We Taste-Tested The Difference Between Canned And Fresh Pumpkin Puree And The Results May Surprise You

This time of year, cans of pumpkin puree are flying off the shelves. Whether you are making pumpkin pie, pumpkin bread, pumpkin cookies, or pumpkin cold foam, you’ll need a can of this stuff. But have you ever thought about making it yourself? And if you did, would the extra work and effort be worth it? Would it make the treat taste better? Or should you just be pulling an Ina Garten?: “Store-bought is fine.”

© Felicia LaLomia – Hearst Owned Whether you are making pumpkin pie, pumpkin bread, or pumpkin cookies, you’ll need a can of pumpkin from the baking aisle. But is making it from scratch worth it?

I decided to test out this theory and put fresh pumpkin and canned pumpkin puree head-to-head to see if breaking down a pumpkin from fruit (yes, a pumpkin is a fruit) to mush is worth doing.

Here are the rules. I would make the same recipe twice, once with canned pumpkin puree, once with fresh pumpkin puree. I chose a pumpkin bread recipe (I don’t love pie), and I would taste them both at the end to see if there was a difference in flavor.

Hold on. What exactly is canned pumpkin?

There isn’t much of a difference between canned pumpkin and fresh pumpkin puree, and looking at the list of ingredients on the back of the can will tell you that. It will probably just say pureed pumpkin or steamed pumpkin puree.

So how does canned pumpkin differ from fresh pumpkin puree?

Well, the recipe I used requires (1) a small sugar pumpkin I purchased from the grocery store, (2) removing its insides, and (3) roasting it before blending it into a puree. That differs from the canned stuff in a few ways. Firstly, it’s made from one type of pumpkin, while the canned version may be a blend of a few different kinds of pumpkins or maybe even squash. And secondly, the fresh kind is roasted rather than steamed.

© Felicia LaLomia – Hearst Owned The canned pumpkin puree (left) and fresh pumpkin puree (right).

What are some important tips to remember when making fresh pumpkin puree?

I thought you’d never ask! Make sure you are using a small pumpkin, often referred to as a sugar pumpkin, instead of the big kinds you might carve as a jack-o-lantern. Also, be sure to puree the cooked mixture enough to get rid of any stringy texture. This recipe even says to strain it through a cheesecloth if using it to bake.

What about the actual baking differences?

Visually, the canned pumpkin was thicker and darker in color. From can to can and brand to brand, you will generally find the same-looking product. The fresh pumpkin puree was slightly thinner in texture, but it was not watery. It also had a more yellow-y golden color.

As for the pumpkin breads themselves, the fresh pumpkin puree pumpkin bread easily added an hour onto my bake time, although most of that was spent roasting the pumpkin in the oven. After that, though, despite the canned pumpkin being thicker, both batters looked identical, as did the loaves coming out of the oven. Both were crusted with a crackly cinnamon-sugar top (which you should not skimp out on—recipe here). Taste-wise? I have to say…I couldn’t tell the difference. One wasn’t more moist or less pumpkin-y or just better in general than the other. I even did a blind tasting and found both slices tasted the same. Which I have to admit, was slightly defeating.

Here’s the good news. This means that most of the time, the canned stuff holds up to the homemade kind, which isn’t often true when it comes to cooking. That said, here’s where I would make a distinction: When you want more control in the flavor of your pumpkin, make it from scratch. Add in different spices or experiment by cutting it with squash. Or let it roast until it’s extra caramelized for a super nutty flavor.

When you just need pumpkin for a recipe, grab the canned stuff. You can always count on this to have a consistent product that will be the same every time you reach for it.

Either way—happy pumpkin bread season!

Internet Explorer Channel Network
News Related


TikTok users left petrified by ‘convincing ghost video which shows spirit removing dog's collar'

© Photo courtesy of @user3228721954538/TikTok Screen Shot 2021-10-21 at 12.05.53 PM.png TikTok users say they were left petrified after a woman posted one of the most “convincing” ghost videos they’ve ... Read more »

Celebs You Forgot Were on Law & Order: Special Victims Unit

Dun, dun! Tonight, Oct. 21 marks the 500th episode of Law and Order: Special Victims Unit, and so, we can’t help but think about the thousands of actors that have ... Read more »

Vitesse v Tottenham result: Five things we learned as Spurs suffer defeat

© Getty Dane Scarlett of Tottenham Hotspur battles for possession with Riechedly Bazoer of Vitesse – Getty Tottenham Hotspur lost away at Vitesse Arnhem tonight in a dreadfully poor performance ... Read more »

No bids received for Sangley airport

© STAR/File No bids received for Sangley airport MANILA, Philippines — The Cavite government received no bids for the Sangley Point International Airport (SPIA) project, leaving its future in limbo. ... Read more »

Putin says Western military backing of Ukraine threatens Russia

© Reuters/SPUTNIK Russia’s President Putin attends a session of the Valdai Discussion Club in Sochi By Vladimir Soldatkin and Gabrielle Tétrault-Farber MOSCOW (Reuters) – President Vladimir Putin said on Thursday ... Read more »

Lark, Companion Rooftop Restaurant to the Landing Kitchen, Will Open This Weekend

© Neal Santos Lark, the long-in-process second Main Line restaurant from Laurel’s Nick Elmi, will open on Saturday, October 23, in Bala Cynwyd. In the same building as his first ... Read more »

An Italian Wine Bar With Pepperoni Panini Hidden Behind a Deli — and More Openings

© Jose Marquez/One19 Wine Bar + Food A selection of dishes at One19 Wine Bar + Food. More than a year and a half into the coronavirus pandemic, restaurants across ... Read more »

Good news about the Southern Ocean's role in carbon drawdown during winter — but it may still not be enough to save us

The Southern Ocean’s role in driving the global carbon cycle may be stronger than expected as the biological carbon pump is not ‘switched off’ in winter as previously thought. These ... Read more »

Vitesse 1-0 Tottenham: Spurs B-team lays egg in Europa Conference League

© Photo by Peter Lous/BSR Agency/Getty Images Tottenham Hotspur went to Arnheim in the Netherlands for an away European Conference League match against Vitesse. With a win, Spurs could’ve really ... Read more »

Ex-skipper Matera returns for Pumas November Tests

© CHARLY TRIBALLEAU Pablo Matera made the first of his 77 Argentina appearances in 2013 Former Argentina captain Pablo Matera was named in the squad on Thursday for November’s Tests ... Read more »

LBC host Steve Allen fat-shamed Gemma Collins before lashing out at Tilly Ramsay

© Anthony Harvey/Getty gemmacollins.jpg LBC Radio host Steve Allen fat-shamed Gemma Collins in historic tweets from 2014 before he lashed out at Strictly Come Dancing star Tilly Ramsay. The host, ... Read more »

After Backlash, Mass Effect 3 Devs Say Team Crunched To Deliver New Ending

© Image: BioWare Mass Effect’s Commander Shepard stands amid the rubble of Earth as the Reapers attack. Almost a decade ago the internet blew up over Mass Effect 3’s controversial ... Read more »

Quality Tuberculosis care begins with people-centred approaches and education

The world is seeing TB deaths starting to increase for the first time in over 10 years. To turn things around and to put an end to TB being a ... Read more »

Google Will Cut App Store Fees for Subscriptions to 15% From Day One

© AP Google Play, the internet giant’s Android app store, will reduce the fee it charges developers who sell subscriptions to 15%, starting when customers sign up for a recurring ... Read more »

Brian Cox Reveals When He Thinks Succession Will Be "Done"

Brian Cox hopes to be “L to the OG”-ing for at least one or two more seasons. In an interview with British GQ, the 75-year-old Scottish actor was asked how ... Read more »

Gigi Hadid, Blake Lively hide their kids' faces online. Should other parents follow their lead?

© Illustration: Andrea Brunty, USA TODAY Network, and Getty Images How do parents navigate the digital world? Gigi Hadid issued a plea to paparazzi, media and fan social media accounts ... Read more »

Emotional Oranges Talk About Their 'Constantly Evolving' Sound and Why Adele Is Like a 'Unicorn'

© Provided by People Tristan Kallas Emotional Oranges always delivers. As they partner with DHL for their Fast-Track series, the soulful R&B duo comprising A and V catch up with ... Read more »

Cop26 road closures: How climate change summit will affect travel in Glasgow

© Jeff J Mitchell/Getty Climate activists in Glasgow – Jeff J Mitchell/Getty More than 25,000 delegates are set to descend on Glasgow in less than two weeks when the Cop26 ... Read more »

Blake Lively Slams Instagram Post for 'Exploiting' Her and Ryan Reynold's Children

© Xavier Collin/Image Press Agency. Some celebrity parents don’t mind their kids being in the spotlight while others don’t like it at all. Turns out, Blake Lively and Ryan Reynolds ... Read more »

One of Chicago's Premier Taquerias Preps to Reopen 14 Months After a Fire

© Barry Brecheisen/Eater Chicago Jarabe’s tacos are one of the city’s best. It’s been 14 months since a fire burned down the Taylor Street location of Jarabe, one of the ... Read more »

Roman Food Is Invading LA, and Next Up Is Echo Park

© Bacetti A preview of the deep green booths at Bacetti. Echo Park’s next big project is Bacetti, a long-awaited Italian destination tucked up towards the hills off Echo Park ... Read more »

Real Madrid XI vs Barcelona: Predicted lineup, confirmed team news, injury latest for El Clasico

© ES Composite LLRealMadridPredictedXIv1.jpg Carlo Ancelotti can keep the pace atop La Liga on Sunday with a win over a Barcelona side surely at their weakest in years. Real Madrid ... Read more »

Why the Big Restaurant Delivery Apps Will Need the Courts to Save Their Business

© Photo: courtesy Richard B. Levine/Newscom/The Mega Agency New York during the COVID-19 pandemic delivery apps in restaurant window. At a Goldman Sachs conference last month, Uber CEO Dara Khosrowshahi ... Read more »

Here's how hard it was to bring Sora to Smash Bros., according to Sakurai

© Image: Nintendo Sora is the latest and final addition to Super Smash Bros. Ultimate’s massive roster, and he may have been the hardest character to secure for the series. ... Read more »

You Won't Believe Which Insecure Character Almost Didn't Make It Past Season One

It’s hard to imagine Insecure without Issa’s on-again, off-again relationship with potential soul mate Lawrence. Yet, according to star and co-creator Issa Rae, Lawrence (played by the oh-so-dashing Jay Ellis) ... Read more »

Halsey Says They 'Don't Care' to Receive Grammy Recognition for If I Can't Have Love, I Want Power

© Provided by People Roy Rochlin/Getty Images Halsey To Halsey, it’s not about the recognition — it’s about the music. In a cover story interview with Billboard on Thursday, Halsey ... Read more »

Bruno Tonioli confirms he will return to Strictly Come Dancing UK tour next year

Bruno Tonioli is to waltz back to Strictly Come Dancing for its UK arena tour next year. The Italian star pulled out of the current series over travel restrictions between ... Read more »

Shoppers Say These $15 Under-Eye Patches Brightened Dark Circles in Minutes

© Provided by Real Simple amazon.com After a sleepless night filled with tossing and turning, we’ll often turn straight to caffeine for a pick-me-up. Java definitely does the trick for ... Read more »

Omgggg Glossier Just Dropped A Cookie Butter Balm Dotcom

© Glossier Perfect for pumpkin patch makeouts, this salve has a “buttery, cinnamon-y, and sweet flavor,” with a glossy caramel finish to give lips that warm, kissable glow. Christian Girl ... Read more »

New Xbox Series X expansion cards from Seagate revealed

© Provided by GamesRadar Seagate Xbox Series X Expansion Cards Xbox has unveiled two brand new hard drive expansion cards for the Xbox Series X and Xbox Series S.  Announced ... Read more »

Cop26: Leaked documents reveal the countries lobbying UN to water down climate crisis response

© Getty Images A worker checks equipment at a coal mine in Ordos, Inner Mongolia, China. Reducing demand for coal is crucial for meeting climate targets, say scientists – Getty ... Read more »

God of War on PC could mark the start of a new era for Sony

© Provided by GamesRadar God of War The playbook for God of War’s jump to PC feels largely unchanged from the release of Horizon Zero Dawn or Days Gone. A ... Read more »

Xbox studios head says he's not looking for an Uncharted or Horizon Zero Dawn

© Provided by GamesRadar Uncharted 3 Xbox Game Studios head Matt Booty says he’s not looking for Microsoft’s take on Uncharted or Horizon Zero Dawn. Speaking on the Kinda Funny ... Read more »

No More Heroes director says he was also approached to make a Deadpool game

© Provided by Total Film Ryan Reynolds in Deadpool A Deadpool game from the director of the No More Heroes series was once in the cards, and he’d love to ... Read more »

Kent Police apologises ‘unreservedly' to journalist unlawfully arrested while documenting Napier Barracks protest

© Andy Aitchison Mr Aitchison was arrested after photographing a demonstration outside Napier Barracks in January – Andy Aitchison Kent Police has apologised “unreservedly” to a journalist who was unlawfully ... Read more »

305 pass October 2021 nutritionist-dietician board exams

© PRC facebook page 361 pass October 2021 CPA licensure exams The Professional Regulation Commission (PRC) on Thursday reported 305 out of 528 examinees or 57.77% passed the October 2021 ... Read more »

Dodge/Gabe Is In Front Of The Omega Door In New "Locke and Key" Season 2 Clip

© Amanda Matlovich – Netflix Fans of Netflix’s “Locke and Key” are hoping for a second season to find out what happens to their favorite characters like Bode, Tyler, and ... Read more »

Adele teases potential name for new album with cryptic message: Here's what we know

Adele is back, and she’s not going easy on us. Last week, she dropped her first single in almost six years, “Easy on Me,” and revealed the inspiration behind her ... Read more »

Newcomer Jamila C. Gray to Star in ‘On the Come Up,' Directed by Sanaa Lathan (EXCLUSIVE)

© Brian Jones Paramount Players has hired newcomer Jamila C. Gray to star in “On the Come Up,” the upcoming film adaptation of Angie Thomas’ New York Times bestselling follow-up ... Read more »

Republican lunch menu includes ‘hot beef sundae' and people are gagging

© Getty Images joni-ernst-iowa-victory.jpg A GOP lunch menu is making the rounds for its strange entree list. Thursday’s GOP lunch, provided by Senator Joni Ernst, features “fare from the Iowa ... Read more »
On free-english-test.com you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic