DANIEL HANNAN: Human rights lawyers demanding the arrest of Israel's elected leader? This is nothing short of tyranny

Just who the hell do they think they are? By what right does a group of human rights lawyers demand the arrest of an elected prime minister?

In issuing warrants for Israel's leader, Benjamin Netanyahu, and his defence minister, Yoav Gallant, the International Criminal Court (ICC) has crossed a line.

Yes, the ICC also issued warrants for various Hamas leaders, but these men were already hunted terrorists. An ICC warrant will make little difference to them.

Israel, by contrast, is a sovereign democracy. A flawed one, to be sure, but nonetheless a functioning state with independent institutions and a robust judiciary. In presuming to leapfrog Israel's own legal system, the ICC is engaging in calculated lawfare.

We must distinguish general principles from particular cases. I am open to a wide range of views about Israel. You can take the view that it is a beleaguered democracy defending itself against genocidal maniacs, or you can take the view that it is an illegitimate occupier carrying out atrocities. My own view is that Israel is broadly a force for good, but that Netanyahu has become a menace to civilisation.

Wherever you come down, though, you are expressing a political rather than a legal opinion. And that does not somehow cease to be true simply because you have a law degree.

In issuing a warrant for Israel's leader, Benjamin Netanyahu, the ICC has crossed a line, writes Daniel Hannan

In issuing a warrant for Israel's leader, Benjamin Netanyahu, the ICC has crossed a line, writes Daniel Hannan

Outside the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands

Outside the International Criminal Court in The Hague, Netherlands

In formulating his position, the ICC's chief prosecutor, Karim Khan, appointed a panel of six experts. While they have impressive legal experience, they also have their prejudices and assumptions, just like the rest of us.

One of them, the American-Israeli judge Theodor Meron, has argued consistently that there should be no Israeli presence in the territories conquered during the 1967 war.

Another, Danny Friedman KC, published an open letter on November 18 arguing that 'Israel's response to the attack on its territory has involved catastrophic mass fatality and untold human suffering of Palestinians', and that 'these are also grave war crimes'.

Now you can agree or disagree. Fine. But let's not pretend that either man is coming disinterestedly to the subject. Both have form on the subject. Indeed, human rights lawyers as a group tend to be well to the Left of the general population. Nothing wrong with that, of course. But we'd be kidding ourselves if we believed them to be unemotional androids.

Consider a third panellist, the Labour peer Helena Kennedy, KC. Now I happen to admire Baroness Kennedy immensely. She is clever, witty and eloquent, and has an unfeigned zeal for raising up the poor and disadvantaged. You can't spend five minutes in her company without liking her. But she is just as much a party politician as I am.

The difference is that, while you will find plenty of human rights lawyers who share her Labour views, you will find almost none who support the Tories, like me. Hence the suspicion that human rights law, at both national and supranational level, is being used to advance an agenda that would be rejected at the ballot box.

It is stunning to see how far and how fast we have moved. Twenty-five years ago, the human rights industry did not exist, and neither did the ICC. A multi-million-pound sector has grown up in an astonishingly short time, driven partly by the intimidating moral fervour of its practitioners and partly by grubbier calculations involving mortgages and school fees.

International law used to have a narrow scope, covering the immunity of ambassadors and the rules of engagement on the high seas. When the first Geneva Convention was signed in 1864, establishing the Red Cross, it was a voluntary intergovernmental accord. The idea that it might have direct force within its signatory states would have been met by bewilderment.

Even the 1945 Nuremberg trials, often cited by advocates of international law as an example of how the international community must sometimes step in to deal with the breakdown of legal norms in a nation, were nothing of the kind.

The Allies were clear that they were exercising their power as the legal occupiers of Germany, and thus its acting government. They turned down a German request for judges from neutral countries for precisely this reason.

No, the sight of supranational tribunals sitting in judgment over elected governments is a new one. What was until a generation ago the stuff of conspiracy theories – shadowy cliques imposing their values on reluctant voters – is now happening. Except that there is nothing shadowy or conspiratorial about it. Those involved could hardly be more proud of themselves.

It is important to understand that when a country accepts a new human rights code or convention, it is not 'giving' people extra rights. It is simply empanelling a different set of officials to arbitrate those rights.

Those officials, whether national, European or international lawyers, would no doubt protest furiously that they are impartial, that they leave their personal opinions at the courtroom door. But notice how their rulings always seem to come from the same direction.

For example, we have come to expect courts to strike down both individual deportation orders and broader attempts to crack down on clandestine entry. But when did you ever hear of a judge stepping in to order an illegal immigrant to be removed?

Courts have regularly imposed maximum sentences for certain crimes but, to my knowledge, never a minimum sentence. If judges are as concerned about the rights of victims as they are about the rights of scoundrels, they keep very quiet about it.

It is hardly surprising, then, that Labour should be keener on these various codes than the Tories. The Shadow Foreign Secretary, in welcoming the ICC ruling, adopted a deliberately partisan tone, condemning the Conservatives for refusing to go along with it. We can expect much more of this if Sir Keir Starmer, a product and exemplar of the human rights industry, becomes PM.

Keir Starmer and Shadow Foreign Secretary David Lammy - who welcomed the ICC ruling - outside Berlin's Reichstag

Keir Starmer and Shadow Foreign Secretary David Lammy - who welcomed the ICC ruling - outside Berlin's Reichstag

Again, the lawyers involved will insist that they are simply interpreting conventions and commitments freely entered into by governments. And, in most cases, they will believe it. But it strikes me as incontestable that they are now making rulings that would have been unthinkable a generation ago.

The case against Boris Johnson's prorogation of Parliament, for example, would until very recently have been deemed inadmissible, on grounds that, as the 1689 Bill of Rights puts it with admirable clarity, 'proceedings in Parliament ought not to be impeached or questioned in any court'.

Likewise the idea that courts should rule on a bilateral treaty between two states, such as the deportation agreement between Rwanda and the UK.

Likewise, come to that, the extraordinary notion that the climate change policy of the Swiss government, partly determined by Swiss voters in referendums, might be struck down by European human rights lawyers.

To repeat, you can agree or disagree with any of these decisions. But they are all fundamentally political. If the judges involved wanted to change policy, they should have stepped down, contested an election and introduced appropriate legislation as a politician.

This latest move by the ICC shows that, 22 years after its establishment, it too now sees itself as a geopolitical player, ready to legislate from the bench. And that is the most alarming thing of all. If a court with a mission is a menace, an international court with a mission is a tyranny.

OTHER NEWS

27 minutes ago

Las Vegas Raiders insider suggests pair of mult-time Pro Bowlers could be summer free agent additions

27 minutes ago

After Maharashtra setback, how BJP is planning to regroup, bridge gap with MVA

27 minutes ago

Insiders predict Rust Belt Republican, possible Trump VP pick, could flip Biden votes in key swing states

27 minutes ago

For Ukrainians in Canada, new conscription rules increase pressure to fight

27 minutes ago

‘Wear a helmet’: Gordon Ramsay shows off full torso bruise after bike accident

27 minutes ago

Putin's nuclear submarine detected off UK coast

27 minutes ago

Trump challenges Biden to take cognitive test - only to get name of his own doctor wrong

27 minutes ago

T20 World Cup: England qualify for Super 8s after rain and Australia fumbles make for nervous group finale

27 minutes ago

How to reverse austerity? Scrap some of the tax-relief schemes worth £204bn

27 minutes ago

Italy's swift response secures victory after record breaking Albania start

27 minutes ago

NRL Highlights: Knights v Panthers - Round 15

27 minutes ago

Down 50%, this FTSE dividend stock looks like a steal to me

27 minutes ago

Australia's record population surge is being driven by Indian migration: Here's why so many of them are moving here - and what they really think about life Down Under

27 minutes ago

Video: Terrifying moment 7ft shark swims at speed towards Gran Canaria shore - with beach forced to close to bathing after sparking fear among tourists and locals

27 minutes ago

Video: Former MI6 agent rates the best and worst spy devices available on Amazon including a lie detector test and rearview sunglasses - and reveals why crisps are the 'best intruder detection system ever invented'

29 minutes ago

‘Dangerous conditions’: Damaging surf warnings in place for parts of the east coast

32 minutes ago

Tories and Labour clash on tax as General Election battles intensify

32 minutes ago

The Andy Griffith Show's Ron Howard Reveals Jokes Killed by Andy Griffith

32 minutes ago

Mbappé wants to erase bad memory of decisive penalty miss and leave Euro 2024 as a champion

32 minutes ago

Gig for Gaza event in Canberra raises funds for Australian doctors working in Palestine

32 minutes ago

Scientists sound alarm after making disturbing discovery in the Amazon: 'We have all this information; now let's act on it'

32 minutes ago

Luai stars as Panthers survive Knights scare

32 minutes ago

Serbia XI vs England: Predicted lineup, confirmed Euro 2024 team news and injuries today

32 minutes ago

Transit expert highlights issues with popular design trend in truck and SUV models: 'It honestly infuriates me'

32 minutes ago

Revealed: The ultimate dad jokes this Father's Day, according to AI - so, would they make you laugh?

32 minutes ago

UK's 'tallest rollercoaster' Hyperia at Thorpe Park 'breaks down' - with thrill-seekers stuck on ride at 236ft for an HOUR just days after reopening

32 minutes ago

Hundreds of Majorcans take over tiny picture postcard cove made famous by Instagram 'influencers' and unfurl banners reading 'SOS Residents' amid Spanish island's anti-tourism backlash against UK holidaymakers

32 minutes ago

Woman claims she was fined £200 for littering after seagulls ate a few McDonald's chips she accidentally dropped on the floor

32 minutes ago

Can I take legal action if I buy a house with invasive bamboo? And do I need to tell buyers if my home's infested? MailOnline answers your questions about 'Japanese knotweed 2.0'

32 minutes ago

Gordon Ramsay is flooded with well wishes from daughter Holly and celebrity pals after chef suffered a horrific cycling accident

35 minutes ago

Harry Kane says England start Euro 2024 with ‘the most in-form squad we’ve had’

35 minutes ago

How the Euros could change the result of the election

37 minutes ago

Sheffield DocFest Confronts Challenges Facing Nonfiction Film Industry, In Midst Of Turbulent Political, Economic Environment

37 minutes ago

When you can hear every word, thank the sound mixers

37 minutes ago

U.S. Open Complaints Grow After Paywall Frustrations: 'Atrocious' Sound & Graphics Issues Anger Golf World

37 minutes ago

Zain Davids, Shilton van Wyk bolster Blitzboks in last-ditch bid for Paris Olympics

38 minutes ago

Star Wars Outlaws: Ubisoft reveals details and gameplay of anticipated game

38 minutes ago

New poll suggests less than half of Americans plan to buy an EV for their next vehicle — here’s why

38 minutes ago

ATP Halle draw: Jannik Sinner finds out first opponent as world No 1 as he lands tricky draw

38 minutes ago

Corey Heim notches best Xfinity Series finish at Iowa Speedway