Space Force should prepare for the threat we have — not the one we prefer

space force should prepare for the threat we have — not the one we prefer

Space Force should prepare for the threat we have — not the one we prefer

As the one-year anniversary of Russia’s invasion of Ukraine came and went, many commentators discussed and debated lessons learned and observations regarding the conflict — especially as it pertains to a potential conflict with China over Taiwan’s independence. Unfortunately, with respect to space-power capabilities and employment, too many commentators have been making assumptions based on the character and practice of the Russians in their war in Ukraine and applying them as the “way of the future” for space deterrence and warfighting techniques.

For example, one such assumption is, given that Russian space forces have relied primarily on reversible or “soft kill” counter-space systems, and not on “hard kill” weapons systems like anti-satellite (ASAT) missiles, the future of space warfighting will be based on such “soft kill” options. This is a dangerous assumption to make. It is especially unwise to base the national security space strategies and posture of the United States on such a view.

Western military commentators and pundits around the world have been making the case that, because the Russians haven’t employed “hard kill” space weapons, and instead have used reversible counter-space systems such as jammers and cyber attacks, any future war with China likely will follow that equation. In addition, based on the success of Starlink’s proliferated low earth orbit (p-LEO) construct’s ability to defeat or deny Russian cyber and jamming effects, it is assumed that the resiliency of such an architecture has been proven. Indeed, the Space Development Agency of the U.S. Space Force is pursuing such systems in many of its next generation communications and missile-tracking system designs.

But are these really the lessons learned by China and are the “soft kill” and reversible counter-space warfighting options the “wave of the future” for space integration in conflict? The short answer is no.

While the U.S. and its allies have been pursuing a strategy of norms, resilience and arms-control measures to ensure the security, safety and sustainability of the space domain, China and Russia have not. They have opposed the U.S.-led proposal to ban destructive ASAT testing. China in particular is taking a much more aggressive route, likely in preparation for eventual conflict with the U.S. and its allies.

China has been developing and deploying a “multi-layered attack architecture” consisting of “kinetic kill missiles, ground-based lasers, and orbiting space robots,” coupled with “an expanded array of surveillance and tracing capabilities” necessary for targeting. Many of these capabilities, such as orbital ASATs, reportedly have engaged in “damaging on-orbit behavior” and, in the case of ASAT missiles, generated thousands of pieces of debris. All of these weapons systems, while providing both “hard kill” and “soft kill” options, lean more toward the “hard kill” in Chinese military writings than the softer, reversible side of counter-space options.

China believes that deterrence does not come from a combined effect of norms, arms control and resilience; it seeks to counter and unravel all of the above. In conflict, China aims to create options for escalation dominance by either destroying enemy satellites in orbit and/or creating “[adverse] influence … [upon] adversary space systems, as well as … [creating] certain psychological pressure on and fear in the adversary … [thereby] forcing the adversary to dare not conduct … [the] initiative” in conflict. These capabilities range from ground to space, space to space, and, as seen in August 2021, space to ground weapons such as fractional orbital bombardment systems (FOBS).

For example, while the p-LEO concepts do provide some measure of resilience for individual satellites, China sees such systems not as a collection of individual satellites but as a single system target that poses a threat to their national security. As a result, China’s deterrence and warfighting concepts are designed to not just hit individual satellites, since that will not create the desired effect of “disposing” of such constellations in a sufficiently timely manner, but instead to take down the entire p-LEO system at once, through a combination of reversible and “hard kill” capabilities, which can escalate — up to and including nuclear detonations.

Although this may sound far-fetched, China has undertaken studies and simulations that suggest a 10-megaton warhead “could create a serious threat to satellites if it detonates at an altitude of 50 miles.” This concept would create strong radiation that the mega constellations would fly through, leading to destruction of such p-LEO architectures.

Knowing the intentions behind the development and deployment of China’s space forces, senior leaders in Congress and the Pentagon should understand that the future for which we should be preparing is one where p-LEO resiliency would unravel in the face of superior Chinese space-power overmatch. Debris generation might be a concern for the West, but it might not necessarily be a concern of long-term strategists such as the Chinese.

We should be preparing for a future where we not only can take a hit but can hit back — in a way that deters and prevents attacks in the first place. The current space deterrence and warfighting posture of the U.S. Space Force and U.S. Space Command is not ready for this reality. We must fix this posture.

Christopher Stone is senior fellow for Space Deterrence Studies at the National Institute for Deterrence Studies. A former special assistant to the Deputy Assistant Secretary of Defense for Space Policy, he is a senior adviser and consultant with Core-CSI in Washington. The opinions expressed here are his alone and do not reflect the position of the Department of Defense.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

News Related


I Stayed at One of the Best New Hotels in NYC — and It Made Me Feel Like a Local

Nine Orchard, a 2023 T+L It List winner, has breathtaking Manhattan views from every room. Mariah Tyler/Travel+Leisure My life as a New York City resident unexpectedly came to a screeching ... Read more »

Sail Canada says coach fired because lack of money, not pregnancy

Sail Canada says coach fired because lack of money, not pregnancy Lisa Ross wants her job back. The two-time Olympic sailor for Canada was named to the national sailing team’s ... Read more »

Apple's Big Push for AI—Here's Why It Could Change the Way You Use Tech

Mac and iOS features could get a boost from AI champpixs / Getty Images Fact checked by Jerri Ledford Apple is reportedly planning a big push into artificial intelligence.  AI ... Read more »

WSL 2022-23 review: club-by-club analysis and our writers’ highlights

Arsenal ACL injuries to Beth Mead, Vivianne Miedema, Leah Williamson and Laura Wienroither. Season-ending injuries to Kim Little and Lia Wälti. Long-term injuries to Caitlin Foord and Steph Catley. Arsenal’s ... Read more »

NATO soldiers deploy in Kosovo clashes with Serb protesters

U.S. forces guard municipal offices in Leposavic By Fatos Bytyci LEPOSAVIC, Kosovo (Reuters) – NATO peacekeeping soldiers formed security cordons around three town halls in Kosovo on Monday as police ... Read more »

Tuberculosis outbreak declared in Naujaat

There is an outbreak of tuberculosis in Naujaat. The Department of Health released a public health advisory about the outbreak Tuesday. There are currently six active TB cases and 10 ... Read more »

Ryan Reynolds remembers terminally ill fan who got his dying wish

Last month, a man terminally ill with cancer made a dying wish: To see his favorite soccer team, Wrexham AFC, and meet the owner, Ryan Reynolds. The fan, Jay Fear, ... Read more »

Johnny Depp Fractures His Ankle and Cancels Performances: 'What a Drag!'

Johnny Depp says a hairline break in his ankle has developed into a more serious fracture, causing him to reschedule performances with the Hollywood Vampires Doug Peters/PA Images via Getty ... Read more »

Oilpatch restarts production that was shut in due to Alberta wildfires

Oilpatch restarts production that was shut in due to Alberta wildfires CALGARY — Crescent Point Energy Corp. said Monday it has resumed production at its operations that were shut in ... Read more »

What to do if you find an orphaned animal

It’s the season for all the critters in your neighbourhood to have their offspring, and you may end up having an encounter with a baby raccoon or baby squirrel. If ... Read more »

Joe Manchin Surprise Win in Debt Deal Has a Unique Twist

U.S. Sen. Joe Manchin (D-WV), Chairman of the Senate Energy and Natural Resources Committee, questions Interior Secretary Deb Haaland during a hearing on May 02, 2023 in Washington, DC. Manchin ... Read more »

Rex Murphy: Jagmeet Singh just can't stop protecting Trudeau

Federal NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh holds a press conference at the University of Saskatchewan on April 13, 2023. (Saskatoon StarPhoenix / Michelle Berg) The nexus of Justin Trudeau and Jagmeet ... Read more »

Martin Pospisil and the season that could have been

Martin Pospisil and the season that could have been Martin Pospisil was one of the longest absent players from the Calgary Wranglers lineup in the 2022-23 season. He was meant ... Read more »

Celtics vs. Heat Game 7 odds, picks, predictions, & props

Celtics vs. Heat Game 7 odds, picks, predictions, & props The second-seeded Celtics are one win away from becoming the first team in NBA history to win a best-of-seven playoff ... Read more »

This 1-Ingredient Chocolate Mousse Is a Miracle of Science

Ask any pastry chef or chocolatier and they will tell you that chocolate’s worst enemy is water. Even a tiny drop accidentally landing in a bowl of tempering chocolate can clump ... Read more »

Blue Jays' Chris Bassitt says Yankees were relaying tips to Aaron Judge: 'We knew it was going on'

The controversy surrounding Aaron Judge’s wandering eyes finally appears to have reached a definitive conclusion, despite the slugger’s insistence otherwise. During an interview with Jomboy Media podcaster Chris Rose, Blue ... Read more »

Federal government seeks Indigenous views on diabetes

The federal government is establishing a national framework for diabetes and is asking Indigenous communities throughout Canada to contribute through a survey and public consultations. “Inuit who participate in the ... Read more »

Familiar dark horse emerging in DeAndre Hopkins race

Familiar dark horse emerging in DeAndre Hopkins race Keep an eye on DeAndre Hopkins possibly reuniting with Deshaun Watson on the Cleveland Browns. It wouldn’t be the strangest thing in ... Read more » CEO says US default would hit crypto initially

Illustration shows representations of cryptocurrencies By Andrew Mills DOHA (Reuters) – A U.S. government default would trigger an initial pull-back from crypto currencies followed by a “push upward” the CEO ... Read more »

The ‘Angel of Alkmaar’, landing haymakers for club, king and country

Photograph: DeFodi Images/Getty Images BUBBLES. LOTS OF BUBBLES In the wake of West Ham’s Tin Pot semi-final win over AZ last week, one man was honoured as a hero, the ... Read more »

Your pets produce just as much pollution as private jets, says luxury aviation company boss

A private jet interior. Marin Tomas/Getty Images Luxaviation’s CEO told a FT summit that one of his firm’s clients produced as much CO2 as three dogs per year. He was ... Read more »

YOU SAID IT: Our buffoon

Italian Prime Minister Giorgia Meloni, French President Emmanuel Macron and Prime Minister Justin Trudeau take part in a working lunch session at the G7 Leaders’ Summit in Hiroshima, Japan, on ... Read more »

Dems Insisted They Wouldn’t Negotiate. Then Biden Started Negotiating.

Photo Illustration by Thomas Levinson/The Daily Beast/Getty/Reuters With just days to go until a catastrophic default on U.S. debt, Republicans are openly bragging that in exchange for accepting massive spending ... Read more »

Australia's Treasury Wine warns of demand hit from inflation

Bottles of Penfolds Grange on sale at a wine shop in Sydney By Navya Mittal and Echha Jain (Reuters) -Australia’s Treasury Wine Estates warned on Thursday that inflation was squeezing ... Read more »

A quarter of Canadians plan to buy investment property in next five years: Royal LePage survey

Royal LePage said a new study uncovered a strong desire among Canadians to purchase a home for investment purposes. Approximately 11 per cent of Canadians currently invest in residential real ... Read more »

Vietnam's VinFast recalls first batch of US-bound EVs over security risk

2022 Paris Auto Show HANOI (Reuters) -Vietnamese electric vehicle (EV) maker VinFast is recalling all of the first batch of vehicles it shipped to the United States following a security ... Read more »

Nicole Kidman Uses This Brightening Concealer for Flawless, Radiant Skin at 55

Nicole Kidman showed off her glowing, radiant skin on the 2023 Met Gala red carpet. The star’s makeup artist revealed that she used Chanel’s Le Correcteur de Chanel Longwear Concealer ... Read more »

As governments shirk their responsibilities, non-profits are more important than ever

In a neoliberal era, where profitability is prioritized over social duty, all orders of government in Canada are increasingly shirking responsibility for providing social services onto non-profits. You’ve likely walked ... Read more »

Biden set to nominate Air Force Gen. C.Q. Brown as the next chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff

President Joe Biden is set to announce on Thursday that he will nominate Air Force chief of staff Gen. Charles Q. Brown as the next chairman of the Joint Chiefs ... Read more »

British EV maker Arrival seeks second chance with US EV tax credits

Jules Carter, vice president of the L-Van program at electric van maker Arrival, walks next to a working prototype vehicle at the company’s factory in Bicester By Paul Lienert and ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự