France's army chief says small drones will lose their battlefield advantage. But Ukraine likely won't be changing tack anytime soon.

microsoft, france's army chief says small drones will lose their battlefield advantage. but ukraine likely won't be changing tack anytime soon.

A Ukrainian reconnaissance unit in Kharkiv Oblast. Global Images Ukraine/ Getty Images

  • Small drones dominate Ukraine's battlefield, but their advantage won't last, France's army chief said.
  • Small, relatively cheap drones have been hugely successful weapons in the war so far.
  • However, experts told BI that advancing countermeasures would limit small drones' capabilities.

Small aerial drones have dominated the battlefield in Ukraine, but according to French Army Chief of Staff Gen. Pierre Schill, they could soon lose their combat advantage.

Speaking at the Eurosatory defense show in Paris on June 19, Schill said that their advantage represented merely "a moment in history," Defense News reported.

"The life of impunity of small, very simple drones over the battlefield is a snapshot in time," Schill said.

"Right now it's being exploited, that's clear, and we have to protect ourselves. Today, the sword, in the sense of the aerial drone, is powerful, more powerful than the shield. The shield is going to grow," he added.

microsoft, france's army chief says small drones will lose their battlefield advantage. but ukraine likely won't be changing tack anytime soon.

The head of the French army, Pierre Schill. ADRIAN DENNIS/ Getty Images

The use of drones will likely fluctuate

Former British Army officer Christopher Lincoln-Jones told Business Insider that the use of small drones in warfare would likely "ebb and flow."

He said: "What will happen is that, as artificial intelligence becomes better and better and the senses become better, medium-sized drones will dominate rather than the small ones."

"Mini drones are limited by the fact that battery technology is not good enough for them yet. And although they can carry a small charge or weapon, they're not really good against military targets," Lincoln-Jones added.

Greg Bagwell, the UK Royal Air Force's former Deputy Commander, told BI "there is some truth" to Schill's comments about the future of small drones in battle.

"I think to say it's nearly had its day, and it's all over is probably a slight exaggeration. But I think it will get harder for them to operate as people now get wise to this threat. We'll start to see the counters maybe begin to take a higher position," he said.

Small drones are at the forefront of the war in Ukraine

Small drones, particularly first-person view drones (FPVs), have been a trademark of Russia's war in Ukraine, with both sides weaponizing them against each other.

FPV drones have had huge success on the battlefield so far, proving to be cheaper and more accurate than most artillery as they can be guided directly to their target.

A NATO official told Foreign Policy magazine in April that more than two-thirds of the Russian tanks that had been destroyed by Ukraine in recent months had been targeted with FPVs.

Ukraine has also pounded Russian oil refineries and airbases with drones as part of a widespread campaign to disrupt Russian military supplies and hamper the Russian air force.

Drone countermeasures are advancing

But Lincoln-Jones and Bagwell both echoed Gen. Schill's warnings that drone countermeasures are advancing and would increasingly render small drones less effective.

"There will be all sorts of techniques being used to jam the signals, the video, or the GPS signal," Bagwell said.

Schill said that electronic warfare — which uses the electromagnetic spectrum, including signals like radio, infrared, or radar, to disrupt an enemy's ability to use those signals itself — was already neutralizing 75% of drones deployed in Ukraine.

"Unless you can encrypt and use direct line of sight to control your drone, you're very vulnerable to nearly every electronic warfare system," Lincoln-Jones said. "You just need to know what frequency the drone is operating on from the point of view of its commands."

Nevertheless, current electronic warfare systems being used to defend against drone attacks have their limits. The use of such systems risks interfering with other technology, such as radios and cellphones that are in the drone's vicinity.

Drones remain key to Ukraine's military strategy

Drone production continues to surge in Ukraine despite the increasing number of defense systems employed against the technology. More than 200 companies now produce aerial drones in the country, and workers were producing around 50,000 FPVs a month by December, Forbes reported.

Both sides are also pumping money into developing AI-powered drones that can bypass electronic warfare systems.

This year, Ukraine also became one of the first countries ever to create a separate branch of its military dedicated to drone warfare.

A recent report by the Atlantic Council said that Ukraine's drone strategy would now likely "continue to focus on flexibility, innovation, and the daily challenge of maintaining a technological advantage over Russia."

Gen. Schill declined an interview with BI.

If you enjoyed this story, be sure to follow Business Insider on Microsoft Start.

OTHER NEWS

9 minutes ago

CBS host interrupts JD Vance after he criticized media for not fact-checking Biden during debate

9 minutes ago

Hamad Al Sharqi receives officers of Fujairah Police General Headquarters

9 minutes ago

REPORT: Erik Johnson To Sign One-Year Extension With Flyers

9 minutes ago

Movie review: 'Despicable Me 4' fun for kids, nightmare for adults

9 minutes ago

Glastonbury cancelled in 2026 as Eavis family issue major update

9 minutes ago

Insider Predicts Bruins Will Sign 2 Top Players

9 minutes ago

First look at Gladiator II previews battle between Paul Mescal and Pedro Pascal

9 minutes ago

EA FC 25: Release date and everything we know about the new football game

9 minutes ago

Netflix’s new number 1 show lands perfect Rotten Tomatoes score and comparisons to Marvel’s Avengers

9 minutes ago

Humans are to blame for crashes - autonomous cars won't fix that

9 minutes ago

Le Pen’s party would be a disaster for France, says Farage

9 minutes ago

US Supreme Court sends Trump immunity claim back to lower court

12 minutes ago

Texas sets execution date for East Texas man accused in shaken baby case

12 minutes ago

Blackhawks sign backup goaltender Laurent Brossoit to 2-year deal

14 minutes ago

Lethal rapids, foot rot... and a close encounter with machete-wielding 'river pirates'. The incredible story of how a middle-aged British IT worker became the first man to kayak down the Amazon - just so he could impress his grandchildren

14 minutes ago

Roy Keane claims England are 'living in cuckoo land' by thinking Gareth Southgate can fix 'embarrassing' performances... but insists the Three Lions can still claim Euro 2024 glory

14 minutes ago

RICHARD LITTLEJOHN: If you thought the U.S. election was bonkers, imagine what they think of us: 'These crazy Brits are like turkeys voting for Thanksgiving!'

14 minutes ago

Alan Shearer urges Gareth Southgate to make THREE changes to his England side ahead of Euro 2024 quarter-final showdown against Switzerland

14 minutes ago

Like Michael J Fox, I developed Parkinson's Disease in my 30s - but doctors mistook it for coffee addiction

14 minutes ago

Why more people are having first-time seizures in middle age like the female motorist who killed two children at Wimbledon school - and the signs doctors say mean you might be at risk

14 minutes ago

I was born at Glastonbury founder Michael Eavis's farmhouse in the 1980s - my mother had no idea she was pregnant

14 minutes ago

England full-back George Furbank heaps praise on Northampton chief Chris Boyd for his resurgence ahead of two-Test series against New Zealand

14 minutes ago

The new 'toothpaste' jab that may be able to rebuild crumbling bones

14 minutes ago

Trendy fermented foods can make you ill, say top scientists, as they reveal the top offenders for causing allergies, rashes, tummy troubles and potentially fatal infections

14 minutes ago

Bankers bonuses are roaring back. Will we live to regret it?

14 minutes ago

Kamala Harris references Drake and Kendrick Lamar beef in BET Awards appearance

14 minutes ago

A Diet of Dark Matter Could Be Making Some Stars Effectively Immortal

14 minutes ago

Video Shows Rocket of China's SpaceX Rival Exploding in Mountains

14 minutes ago

Boeing Starliner astronauts ‘are not stranded’ in orbit, NASA insists

14 minutes ago

Millions of taxpayers' cash spent sending diplomats' kids to private schools including Eton

14 minutes ago

Biden’s SAVE Student Loan Repayment Plan Can Resume Amid Lawsuits, Appeals Court Says

14 minutes ago

Liberal justices Sotomayor and Jackson issue scathing dissents of Trump immunity ruling

14 minutes ago

Universal Hydrogen runs out of runway and shuts down, one year after first flight

14 minutes ago

‘He is a divisive, controversial figure’: Petition launched to rescind Prince Harry award

14 minutes ago

Tyler Toffoli to sign with San Jose Sharks

14 minutes ago

This is the Cotswolds pub Jeremy Clarkson has bought in Burford

14 minutes ago

Russian glide bombs' faulty guidance systems may have led to dozens being dropped on its own territory, experts say

14 minutes ago

Nvidia and Microsoft will drive AI revolution: Wedbush’s Dan Ives

14 minutes ago

Check out this cool video of NaakMusiQ and his father

14 minutes ago

New Avengers 5, Secret Wars, and Avengers 7 plot leaks shed light on the end of the Multiverse Saga