Post Office victims not exonerated ‘being punished for efficiency and courage’

post office victims not exonerated ‘being punished for efficiency and courage’

Post Office Horizon IT scandal

Victims of the Post Office Horizon scandal not being exonerated are being “punished for their efficiency and courage”, a leading campaigner has told Parliament.

New legislation to quash the convictions of affected subpostmasters will not include those whose cases have already been considered by the Court of Appeal or those who were prosecuted by the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP).

There are at least 13 cases of subpostmasters whose convictions were upheld by the Court of Appeal or were refused permission for their case to be heard, and an estimated 62 who were prosecuted by the DWP.

Conservative peer Lord Arbuthnot of Edrom, a former MP who campaigned for justice for subpostmasters for years and sits on the Horizon Compensation Advisory Board, urged the Government to consider including these cases.

On those excluded because their case has been considered by the Court of Appeal, he said: “I’m very uncomfortable indeed about this.

“The Bill overturns many hundreds of convictions.

“The Government accepts, as it should, that some of the convictions overturned will in fact have been of subpostmasters who were actually guilty of a crime. That is the price that we pay for the exoneration of the innocent.

“Those who have been in front of the Court of Appeal, in exactly the same way as those subpostmasters who have been in front of other courts, may or may not be guilty.

“I don’t think it’s acceptable to tell them ‘you can go back to the Court of Appeal if there is new evidence’, because other subpostmasters are not being required to provide individual evidence of their innocence, a reversal of the burden of proof.

“These 13 are being punished for their efficiency and courage in being early in taking their convictions to the Court of Appeal…

“It stretches credulity to believe that the Court of Appeal would say, of all of the hundreds of convicted subpostmasters, these are the 13 that we would choose to remain convicted.”

His comments came as the Post Office (Horizon System) Offences Bill received its second reading in the House of Lords.

The Bill is set to quash convictions of theft, fraud, false accounting and other offences for subpostmasters who have suffered as a consequence of the Post Office Horizon scandal, and relevant cautions will be deleted from records.

The Bill will apply to all those convicted of such offences in England, Wales and Northern Ireland, who were prosecuted by the Post Office, Crown Prosecution Service (CPS) or Northern Ireland authorities in the years 1996 to 2018.

Those whose convictions are quashed will then be eligible to receive compensation payments from the Horizon Convictions Redress Scheme, which will be set up after the legislation is passed.

Former Labour Cabinet minister Lord Browne of Ladyton told peers that new evidence has emerged since the Court of Appeal upheld convictions of subpostmasters.

He said: “There is no doubt that the public inquiry has revealed considerable further evidence since those appeals were refused.

“There is no question.

“If any of those cases involve Horizon-generated evidence, they should be given the same consideration as the cases that have been prosecuted to conviction but not appeal.”

Labour former shadow attorney general Lord Falconer of Thoroton added: “The decision to exclude from exoneration those cases which have already been dealt with by the Court of Appeal, I am strongly against that.

“Everybody should be exonerated.”

On those prosecuted by the DWP, Lord Arbuthnot said: “I would very much like to hear why the Government considers that DWP convictions are safe, when CPS convictions are not.

“And I would also like to hear what the DWP is doing to re-examine their convictions to make sure they have not relied on tainted Post Office evidence and investigations.”

He asked: “Should we consider, perhaps, widening the scope of the Bill, so that those convictions too are overturned?”

Responding to concerns about the exclusion of Court of Appeal cases, business minister Lord Offord of Garvel said: “This is a difficult issue.

“Including convictions that have been upheld by the Court of Appeal would override decisions taken by the senior judiciary.

“Of the 13 such cases that we know of, seven were upheld by the Court of Appeal and six were refused leave to appeal.

“They are excluded from the Bill because the Government believes that we should tread very carefully where judges in the senior appellant courts have considered a case on its merits.

“We recognise this approach may leave a small number of individuals concerned about the way forward for their cases.”

On prosecutions brought by the DWP, the minister said: “These cases, unlike many of the cases prosecuted by the Post Office or CPS involved wider corroborating evidence beyond that supplied by the faulty Horizon system and so are unlikely to be unsafe in the same way.”

To receive the best stories in your inbox every day, click here to register for one or more newsletters from The Standard.

OTHER NEWS

23 minutes ago

England vs Serbia referee had 'disaster' at World Cup which led to Lionel Messi glory

23 minutes ago

Hynes axed as new-look Blues squad confirmed

23 minutes ago

England vs Serbia: Date, kick-off time and TV channel for Euro 2024 group-stage game

23 minutes ago

Is Poland v Netherlands on TV? Kick-off time, channel and how to watch Euro 2024 match today

23 minutes ago

As Boeing looks to buy a key 737 supplier, a whistleblower says the problems run deep

23 minutes ago

A Swiss museum will remove 5 paintings potentially looted by Nazis

25 minutes ago

UK Conservatives getting ‘smashed’ in the polls

31 minutes ago

GT Aston Martin Exits Le Mans In a Dramatic Rollover Crash

31 minutes ago

Fernando Alonso knows the moment it will be ‘bye bye’ from F1 for good

37 minutes ago

The Tory manifesto raises more questions than answers – here are 20 of the biggest

37 minutes ago

'This film is about a survivor': Alicia Vikander on playing Katherine Parr

37 minutes ago

Controversial finish in Collingwood and North Melbourne game, as Bobby Hill takes MOTY contender, and Giants down Power

37 minutes ago

THR Frontrunners Q&A With the Cast and Creators of 'Young Sheldon' | THR Video

37 minutes ago

'We'll hunt you': Trump, MAGA supporters' violent rhetoric isn't a glitch. It's a feature.

37 minutes ago

The big lie: why taxes are going up (no matter what the Tories or Labour say)

37 minutes ago

‘Star of the show’: DeChambeau firmly in driver’s seat to win second U.S. Open

37 minutes ago

‘Keep the coaches, change entire team’: Wasim Akram wants all players of Babar Azam-led Pakistan squad dropped

37 minutes ago

Donald Trump challenges Joe Biden to cognitive test but then forgets name of his own doctor

37 minutes ago

Lady Elliot Island boat capsize: Desperate search for missing man after boat overturned ends in tragedy off Queensland coast near Bundaberg after Life Flight winched a father and son to safety

40 minutes ago

Ashley Graham debuts children's book encouraging self-love, confidence

44 minutes ago

Video: Hundreds of Majorcans take over tiny picture postcard cove made famous by Instagram 'influencers' and unfurl banners reading 'SOS Residents' amid Spanish island's anti-tourism backlash against UK holidaymakers

44 minutes ago

Ukraine proves it can target the Russian air force's weakest link

44 minutes ago

Canada cricketers miss out on marquee matchup with India due to wet ground conditions

44 minutes ago

Luai praised as Origin awaits

44 minutes ago

'Good to go': Edwards, Luai shine in final NSW audition

44 minutes ago

Down 10% in a week! What’s wrong with the Legal & General Group share price?

44 minutes ago

Gary Neville hammered after naming England XI Southgate MUST pick for Euro 2024 opener

44 minutes ago

'Prison-cell' flat that costs £475 a month is like a sit-com set

44 minutes ago

Ox Nche makes the cut as Bulls dominate URC Team of the Season

44 minutes ago

Israel announces ‘pause’ along southern Gaza route to allow in aid but no let up in Rafah offensive

48 minutes ago

Thorpe Park’s Hyperia rollercoaster breaks down again leaving thrillseekers hanging at 236ft

49 minutes ago

Woman who spent 43 years behind bars has murder conviction overturned

49 minutes ago

"Pogacar seems unbeatable, so we must aim for stage victories": What can EF-boys Powless and Van den Berg pull off in the Tour?

49 minutes ago

Samantha Murphy: Cop makes bleak admission about the endless search for missing Ballarat mum after discovery by a dam renewed hopes of finding her body

49 minutes ago

Video: Married At First Sight's Martha Kalifatidis and Michael Brunelli's one-year-old son Lucius shares first words

49 minutes ago

Video: All the best videos from Trooping the Colour: Kate's great comeback, glimpses behind the scenes and Charlotte and Louis acting up

55 minutes ago

Sex attacker dubbed 'Coronation Street rapist' launches NEW parole bid - despite breaking rules when he was last released from jail

55 minutes ago

Jobless man, 60, who still lives with his mother smashed woman's windscreen with his fists in fit of rage after she turned her car around in his driveway

55 minutes ago

From AI-powered limb-tracking to a match ball with a chip inside: The futuristic technologies powering Euro 2024 in Germany this month, revealed

55 minutes ago

NASA's Chandra X-ray telescope captures closest super star cluster to Earth (image)