Supreme Court backs GOP plan in SC that critics say discriminated against Black voters

supreme court backs gop plan in sc that critics say discriminated against black voters

Rep. Nancy Mace (R-SC) arrives for a meeting of the Republican House caucus on Sept. 30, 2023, in Washington, DC. The government is expected to shut down at midnight if the House does not reach a last-minute budget deal on Saturday.

WASHINGTON – A divided Supreme Court on Thursday signed off on a South Carolina congressional map that critics − including a lower court − said discriminated against Black voters to make Rep. Nancy Mace's district friendlier to Republicans.

The 6-3 conservative majority said the challengers provided no direct evidence that race was the dominant reason for the boundaries.

“When partisanship and race correlate, it naturally follows that a map that has been gerrymandered to achieve a partisan end can look very similar to a racially gerrymandered map,” Justice Samuel Alito wrote for the majority.

Start the day smarter. Get all the news you need in your inbox each morning.

Writing for the minority, Justice Elena Kagan said the challengers introduced more than enough evidence to show race was improperly a factor.

More: Another controversial flag flew over a home of Supreme Court Justice Alito: New York Times

'Go right ahead': Kagan says decision will embolden other states to discriminate

Kagan said the majority’s decision will embolden other state legislators who “often have an incentive to use race as a proxy to achieve partisan ends.”

“Go right ahead, this Court says to States today,” she wrote in a sharply worded dissent joined by Justices Sonya Sotomayor and Ketanji Brown Jackson.

Justice Clarence Thomas mostly sided with the majority but wrote a separate opinion to argue courts should not be deciding whether a district’s boundaries have been unfairly manipulated along racial lines.

“Drawing political districts is a task for politicians, not federal judges,” Thomas wrote.

President Joe Biden said the decision "undermines the basic principle that voting practices should not discriminate on account of race and that is wrong."

It won't change the map in place for this fall's elections.

In March, a federal appeals court, which had previously ruled the map unconstitutional, said it had no choice but to require it be used this year since the Supreme Court had not issued its opinion after hearing oral arguments in October.

Early voting for South Carolina's June 11 primary starts next week, on Tuesday.

The coastal South Carolina district is held by Mace, one of eight Republicans who voted last year to oust former Speaker Kevin McCarthy.

The decision turned on whether the state’s 2020 redistricting violated the Constitution's equal protection clause by moving about 30,000 Black voters into another district.

Decision follows a surprise Supreme Court ruling

It comes at a moment of uncertainty about redistricting, the once-a-decade process of redrawing congressional districts. Last year, in a surprise ruling, the Supreme Court invalidated a congressional map in Alabama that was also challenged for diluting the Black vote. That case challenged the maps as a violation of the landmark Voting Rights Act of 1965.

The South Carolina case, by contrast, was challenged on constitutional grounds.

A divided Supreme Court in 2019 took federal courts out of the business of deciding partisan gerrymander lawsuits – holding that the disputes are more political than legal. But voters and groups may still file lawsuits over racial gerrymanders and allege that minority voters are facing discrimination as state lawmakers draw new congressional boundaries.

The problem is that race and political affiliation are often intertwined. South Carolina lawmakers said they were not targeting Black voters, which would be illegal, but were instead moving Democratic voters into a different district, which would be unreviewable by federal courts.

The South Carolina State Conference of the NAACP, which challenged the state’s map along with other groups, said there were signs that mapmakers were focused on race. For example, despite a sharp increase in the number of Black voters in the district, the redrawn map had a nearly identical share of Black voters as the version drawn following the 2010 census.

Critics said that indicated the mapmakers were aiming for a target based on race. After an eight-day trial, a lower federal court last year unanimously agreed.

“The court finds that race was the predominant motivating factor in the…design of” the district, the lower court said.   “Traditional districting principles were subordinated to race.”

The case is Alexander v. NAACP.

Contributing: John Fritze.

This article originally appeared on USA TODAY: Supreme Court backs GOP plan in SC that critics say discriminated against Black voters

OTHER NEWS

23 minutes ago

After Maharashtra setback, how BJP is planning to regroup, bridge gap with MVA

23 minutes ago

Insiders predict Rust Belt Republican, possible Trump VP pick, could flip Biden votes in key swing states

23 minutes ago

For Ukrainians in Canada, new conscription rules increase pressure to fight

23 minutes ago

‘Wear a helmet’: Gordon Ramsay shows off full torso bruise after bike accident

23 minutes ago

Putin's nuclear submarine detected off UK coast

23 minutes ago

Trump challenges Biden to take cognitive test - only to get name of his own doctor wrong

23 minutes ago

T20 World Cup: England qualify for Super 8s after rain and Australia fumbles make for nervous group finale

23 minutes ago

How to reverse austerity? Scrap some of the tax-relief schemes worth £204bn

23 minutes ago

Italy's swift response secures victory after record breaking Albania start

23 minutes ago

NRL Highlights: Knights v Panthers - Round 15

23 minutes ago

Down 50%, this FTSE dividend stock looks like a steal to me

23 minutes ago

Australia's record population surge is being driven by Indian migration: Here's why so many of them are moving here - and what they really think about life Down Under

23 minutes ago

Video: Terrifying moment 7ft shark swims at speed towards Gran Canaria shore - with beach forced to close to bathing after sparking fear among tourists and locals

23 minutes ago

Video: Former MI6 agent rates the best and worst spy devices available on Amazon including a lie detector test and rearview sunglasses - and reveals why crisps are the 'best intruder detection system ever invented'

26 minutes ago

‘Dangerous conditions’: Damaging surf warnings in place for parts of the east coast

28 minutes ago

Tories and Labour clash on tax as General Election battles intensify

28 minutes ago

The Andy Griffith Show's Ron Howard Reveals Jokes Killed by Andy Griffith

28 minutes ago

Mbappé wants to erase bad memory of decisive penalty miss and leave Euro 2024 as a champion

28 minutes ago

Gig for Gaza event in Canberra raises funds for Australian doctors working in Palestine

28 minutes ago

Scientists sound alarm after making disturbing discovery in the Amazon: 'We have all this information; now let's act on it'

28 minutes ago

Luai stars as Panthers survive Knights scare

28 minutes ago

Serbia XI vs England: Predicted lineup, confirmed Euro 2024 team news and injuries today

28 minutes ago

Transit expert highlights issues with popular design trend in truck and SUV models: 'It honestly infuriates me'

28 minutes ago

Revealed: The ultimate dad jokes this Father's Day, according to AI - so, would they make you laugh?

28 minutes ago

UK's 'tallest rollercoaster' Hyperia at Thorpe Park 'breaks down' - with thrill-seekers stuck on ride at 236ft for an HOUR just days after reopening

28 minutes ago

Hundreds of Majorcans take over tiny picture postcard cove made famous by Instagram 'influencers' and unfurl banners reading 'SOS Residents' amid Spanish island's anti-tourism backlash against UK holidaymakers

28 minutes ago

Woman claims she was fined £200 for littering after seagulls ate a few McDonald's chips she accidentally dropped on the floor

28 minutes ago

Can I take legal action if I buy a house with invasive bamboo? And do I need to tell buyers if my home's infested? MailOnline answers your questions about 'Japanese knotweed 2.0'

28 minutes ago

Gordon Ramsay is flooded with well wishes from daughter Holly and celebrity pals after chef suffered a horrific cycling accident

31 minutes ago

Harry Kane says England start Euro 2024 with ‘the most in-form squad we’ve had’

31 minutes ago

How the Euros could change the result of the election

33 minutes ago

Sheffield DocFest Confronts Challenges Facing Nonfiction Film Industry, In Midst Of Turbulent Political, Economic Environment

33 minutes ago

When you can hear every word, thank the sound mixers

33 minutes ago

U.S. Open Complaints Grow After Paywall Frustrations: 'Atrocious' Sound & Graphics Issues Anger Golf World

33 minutes ago

Zain Davids, Shilton van Wyk bolster Blitzboks in last-ditch bid for Paris Olympics

34 minutes ago

Star Wars Outlaws: Ubisoft reveals details and gameplay of anticipated game

34 minutes ago

New poll suggests less than half of Americans plan to buy an EV for their next vehicle — here’s why

34 minutes ago

ATP Halle draw: Jannik Sinner finds out first opponent as world No 1 as he lands tricky draw

34 minutes ago

Corey Heim notches best Xfinity Series finish at Iowa Speedway

34 minutes ago

Biden, Trump step up outreach to Black men