Sunak v Starmer - THE VERDICT: MailOnline panel have their say

Voters have given a damning verdict for Keir Starmer following a second head-to-head debate between Rishi Sunak and the Labour leader - as the Prime Minister bruised his opposition in a fiery performance.

Attacks were thrown from each side in the BBC studio as the Prime Minister and the Labour leader locked horns over welfare, taxation and immigration.

It comes after a hectic week for both parties - as at least five Tory candidates are being investigated by the Gambling Commission, with a further Labour candidate being suspended by the party for betting that he would lose his own contest.

And with just a week to go before the nation casts its votes, MailOnline's panel of readers, who have been called upon to provide verdicts after each televised debate on the campaign, said that Sunak was far more convincing over immigration and taxation.

But they admitted that Starmer had won them over by swiftly dealing with the gambling scandal.

As they react to the second-to-last debate of the election season, this is what they have to say...

sunak v starmer - the verdict: mailonline panel have their say

Labour Party leader Keir Starmer and British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak take part in BBC's Prime Ministerial Debate, in Nottingham

sunak v starmer - the verdict: mailonline panel have their say

Attacks were thrown from each side in the BBC studio as the Prime Minister and the Labour leader locked horns over welfare, tax levels and immigration

sunak v starmer - the verdict: mailonline panel have their say

It comes after a hectic week for both parties - as at least five Tory candidates are being investigated by the Gambling Commission

'Where are they going to go? He's not answering that one' : Cancer patient Denise Clarke, 59

sunak v starmer - the verdict: mailonline panel have their say

Mrs Clarke has been reliant on the NHS for care after being diagnosed with cancer last August

Amid leaders' debate, Denise Clarke, 59, praised Labour for quickly dealing with the gambling standards, although she admitted that he did not seem to have a plan for the future.

But Denise - who is currently on Universal Credit after a cancer diagnosis meant she had to give up her job at Asda supermarket - said that he had a point when he spoke about bringing down waiting lists and getting people back to work.

Denise, from Lewisham, South London said: 'Keir Starmer acted faster in the gambling situation - he suspended somebody straight away whereas the Prime Minister was holding it off.

'The waiting lists do have to be dealt with and we won't get people back to work if they're sick, and they will be sick because they're waiting so long for an operation, so that does need to be dealt with. Keir Starmer has that point.

'Combining the waiting lists with getting back to work seems to make sense to me. Get people off the waiting lists, get their operations done, get them back healthy so they can go to work. I'm sure most of them want to - I know I want to!

'The gangs do need to be taken down buyt they can't just let everybody in. We don;t have space for everybody. I don't quite know what Keir Starmer's going to do about that.

'I think the processing does need to be done but at the same time where are they going to go? He's not answering that one, is he.

'Neither of the two managed to cut through': Student Archie Parker-Goff, 21

sunak v starmer - the verdict: mailonline panel have their say

Archie, from Chester, has just finished studying for an economics degree at Bristol University.

Student Archie Parker-Goff told how he believed neither of the two political heavyweights managed to cut through BBC TV debate - but admitted that the audience seemed to be siding with Sunak.

Archie, 21, from Chester, said: 'I think neither of the two candidates really managed to cut through just with so much that's going on.

'While Starmer tried to illustrate what he thought and get back on message of those who can work should work, I think the audience in the auditorium responded more positively to Rishi, who pointed to some sick note reform that he tried to put through, and indeed, the Labor Party's recent record at voting against all of these measures.

'I think Starmer did well to point out that he's got experience as leader of the CPS in the past working with international police organizations.

'But the audience was more vocal in its support when Rishi pointed towards the Rwanda scheme.

'[It was] by no means conclusive, but I think Rishi probably looked stronger than he has done in previous debates.'

'Keir Starmer is the clear leader': Lawyer Benedict Sharrock-Harris, 32

Lawyer Benedict Sharrock-Harris said that Keir Starmer was the 'clear leader' following the BBC debate.

The 32-year-old said that the Labour leader's ideas were 'realistic' - whereas the Prime Minister was givingout 'soundbites'.

He said: 'I would say there is a clear leader between the two, and it is Keir Starmer.

'Lnlike how many media outlets would put for a long time, it is clear that Labor is the party that is trusted on the economy and Keir Starmer was much more comfortable on this, and he seemed to be more realistic.

'Whereas Rishi Sunak was just pushing sound bites again and again, running the same few things on taxes, talking about surrender again and again, saying that he was going to be compassionate to people on benefits, whereas it's clear that all that they want to do is attack people on benefits, suggesting that they are lazy and that there is money to be cut here, and there are people who should be in work who are not just because they are lazy.

'I think one of the best blows that Keir Starmer landed was that if he actually talked to people, he wouldn't be so out of touch. And that went down really well with the audience.

'Surprisingly, even on immigration, I think labor did better. They had a referred to it as a national security issue, which I think was a bit unfortunate, but certainly nothing like Rishi Sunak's attack on people who are fleeing desperate situations, referring to them jumping the queue, calling them illegal migrants.

'I think it was a good statement from Keir Starmer about the timing of the election asking why Rishi Sunak had done this prior to the first Rwanda flights going off, if it was such a wonderful thing.

'Immigration is going to be Keir's downfall': Dover fisherman Matt Coker, 44

Dover fisherman Matt Coker, 44, said that Sunak got the better of Starmer over immigration - and it would be the Labour leader's downfall.

He said he did not seem to have 'the details' and Sunak was giving some much better answers.

He said: 'We are halfway through now, and, and at the start, it was fairly neck and neck as far as I was concerned.

'Because, you know, I think Keir does talk a good argument - I mean, that was obviously his profession for a while.

'And I think they were both making it sound like they really did want to make a difference.

'But then the thing is, with Starmer, he doesn't seem to have much in the way of the facts and figures and the background. And Sunak was actually giving some good answers, some really good answers.

'And he does argue well, you know, you can tell he is quite passionate about what he wants to do, and he wants to do it whether people will think it's right or wrong. And I think that's quite good to see.

'And then the immigration question came, and I do think that is going to be the downfall for Keir Starmer, because he really expanded on nothing in that. He just says the same thing.'

'Sunak is getting the better of him': Medical student Jon Craven, 23

Medical student Jon Craven, from Norfolk, said that he thought Sunak had got the better of Starmer in the election.

The 23-year-old said that he thought the Labour leader was 'waffley' - although he admitted he didn't think Sunak's performance would sway the election.

He said: 'I think it's very clear that Sunak and Starmer have very different styles to one another. So Sunak is a little bit angrier, he's a little bit tetchier and he's a bit more direct.

'I think this hasn't come across that well in previous interactions with the public but I think head to head with Starmer, he's probably getting the better of him this time.

'So I think Starmer's slightly more waffly style isn't really doing him any favors here.

'He's mostly been on the defensive on topics of immigration, welfare, and he's had some quite difficult exchanges on tax. Now, there certainly are things that he could be attacking the Conservatives for, and he could be attacking Sunak for, but he's not quite managed to get in gear and get his attacks over yet.

'I think so far, you'd have to say that Sunak has probably had the better night overall.

'Is it going to matter for him? Probably unlikely, but overall, I think so far, he's going to be a lot happier.'

Read more

OTHER NEWS

10 minutes ago

Two cash-strapped rehab center execs commit suicide within days of each other, leaving company in chaos

11 minutes ago

Canberra Institute of Technology explores legal options follow former CEO corruption

11 minutes ago

Clement can finally replace Davis in Rangers move for 25k-p/w star

11 minutes ago

Supreme Court deals major blow to federal agency regulatory authority

11 minutes ago

Tropical Storm Beryl forecast to become a major hurricane as it approaches the southeast Caribbean

11 minutes ago

'Melon Man' Ross Chastain hopes to rekindle NASCAR magic at Nashville Superspeedway

11 minutes ago

Every Calgary Flames pick from 2024 NHL Draft

11 minutes ago

NASCAR driver Bubba Wallace not sharing details of last altercation with Aric Almirola

11 minutes ago

Germany's game with Denmark resumes at Euro 2024 after thunderstorm

11 minutes ago

I Tried 6 Butter Cracker Brands, and Only One Belongs in Your Pantry

11 minutes ago

JDU delegation to meet PM Modi over Bihar's special status

11 minutes ago

Switzerland outclass Italy to reach last eight and end the torment for Spalletti

12 minutes ago

Thousands attend annual EuroPride parade in Greek city of Thessaloniki amid heavy police presence

12 minutes ago

Virat Kohli and Rohit Sharma retire from format after India’s T20 World Cup win

12 minutes ago

Euro 2024 fan park closes during Germany-Denmark knockout tie as weather spoils party

12 minutes ago

Former Northeastern University lab manager convicted of staging hoax explosion at Boston campus

12 minutes ago

Young Sheldon's Raegan Revord & Montana Jordan Reunited For An Adorable Reason

13 minutes ago

Funeral held for retired Chicago police officer murdered in West Garfield Park

13 minutes ago

BP halts offshore wind projects, renews focus on oil and gas as demand soars

13 minutes ago

Flouting Biden pause, agency approves largest LNG terminal in US

13 minutes ago

Home expert shares genius tip to make use of vitamin-packed citrus peels: 'Elevates every bite'

13 minutes ago

How LeBron James' decision to opt out of contract potentially benefits Lakers

13 minutes ago

Ally McCoist fumes at Michael Oliver after English ref disallows Germany goal at Euro 2024

13 minutes ago

Soccer-Slovenia score most powerful goal, Denmark longest at Euros so far

13 minutes ago

Video: ANDREW NEIL: Labour's Net Zero policy is fantasy piled upon stupidity. It will end in tears long before 2030 - but not before your bills go through the roof

13 minutes ago

Video: Time for tea! Rishi Sunak and Keir Starmer both enjoy a cuppa with veterans as they trade blows over defence - while Ed Davey messes around for the camera again

19 minutes ago

Kentucky judge throws out Jewish mothers' lawsuit challenging the state's abortion ban

19 minutes ago

Polls close in Mauritania, with the incumbent ally of the West favored to win

19 minutes ago

Brazil's Vinícius Jr. slams Copa organisers over pitches, refs

19 minutes ago

‘The God of the Woods’ should be your next summer mystery

19 minutes ago

What happens if you don't use your long-term care insurance benefits?

19 minutes ago

How South African Jews founded the modern city of Ashkelon

19 minutes ago

‘To a man they left everything out there’ – Padraic Joyce full of praise for trojan Tribesmen

19 minutes ago

13-man Tipperary overcome Kilkenny in All-Ireland minor final

19 minutes ago

Galway hang tough to dump champions Dublin out in thriller at Croke Park

19 minutes ago

Mother faces death penalty over horrific torture and murder of her two adopted children - after police found their remains in a burn barrel

19 minutes ago

SAUCY SECRETS: I think my husband has given me a disgusting disease. What should I do now?

19 minutes ago

Why I was suddenly left in the cold after a series of tough opinion pieces about Anthony Albanese's woes

21 minutes ago

Trump campaign memo signals plans to reduce the national GOP platform

24 minutes ago

England winger Anthony Gordon recounts bicycle ride crash