Fish Oil Supplements May Increase Risk of Stroke and Heart Disease for Some

Fish oil supplements might not be as good for your heart as we once thought, a new study suggests. At least, not for everyone.

Numerous studies have shown that eating fish is associated with a reduced risk of dying from heart disease or stroke. However, whether these same benefits can be achieved through taking fish oil supplements is less conclusive. Even so, roughly one in 13 American adults takes fish oil supplements on a semiregular basis, according to surveys from the National Center for Complementary and Integrative Health.

Historically, the side effects of fish oil supplements have been considered to be fairly mild, including bad breath, headaches and stomach issues. But, according to new research, regular fish oil supplementation might actually be increasing our risk of the very thing they are purported to prevent.

fish oil supplements may increase risk of stroke and heart disease for some

Fish oil supplements are often taken for their purported benefits on heart health. But the evidence supporting these assertions is somewhat unclear. magicmine/Getty

The study, published in the journal BMJ Medicine, drew on data from 415,737 participants from the U.K. between the ages of 40 and 69, nearly a third of whom regularly took fish oil supplements.

Over an average 12-year monitoring period, those with no known cardiovascular disease at the start of the study who regularly took fish oil supplements were 13 percent more likely to develop atrial fibrillation—a condition that causes an abnormal heart rhythm and increases your risk of stroke—and 5 percent more likely to have a stroke than those who did not take the supplements.

However, among those who had already developed cardiovascular disease before the study period, regular fish oil supplements were associated with a 15 percent lower risk of progressing from atrial fibrillation to a heart attack, and a 9 percent lower risk of progressing from heart failure to death.

On further analysis, women and nonsmokers with no heart health concerns at the start of the study who took regular fish oil supplements were at the highest risk of suffering heart attacks, strokes and heart failure by the end of the study period, while men and older participants were more likely to see protective effects.

This study was, of course, purely observational so no causal relationships can be concluded from its findings. Secondly, while the researchers did account for certain confounding variables—like smoking, sex, fish consumption and age—other confounding variables may still exist.

Thirdly, the researchers did not have access to information on the doses and formulations of fish oil supplements used by the participants. However, Deepak Bhatt, Director of Mount Sinai Fuster Heart Hospital and Professor of Cardiovascular Medicine at the Icahn School of Medicine at Mount Sinai, said that this research adds to a growing body of evidence that fish oil supplements may not be necessary, or indeed suitable, for the general population.

"Higher doses of prescription omega-3 fatty acid preparations have shown a slight increase in the risk for the heart arrythmia known as atrial fibrillation," Bhatt, who was not involved in the research, told Newsweek. "Thus, the high-quality studies that already exist do not support healthy people taking fish oil supplements, even though this is a very common and popular practice.

"The present observational study—which is a lower grade of evidence than randomized trials—also suggests that there is an increased risk of atrial fibrillation, so this is another word of caution in terms of using fish oil supplements. The present study did also suggest there might be a cardiovascular benefit, but given the limitations of this type of study design, for now it would be best to stick with what we know from the randomized trials— healthy people don't need to take fish oil supplements."

The study's authors add that further research is required to determine whether fish oil supplements have a causal effect on the development and prognosis of cardiovascular disease.

The full results can be found in the journal BMJ Medicine.

Is there a health problem that's worrying you? Let us know via [email protected]. We can ask experts for advice, and your story could be featured in Newsweek.

Related Articles

    Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

    OTHER NEWS

    16 minutes ago

    Doctor Who season 2: Release date speculation, cast, and everything we know about Ncuti Gatwa’s next season

    16 minutes ago

    Stellantis: Vauxhall owner threatens to quit UK over ‘stupid’ EV sales mandate

    16 minutes ago

    Disability groups urge government to tread carefully with NDIS changes as minister gets in a tangle with the senators over Brazil trip

    16 minutes ago

    Rams News: Joshua Karty Brings Hope to Kicking Woes

    16 minutes ago

    Mitchell looks to defend title in Paris as part of Canada's Olympic cycling team

    16 minutes ago

    Consensus: Chicago Bears are not a playoff team for 2024 season

    16 minutes ago

    From dessert to donuts, treat yourself at the best places for sweets

    16 minutes ago

    Philadelphia 76ers Contenders to Sign New Orleans Pelicans Player

    16 minutes ago

    Brandon Aiyuk Calls Out 49ers Following Report of Declined Trade Offer Involving Him

    16 minutes ago

    Europe's big five leagues generate 19.6 billion euros in season post-COVID

    16 minutes ago

    Southgate asks fans to back his players after another poor performance

    17 minutes ago

    Texas authorities investigating why officer responding to a robbery had a man in his back seat before crash that killed mom and son

    17 minutes ago

    Houston water bills could be changing in August. Here's why

    17 minutes ago

    Delaware Senate gives final approval to bill mandating insurance coverage for abortions

    17 minutes ago

    Euro 2024 day 12: Austria cause a stir and England win group

    19 minutes ago

    The yuan's status as a global currency might be gaining ground. But top CEOs see more hurdles to clear

    19 minutes ago

    Chicago activists react after U.S. Surgeon General declares gun violence a public health crisis

    20 minutes ago

    S&P/TSX composite closes down as telecom and metal stocks fall, U.S. markets mixed

    20 minutes ago

    Kenya Moore Not Returning To Bravo’s ‘The Real Housewives Of Atlanta’ Following Suspension

    20 minutes ago

    ‘The Who’s Tommy’ Sets Broadway Closing Date

    22 minutes ago

    Chelsea should sign 'very solid' Euro 2024 star this summer, says William Gallas

    22 minutes ago

    Kaizer Chiefs new fitness guru arrives to bolster technical team

    22 minutes ago

    Texas QB Quinn Ewers gets honest about Ryan Day, Ohio State

    22 minutes ago

    Florida Panthers beat Edmonton Oilers, win first Stanley Cup title

    22 minutes ago

    Copa America 2024: Updated power ranking for all 16 teams

    22 minutes ago

    Roenick gets into Hockey Hall of Fame after a lengthy wait. 2024 class includes 2 US women's players

    22 minutes ago

    Roy Keane warns Gareth Southgate is 'under huge pressure' to start England star in last 16

    22 minutes ago

    Focused on Investing Products For Kids: Acorns CEO

    22 minutes ago

    Woe de Cologne: England fans’ party ends in boos as team turns clock back

    22 minutes ago

    Widespread heavy rainfall and isolated thunderstorms in B.C.

    22 minutes ago

    Chargers News: Late-Round Rookie Primed for Success

    22 minutes ago

    Oklahoma high court rules state funded religious charter school unconstitutional

    25 minutes ago

    Love Actually's Thomas Brodie-Sangster Marries Elon Musk's Ex Talulah Riley

    25 minutes ago

    LoveShackFancy Partners With Suni Lee For An Americana Collection With Cotton

    25 minutes ago

    Duke and Duchess of Westminster top social power list after headline-making wedding

    25 minutes ago

    LinkedIn’s co-founder slams Trump social network Truth Social’s ‘absurd’ $6 billion valuation

    28 minutes ago

    Video: Panthers' Matthew Tkachuk takes a dip in the ocean with Stanley Cup as wild celebrations hit Fort Lauderdale Beach barely 24 hours after Florida wins its first-ever championship

    28 minutes ago

    Video: Jamie Oliver and wife Jools renew their vows AGAIN in Vegas Elvis-themed ceremony on their 24th wedding anniversary - after exchanging them for the second time just last year

    28 minutes ago

    Video: Love Island's Harriett Blackmore does the SPLITS and passionately kisses Ronnie Vint as her co-stars strip down to sexy lingerie during show's Heart Rate Challenge

    28 minutes ago

    Copa America referee COLLAPSES in frightening scene during Canada-Peru game with Kansas City temps in the 90s as official is removed on stretcher