Parents of stillborn baby receive record £2.8 million payout from hospital trust where they worked

Sarah and Jack Hawkins both worked at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust at the time of their baby’s stillbirth – Shawn Ryan / Nottinghamshire Live /Shawn Ryan / Nottinghamshire Live

The parents of a stillborn baby have received a record £2.8 million settlement from a hospital trust, at which they previously worked, after its failings caused their child’s death.

Harriet Hawkins was stillborn at Nottingham City Hospital in 2016 after a six-day labour.

An official external report later found 13 failures in Harriet and her mother's care and concluded her death was “almost certainly preventable”.

Her parents, Sarah and Jack Hawkins, both worked at Nottingham University Hospitals NHS Trust (NUH) at the time of her death but neither have been able to return due to the “psychological and psychiatric impact” of the event.

A legal case against NUH has now been settled for £2.8 million, which solicitors acting on behalf of the couple have said is the largest payout for a stillbirth clinical negligence case.

A Root Cause Analysis Investigation Report found the trust failed to follow correct risk management policies, to consider the patients full clinical history, and that it delayed administering appropriate treatment.

It added there were “inadequate systems and processes which did not support the sharing of clinical information, records of phone calls and hospital admissions and an inability to access these records in all clinical areas”.

'Multiple missed opportunities' for intervention earlier in the labour

There were “multiple missed opportunities for intervention and appropriate monitoring earlier in the labour”, it added, and had one of these been taken it would have been likely Harriet’s death “would not have occured”.

Following the publication of the report in 2018, Mr Hawkins said he and his wife were “both unable to work because of the psychological and psychiatric impact Harriet’s death has had on us”.

The Trust apologised after the report and said it had already made “substantial changes”.

Mr and Mrs Hawkins were first told Harriet had died of an infection. It took nine hours for her to be delivered after dying.

Janet Baker, from Switalskis Solicitors, which represented Mr and Mrs Hawkins, told the BBC: “£2.8m is the highest damages award in a stillbirth case, with legal fees for both sides the total cost to the NHS is likely to be over £3.5m.

“I believe that this is a cost which was unnecessary and could have been avoided if NUH had acknowledged responsibility for Harriet's death straight away and had been open with Sarah and Jack.”

She added that the couple suffered “psychiatric injury” because of the “shocking and traumatic way” in which their child died.

“But this was made significantly worse by the protracted failure of NUH to acknowledge responsibility for Harriet’s death and the psychiatric injuries caused to Sarah and Jack,” she said.

The trust has been the centre of other maternity scandals, with a Channel 4 News investigation revealing earlier this year 46 babies had suffered brain damage and 19 were stillborn in Nottingham since 2010.

In December last year the Care Quality Commission rated maternity units at two of the trust’s main hospitals as inadequate, and highlighted “several serious concerns” around staffing, leadership and culture.

'Time after time families are contacting us'

Mrs Hawkins told the BBC: “I couldn't grieve when [the trust] chose to say Harriet's death was caused by an infection, rather than their own failures.

“We had to keep Harriet's body in the mortuary for two years so we could keep her as 'evidence'.

“Time after time families are contacting us, and every single time I get contacted my heart sinks.”

Mr Hawkins said the couple had to “fight to be heard”, but added many other families are yet to be listened to “because there has been no proper accountability for such a long time now”.

A spokesperson at Nottingham University Hospitals Trust, said: “We would like to reiterate our sincere apologies to Mr and Mrs Hawkins for failures in the care around the delivery of baby Harriet.

“Our Maternity Improvement Programme has introduced a number of improvements including better training and monitoring with renewed focus on the recruitment and retention of midwives and maternity teams to ensure that we offer the best services possible to every family in our care.”

News Related


Kumpulan pengguna alu-alukan langkah pecah monopoli Touch ‘n Go

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today Menteri Kerja Raya Fadillah Yusof berkata, penggunaan penyedia bayaran tol lain akan dibenarkan sebaik sahaja syarikat konsesi lebuh raya bersedia dan apabila penembusan RFID ... Read more »

AEON, Grab berganding tawar pilihan e-dompet lebih berbaloi

© Provided by Free Malaysia Today AEON Co (M) Bhd dengan kerjasama Grab Malaysia menggalakkan pembayaran nirtunai menerusi e-dompet GrabPay. PETALING JAYA: Permintaan tinggi terhadap pembayaran nirtunai ketika pandemik Covid-19 ... Read more »

Where to find Piplup in Pokémon Legends: Arceus

© Provided by Dot Esports As players begin their adventures in Pokémon Legends: Arceus, they will quickly discover that the starter Pokémon options have changed vastly from Pokémon Diamond, Pearl, ... Read more »

What are Merit Points and what do they do in Pokémon Legends: Arceus?

© Provided by GamePur Besides the typical Pokémon Dollars you can spend at general stores and base camps, Pokémon Legends: Arceus introduces a second currency known as Merit Points that ... Read more »

Barnard Castle: Site made famous by Dominic Cummings among 'hidden gems' Britons rediscovered during pandemic

English Heritage says its "more intimate local sites" have often been overlooked - but the pandemic appears to persuaded more people to check them out. Read more »

2022 Concacaf World Cup Qualifiers: USA 1-0 El Salvador - A whiff of lightsaber delivers three points

© Photo by Omar Vega/Getty Images The USA entered the penultimate round of World Cup qualifiers with hopes of getting nine out of nine points no matter the weather conditions ... Read more »

The best cards from day 1 of Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty spoiler season

© Provided by Dot Esports Day one of Kamigawa: Neon Dynasty spoilers is a wrap and there are plenty of new mechanics and cards to get the hype train rolling ... Read more »

O'Toole promises change after internal report into Conservative's election loss

OTTAWA — Conservative Leader Erin O’Toole says changes will be made to his team and to the party after an internal review revealed what went wrong in the recent election ... Read more »

Burkina Faso: Military junta commits to restoring 'constitutional order'

© Provided by DW Burkina Faso’s new military leader says constitutional order will be restored “when conditions are right” The new military leader of Burkina Faso said he would restore ... Read more »

Ankit Bathla To Play A Double Role In &TV's ‘Ghar Ek Mandir Kripa Agrasen Maharaja Ki'

© Provided by Lehren Ankit Bathla To Play A Double Role In &TV’s ‘Ghar Ek Mandir Kripa Agrasen Maharaja Ki’ After winning viewers over with his bad-boy character as Siddhant ... Read more »

Watch out Nicole! Dolly Parton reveals Keith Urban is her dream duet partner as he's one of the 'most talented and cutest guys' - but insists she's 'not trying to hit on him'

American music legend Dolly Parton has revealed she’s got her eyes on Kiwi rocker Keith Urban – but strictly for a duet and maybe even a baking session.  The age-defying ... Read more »

Samantha Ruth Prabhu falls while skiing in Switzerland – Watch VIRAL video

© Provided by DNA Samantha Ruth Prabhu is currently in Switzerland having the time of her life. The actress recently shared a video of herself falling while trying to ski ... Read more »

Nicki Minaj's husband Kenneth Petty accused of PUNCHING a security guard and breaking his jaw in new lawsuit... and filing claims Nicki threw her SHOE at him

Minaj, 39, and Petty, 43, are being sued by security guard Thomas Weidenmuller Weidenmuller was head of security at Nicki's concert in Germany in March 2019 He claims that Minaj threw her shoe at him after yelling at another guardAfter he confronted the rapper, he alleges that her husband sucker punched himWeidenmuller says his jaw was broken from the alleged attack He claimed he had eight operations on his jaw and will require several more  Read more »

Philadelphia teenager, 17, is fatally shot in the chest while walking out of his high school - the 39th homicide in the city this year

Philadelphia teenager Christopher Braxton, 17, was shot twice after he walked out of Bartram High School on Wednesday afternoonAn unidentified gunman opened fire on Braxton and shot him in the chest while on the 2300 block of South 66th Street at around 3pm He was later transferred to a local hospital where he was pronounced deadPolice have yet to identify any suspects involved in the shooting and are currently investigating the motive for the incidentThis shooting comes after Philadelphia reported its 39th homicide for this year after seeing a violent 2021 with 562 city residents killed Read more »

Lauren Jauregui: Women are always being asked to prove themselves

© Bang Showbiz Lauren Jauregui has hit out at a perceived injustice Lauren Jauregui thinks female artists are asked to “provide constant proof” of their talent. The 25-year-old singer – ... Read more »

James Bay admits to 'losing himself' on tour

© Bang Showbiz James Bay has confessed to losing himself in 2019 James Bay “lost [himself]” on tour in 2019. The 31-year-old singer went on tour with Ed Sheeran three ... Read more »

Filmy Friday: When Sohail Khan took a royal dig at Hrithik Roshan, 'Even if he works for 10 years, he won't be able to do what Nawazuddin Siddiqui does'

© Provided by There was a time when Salman Khan and Hrithik Roshan were not on good terms with each other. Once friends then enemies, Salman and Hrithik’s friendship ... Read more »

Kevin Durant named All-Star captain for second straight year

Kevin Durant may not actually play in the game, but for the 12th time, he is an All-Star — and for the second time, a captain. The Nets forward, who ... Read more »

Teammates say they are uncomfortable changing in locker room with trans UPenn swimmer Lia Thomas

University of Pennsylvania transgender swimmer Lia Thomas apparently shows off his male genitalia in the locker room, according to a teammate. Hunter Martin/Getty Images A member of the University of ... Read more »

Teenager, 18, is charged with racially aggravated ABH after two Jewish shop owners were beaten up on London street as Boris Johnson calls attack 'despicable'

Malaki Thorpe, 18, of Tottenham, north London, has been charged with two counts of racially aggravated ABHTwo Jewish shop owners were assaulted in Cadoxton Avenue, Haringey, on Wednesday night, Met Police saidThorpe was also charged with possessing an offensive weapon, and is due to appear in court on Friday Read more »

'Shambles' as hunt for Ofcom boss is re-run with deadline for applications extended

Tory MP Julian Knight said the Ofcom recruitment process as 'a shambles' The regulator's role has been vacant since Lord Burns ended his term of office Ministers have again extended the deadline for applications for the role   Read more »

Two post offices are shut a week and service to customers is at 'breaking point', watchdog warns

Two post offices a week have been closed during the past two years Citizens Advice have warned that it will leave vulnerable people without access to vital services like paying their utility bills by mail Read more »

'Green corridors' will bring cities closer to the countryside by improving access to rural areas, National Trust bosses say

New scheme aims to ‘improve access to nature for those in urban areas' Footpaths will run through fields that will be planted with trees and hedgerows The National Trust plans to create 20 green corridors by 2030 Read more »

Fresh setback for students as 50,000 university lecturers plan strike over pay and conditions

University students face strike action between February 14 and March 2The dispute involves a row over pensions, pay and working conditions The University College Union said the strikes will be called off with a pay rise   Read more »

THREE FEET of snow is expected to fall on New England this weekend as nor'easter blasts the East Coast as forecasters warn travel chaos is likely: New Yorkers could see up to 12 inches of snowfall

A major winter storm is set to slam the Northeast on Saturday, bringing intense snowfall, powerful winds and coastal flooding to the east coast The heaviest snowfall is expected farther up north in Boston and New England, which will be 'clobbered' with as much as two feet of snowSome areas of New England could see as much as three feet The storm, which will develop off the coast of the Carolinas late this week, could potentially strengthen as it moves along the East Coast into a bomb cyclone NYC could get anywhere between 8 and 12 inches of snow, and parts of eastern Long Island may see up to 18 inches before the storm leaves the region  Read more »

IMD Alert! Cold wave to continue for another week across India

© Provided by DNA As the month of January comes to an end, the cold wave still seems to continue in many parts of the country and it will continue ... Read more »

Only Fools and Horses star Patrick Murray says woke BBC would wreck a reboot: Mickey Pearce actor fears word 'plonker' could be axed because viewers would find it 'offensive'

Only Fools And Horses star Patrick Murray revealed he would love to play Mickey Pearce again, but said he fears jokes would be axed due to 'wokery' The actor, admitted the 'ridiculous woke thing' could destroy the series by banning the use of the show's most iconic catchphrasesHe predicted that the word 'plonker' could be banned from the iconic show, despite being one of the series' most famous insults Murray is best known for his role as Trilby loving wide-boy Mickey Pearce in BBC sitcom Only Fools and Horses, a role that defined his career  Read more »

Kim Kardashian And Pete Davidson Spotted Attending Jeff Bezos's Dinner Party

© Provided by Lehren Kim Kardashian And Pete Davidson Spotted Attending Jeff Bezos’s Dinner Party Kim Kardashian and Pete Davidson are not shy of their relationship anymore and they’re making ... Read more »

US issues warning over Russian 'dirty money' in the UK: Diplomats fear financial sanctions won't work against Putin if he invades Ukraine because of the illicit cash from his oligarch allies that is 'entrenched' in London

US diplomats are said to be worried sanctions on Russia would be ineffectiveA source in Washington said the UK has allowed in too much Russian wealthThey said sanctions imposed on Russia would be merely 'symbolic' as a resultEarlier this week MPs accused Boris Johnson of killing off an economic crime billA parliamentary committee report in 2020 said London has long been used was as a 'laundromat' for Russian oligarchs' moneyIt comes amid soaring tensions over Ukraine with many NATO countries sending arms to eastern Europe and promising harsh penalties for a Russian invasion  Read more »

Elderly motorist, 84, is pulled over for having no licence after driving without one since the the age of 12

Police in Nottingham found a pensioner who drove without a licence for 70 yearsThe man was born in 1938 and admitted he had driven illegally since age of 12His car was flagged by automatic number-plate recognition (ANPR) camerasNottinghamshire Police officers said: 'We can’t quite believe what happened''Thankfully he had never had an accident or caused anyone an injury' Read more »

E-scooters could make a sound like a tuba to warn pedestrians of their presence and slash the risk of accidents, researchers say

E-scooters could be fitted with speakers with a ‘tuba-like’ sound to warn peopleThe vehicles currently make a whirring noise not loud enough for pedestriansFirms TIER, Lime and Dott are working with experts at University College LondonTIER promises to use the finalised sound and make it available to other firms  Read more »

How sweet! Street bollards made from sugar cane are latest weapon in war on pollution

New street bollards made of sugar cane could be installed on Britain's roads The £150 barriers are cheaper and lighter and produce less CO2 than concrete The bollards are made from a plant-based plastic derived from the sugar cane Read more »

Horoscope Today, January 28, Friday: Libra Should Strike a Work-Life Balance, Pisces Might Make Few Wrong Decisions

© Anjali Thakur | Pandit Jagannath Guruji Horoscope Today Horoscope Today, January 28, Friday: All of us want to begin our day on a super energetic note, or with a ... Read more »

Indian Family Found Dead Near US-Canada Border Identified, Young Girl and Infant Among Victims

© Provided by News18 Indian Family Found Dead Near US-Canada Border Identified, Young Girl and Infant Among Victims A week after their bodies were found frozen near the Canada/US border, ... Read more »

U.S., Taiwanese vice presidents speak at rare encounter in Honduras

© Reuters/POOL U.S. Vice President Kamala Harris talks to reporters in Palmerola By Trevor Hunnicutt and Gustavo Palencia TEGUCIGALPA (Reuters) – The U.S. and Taiwanese vice presidents had a brief ... Read more »

Rihanna and ASAP Rocky are 'inseparable'

© Bang Showbiz Rihanna is in a good place with ASAP Rocky Rihanna and ASAP Rocky are closer than ever. The 33-year-old singer and the rap star – who have ... Read more »

Wayne Phillips on the mental-health struggles that curtailed his career: 'I was vomiting during games'

© Adrian Murrell / © Getty Images “We didn’t know about mental health in those days, so I didn’t say a word,” Wayne Phillips says about his troubled mid-’80s career ... Read more »

James: Puneeth Rajkumar's last movie to release on this SPECIAL DAY; theatres in Karnataka to ONLY show his film? [EXCLUSIVE]

© Provided by Puneeth Rajkumar’s last film, James, will soon make its way to his scores of fans. The first look of James was unveiled a couple of days ... Read more »

I NEVER tell my kids to stop crying when they hurt themselves – you're setting them up for major issues if you do

WHEN it comes to children crying, most parents' natural instinct is to immediately ask them to stop – after all, it can be frustrating. However, according to an expert, while ... Read more »

ICC U-19 World Cup 2022: Afghanistan Defend 134 Against Sri Lanka to Enter Semi-Super League Semi-finals

© Provided by News18 ICC U-19 World Cup 2022: Afghanistan Defend 134 Against Sri Lanka to Enter Semi-Super League Semi-finals Afghanistan produced a sensational fightback to edge a thriller with ... Read more »
On you will find lots of free English exam practice materials to help you improve your English skills: grammar, listening, reading, writing, ielts, toeic