diet

© Provided by The Indian Express Fearing weight gain, many people tend to completely skip fats from their daily diet. However, is it a wise move? Nutritionist Lovneet Batra busted ... Read more »

UK Covid live: No 10 refuses to back health chief's call for people to avoid unnecessary socialising

© Photograph: WIktor Szymanowicz/NurPhoto/REX/Shutterstock Commuters arrive at Waterloo station during morning rush hour. Masks are mandatory on public transport again from today. LIVE – Updated at 12:38 Unusual rebuke for ... Read more »

Burger King Has Launched 12 Days Of Free Food And Special Offers For Christmas

© Burger King All you have to do to get involved in the 12 Days Of Whopper event is download the Burger King app on your Apple or Android phone. ... Read more »

Storm Arwen: 'Smell of vomit everywhere': Passengers left terrified as flight lands in Edinburgh during red weather warning

The flight from Stansted to Edinburgh took off at 7.50 pm on Friday, right in the middle of the Met Office’s red weather warning for Scotland’s east coast. © Storm ... Read more »

ITV to host special Christmas carol concert led by Duchess of Cambridge in BBC snub

© PA Royal visit to the Imperial War Museum ITV has confirmed it will host a special Christmas carol service led by the Duchess of Cambridge in a snub to ... Read more »

BMW unveils radical concept car XM SUV

© Provided by The National The XM’s face is distinguished by a large twin-nostril grille flanked by eight lights. BMW has in recent times challenged public perceptions with its oversized ... Read more »

'We need to move forward' - Cosatu does about-turn in support of mandatory jabs

© Provided by CapeTalk Cosatu has changed its position on mandatory vaccination in a bid to avoid more devastating lockdown restrictions The trade union federation now says mandatory vaccination will ... Read more »

'Vaccination is not the worst option' – Cosatu supports mandatory jabs

© Provided by CapeTalk Cosatu now supports mandatory Covid-19 vaccination, after initially voicing its doubts. “We do not want another lockdown; we would rather have people forced to vaccinate than ... Read more »

Putin gives government a week to prepare Omicron action plan

© Reuters/SPUTNIK Russian President Vladimir Putin attends the VTB Capital Investment Forum “Russia Calling!” in Moscow MOSCOW (Reuters) – Russian President Vladimir Putin has ordered the government to prepare an ... Read more »

Who might upset Macron's bid for a second term in office

© Reuters/BERNADETT SZABO French far-right leader Le Pen and Hungarian PM Orban deliver statement in Budapest PARIS (Reuters) – France’s 2022 presidential election is Emmanuel Macron’s to lose. All opinion ... Read more »

HS2: transport expert on the huge gaps in the government's new plan

Dropping the Leeds branch of HS2 has been seen as a betrayal of the north. Martin D Brown | Shutterstock In 2009, the company HS2 was set up to provide ... Read more »

Dubai FinTech platform iOL Pay goes live and sets sights on $1bn valuation

© Provided by The National Faisal Memon, founder and chief executive of iOL Pay. Photo: iOL Pay Dubai-based iOL Pay, a financial technology platform focused on the hospitality industry, has ... Read more »

Feds: Man laundered money through Hard Rock Casino; funded wife's 'shopping spree'

Currency transaction reports revealed that from May 24 through Aug. 24 Shalash cashed in $464,796 and cashed out $789,541 from the casino. A foreign national with local ties, currently wanted ... Read more »

Chris Cuomo coordinated with brother's top aide, documents show

CNN anchor and journalist Chris Cuomo sought to help tailor former New York Governor Andrew Cuomo’s responses to allegations of sexual misconduct, according to documents released Monday by the state’s ... Read more »

Bitcoin and ethereum ETFs with monthly payouts launch in Canada

Canada continues to be at the forefront of cryptocurrency ETFs and today the trend continues with new offerings that track bitcoin and ethereum, while providing monthly payouts. ETFs allow investors ... Read more »

Sturgeon ready to take ‘difficult decisions' after Omicron discovery in Scotland

First Minister Nicola Sturgeon (Jane Barlow/PA) (PA Wire) Nicola Sturgeon has vowed she will not shy away from tough decisions following the emergence of the new Omicron strain of Covid-19 ... Read more »

German police smash cocaine ring accused of smuggling tons

On Location: November 29, 2021 Catch up on the developing stories making headlines.ABCNews.com BERLIN — German investigators said 14 suspects were arrested Tuesday in an investigation of a gang accused ... Read more »

Consumer prices jump 7.7% in Poland, faster than expected

The Associated PressA customer wearing a face mask prepares to leave a bakery, in Warsaw, Poland, on Friday Nov. 26, 2021. Poland is facing skyrocketing COVID-19 infections and deaths but ... Read more »

Now open: Urla brings coastal dining to the heart of Downtown Dubai

© Motivate Publishing urla-new-venue-downtown-dubai-feat This chic outdoor venue is sure to be next on your must-visit list… When it comes to chic Mediterranean-inspired venues, the beachy shores of Palm Jumeirah, ... Read more »

Universal Credit £1,000 boost for half a million working Brits to hit bank accounts TOMORROW in win for Sun campaign

HALF a million will see their Universal Credit boosted by £1,000 from tomorrow – in a win for our Sun campaign. The harsh taper rate is being slashed just before Christmas as ... Read more »

Millions of Android phones need to be fixed NOW over ‘eavesdropping' scare

MILLIONS of people around the world have been exposed to snoopers by dodgy microchips loaded into Android smartphones. According to security experts, vulnerabilities in processors produced by Taiwanese firm MediaTek ... Read more »

With Steve Cohen's checkbook, the Mets change their perception and their reality

Getty Images Sign up here to get Beyond the Back Page delivered to your inbox each weekday morning. Less than a week ago, Steve Cohen fumed about losing out on ... Read more »

Becky Hill, Bastille, Feeder and more set for National Lottery's Revive Live Tour 2022

Becky Hill, Bastille, Feeder and more are set to play one-off gigs when The National Lottery’s Revive Live Tour returns early next year. © Bang Showbiz Becky Hill and more ... Read more »

Gillian Anderson wows at The Fashion Awards 2021

Last night’s Fashion Awards was a starry affair with the crème de la crème of A-listers walking the red carpet in their finery but there was one star in particular ... Read more »

Nine further Covid cases confirmed in Munster rugby squad

A further nine positive cases of Covid-19 have been confirmed in Munster’s wider rugby squad in South Africa. © Donall Farmer A team spokesman described the situation as ‘challenging’ (Donall ... Read more »

I'm A Celebrity stars returning to castle after mid-show quarantine but more bad weather ahead

The ‘I’m A Celebrity… Get Me Out Of Here!’ stars will head back into the castle today (30.11.21) – but bosses are “slightly worried” about more bad weather scheduled to ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic