Liberal justices Sotomayor and Jackson issue scathing dissents of Trump immunity ruling

liberal justices sotomayor and jackson issue scathing dissents of trump immunity ruling

WASHINGTON — The Supreme Court's liberal bloc issued blistering dissents in the Trump immunity ruling, arguing that the decision "reshapes the institution of the presidency" and "makes a mockery" of the constitutional principle that no man is above the law.

Justice Sonia Sotomayor, reading her dissent from the bench, said that "relying on little more than its own misguided wisdom ... the Court gives former President Trump all the immunity he asked for and more."

She added that "because our Constitution does not shield a former President from answering for criminal and treasonous acts, I dissent."

The Supreme Court ruled 6-3 on ideological lines that former President Donald Trump has immunity for some of his conduct as president but not unofficial acts in the federal election interference case. The court did not determine what constitutes an "official" act in this case, leaving that to the lower court.

The decision adds another hurdle and further delay to special counsel Jack Smith's prosecution of the former president. Trump was indicted last year on charges he conspired to "overturn the legitimate results of the 2020 presidential election."

Sotomayor said that the majority opinion, written by Chief Justice John Roberts, invents "an atextual, ahistorical, and unjustifiable immunity that puts the President above the law."

Their ruling, she went on, makes three moves that she said "completely insulate Presidents from criminal liability." Sotomayor said the court creates absolute immunity for the president's exercise of "core constitutional powers," creates "expansive immunity for all 'official acts,'" and "declares that evidence concerning acts for which the President is immune can play no role in any criminal prosecution against him."

Sotomayor warned that the ruling "will have disastrous consequences for the Presidency and for our democracy."

In her own written dissent, Jackson wrote that the majority's ruling "breaks new and dangerous ground."

"Departing from the traditional model of individual accountability, the majority has concocted something entirely different: a Presidential accountability model that creates immunity—an exemption from criminal law — applicable only to the most powerful official in our Government," she wrote.

Jackson warned that under the majority's "new Presidential accountability mode," a hypothetical president "who admits to having ordered the assassinations of his political rivals or critics...or one who indisputably instigates an unsuccessful coup...has a fair shot at getting immunity."

This article was originally published on NBCNews.com

OTHER NEWS

2 minutes ago

Tesla will disappoint investors despite better-than-expected Q2 deliveries: Wells Fargo's Langan

2 minutes ago

TSX futures rise ahead of US Fed minutes, economic data

2 minutes ago

Ian O’Doherty: As Labour prepares for victory, it’s like 1997 all over again, minus the optimism

2 minutes ago

Three RB juniors ‘ready to go’ with Daniel Ricciardo help plan revealed

2 minutes ago

Raging wildfire forces 13,000 people to evacuate in northern California

2 minutes ago

Green Bay Packers Urged to Sign QB with 216 Touchdown Passes

2 minutes ago

Star Pies race against the clock

2 minutes ago

Steelers' Patrick Queen's Career Could Only Survive Because Of Roquan Smith: 'He's A Robin'

2 minutes ago

Analyst explains reason for optimism surrounding NFC North QB

2 minutes ago

Bloomberg Invest 2024 Highlights

2 minutes ago

Taking a deeper look at the current conversations around the Blue Jays

2 minutes ago

Ukrainian drone attack damaged Russia's only full-cycle metallurgical enterprise, source says

2 minutes ago

Raiders Declined Trade Offer For Brock Bowers Pick

2 minutes ago

GM to pay $145.8 million penalty after US finds excess emissions in 5.9 million vehicles

2 minutes ago

Erdogan tells Putin that Turkey can help reach fair end to Russia-Ukraine war

2 minutes ago

Soccer-Alvarez, Otamendi named in Argentina squad for Olympics

2 minutes ago

Jeff Bezos to sell Amazon shares worth about $5 billion after stock hits record high

2 minutes ago

Caitlin Clark Earns New Nickname From Indiana Fever Teammate After WNBA's Announcement

2 minutes ago

'You're kidding': Hinkley still feeling heat despite win

2 minutes ago

Conditions set and now treble-winning Liverpool target looks almost certain to move

2 minutes ago

Dick Smith enters nuclear debate but CSIRO analysis shows his argument in meltdown

2 minutes ago

Zelda fan sentenced to prison for carrying a Master Sword in public in Nuneaton

2 minutes ago

10 movie releases we're excited for in the second half of 2024

2 minutes ago

Former England head coach Jack Rowell passes away aged 87

2 minutes ago

Why Dolphins star Tyreek Hill could be forced to miss part of NFL season after update in lawsuit involving OnlyFans model Sophie Hall

2 minutes ago

Emma Raducanu vows to 'put it on the line and fight' as she starts her Wimbledon second round match against Elise Mertens

2 minutes ago

British tourist, 52, who died rushing into the sea to try to save children aged six and seven when got into difficulty in Spain is named

2 minutes ago

Kate and Prince William beef up their team of advisors by appointing 'drastic Dave' - the man credited with turning Tesco around

2 minutes ago

Jay Leno's dementia-stricken wife Mavis, 77, appears to sport black eye as the couple are seen on Los Angeles outing - after host, 74, was appointed as her conservator

2 minutes ago

Video: Andrea Bocelli, 65, performs an emotional song with his daughter Virginia, 12, ahead of Hyde Park show

2 minutes ago

Video: Heidi Klum, 51, set pulses racing as she flashes her underboob in a racy cut-out dress while riding a gondola in Venice

2 minutes ago

Video: And exhale... England stars recover from stress of dramatic win over Slovakia with breath-work session led by Radio 1 DJ, as Gareth Southgate's squad reset ahead of Switzerland clash

2 minutes ago

‘The Bachelorette’s Jenn Tran Says It’s “Unfortunate” There Aren’t More “Asian Men This Season”

2 minutes ago

Buzz Cason Dies: Songwriter Of Pop Classic ‘Everlasting Love’ Was 84

2 minutes ago

Biden to meet with governors Wednesday amid alarm after debate performance

2 minutes ago

As Biden team suggests there can be no alternative, DNC rules provide a path

2 minutes ago

'KHive' and 'coconut-pilled': Kamala Harris sees a sudden social media renaissance

2 minutes ago

Source: Bronny James getting 4-year, $7.9M deal with Lakers

2 minutes ago

Sources: Lakers adding Nate McMillan, Scott Brooks to staff

2 minutes ago

The Bachelorette star speaks out about ‘unfortunate’ lack of Asian men this season