Calcutta HC cancels OBC certificates for 77 groups, Mamata rejects order

The Calcutta high court on Wednesday scrapped other backward classes (OBCs) certificates awarded to 77 communities since 2010, an overwhelming majority of them Muslim, and called the classification process illegal, marking a significant verdict that came as a blow to the ruling Trinamool Congress in the middle of ongoing general elections.

The judgment sparked a political controversy with chief minister Mamata Banerjee saying she won’t accept the ruling, and Union home minister Amit Shah accusing the Bengal government of appeasement.

Roughly 500,000 people are likely to be affected by the judgment. The court barred the state from appointing people from these communities with immediate effect but said those appointed so far on the basis of OBC certificates will not be touched.

calcutta hc cancels obc certificates for 77 groups, mamata rejects order

“This court is of the view that the selection of 77 classes of Muslims as Backward is an affront to the Muslim community as a whole. This court’s mind is not free from doubt that the said community has been treated as a commodity for political ends,” said a division bench of justices Tapabrata Chakraborty and Rajasekhar Mantha.

“Identification of the classes in the aid community as OBCs for electoral gains would leave them at the mercy of the concerned political establishment and may defeat and deny other rights. Such reservation is therefore also an affront to Democracy and the Constitution of India as a whole,” the order added.

West Bengal provides 17% percent OBC reservation, divided into two buckets -- OBC A which has 10% and 81 communities, out of which 56 are Muslims, and OBC B which has 7% and 99 communities, out of which 41 are Muslims.

Muslims are a key demographic in the 17 Lok Sabha seats that will go to the polls in the sixth and seventh phases of the general elections in Bengal. The TMC holds 12of these and the BJP seven.

The court also struck down key sections of the 2012 law that subclassified the OBC pool.

Of the 77 communities, 42 were earmarked for OBC status by the erstwhile Left Front government in 2010, a year before it was ousted by Banerjee’s TMC. Out of these, 41 were Muslims, said the court. The other 35 -- 34 of which were Muslim, according to the verdict -- were included by the TMC government via a notification on May 11, 2012.

The order is a blow to the TMC, which counts Muslims as a key vote base and under whose regime the reservation benefits materialised. Chairman of West Bengal Imams Association Md Yahiya, said: “We don’t think this verdict follows the spirit of the Constitution. Why is everybody concerned only about OBC-A reservation? Why similar questions are being raised on reservation for scheduled caste and scheduled tribe people?”

“The authorities have violated the constitutional provisions and had practised protective discrimination in deviation to the constitutional norms. No data was disclosed on the basis of which it was ascertained that the concerned community is not adequately represented in the services under the government of West Bengal,” said the court.

The high court said the backward classes welfare department of Bengal along with the backward classes commission will place a report before the legislature with recommendations, for inclusion of new classes or for exclusion of the remaining classes, in the state list of OBCs.

The order came on petitions filed by three individuals and Atmadeep, a human rights organisation, between 2010 and 2020.

The petitioners alleged that reservations under both OBC-A (most backward) and OBC-B (backward) categories were awarded to many communities since 2011, when TMC came to power, without any evaluation of their economic status.

“If history and realities of life provide any guide, it would be axiomatic to say that human ingenuity has no limits in finding out the ways of avoiding and circumventing the provisions of law much more in cases where confidence of the people at large rests upon the government. The society at large has a stake in proper application of the yardsticks pertaining to reservation,” said the court.

“The allegations in the instant case are neither skirmishes nor bald, but speak of overt acts indicating non compliance of the statutory provisions and the law as laid down by the Hon’ble Supreme Court.”

The order cited the guidelines in the West Bengal Commission for Backward Classes Act of 1993 which said consultation with the commission is mandatory both for the purposes of subclassification of OBCs and determining the percentage of reservation for the classes or the sub-classes.

“After the commencement of the West Bengal Backward Classes (Other Than Schedule Castes And Schedule Tribes) (Reservation Of Vacancies And Posts) Act of 2012 only the state legislature is empowered to make provisions for reservation in the state services thereunder or under Art. 16(4). The state executive, therefore, is no longer permitted either under the Act of 1993 or even under Art. 16(4) to make provisions for reservation for OBCs in state services,” the order said.

“Article 16(4) of the Constitution has two wings, one is determination of backwardness and the other is whether the concerned class is adequately represented in the services under the State. No reasonable procedure has been followed for determination of such backwardness,” said the order, striking down the state government orders through which the quantum of quotas was determined under OBC-A and OBC-B categories.

In 2010, the Left Front government headed by then chief minister Buddhadeb Bhattacharya announced 10% reservation in state government jobs for “economically, socially and educationally backward” Muslims who come under the OBC-A category.

The 10% reservation in the OBC-A category was based on the recommendations of the National Commission for Religious and Linguistic Minorities whose report was tabled in Parliament in December 2009. At the time, there were 108 communities with an OBC tag, of which 53 were Muslims. Most of these communities were not affected by the order.

The state’s Muslim population stood at 27.01% during the 2011 census and is projected to have increased to around 30% now. After coming to power in 2011, Banerjee included more communities in the OBC lists.

Later in the day, Banerjee asserted that she “will not accept” the order . “The OBC reservation quota introduced by the West Bengal government will continue. We had drafted the bill after conducting a house-to-house survey, and it was passed by the cabinet and the assembly,” she said. “If necessary, we will move a higher court.”

Shah, who was in Bengal to address three BJP rallies, said, “These OBC reservations were done to appease Muslims.”

Read more news like this on HindustanTimes.com

OTHER NEWS

2 hrs ago

From Aries to Pisces; Here are the weaknesses of Zodiac Signs

2 hrs ago

Aishwarya Rai, Shah Rukh Khan, Deepika Padukone: Exploring the fascinating world of Bollywood lookalikes on social media

3 hrs ago

Trump asks Biden to take drug test ahead of first presidential debate on June 27

3 hrs ago

MM Keeravani recalls when RD Burman got credit for his composition: ‘Ram Gopal Varma told me that Pancham da will get the credit’

3 hrs ago

MapMyIndia promoter Rakesh Kumar Verma likely to trim stake in ₹115 crore block deal

3 hrs ago

Here are the best Lego sets you can find in 2024

3 hrs ago

Kamal Haasan speaks about writing ‘Thevar Magan’: 'I was thinking of Sivaji Ganesan sir…'

3 hrs ago

Another AI bot to contest elections, this time in the UK

3 hrs ago

BMW to launch 4 new cars, two-wheeler on July 24

3 hrs ago

Hanuma Vihari Makes U-Turn; Set To Continue Playing For Andhra Pradesh After Assurance From Ruling Party TDP

3 hrs ago

Fans Term Nayanthara And Nazriya Nazim Reunion 'Regina And Keerthana From Parallel Universe ', Wins Approval From Actors

3 hrs ago

5 Veggies that can naturally clean the colon

3 hrs ago

Gardening for beginners: 10 common mistakes even seasoned gardeners make

3 hrs ago

Warner, Babar, Narine, Shakib among galaxy of stars to light up GT20 Canada 2024

3 hrs ago

Tatas to build Rs 650 crore 'museum of temples' in Ayodhya, UP cabinet clears proposal

3 hrs ago

Indian railways to introduce a bullet train between Patna-New Delhi; travel time to reduce by 3 hours

3 hrs ago

Anime with sudden endings: Five stories that left fans in shock

3 hrs ago

Makers of 'Stree 2' unveil its teaser, Richa Chadha comes out in support of Deepika Padukone, Sonakshi Sinha and Zaheer Iqbal's unseen photo from wedding reception: Top 5 entertainment news of the day

3 hrs ago

Indian artist's incredible hula hoop dance in a saree in Paris ahead of Olympics 2024

3 hrs ago

Shah Rukh Khan completes 32 years in Hindi film industry, from DDLJ to Jawan, a look at major movies of King Khan

3 hrs ago

Taliban Thank India After Afghanistan Create History By Reaching T20 World Cup 2024 Semi-Final

3 hrs ago

Red Sox CF makes history with rare stat, strengthens All-Star case

3 hrs ago

After Nagarjuna, Dhanush faces backlash as his bodyguards push away fans. Watch

3 hrs ago

Vijay Sethupathi's Maharaja Creates New Record, Earns Rs 81 Crore In 10 Days!

4 hrs ago

VinFast making a tiny Rs 8L EV for India?

4 hrs ago

Indian 2 trailer: Kamal Haasan fights shirtless, returns as master of disguise. Watch

4 hrs ago

"One of the heroes of Real Madrid's great history": Ronaldo shares special message for Nacho

4 hrs ago

Nissan To Launch X-Trail Luxury SUV Soon In India

4 hrs ago

'Indian 2' trailer: Kamal Haasan's Senapathy is set to fight evil once again

4 hrs ago

'No money was deducted, recon issue': Groww responds to backlash after 'investment error'

4 hrs ago

Who is Marissa Teijo? 71-year-old woman makes history as oldest Miss Texas USA contestant

4 hrs ago

AFG vs BAN: Afghanistan storm into historic semi-final after thriller vs Bangladesh

4 hrs ago

Vashu Bhagnani's office sold to clear employees' dues? Producer reacts

4 hrs ago

BGauss RUV 350 electric scooter launched, priced from ₹1.10 lakh

4 hrs ago

India to add 7 new nuclear reactors, increase power generation capacity by 70% in 5 years: Minister

4 hrs ago

Red Velvet's 'Cosmic' dominates iTunes charts globally, including U.K. and U.S.

4 hrs ago

’TVF gave voices to the stories that no one was telling,’ says Tillotama Shome while sharing her journey

4 hrs ago

Bhagavad Gita, Chapter 3, Verse 3: How to Live Fully & Practice Detachment

4 hrs ago

Delhi's engineer Anand Goel vowed to plant 800 crore trees

4 hrs ago

Sai Sudharsan's contract re-newed, returns to Surrey for County Championship