Which Cruise Line Stock Is Sailing Toward Higher Investor Returns?

Which Cruise Line Stock Is Sailing Toward Higher Investor Returns?

As the cruise industry navigates its way back to full strength, Carnival Corp. (NYSE: CCL) and Royal Caribbean Cruises (NYSE: RCL) continue charting their courses as giants on the seas. Both have shown remarkable resilience and strategic acumen over time, especially with pandemic recovery. Carnival's superior cost management and exceptional financial recovery seem to give it a slight edge.

Let's look into the financial strategies and performance of both companies, and see if Carnival might be the better buy for long-term gains.

Carnival Corporation shows robust financial recovery and strategic cost management

Carnival Corporation continues to build on its significant financial recovery, marked by record second-quarter (ending May 31) results in 2024. The company reported unprecedented revenue of $5.8 billion, showcasing both effective strategies and strong demand. This impressive revenue growth indicates a healthy and expanding business, which can lead to higher stock prices and potential dividend increases.

Carnival's ability to manage its costs effectively helps drive its stellar financial results. By focusing on operational efficiencies and strategic expense management, the company has kept its cost increases relatively low. Effective cost management means more funds can be reinvested into the business or returned to shareholders, enhancing long-term value.

Operating results and bookings

Carnival reported a record Q2 operating income of $560 million, a massive increase of more than four times the 2023 levels. Operating income shows the profit earned from core business operations, excluding deductions of interest and taxes. This substantial increase underscores Carnival's efficiency in managing its core operations.

Carnival's customer deposits reached an all-time high of $8.3 billion, surpassing previous records by $1.1 billion. Such strong booking momentum indicates a sustained demand for Carnival cruises, providing a solid foundation for future revenue growth. High customer deposits signify robust future earnings potential, which can lead to rising share prices and increased investor confidence.

Royal Caribbean Group delivers impressive performance and promises a bright future

Royal Caribbean Group has also shown strong performance, with first-quarter results (ending March 31) in 2024 exceeding expectations. The company reported total revenue of $3.7 billion for Q1, with a net income of $360 million, highlighting its profitability. Additionally, the company projects its adjusted earnings per share (EPS) for 2024 to fall between $10.70 and $10.90, indicating strong earnings growth.

The company's ability to leverage strong demand and onboard spending continues to drive these significant revenue increases alongside earnings growth. Strong earnings growth suggests a solid financial footing and the potential for higher dividends or stock buybacks here as well, likely enhancing shareholder value over time.

Onboard revenue and customer engagement

A significant portion of Royal Caribbean's revenue growth comes from increased onboard spending. The company's efforts to improve customer experience through premium offerings and innovative amenities have resulted in higher onboard revenue rates. This strategy highlights Royal Caribbean's ability to drive incremental revenue, which can support sustained financial performance and stock price appreciation.

The company also reported 2024 sailings booked at higher rates than 2023. Higher booking rates demonstrate Royal Caribbean's ability to attract customers and maximize their spending, reinforcing its strong market position and enhancing its appeal to investors looking for sustained growth and returns.

Carnival edges ahead in many areas

Comparing the two cruise giants, Carnival's robust financial recovery and effective cost management results appear to give it an advantage. Carnival's record revenue and customer deposits indicate a strong demand environment and efficient operational execution, critical components for long-term success. Carnival's focus on operational efficiency and expense management also translates more easily into a resilient and potentially more profitable investment.

While Royal Caribbean's growth appears impressive, there are a few reasons why it might not be the top choice right now. Royal Caribbean has higher debt levels, which means more of its revenue goes toward interest payments rather than being reinvested or given back to shareholders. Its operational costs continue rising due to investments in new attractions and drydock days. Carnival's broader portfolio and stronger market position also give it an edge in stability and efficiency as the company maintains its position as the best revenue generator in the market.

Not always smooth sailing

While both companies have shown resilience, potential challenges still threaten the industry's resurgence. For Carnival, these include rising fuel costs and geopolitical uncertainties that could affect operational costs and profitability. However, Carnival's strategic focus on cost management and operational efficiencies provides a buffer against these risks.

For Royal Caribbean, the reliance on onboard spending for revenue growth could be vulnerable to economic downturns or changes in consumer spending behavior. Nonetheless, the company's diversified revenue streams and strong brand reputation help mitigate these risks. Neither appears to be a poor choice for investment, and there are no immediate signals of choppy waters ahead.

A rising tide raises all boats, but Carnival sails ahead

As the cruise industry continues its robust recovery, both Carnival Corporation and Royal Caribbean Group present compelling investment opportunities. The industry's upward momentum benefits both companies, driving revenue growth and profitability. However, Carnival stands out at this time due to its exceptional cost management, record-breaking customer deposits, and strong financial recovery.

Carnival's focus on operational efficiency and effective cost control positions it as a resilient choice for long-term investors. While Royal Caribbean's strong earnings growth and innovative onboard offerings make it a solid investment, Carnival's overall financial health and execution provide a more compelling case for higher investor returns.

Investing in either company offers the potential for substantial gains as the industry rebounds. However, Carnival's current performance and strategic direction make it the standout choice. Investors going this route benefit from both the rising cruise industry tide and Carnival's strong individual momentum.

Should you invest $1,000 in Carnival Corp. right now?

Before you buy stock in Carnival Corp., consider this:

The Motley Fool Stock Advisor analyst team just identified what they believe are the 10 best stocks for investors to buy now… and Carnival Corp. wasn’t one of them. The 10 stocks that made the cut could produce monster returns in the coming years.

Consider when Nvidia made this list on April 15, 2005... if you invested $1,000 at the time of our recommendation, you’d have $757,001!*

Stock Advisor provides investors with an easy-to-follow blueprint for success, including guidance on building a portfolio, regular updates from analysts, and two new stock picks each month. The Stock Advisor service has more than quadrupled the return of S&P 500 since 2002*.

See the 10 stocks »

*Stock Advisor returns as of June 24, 2024

Nicholas Robbins has no position in any of the stocks mentioned. The Motley Fool recommends Carnival Corp. The Motley Fool has a disclosure policy.