Opinion: Prosecutors in Trump trial have strayed from their mandate to ensure justice is done

opinion: prosecutors in trump trial have strayed from their mandate to ensure justice is done

Opinion: Prosecutors in Trump trial have strayed from their mandate to ensure justice is done

The New York state district attorney’s Ethical Guidelines for Prosecutors states that the prosecutor “Is the representative not of an ordinary party to a controversy but of a sovereignty…whose interest, therefore, in a criminal prosecution is not that it shall win the case, but that justice shall be done.”

This quote, which comes from the Supreme Court’s opinion in Berger v. U.S., is even more applicable now that the Manhattan District Attorney’s Office’s case against former President Donald Trump has concluded.

In this case, prosecutors have strayed from their own ethical mandate to ensure justice is done, instead assuming the role of an ordinary party fixated on winning a case despite clearly having inadequate evidence.

There is an embedded principle in American jurisprudence that the uncorroborated testimony of one individual should be insufficient to convict another and take away his or her liberty. Article III, Section 3 of the Constitution states that, “No Person shall be convicted of Treason unless the Testimony of two Witnesses to the same overt Act.” Similarly, federal perjury statute 1621, derived from common law, requires two witnesses to sustain a perjury conviction.

These principles exist precisely because it is often impossible to discern the credibility of a single witness and therefore manifestly unfair to convict any defendant based on that testimony alone.

Although the two witness rule is not a requirement of the New York statutes, it is telling that no witness corroborated the statements that Michael Cohen attributed to Trump in his testimony. In fact, Cohen’s surreptitious audio recording of Trump, wherein he merely stated “Just take care of it,” buttresses the defense’s claim that Trump was not involved in the formulation, mechanics or accounting classification of the transaction that precipitated this entire case.

This is hardly evidence that Trump “repeatedly and fraudulently falsified business records,” as the prosecution alleges. Fraud requires a culpable state of mind and, no matter how creative the prosecutors may be, the phrase “Just take care of it” does not meet the necessary threshold.

In fact, Trump even paid for the taxes on the transaction, which is hardly the hallmark of an illegal scheme.

Upon cross examination, Cohen was evasive and played semantic games with ambiguous answers such as, “It sounds like something I would say.” In the most devastating portion of the cross examination, Trump’s counsel Todd Blanche masterfully exposed Cohen’ to be an inveterate liar’s mendacity. Cohen testified with certainty on direct examination that on Oct. 24, 2016 he had called Trump’s bodyguard Keith Schiller, who handed the phone to Trump, whereupon Trump and Cohen finalized the Stormy Daniels deal. But upon cross examination, text messages before and after the call revealed that the call was actually between Cohen and Schiller about harassing telephone calls from a teenager.

Cohen was also forced to admit that he had stolen money from Trump. Thus, the only direct witness to Trump’s supposedly incriminating statements was exposed as both fabricating his testimony and stealing from the defendant.

Critically, prosecutors also failed to establish a nexus between Trump’s purported actions and the concealment of information from voters. The prosecutors alleged that Trump falsified business records in order “to conceal crimes that hid damaging information from the voting public during the 2016 election.” But even if each check and accounting entry bore the marking “Payment to Stormy Daniels,” voters would never have had access to those records. The Trump Organization is not a public company and does not store its accounting records in Trump Tower’s public atrium.

Prosecutors also attempted to downplay the significance of the 2011 blog article that detailed Daniels’s allegations. The prosecutor asked Cohen, “Did the article get any traction in 2011; meaning was it out there much?” Cohen responded “No.” But Cohen’s assessment of whether the article received “traction” is irrelevant to the question of whether it had been previously placed into the public domain and therefore not hidden from the public as prosecutors allege.

Finally, prosecutors brazenly referred to Cohen’s guilty plea to federal election law violations on numerous occasions. This was a calculated and unethical attempt by the prosecution to impute Cohen’s guilty plea onto Trump, and to suggest that somehow he too had committed violations. Judge Juan Merchan sustained some of the defense objections to this, and issued limiting instructions to the jury, but this was insufficient to cure the prejudicial nature of those statements.

In reality, Cohen was pressured to plead guilty to those crimes because federal prosecutors threatened to indict his wife.

At the outset of this case, many speculated that surely the Manhattan district attorney had credible evidence to substantiate these unprecedented allegations. However, it is now clear that prosecutors did not heed the admonition of the Supreme Court in Berger that the prosecutor, “While he may strike hard blows is not at liberty to strike foul ones.”

District Attorney Alvin Bragg clearly struck a foul blow in this case by gambling that a Manhattan jury would ignore his lack of evidence. There is a certain poignancy to the fact that Trump rallies play Lee Greenwood’s “God Bless the USA” that includes, “Proud to be an American where at least I know I’m free.” Whether Trump will remain free depends on whether, unlike the prosecutors, the 12 jurors understand that their mandate is to ensure justice is done.

George G. Demos is a former United States Securities and Exchange Commission enforcement attorney and an Adjunct Professor at U.C. Davis School of Law where he teaches Corporate and White Collar Crime.

Copyright 2024 Nexstar Media, Inc. All rights reserved. This material may not be published, broadcast, rewritten, or redistributed.

For the latest news, weather, sports, and streaming video, head to The Hill.

OTHER NEWS

24 minutes ago

Red Bull tipped to ‘walk it’ at Spanish GP under one key condition

24 minutes ago

Starting from scratch at 40? I’d use Warren Buffett’s golden rule to build wealth

24 minutes ago

Loving husband and father who was diagnosed with leukaemia in 1989 and infected with Hepatitis C through contaminated blood products was unable to recognise his own children after being 'abandoned'  by the UK's healthcare system

24 minutes ago

How David Beckham is swapping the bright lights of the A-list for idyllic country living - just like The Good Life's Tom and Barbara

24 minutes ago

Edinburgh studio flat with bunk bed in kitchen hits the market for an eye-watering £950 a month

24 minutes ago

Can YOU find the three broken suitcases within 30 seconds? Test your eagle eyes with this tricky brainteaser

24 minutes ago

Dave Cassin: Ultra-fit bodybuilder husband suddenly dies after celebrating anniversary

24 minutes ago

What England's axed Euro 2024 players are getting up to on their summers off from Marcus Rashford partying out in Cannes to Jack Grealish jetsetting off to Dubai

24 minutes ago

Two boats crash into each other and man thrown overboard as brutal gales plunge Isle of Wight annual yacht race into chaos

24 minutes ago

The 'David vs Goliath' court battles... where the little guy wins: How huge corporations like McDonalds, Vogue and Louis Vuitton dragged small businesses into legal battles in a bid to 'protect their brands' - but common sense prevailed!

24 minutes ago

Families' fury over 'awful' overgrown cemetery as grieving relatives are forced to cut grass and weeds themselves with scissors to access loved ones' graves

24 minutes ago

We live near to landfill site that stinks of rotten eggs - the stench is making our lives a misery and causing a spate of illnesses

24 minutes ago

Interactive map reveals the cheapest Spoons in London for a pint during the Euros for just £2.24 - and the most expensive

24 minutes ago

Andy Murray selected for fifth Olympics as Emma Raducanu turns down Paris Games

24 minutes ago

UFL championship game: Odds, how to watch Birmingham Stallions vs. San Antonio Brahmas

24 minutes ago

Southgate jumps to England star's defence after Keane and Rooney criticism

24 minutes ago

Injury set to rule All Blacks star out of Super Rugby Pacific final

24 minutes ago

Las Vegas Strip Sphere signs huge rock band for new residency

24 minutes ago

Why animal activists want to cancel the RSPCA

24 minutes ago

'Panda swap' confirmed for Aussie zoo amid boost to China relations

24 minutes ago

2024 US Open Leaderboard Live: Updates, score for golf leaders at Pinehurst Sunday

24 minutes ago

Ex Odisha Guv Bhandare passes away: Naveen Patnaik condoles demise

24 minutes ago

‘Stay away’: Barnaby Joyce urges businesses not to play politics after Voice defeat

24 minutes ago

IDF backtracks on Rafah tactical truce after Netanyahu, Ben-Gvir lash out

31 minutes ago

Ex-Eastenders actor turned Labour lord Michael Cashman makes grovelling apology to Rosie Duffield for branding gender-critical candidate 'frit or lazy' after she pulls out of election events over harassment fears

31 minutes ago

How Harry Styles fans are paying £20 for official guided tours of star's old haunts including bakery where he earned £6-an-hour and railway bridge where he 'had first kiss'

31 minutes ago

Horrifying new footage shows police ramming terrified runaway calf with their squad car down London street - as furious neighbours berate officers' 'heavy-handed' response

31 minutes ago

Inside Indonesian Dani tribe where women amputate their fingers to mourn loved ones after death, mothers 'bite off the tips of their babies' fingers' and men with sheathed penises guard 250-year-old mummy

31 minutes ago

Police hunt 'moron' jet-skiers who nearly killed paddleboarder, 44, in the sea by performing a hard turn at 50mph just 7ft away from him

31 minutes ago

Video: Labour's Wes Streeting refuses to rule out council tax rises and revaluation under Keir Starmer government as Tories claim party is also quietly admitting it will need more public  money for the NHS as well

31 minutes ago

Dave Cassin: Ultra-fit bodybuilder husband suddenly dies after celebrating anniversary

32 minutes ago

Newport County star Will Evans sends important message over mental health and speaking out

32 minutes ago

China’s Lust for Durian Is Creating Fortunes in Southeast Asia

32 minutes ago

Mahomes Has 'Good Connection' With New WR, Says Andy Reid

32 minutes ago

White Sox score tying run after intentional balk, beat Diamondbacks 9-2 for rare road win

32 minutes ago

Where has Patriots QB Drake Maye made strides this spring?

32 minutes ago

'We would get in the room and negotiate'

32 minutes ago

As Cowboys Keep Goofing Up Dak Prescott Contract, A Jayden Daniels Lesson for Commanders?

32 minutes ago

Neil Jordan recalls backlash over casting Tom Cruise in 'Interview With the Vampire'

32 minutes ago

T20 World Cup Super 8 groups, full fixture: Which teams will India face? England clubbed with? All you need to know