Diversity Was Supposed to Make Us Rich. Not So Much.

When management consulting firm McKinsey declared in 2015 that it had found a link between profits and executive racial and gender diversity, it was a breakthrough. The research was used by investors, lobbyists and regulators to push for more women and minority groups on boards, and to justify investing in companies that appointed them.

Unfortunately, the research doesn’t show what everyone thought it showed.

There are obvious benefits of diverse corporate leadership for society, both in providing role models and in showing a commitment to promoting the best people, irrespective of skin color or gender. But doing it because it is the right thing is not the same as doing it because it makes more money.

Since 2015, the approach has been tested in the fire of the marketplace and failed. Academics have tried to repeat McKinsey’s findings and failed, concluding that there is in fact no link between profitability and executive diversity. And the methodology of McKinsey’s early studies, which helped create the widespread belief that diversity is good for profits, is being questioned.

McKinsey has tried to remedy one of the most obvious flaws. It originally linked profits over several years with diversity at the end of the period, meaning the most it could prove is that profitability led to more diversity, not the other way around. In its latest study, it said it had now run the tests using diversity at the start of the period, and still found a correlation.

“In light of a recent study criticizing our methodologies, we have reviewed our research and continue to stand by its findings—that diverse leadership teams are associated with a higher likelihood of financial outperformance,” McKinsey said. “We have also been clear and consistent that our research identifies correlation, not causation, and that those two things are not the same.”

The trouble is that McKinsey behaves as though the studies do show causation, constantly talking of the corporate benefits of diversity.

Even the correlation is in doubt. Academics can’t replicate McKinsey’s study precisely, because it keeps secret the names of the companies it used. But a paper published this year finds that McKinsey’s methodology doesn’t show benefits from diversity for S&P 500 companies for a range of profitability metrics. It isn’t that a lack of diversity is good for profits either, it’s just there’s no link.

diversity was supposed to make us rich. not so much.

This shouldn’t come as a surprise. If companies could boost their profits as easily as McKinsey suggested—the most-diverse firms had a 39 percentage point higher chance of higher-than-average profit margins than the least-diverse—then surely companies would have rushed to promote more women and minority racial groups.

“It seemed implausible because companies would have jumped on it and the advantages would be competed away,” said John Hand, an accounting professor at the University of North Carolina at Chapel Hill. With Jeremiah Green of Texas A&M University, he found no results that were statistically significant when repeating McKinsey’s study for the S&P 500. McKinsey keeps secret the names of the companies in its study, which in 2015 included 186 from the U.S. and Canada, so it can’t be independently verified.

This matters, because the McKinsey study was hugely influential. McKinsey’s research figures first in BlackRock’s references for supporting a board diversity target of 30% in its proxy voting guidelines. It featured prominently among studies used by a Securities and Exchange Commission commissioner in 2020 to explain why she supported corporate disclosure of diversity metrics. Nasdaq cited it as evidence when the exchange applied to the SEC for a rule requiring companies it lists to have minimum diversity on boards, or explain why they don’t. It has been cited by dozens of campaign groups pushing for rules to support consideration of social issues by pension funds and others, too.

McKinsey’s influence wasn’t only on policy, which ought anyway to consider moral and societal issues as well as purely financial ones. BlackRock and Refinitiv, now part of the London Stock Exchange Group, cited the study as evidence of financial benefits from diversity when they created an ETF that tracked a diversity index. That index has lagged badly behind since its 2018 launch, returning about 55% against more than 70% for the global index without diversity conditions.

This seems to be less about diversity than the choice of how to invest in it. The ETF is equal-weighted, which has held it back as giant stocks beat the rest of the market. Because of the diversity requirements, it held a lot more banks and insurers, and less technology, than the market as a whole.

A similar fund was created earlier by State Street Global Advisors with the ticker SHE. It was promoted through the “Fearless Girl” statue—briefly installed opposite Wall Street’s bronze bull and now opposite the New York Stock Exchange—and backed by research from MSCI, which claimed a 36% higher return on equity for firms with at least three women on the board, or “strong female leadership.”

A moment’s thought would suggest this was far too high a figure to be explained by the presence of a handful of women, and subsequent deep underperformance shows skepticism was the right response. Since its 2016 launch the fund’s return has lagged more than 70 percentage points behind that of the top 1,000 companies, from which it selected before switching to an MSCI gauge two years ago. It has shrunk from a peak of $400 million to $245 million.

McKinsey said in its original paper that “it stands to reason…that more diverse companies are better able to win top talent, and improve their customer orientation, employee satisfaction, and decision-making, leading to a virtuous cycle of increasing returns.” Common sense also says it’s easier to avoid potentially catastrophic groupthink if people have a range of different experiences.

Common sense also insists that it’s important to build team spirit and trust, where people with a shared background have a head start. University of Chicago law professor Lisa Bernstein showed this for New York’s Jewish diamond dealers, who would score zero for diversity but gained financially by the trust from their common heritage. Similar studies have shown the same for other small ethnic business groups.

Bernstein thinks such trust can be built from networks of social connections, but it comes built-in for some backgrounds.

Skin color and sex don’t perfectly capture diversity of thought, anyway. A privately-educated Black Harvard Business School graduate would probably think much the same way about business as a white one. A top female New York lawyer may have a similar experience of life—or lack of it—as a male one. McKinsey’s diversity of thought suggestions don’t extend to, for example, appointing worker representatives to the board, even though their ideas might well be quite different to those of senior management.

Finally, correlation is not causation! McKinsey repeatedly says in its study that it only found a correlation. The Aztecs mistook correlation for causation with tragic results, cutting out the heart of a victim to rekindle fire every 52 years in order to ensure the world’s survival. There was a strong correlation between the human sacrifice and the world not ending—but no causation.

Investors don’t risk having vital organs removed, but they should pay more attention to the studies they rely on.

Write to James Mackintosh at [email protected]

OTHER NEWS

22 minutes ago

Support for Albo, Dutton plunges

22 minutes ago

Taylor Swift gets stuck on platform at Dublin concert as dancer forced to step in

25 minutes ago

Advocate calls on Alberta to opt out of $10-a-day child care plan

27 minutes ago

Video: Love Island fans slam Jess White for getting the 'ick' with new bombshell Trey Norman after 'chasing a balding man who played her like a fiddle on national TV'

27 minutes ago

Video: Louis Tomlinson and his sister Lottie delight Glastonbury fans by bringing a TV for fans to watch England's nail-biting 2-1 victory over Slovakia

27 minutes ago

Video: The Block winners Steph and Gian Ottavio reveal next project after record win: 'We've got this ultimate plan'

27 minutes ago

Manchester United 'close to reaching settlement with Newcastle to appoint Dan Ashworth as their new sporting director' with the Magpies having held out for compensation fee of around £20m

27 minutes ago

SPORTS AGENDA: Trent Alexander-Arnold hits back in £50,000 padel court row at his Cheshire home, Qatar fire shots at Germany... while police are left stretched in Gelsenkirchen

27 minutes ago

Gary Neville blasts England's 'woeful' Euro 2024 displays and claims Gareth Southgate and his side were 'very lucky' to advance to the quarter-finals after their dramatic win over Slovakia

28 minutes ago

Taylor Swift Gets Stuck on Platform After Stage Malfunction During Dublin Concert

28 minutes ago

'I Love Life, I Love Golf, It Can't Get Any Better At The Moment' - Marcel Siem Claims Thrilling Italian Open In Playoff

28 minutes ago

Shaq says he would love to play for Warriors in today's NBA: "I would do what these bums are doing now, and I'd be making a lot of money"

28 minutes ago

I’m on right side of history over trans athletes, says Martina Navratilova

28 minutes ago

Ferocious Hurricane Beryl nearing landfall in the Caribbean

29 minutes ago

Warriors waive Chris Paul; Klay Thompson likely leaving

29 minutes ago

SZA review, Glastonbury 2024: One of the sparsest sets in recent memory frequently leaves you breathless

29 minutes ago

Georgia to look back with joy when dust settles after defeat

29 minutes ago

Spain deserved win says coach who now has Germany in his sights

29 minutes ago

Ipswich sign Hutchinson from Chelsea on five-year deal

29 minutes ago

Anthony Albanese doubles down on decision to suspend WA Senator Fatima Payman

29 minutes ago

Potential Celtics free agent targets

29 minutes ago

Supreme Court makes prosecution of Trump on obstruction charge more difficult, with ruling to narrowly define law used against him and Jan. 6 rioters

29 minutes ago

2024 U.S. Senior Open postponed till Monday due to a 'dangerous weather situation'

29 minutes ago

Denver Nuggets pursued Paul George and a future Hall of Fame All-Star, but now may be scrambling in NBA free agency

29 minutes ago

Orlando Pirates to announce new specialist

29 minutes ago

Coco Gauff next match at Wimbledon 2024: TV schedule, scores, results for tennis grand slam

29 minutes ago

Cam Davis wins 2024 Rocket Mortgage Classic

29 minutes ago

Warriors waive Chris Paul

29 minutes ago

North Korea launches a ballistic missile toward sea, after end of new US-South Korea-Japan drill

31 minutes ago

Protests turn violent in Jerusalem as Ultra-Orthodox resist order to enlist in Israeli military

34 minutes ago

Turkish airport officials reject Israeli plane emergency refuel, departs to Greece

34 minutes ago

Reform candidate defects after becoming 'disillusioned' with the party

34 minutes ago

How to watch USMNT vs. Uruguay in decisive Copa America game

34 minutes ago

Aerovironment CEO Wahid Nawabi sits down with Jim Cramer

34 minutes ago

WNBA Fans Moved By Caitlin Clark and Diana Taurasi's Pregame Interaction

34 minutes ago

Kyle Busch Unravels the "Exact Story" That Led to His New Hampshire Disaster

34 minutes ago

Officials rejoice after iconic US lake system reaches peak water levels for first time in over a decade: 'Keep conserving, it's actually working'

34 minutes ago

Bystander captures nerve-wracking photo of tourist getting too close to adult bear for photo opportunity: 'It could attack him'

34 minutes ago

Simone Biles Stunned by Husband Jonathan Owens' Luxury Gifts at Olympic Trials

34 minutes ago

Decision to name Prince Harry the recipient of Pat Tillman award scorched by mom: 'Controversial and divisive'