Sunak backtracked on climate policies – and voters may punish him

sunak backtracked on climate policies – and voters may punish him

The then chancellor, Rishi Sunak, holds a green ministerial documents box at the Cop26 summit in Glasgow, 2021. Photograph: Stefan Rousseau/PA

Every time a UK government minister is asked about the climate crisis, the answer is the same. “We are the first major economy to halve emissions and have the most ambitious legally binding emissions targets in the world,” is the response, or a variation on those words.

It is true that since 1990 the UK has cut greenhouse gas emissions further and faster than any other major developed economy, while increasing the size of the economy. Emissions per capita are now lower than they have been since the mid-nineteenth century.

However, these repeated claims tell only half the story: those past emissions cuts came mainly from the switch from coal to gas, and the pace of reduction has now slowed considerably. On current form, the UK will miss its emissions-cutting obligations by 2030 and by 2050 by a wide margin, and lacks any coherent plan to achieve the much harder transformation of the economy now needed.

“The UK is not on track to net zero, with emissions flatlining for the last decade across transport, industry, homes and agriculture,” says Ed Matthew of the E3G thinktank. “At the same time energy bills have gone through the roof [due] to our ongoing dependence on gas … This government is in dire danger of being severely punished for their failure at the ballot box.”

Sunak has made his pitch to the electorate not quite as an anti-net zero prime minister, but through an appeal to “pragmatism”. He and his ministers have repeatedly said net zero policy must be “proportional”. He has claimed that net zero is an intolerable burden on the poorest in society, even though it is the government’s decisions that determine where the costs will fall, and poorer people could be the biggest beneficiaries of investments in renewable energy and home insulation, if done right.

The government’s message is to go more slowly on tackling the climate crisis, rather than give it up. But this is a dangerous path, interpreted by many as a signal to slow down drastically.

Sunak knew this when he decided last September to make a major speech rowing back on commitments to net zero, vowing to stick to the targets while dismantling many of the policies – on electric vehicles, boilers, public transport – needed to get there. This made climate, for the first time in the UK, into a culture war issue, said campaigners.

“The prime minister decided to weaponise the climate crisis by rowing back on net zero commitments, all to try and save his own skin,” said Georgia Whitaker, climate campaigner at Greenpeace. “It won’t work. People up and down this country are crying out for more climate action, not less.”

On a string of key environmental policies, Sunak has come up short. He promised to lift the ban on onshore wind, the cheapest form of power – but the ban has only been weakly reformed, so there are still no new windfarms being built in England. An auction to attract investment in offshore wind failed when it received no bids, though a subsequent effort fared better. Home insulation installations have stalled, after a botched scheme initiated during the Covid lockdowns.

Housebuilders, which are major donors to the Tory party, have saved tens of billions after the government scrapped rules that would have forced them to fit solar panels and heat pumps to new homes – while households will face bills of £20,000 each to upgrade their newly bought properties. Heat pump installations are lagging well behind targets, despite the need to move away from expensive gas.

Sunak cancelled the northern leg of the UK’s proposed high speed rail link, diverting much of the money to road schemes. Public transport remains under-funded, and the timetable for the switch to electric vehicles has been delayed.

Meanwhile, the government has vowed to “max out” the oil and gas reserves of the North Sea, a stance that has all but destroyed the UK’s international reputation as a climate leader. A new coal mine was given the go-ahead, sealing the impression of a nation that talks big on climate but delivers little.

Jamie Peters of Friends of the Earth said: “It’s time to end the war on our environment. We need the next government – from whatever party – to commit to the strong, green policies needed to tackle the climate and nature crises and ensure we all benefit from huge economic benefits that developing a zero-carbon economy will bring.”

Post-Brexit, the UK has also sought to unpick the environmental regulations shared with the EU. Guardian analysis found dozens of examples where the UK has watered down regulations, on areas from air pollution and water quality to pesticides and antibiotic use in farming.

Farmers were supposed to benefit from Brexit, but the transition has been botched, meaning wealthier farmers have benefited from the new payments scheme, while the poorer are struggling.

Perhaps the most visible and telling of all this government’s failures on environmental policy has been sewage. The UK’s rivers and beaches are now filthy with raw sewage, as water companies have creamed off more than £70bn in dividends while failing to invest in sewage plants or new reservoirs. This is combined with effluent from farms, now barely supervised after steep cuts to the Environment Agency. Rates of waterborne illness have risen, fish and other aquatic life are dying and people are advised to avoid beaches and rivers. The UK has become once again the dirty man of Europe, and on this government’s watch.

This record of failure stretches back further than the current prime minister, or even the current parliament. Since the Conservatives took power in 2010, there have been some green successes. But while David Cameron vowed to lead “the greenest government ever” in 2010, by 2015 he was banning onshore windfarms in England, shelving plans for home insulation and scrapping plans for all homes to be net zero.

Theresa May enshrined in law the target of net zero emissions by 2050, and set out a 25-year environment plan, but these were long on targets and aspiration and short on policy detail. Boris Johnson talked a good game at the Cop26 summit in Glasgow in 2021, and vowed to “build back greener” from the pandemic, but his main environmental policy – another home insulation plan – was “botched in execution”, according to MPs, and he also encouraged airport and road expansion, toyed with fracking and backed a new coal mine. Liz Truss – well, Truss has since called for climate laws to be dropped altogether.

“On both nature and climate, the UK’s international leadership has been squandered,” said Shaun Spiers, executive director of the Green Alliance thinktank. “Taking the 14 years as a whole, it’s hard to avoid the verdict: some very good work, but could do much better.”

Greenpeace’s Whitaker said that the July general election is the most pivotal for the climate in the UK’s history.

“We’ve had the wettest and warmest years on record, but right at the time the government should have been ramping up climate action, they made a series of devastating row backs that have put future generations at risk.

“We desperately need politicians who prioritise clean cheap energy, warm homes and healthy clean air and water. For too long politicians have served the interests of the elite, making fossil fuel giants and water companies ever richer at the expense of ordinary people, climate and nature. Greenpeace is calling on voters to demand the climate leadership that we deserve.”

OTHER NEWS

28 minutes ago

Former Everton star Frank D'Arcy dies aged 77, as Toffees pay tribute to their title-winning defender

31 minutes ago

Ron Washington won't let losses deter belief in Angels: 'Ain't no damn failure'

32 minutes ago

General election 2024 live: Tories could win just 72 seats in next Parliament, new Survation poll says

32 minutes ago

Slovenia v Denmark LIVE: Euro 2024 team news, line-ups and more today

32 minutes ago

Gino D'Acampo 'rakes in £6m in two years' after he 'failed to pay £5m to staff and taxman' when his My Pasta Bar chain went under

32 minutes ago

'Britain's FBI' investigating PPE scandal linked to 'Baroness Bra' Michelle Mone interview at least five suspects under caution - as case reaches China

32 minutes ago

The Entire Young Sheldon Timeline Explained

35 minutes ago

John Sterling’s kids reveal what it’s like to have the legendary Yankees announcer as a dad: ‘Unlike any other human’

36 minutes ago

Londis shop orders staff to pour famous cider down drain over 'stolen' name

36 minutes ago

Hamas response to Gaza ceasefire proposal 'consistent' with principles of US plan, leader says

36 minutes ago

Top model Josh: ‘Celebs love me because I’m a Kiwi’

37 minutes ago

Greene homers twice and has a career-best 6 RBIs as Tigers rout Astros 13-5

37 minutes ago

Boozy England fans drink in the Euro 2024 atmosphere ahead of first game vs Serbia

40 minutes ago

Playwright James Graham: ‘We’re still living in Thatcher’s country’

41 minutes ago

Kate Middleton - latest: Prince William shares sweet message day after Princess returns to public duties

41 minutes ago

Poland vs Netherlands LIVE: Euro 2024 team news and line-ups ahead of Group D clash as Robert Lewandowski out

41 minutes ago

China is getting too much rain in the south and not enough rain, plus a heat wave, in the north

43 minutes ago

As the Raspberry Pi share price soars, is it set to be a great UK growth success?

43 minutes ago

World leaders condemn Putin's 'dictatorial' Ukraine ceasefire proposal

43 minutes ago

Richie Sambora on Bon Jovi docuseries: 'That's one person's perspective'

43 minutes ago

With a forward P/E of 3.28x, could this FTSE 250 stock make me rich?

43 minutes ago

NASCAR radio station: Channel, live streams to listen to 2024 Iowa race broadcast

43 minutes ago

Matt Shirvington reveals what he REALLY thinks of 'fast-paced' Sunrise

43 minutes ago

LISTEN to It's All Kicking Off! Why it's criminal to leave Trent Alexander-Arnold out of the England team

43 minutes ago

Axed Match of the Day pundit Mark Lawrenson claims BBC bosses threatened to drop him from the World Cup final over a 'handbag' joke

43 minutes ago

Alisha Lehmann and Douglas Luiz 'set for historic double transfer to Juventus' this summer... as Italian club continues negotiations for the Aston Villa power couple

43 minutes ago

Married At First Sight's Jules Robinson throws wild baby shower complete with nappy-sniffing challenge and VERY racy games

43 minutes ago

Video: Lady Elliot Island boat capsize: Desperate search for missing man after boat overturned ends in tragedy off Queensland coast near Bundaberg after Life Flight winched a father and son to safety

43 minutes ago

Lady Elliot Island boat capsize: Desperate search for missing man after boat overturned ends in tragedy off Queensland coast near Bundaberg after Life Flight winched a father and son to safety

43 minutes ago

Man City are 'prepared to take Joao Cancelo on pre-season tour' after 17-month absence... as Premier League champions demand Barcelona meet £25m asking price

43 minutes ago

Video: FA 'warn England fans will have their Euro 2024 tickets confiscated if they misbehave in Germany'... as footage emerges of supporters singing '10 German bombers' in the streets ahead of clash with Serbia

43 minutes ago

Brave Kate releases Father's Day photo of William and the children - after Princess of Wales attended Trooping the Colour amid her cancer battle in boost to the nation

45 minutes ago

Why Hollow Knight: Silksong Referencing the Original Now Could Be a Boon

45 minutes ago

Texas continues to use controversial recruiting method despite outcry

45 minutes ago

Heatwave in Middle East makes power shortages hot topic during Eid Al Adha

45 minutes ago

Dragon Age: The Veilguard Dwarf Companion Has Magical Powers

46 minutes ago

Ex-presidential candidate Anies gets boost for Jakarta polls from Indonesia’s largest party

46 minutes ago

South-East Asia’s carbon storage dreams: Visionary climate solution or folly?

46 minutes ago

With future sorted, France’s Mbappe will be ‘unstoppable’ at Euro 2024, says Djibril Cisse

49 minutes ago

Does Donald Trump have a shot in appealing his hush money conviction?