Green activists don’t care how many people will die from zero fossil fuel use

opinion, climate change, fossil fuel, green energy, green activists don’t care how many people will die from zero fossil fuel use

Demonstrators calling for an end to funding fossil fuels at a protest in Washington, DC on April 19, 2024. Photo by Kent Nishimura/Getty Images

We endlessly hear the flawed assertion that because climate change is real, we should “follow the science” and end fossil fuel use.

We hear this claim from politicians who favor swift carbon cuts, and from natural scientists themselves, as when the editor-in-chief of Nature insists “The science is clear — fossil fuels must go.”

The assertion is convenient for politicians, because it allows them to avoid responsibility for the many costs and downsides of climate policy, painting these as inevitable results of diligently following the scientific evidence.

But it is false because it conflates climate science with climate policy.

The story told by activist politicians and climate campaigners suggests that there is nothing but benefits to ending fossil fuels, versus a hellscape if nothing is done.

But the reality is that the world over the past centuries has improved dramatically — largely because of the immense increase in available energy that has come mostly from fossil fuels.

Life spans have more than doubled, hunger has dramatically declined, and incomes have increased ten-fold.

While the impact of climate change is likely negative, it is enormously exaggerated.

We constantly hear about extreme weather such as droughts, storms, floods and fires, although even the UN Climate Panel finds that evidence of them worsening cannot yet be documented for most of these.

But much more importantly, a richer world is much more resilient and hence much less affected by extreme weather.

The data shows that climate-related deaths from droughts, storms, floods and fires have declined by more than 97% from nearly 500,000 annually a century ago to less than 15,000 in the 2020s.

At the same time, the costs of the climate campaigners’ calls to “just stop” oil, gas and coal are massively downplayed.

Currently, the world gets almost four-fifths of all its energy from fossil fuels. If we quickly ended our use of fossil fuels, billions would die.

Four billion people — half the world’s population — entirely depend on food grown with synthetic fertilizer produced almost entirely by natural gas.

If we ended fossil fuels quickly, we would physically have no way to feed four billion people.

Add the billions of people dependent on fossil fuel heating in the winter time, along with the dependence on fossil fuels for steel, cement, plastics, and transport, and it is little wonder that one recent estimate shows abruptly ending fossil fuels would lead to 6 billion people dying in less than a year.

Most politicians suggest a slightly less rushed end to fossil fuels by 2050.

This slower pace would avoid billions of people dying outright, but the downsides are still immense.

The latest, peer-reviewed climate-economic research shows that efficiently reaching net-zero emissions by 2050 will cost a staggering $27 trillion per year on average over the century.

That is one-quarter of the world’s current GDP.

The same research shows that the benefits will be just a small fraction of that cost. The policy is prohibitively expensive for little benefit.

A good analogy is to consider the more than 1 million global traffic deaths annually.

Traffic — like climate change — is a man-made problem. Like climate change, it is something we could entirely solve.

If scientists were to only look at how to avoid the million traffic deaths, one solution would be to reduce speed limits everywhere to 3 mph.

If heavily enforced, this would almost entirely eliminate traffic deaths.

Of course, it would also almost entirely eliminate our economies and our productive lives.

We would laugh if politicians said we should “follow the science” and stop traffic deaths by reducing speeds to 3 mph.

As we do with traffic, in the climate debate we should take a sensible approach. This means focusing on short-term adaptation to build resilience, and long-term investment in R&D for green energy.

Innovation must drive the price of reliable, green energy down below fossil fuels, eventually making sure everyone can switch to low-carbon alternatives.

When politicians tell us they are “following the science,” they use the claim to shut down open discussion of the enormous costs of their policies.

“The science” informs us about the problem, but is not the arbiter of solutions.

Democracies are.

Sudden, dramatic cuts in fossil fuel consumption will have huge downsides — which their backers would rather ignore.

Climate change is a problem, but a civilization-endangering cure can be far worse than the illness.

Bjorn Lomborg is President of the Copenhagen Consensus, Visiting Fellow at Stanford University’s Hoover Institution, and author of “False Alarm” and “Best Things First.”

OTHER NEWS

25 minutes ago

Chris Billam-Smith says experience was the key in avenging Richard Riakporhe loss

25 minutes ago

Baby-wearing dads celebrate Fathers’ Day with record-breaking walk in S’pore

25 minutes ago

‘In South Africa, you hear of disappearance all the time’: one photographer’s search for his sister’s missing years

25 minutes ago

HMRC has failed to fine a single ‘enabler’ of offshore tax fraud in five years

25 minutes ago

Cameron Smith's shirt at the 2024 U.S. Open is a periodic table of alcohol — and you can own it, too

25 minutes ago

From Oregon Trail to Wurdweb, five fun games to play on Apple Arcade this summer

25 minutes ago

2 dead, 6 injured in shooting at Texas Juneteenth celebration: officials

28 minutes ago

Inmates take staff hostage at a detention center in southern Russia

32 minutes ago

Seibold lauds gutsy Manly after 30-14 win over Dragons

32 minutes ago

Saudi FM: Ukraine peace process will need Russia’s participation

32 minutes ago

How to pick a watermelon: Sweet and ripe every time

32 minutes ago

Ratcliffe must axe Man Utd ace who earns 4x more than Branthwaite

32 minutes ago

Rachel Stevens admits she was left in 'turmoil' after falling for Dancing on Ice partner Brendyn Hatfield ahead of 'messy and scary' split from husband Alex Bourne

32 minutes ago

Brave Kate is a beacon of light in new behind-the-scenes Trooping the Colour video - as Waleses reveal they are 'in awe' at 'incredible' ceremony that included Princess' Buckingham Palace balcony appearance

38 minutes ago

The Rev James Lawson, Martin Luther King’s right-hand man in the Civil Rights struggle – obituary

38 minutes ago

Here’s how I’d target £1,580 in passive income next year using a £20k Stocks and Shares ISA

38 minutes ago

Artem Dovbyk’s path from Ukraine’s third tier to La Liga’s finest finisher

38 minutes ago

Christian Eriksen to complete football's greatest comeback - "I'd died for five minutes"

38 minutes ago

Slovenia vs Denmark: Euro 2024 prediction, kick-off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h, odds today

38 minutes ago

Poland vs Netherlands: Euro 2024 prediction, kick-off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h, odds today

38 minutes ago

Larsson: Barca need signings to win trophies next season

38 minutes ago

I have a terminal brain tumour and doctors have given me a year to live - I want this Father's Day to be the best ever in case it's my last one

38 minutes ago

Israel announces daily 'tactical pause' in fighting in southern Gaza to let humanitarian aid flow into the war-torn region

38 minutes ago

Tom Parker widow Kelsey says their young children, Aurelia, 4, and Bodhi, 3, still make Father's Day cards for the singer two years on from his death

38 minutes ago

We're parenting experts and here are 9 tips to help you survive Father's Day as a single mother

38 minutes ago

Inside King Charles's changing relationship with Prince William and Prince Harry amid family turmoil in recent years - as he celebrates Father's Day without his youngest son

40 minutes ago

Jayden Daniels has signed his rookie contract with the Washington Commanders

42 minutes ago

Taylor Swift Chokes Up On Stage During Final Liverpool Concert In Eras Tour

44 minutes ago

Michael Clarke appears to confirm romance with new real estate guru Arabella Sherborne as they enjoy romantic holiday on the Gold Coast

44 minutes ago

Driver shares frustration with photo of 'gas guzzler' parked in electric charging spot: 'Why is it that pickup truck drivers have such hate for EVs?'

44 minutes ago

The Wanted singer Tom Parker's kids make him Father's Day cards two years after death

44 minutes ago

New tool for tactical votes in Tory-held seats aims to change voting system

44 minutes ago

Whatever way you look at it, the Dublin Mayo rivalry covered up for years of poor football

46 minutes ago

Billy Crystal poked fun at Robert De Niro’s acting on set of ‘Analyze This’

46 minutes ago

Céline Dion believes late husband’s spirit is still in her life

46 minutes ago

Keith Richards got so wasted on Rolling Stones tour he was flown to another country while still in bed

46 minutes ago

Clive Myrie reveals shocking extent of racial abuse faced as BBC newsreader

47 minutes ago

France seek fast start to help end 24 years of waiting for European Championship glory

48 minutes ago

Richards Bay have Premiership fate in own hands with AmaTuks draw

48 minutes ago

In Sudan, Russia's Africa strategy advances another step