Fish Oil Supplements May Increase Risk of Stroke and Heart Disease for Some

Fish oil supplements might not be as good for your heart as we once thought, a new study suggests. At least, not for everyone.

Numerous studies have shown that eating fish is associated with a reduced risk of dying from heart disease or stroke. However, whether these same benefits can be achieved through taking fish oil supplements is less conclusive. Even so, roughly one in 13 American adults takes fish oil supplements on a semiregular basis, according to surveys from the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.

Historically, the side effects of fish oil supplements have been considered to be fairly mild, including bad breath, headaches and stomach issues. But, according to new research, regular fish oil supplementation might actually be increasing our risk of the very thing they are purported to prevent.

fish oil supplements may increase risk of stroke and heart disease for some

Fish oil supplements are often taken for their purported benefits on heart health. But the evidence supporting these assertions is somewhat unclear. magicmine/Getty

The study, published in the journal BMJ Medicine, drew on data from 415,737 participants from the U.K. between the ages of 40 and 69, nearly a third of whom regularly took fish oil supplements.

Over an average 12-year monitoring period, those with no known cardiovascular disease at the start of the study who regularly took fish oil supplements were 13 percent more likely to develop atrial fibrillation—a condition that causes an abnormal heart rhythm and increases your risk of stroke—and 5 percent more likely to have a stroke than those who did not take the supplements.

However, among those who had already developed cardiovascular disease before the study period, regular fish oil supplements were associated with a 15 percent lower risk of progressing from atrial fibrillation to a heart attack, and a 9 percent lower risk of progressing from heart failure to death.

On further analysis, women and nonsmokers with no heart health concerns at the start of the study who took regular fish oil supplements were at the highest risk of suffering heart attacks, strokes and heart failure by the end of the study period, while men and older participants were more likely to see protective effects.

This study was, of course, purely observational so no causal relationships can be concluded from its findings. Secondly, while the researchers did account for certain confounding variables—like smoking, sex, fish consumption and age—other confounding variables may still exist.

Thirdly, the researchers did not have access to information on the doses and formulations of fish oil supplements used by the participants. However, Deepak Bhatt, Director of Mount Sinai Fuster Heart Hospital and Professor of Cardiovascular Medicine at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, said that this research adds to a growing body of evidence that fish oil supplements may not be necessary, or indeed suitable, for the general population.

"Higher doses of prescription omega-3 fatty acid preparations have shown a slight increase in the risk for the heart arrythmia known as atrial fibrillation," Bhatt, who was not involved in the research, told Newsweek. "Thus, the high-quality studies that already exist do not support healthy people taking fish oil supplements, even though this is a very common and popular practice.

"The present observational study—which is a lower grade of evidence than randomized trials—also suggests that there is an increased risk of atrial fibrillation, so this is another word of caution in terms of using fish oil supplements. The present study did also suggest there might be a cardiovascular benefit, but given the limitations of this type of study design, for now it would be best to stick with what we know from the randomized trials— healthy people don't need to take fish oil supplements."

The study's authors add that further research is required to determine whether fish oil supplements have a causal effect on the development and prognosis of cardiovascular disease.

The full results can be found in the journal BMJ Medicine.

Is there a health problem that's worrying you? Let us know via [email protected]. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured in Newsweek.

Related Articles

    Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

    OTHER NEWS

    22 minutes ago

    The 20 best places to retire in Britain: From the Highlands and an average house price of £200,000, to the historic town within 90 miles of London

    23 minutes ago

    Kieran Culkin says 'Succession' made him realise his passion for acting

    23 minutes ago

    Dutton edges out Albo as preferred PM

    23 minutes ago

    Emma Raducanu snubs Olympic wildcard as Andy Murray learns Paris 2024 fate

    23 minutes ago

    Albania fans snapping spaghetti at Italy supporters is already the best thing from the Euros

    23 minutes ago

    DUP founding Wallace Thompson says nationalists need to reach out to unionists over unity

    23 minutes ago

    Bulls to host Glasgow Warriors in UFC final: Here’s when

    23 minutes ago

    Legendary coach highlights one aspect that will ‘pay huge dividends’ for Jannik Sinner on grass

    23 minutes ago

    Nasreddine Nabi confirms he’s held talks with Kaizer Chiefs, but has other offers as well — report

    23 minutes ago

    Finder survey shows nearly 50 per cent of Aussies are reluctant to travel abroad

    23 minutes ago

    Today in Politics: Amit Shah to chair high-level huddle on J-K security, Amarnath Yatra preps

    23 minutes ago

    Wells Fargo Bet on a Flashy Rent Credit Card. It Is Costing the Bank Dearly.

    23 minutes ago

    Swiss right-wing leader calls Ukraine summit an 'embarrassment'

    27 minutes ago

    Emma Raducanu REJECTS Team GB wildcard for the Paris Olympics as she continues to ease her way back after injury hell... while Andy Murray is set for a fairytale send-off at the Games

    27 minutes ago

    Video: 'Hardest Geezer' Russ Cook arrives in Germany for Euros after running 352 miles to support England - and predicts Three Lions victory over Serbia

    27 minutes ago

    Former sub-postmaster slams 'buffoonery' of Ed Davey's stunt-laden election campaign as Lib-Dem leader faces questions over lack of help during Horizon scandal when he was a minister

    27 minutes ago

    John Farnham's newly married son Rob shares first photos of his music legend father following cancer surgery that saw 26 doctors reconstruct his jaw

    27 minutes ago

    Anne is praised as 'outstanding horsewoman' after Princess Royal managed to keep control of her horse during Trooping the Colour

    27 minutes ago

    Poland vs Netherlands - Euro 2024: Live score, team news and updates as Virgil Van Dijk aims to captain 1988 winners to victory in opening Group D clash

    27 minutes ago

    Video: Hippy-crack driver, 24, who killed cyclist, 56, as he inhaled laughing gas from a balloon while driving BMW with his knees is jailed - as horrific CCTV shows moment car knocks down nurse

    27 minutes ago

    Gloating masked Serbian thugs pose with 'stolen' England flags ahead of Three Lions clash - amid fears that mob of violent hooligans will spark chaos at the Euros

    27 minutes ago

    Video: 'Is my mother still alive?': Hostage Noa Argamani's first words revealed after she was rescued by Israeli special forces - as dramatic footage shows daring raid on Hamas compound

    27 minutes ago

    Video: Anne is praised as 'outstanding horsewoman' after Princess Royal managed to keep control of her horse during Trooping the Colour

    27 minutes ago

    Euro 2024: Man shot by Hamburg police after axe attack

    27 minutes ago

    German police shoot person armed with axe ahead of Euro 2024 game in Hamburg

    27 minutes ago

    Why has Ed Davey been throwing himself in the water to win the Lib Dems votes?

    27 minutes ago

    Kate shares touching new photo of William with George, Charlotte and Louis to mark Father’s Day

    27 minutes ago

    Grace Kim shoots 66 to take five-shot lead in Meijer LPGA Classic

    27 minutes ago

    NASCAR starting lineup for Iowa Speedway

    27 minutes ago

    Euro 2024: Serbia's superstar coach names the England star his side fear most

    27 minutes ago

    Tottenham scouts in attendance for €30m attacking talent primed to star at Euro 2024

    27 minutes ago

    New signs warning of great white sharks in the works for some East Coast beaches

    27 minutes ago

    Arsenal To Hold Talks With Declan Rice Over Position

    27 minutes ago

    Exclusive poll: Black voters aren't thrilled with Biden but dislike Trump more

    27 minutes ago

    How I dress for five days of Royal Ascot

    27 minutes ago

    Arsenal news: Edu faces transfer delay as Gunners name fee for midfielder star

    27 minutes ago

    Princess Charlotte's touching act during carriage ride to stop rain ruining Trooping parade

    27 minutes ago

    Gareth Southgate sends England stars message that leaves no doubt over Euro 2024 plans

    35 minutes ago

    PepsiCo announces plans to triple size of its electric fleet: 'Good for the planet, good for our business'

    35 minutes ago

    Elon Musk vs BJP's Rajeev Chandrashekhar on whether EVMs can be hacked