Plastic pollution is the new front in the culture war

Last week, Lianne Rood decided to take a stand.

Appearing in a video recorded outside a Tim Horton's restaurant in downtown Ottawa, the duly elected Conservative MP for the Ontario riding of Lambton—Kent—Middlesex announced that she would not be partaking of the iconic chain's coffee unless it discontinued its use of paper lids.

"I'm done with Tim Hortons until they stop trying to push these woke paper lids that dissolve in your mouth," she wrote in a social media post.

The non-plastic lids were part of a product test by the company in Ottawa and Prince Edward Island.

Rood's use of "woke" is further evidence that the word (whatever its original meaning) has been reduced to a catch-all term for things Conservatives don't like. But it also speaks to her party's apparent desire to turn the issue of plastic pollution into a culture war battle.

plastic pollution is the new front in the culture war

Conservative member of Parliament Lianne Rood rises during question period in the House of Commons on Parliament Hill in Ottawa on March 23, 2021. (THE CANADIAN PRESS/Sean Kilpatrick)

"This is not about science," Conservative MP Corey Tochor told the House of Commons last month. "It is about government controlling our lives."

Tochor was speaking about Bill C-380, his own initiative to reverse the Liberal government's move to list manufactured plastic items as a toxic substance under the Canadian Environmental Protection Act.

That listing was part of a broader effort by the federal government to ban a number of single-use plastics, actions taken in response to growing concern about global plastic pollution. The listing was challenged by major plastics producers and a Federal Court judge ruled last fall that it was overly broad. The federal government is appealing that decision.

Torchor's primary concern is the paper straw, which he described as "soggy, limp, wet and utterly useless."

Five days after Tochor's bill was debated in the House, Conservative MP Branden Leslie posted an eight-minute video that promoted Tochor's bill. Leslie's complaints extend to reusable bags — which he says he's always forgetting to take with him when he goes shopping — and non-plastic cutlery.

"Turns out those crappy paper straws they literally jammed down your throat are linked to cancer and a bunch of other diseases," Leslie wrote (it should be noted that the government is not "literally" doing that).

"Liberal virtue signaling is literally making people sick."

In pointing to health concerns, the Conservatives are seizing on a study released last fall that found the presence of poly- and perfluoroalkyl substances — otherwise known as PFAS or "forever chemicals" — in paper straws. Researchers also found PFAS in some of the plastic straws they tested.

But the Conservatives are not merely raising questions about existing alternatives to plastic straws.

"Let us get back to the plastic straw. It is functional. It works. It is better for the environment," Tochor told the House.

He is promoting a petition to "save" the plastic straw.

The hard math of plastic waste

The recent wave of public concern about plastic pollution was driven, in part, by concern about the amount of plastic in the world's oceans — and a widely publicized image of a sea turtle with a plastic straw in its nose.

Tochor and Leslie acknowledge that concern for the world's oceans but argue that Canada is just a small part of the problem. Leslie also points to a federal scientific assessment, published in 2020, that says one per cent of plastic waste in Canada — seemingly a small amount — found its way into the environment.

But one per cent of Canada's plastic waste amounted to 29,000 tonnes of plastic pollution in 2016, the report notes. According to Statistics Canada, the total was 43,140 tonnes in 2019.

"Since plastic degrades very slowly and is persistent in the environment, the amount of plastic pollution is anticipated to continue to increase over time," the 2020 federal assessment states. "There are growing concerns that plastic pollution may adversely impact the health of the environment and humans."

plastic pollution is the new front in the culture war

A man walks on a railway track littered with plastic and other waste materials on Earth Day in Mumbai, India on April 22, 2024. (Rafiq Maqbool/Associated Press)

The report says that "the most common litter items collected on Canadian shorelines include cigarette butts, bottle caps, plastic bags, plastic bottles and straws" and that "a greater abundance of plastic pollution has been found in areas with high human and industrial activity, notably in the Great Lakes."

Speaking to his bill last month, Tochor pointed to recycling as a solution. But the 2020 federal assessment reported that just nine per cent of plastic waste in Canada is recycled annually.

"We do need to improve recycling, but it's not the solution. It's not the one solution. We also need to turn off the tap of production," said Tony Walker, a professor in the school for resource and environmental studies at Dalhousie University.

The hotly contested plastic straw, Walker said, is both "low hanging fruit" (an easy object to focus on) and the "tip of the iceberg" (a small part of a much bigger problem).

The politics of the paper straw

"The issue is that we've so overproduced plastics that ultimately turn into microplastics and nanoplastics. And they pollute the environment and they pollute humans," said Miriam Diamond, a professor in the department of earth sciences at the University of Toronto.

Diamond — who is a member of the Scientists Coalition for an Effective Plastics Treaty and vice-chair of the International Panel on Chemical Pollution — said she worries that a focus on plastic straws risks trivializing the larger issue.

With the exception of those with physical limitations, most people don't actually need to drink through a straw (or a coffee lid). People still managed to consume liquids before plastic straws came into widespread use in the latter half of the 20th century. But in the rush to find non-plastic alternatives, governments do have to be mindful of unforeseen consequences and there's a valid debate to be had about the best and smartest way to reduce plastic waste.

At the same time, Justin Trudeau's government is hardly alone in targeting single-use plastics.

plastic pollution is the new front in the culture war

A 2020 federal assessment said that just nine per cent of plastic waste in Canada is recycled annually. (Credit: iStock/Getty Images)

The Conservative government in the United Kingdom — a government that likely would resent being called "woke" — has implemented its own bans and restrictions on a number of items, including straws. In 2015, shortly before it lost power, Stephen Harper's Conservative government began the process that ultimately led to a ban on microbeads.

If there were any Conservatives worried at the time about the freedom of Canadians to exfoliate, they stifled their objections. But the current enthusiasm for plastic straws recalls Conservative MP Cheryl Gallant's lonely fight against the Harper government's move to phase out incandescent light bulbs.

Paper straws have already been a culture war flashpoint in the United States. In 2019, Donald Trump's presidential campaign sold Trump-branded plastic straws as an alternative to "liberal" paper straws (and reportedly raised half a million dollars for Trump's re-election effort in the process).

In 2007, when the Harper government first announced its intention to regulate the use of more efficient light bulbs, one cabinet minister remarked that "this is more than just about light bulbs. The light bulb is only the gateway to broad public engagement on energy efficiency and action on climate change."

The same could be said of plastic straws (or bags or lids) and plastic pollution. But if plastic pollution is a problem worth worrying about, it will become much harder to confront if one's choice of straw becomes a symbol of political or cultural identity.

OTHER NEWS

9 minutes ago

Woman left cleaning dishes in bath after builders disappear during £20K renovation

9 minutes ago

The Bear’s Jeremy Allen White wants to do his own singing in Bruce Springsteen biopic

9 minutes ago

Aaron Judge Issues Serious Yankees Demand After Embarrassing Loss To Mets

9 minutes ago

John Curtis Defeats MAGA Opponent in Utah GOP Senate Primary to Replace Romney

9 minutes ago

Climate scientist responds to commenter on the misconception that burning wood pollutes more than burning fossil fuels: 'It's very clear'

9 minutes ago

Hiker shares disappointment after stumbling upon scene left by tourists on popular trail: 'I've seen it far too many times'

15 minutes ago

Ukraine updates: Zelenskyy visits Donetsk frontline

15 minutes ago

UAE Leads in AI Enthusiasm and Application Insights from a Global BCG Survey

15 minutes ago

KIB concludes two-day Al Dirwaza promotional event at Al Khiran Mall

15 minutes ago

Martin Lewis alert on 'little-known' savings rate tax that goes above £1,000 cap

15 minutes ago

Soccer-Argentina's Scaloni says balance is key in deciding who starts up front

15 minutes ago

Japan chipmaker Kioxia to file preliminary IPO application, sources say

15 minutes ago

10 tips and tricks to save money on your summer holiday

15 minutes ago

Soccer-Mbappe starts for France as Griezmann drops to bench against Poland

15 minutes ago

What salary makes someone 'rich'? Britons reveal their magic number...

15 minutes ago

Google confirms the date for its next unveiling event where it could reveal a new AI-powered smartphone - and it's much earlier than we expected

15 minutes ago

Video: UK braces for 31C scorcher TODAY as thousands of revellers descend on Glastonbury (but NHS warns heatwave will cause even more delays)

15 minutes ago

Video: How WikiLeaks founder Julian Assange sneaked out of Britain to freedom aboard a £20 million private jet after 14 years tumultuous years, write SAM GREENHILL and GEORGE ODLING

15 minutes ago

Video: Jay Slater probe is thrown into further confusion as Tenerife Mayor says Spanish police are examining CCTV footage - and suggests 'several witnesses' claim to have 'seen the teen watching Euros'

15 minutes ago

Video: Dramatic moment hero off-duty cop tackles prolific knife-wielding thief who stole dishwasher tablets and marshmallows from Poundland

17 minutes ago

Perrie Edwards hints at new solo song about former Little Mix bandmate Jesy Nelson

17 minutes ago

Ayra Starr talks 'crazy' Glastonbury debut and studio time with Chris Martin

19 minutes ago

'A real anomaly': How pommel horse specialty could carry Stephen Nedoroscik to Paris

19 minutes ago

Revealed: 'Every manager's salary at Euro 2024, as Gareth Southgate earns the most of ANY boss with jaw-dropping pay packet'... but which football legend takes home almost 30 times less?

19 minutes ago

Luxury retail firm founded by the mother of Foreign Secretary Lord Cameron's wife Samantha Cameron suddenly shuts its US stores after filing for bankruptcy

19 minutes ago

Martin Lewis reveals two simple ways to check whether you're overpaying council tax

19 minutes ago

Chelsea make an enquiry for Newcastle striker Alexander Isak - but would face having to break the club-record £115m fee they paid for Moises Caicedo

19 minutes ago

Congress poured billions of dollars into schools. Did it help students learn?

19 minutes ago

Highland Park parade shooting suspect expected to change plea at hearing Wednesday

19 minutes ago

84-year-old woman, 9-month-old baby found dead in mobile home fire, Liberty County Fire Marshal says

24 minutes ago

Rishi Sunak wades into Tory trans row with David Tennant

24 minutes ago

MK Party takes its fight with the IEC to the streets in protest

24 minutes ago

Victorian nurses in line for huge wage rise

24 minutes ago

Days of UAE Culture will be held in the Russian Capital

24 minutes ago

NCIS legend Mark Harmon to return to iconic role next year - and it's not Gibbs

24 minutes ago

Centre denies not consulting WB govt on water talks with Bangladesh

24 minutes ago

Celtics' Kristaps Porzingis to miss Olympics because of leg surgery

24 minutes ago

‘It’s ridiculous’: Tony Abbott calls out Albanese government’s nuclear stance

25 minutes ago

Bands and musicians sue British copyright company over live performing rights

25 minutes ago

Swim star Cate Campbell retires without any regrets