NBA legend John Stockton has COVID-related 'free speech' lawsuit thrown out by judge

nba legend john stockton has covid-related 'free speech' lawsuit thrown out by judge

John Stockton is honored for being selected to the NBA 75th Anniversary Team during halftime in the 2022 NBA All-Star Game at Rocket Mortgage FieldHouse.

A federal judge has dismissed a lawsuit filed by NBA legend John Stockton that had accused government officials in Washington state of violating the “free speech” rights of doctors after they spoke out against the "mainstream COVID narrative."

Stockton and other plaintiffs filed the lawsuit in March, with presidential candidate Robert F. Kennedy Jr. listed as one of their attorneys. The complaint named the state attorney general, Bob Ferguson, as a defendant along with the executive director of the Washington Medical Commission (WMC), which regulates and licenses doctors in the state.

The lawsuit’s goal was to “stop the Commission from investigating, prosecuting or sanctioning physicians who speak out in public against the so-called `mainstream Covid narrative,'” according to the complaint.

From NFL plays to college sports scores, all the top sports news you need to know every day.

But U.S. District Judge Thomas O. Rice found several flaws with their complaint and also denied the plaintiffs’ request for a preliminary injunction against the state. He issued his ruling Wednesday and noted that in the case of certain plaintiffs, such as Stockton, the state “has not prevented them from hearing what they want to hear.”

“As such, Plaintiffs’ First Amendment claims must be dismissed,” said the judge's ruling, obtained by USA TODAY Sports.

Why did the judge throw out the lawsuit?

Among other reasons, Rice ruled the lawsuit was not “ripe” for the court to review since the WMC hasn’t punished any of the plaintiff doctors for anything they said. Those disciplinary proceedings are pending against two of the plaintiffs, doctors Richard Eggleston and Thomas Siler, who have been accused by the WMC of professional misconduct for misinformation they spread about COVID and vaccines, according to the state.

In the case of other plaintiffs such as Stockton, they haven’t even been subject to prosecution by the WMC. Stockton isn’t a doctor subject to regulation from the WMC, which seeks to protect public health.

Those plaintiffs’ claims are “based on speculation and conjecture,” the judge ruled in the Eastern District of Washington. “The remaining Plaintiffs claim they are injured by the alleged chill of licensed physicians presenting an alternative narrative about COVID. But Plaintiffs have not shown that they are impeded from otherwise accessing this information.”

Why was John Stockton involved in this lawsuit?

Stockton’s complaint said he was suing on his own behalf and that he was advocating “for all Washingtonians who share his belief that people have the First Amendment right to hear the public soapbox speech of Washington licensed physicians who disagree with the mainstream Covid narrative.”

He played college basketball at Gonzaga in Spokane and had his season tickets revoked there after he refused to wear a mask at games during the pandemic. In a court filing, he also said listened to the advice of a chiropractor who told him to consider “not vaccinating my children” even though chiropractors are not epidemiologists trained in investigating patterns and causes of illnesses such as COVID-19.

Stockton, 62, said these are deeply held beliefs of his. He has endorsed Kennedy in his bid for president – a candidate who has become known for his misleading, unfounded or debunked claims about vaccines and the pandemic. Stockton also has supported former Washington State football coach Nick Rolovich in his legal battle against the university after he was fired in 2021 for not complying with the state vaccination mandate against COVID-19.

Who had joined Stockton’s lawsuit?

Two of the co-plaintiffs were doctors Eggleston and Siler, who spread misinformation about COVID-19 in public venues, triggering complaints, according to the state. In newspaper articles, for example, the state said Eggleston minimized deaths from the SARS-CoV-2 virus, falsely stated that COVID-19 vaccines are harmful or ineffective and that ivermectin is a safe and effective treatment instead.

As a result, the state then sought to discipline them and other doctors for professional misconduct. It described their lawsuit as “frivolous” and “not ripe” for the court because they and other doctors who were charged by the WMC had not yet been punished. Judge Rice agreed with this.

“WMC does not investigate and discipline providers merely based on statements against the mainstream COVID-19 narrative, but based on the licensees’ use of their medical credentials to lend heft to verifiably false and dangerous misrepresentations,” the state said in a previous court filing.

Attorneys for the state also noted that the same court dismissed Eggleston’s previous effort to block an ongoing investigation into his conduct by the WMC.

“Now, nine months later, Dr. Eggleston is back, this time joined by two other doctors, a non-profit, and, bizarrely, former Utah Jazz point guard John Stockton, seeking the same relief this Court already denied,” the state said in court filing in April.

Stockton also was joined in his suit by the Children’s Health Defense, a nonprofit founded by Kennedy.

“The Commission’s investigations regulate professional conduct, with only an incidental impact on speech,” Rice ruled Wednesday. “Although Plaintiffs’ challenges to the investigations arise out of the COVID-19 pandemic, it is within the State’s long-recognized authority to regulate medical professionals, and that authority does not run afoul of the First Amendment.”

What about attorneys' fees?

The state had requested to pay for its attorneys' fees because it considered the lawsuit to be frivolous. The judge disagreed.

"The Court finds this lawsuit is unwarranted given the stage of the administrative proceedings, but does not find it frivolous, unreasonable, or without foundation," Rice wrote. "Accordingly, attorneys’ fees are denied."

Follow reporter Brent Schrotenboer @Schrotenboer. Email: [email protected]

OTHER NEWS

17 minutes ago

Trump challenges Biden to take cognitive test - only to get name of his own doctor wrong

17 minutes ago

T20 World Cup: England qualify for Super 8s after rain and Australia fumbles make for nervous group finale

17 minutes ago

How to reverse austerity? Scrap some of the tax-relief schemes worth £204bn

17 minutes ago

Italy's swift response secures victory after record breaking Albania start

17 minutes ago

NRL Highlights: Knights v Panthers - Round 15

18 minutes ago

Down 50%, this FTSE dividend stock looks like a steal to me

18 minutes ago

Australia's record population surge is being driven by Indian migration: Here's why so many of them are moving here - and what they really think about life Down Under

18 minutes ago

Video: Terrifying moment 7ft shark swims at speed towards Gran Canaria shore - with beach forced to close to bathing after sparking fear among tourists and locals

18 minutes ago

Video: Former MI6 agent rates the best and worst spy devices available on Amazon including a lie detector test and rearview sunglasses - and reveals why crisps are the 'best intruder detection system ever invented'

20 minutes ago

‘Dangerous conditions’: Damaging surf warnings in place for parts of the east coast

23 minutes ago

Tories and Labour clash on tax as General Election battles intensify

23 minutes ago

The Andy Griffith Show's Ron Howard Reveals Jokes Killed by Andy Griffith

23 minutes ago

Mbappé wants to erase bad memory of decisive penalty miss and leave Euro 2024 as a champion

23 minutes ago

Gig for Gaza event in Canberra raises funds for Australian doctors working in Palestine

23 minutes ago

Scientists sound alarm after making disturbing discovery in the Amazon: 'We have all this information; now let's act on it'

23 minutes ago

Luai stars as Panthers survive Knights scare

23 minutes ago

Serbia XI vs England: Predicted lineup, confirmed Euro 2024 team news and injuries today

23 minutes ago

Transit expert highlights issues with popular design trend in truck and SUV models: 'It honestly infuriates me'

23 minutes ago

Revealed: The ultimate dad jokes this Father's Day, according to AI - so, would they make you laugh?

23 minutes ago

UK's 'tallest rollercoaster' Hyperia at Thorpe Park 'breaks down' - with thrill-seekers stuck on ride at 236ft for an HOUR just days after reopening

23 minutes ago

Hundreds of Majorcans take over tiny picture postcard cove made famous by Instagram 'influencers' and unfurl banners reading 'SOS Residents' amid Spanish island's anti-tourism backlash against UK holidaymakers

23 minutes ago

Woman claims she was fined £200 for littering after seagulls ate a few McDonald's chips she accidentally dropped on the floor

23 minutes ago

Can I take legal action if I buy a house with invasive bamboo? And do I need to tell buyers if my home's infested? MailOnline answers your questions about 'Japanese knotweed 2.0'

23 minutes ago

Gordon Ramsay is flooded with well wishes from daughter Holly and celebrity pals after chef suffered a horrific cycling accident

26 minutes ago

Harry Kane says England start Euro 2024 with ‘the most in-form squad we’ve had’

26 minutes ago

How the Euros could change the result of the election

27 minutes ago

Sheffield DocFest Confronts Challenges Facing Nonfiction Film Industry, In Midst Of Turbulent Political, Economic Environment

28 minutes ago

When you can hear every word, thank the sound mixers

28 minutes ago

U.S. Open Complaints Grow After Paywall Frustrations: 'Atrocious' Sound & Graphics Issues Anger Golf World

28 minutes ago

Zain Davids, Shilton van Wyk bolster Blitzboks in last-ditch bid for Paris Olympics

29 minutes ago

Star Wars Outlaws: Ubisoft reveals details and gameplay of anticipated game

29 minutes ago

New poll suggests less than half of Americans plan to buy an EV for their next vehicle — here’s why

29 minutes ago

ATP Halle draw: Jannik Sinner finds out first opponent as world No 1 as he lands tricky draw

29 minutes ago

Corey Heim notches best Xfinity Series finish at Iowa Speedway

29 minutes ago

Biden, Trump step up outreach to Black men

29 minutes ago

Four nights in the Maldives taught me something I wish I'd known 10 years ago

29 minutes ago

My Spy The Eternal City official trailer

29 minutes ago

Jo Cox's sister warns that politicians are still forced to fear for their lives eight years after Labour MP's murder by far-Right thug

29 minutes ago

Lady Louise Windsor, 20, borrowed her mother the Duchess of Edinburgh's floral fascinator for Trooping the Colour

29 minutes ago

Kevin Campbell tells incredible story of a 14-year-old Wayne Rooney during Southport friendly in resurfaced footage of late striker, after the former England captain paid tribute to his ex-Everton team-mate following his death aged 54