Israel’s protesters are enemies, not heroes, of democracy

Israeli Prime Minister

Israeli Prime Minister visits Berlin, Germany and meets chancellor Scholz.

Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin “Bibi” Netanyahu announced Monday night he was temporarily pausing his government’s judicial-reform efforts in the face of strikes by key industries, insubordination in some parts of the military and huge protests.

While many within the international community, as well as on the Israeli left, will attempt to portray the announcement as a triumph of democracy, it is anything but.

The reforms seek to introduce a modicum of checks and balances into Israel’s political system, where the “court” sits as a de facto unelected supreme legislative chamber that can exercise veto power over every single government action.

The assault on the proposals, apart from the telegenic protesters, was actually rooted in the state’s bureaucracy, which remains highly sympathetic to the judiciary.

For 25 years, Israel’s Supreme Court has operated entirely without democratic constraints.

Not only does the court remain unfettered by any written constitution when evaluating a law — it is guided by such nebulous principles as “human dignity” and “liberty” — it’s also seized the ability to block any government act it deems “unreasonable.”

opinion, benjamin netanyahu, courts, democracy, israel, protests, supreme court, israel’s protesters are enemies, not heroes, of democracy

Activists assembled from around the country demonstrate outside the Knesset in Jerusalem against the new Israeli government. Alon

Perhaps most confounding, judges exercise veto power over the selection of their successors, resulting in an ideologically homogenous judiciary.

To top it off, what little power the court has not assumed for itself, it has delegated to the attorney general, who can veto any government action or policy by his or her own discretion.

In the United States, presidents can and do fire their AGs. In Israel, it is closer to the opposite.

As soon as Israel’s AG Gali Baharav-Miara learned of the proposed reforms, she issued Bibi a directive ordering him to halt any involvement in or discussion of the proposals — a strategic decapitation strike on the reform movement’s leadership.

She claimed Bibi had a “conflict of interest” due to the criminal charges he faces in a case that’s dragged on for years.

Never mind the fact the presiding judge has already been selected for Bibi’s case, rendering the conflict-of-interest accusation speculative at best.

Some of the reforms would check the AG’s power.

Ironically, this interplay amounted to a genuine conflict of interest that did not give Baharav-Miara pause when rebuking Netanyahu.

opinion, benjamin netanyahu, courts, democracy, israel, protests, supreme court, israel’s protesters are enemies, not heroes, of democracy

The reforms seek to introduce a modicum of checks and balances into Israel’s political system.

REUTERS/Ammar Awad

What makes the situation even more peculiar is that Israel is supposed to be a parliamentary-sovereignty system — like many countries with roots in British law — in which the legislature is granted the last word.

For years, that simply has not been the case. The court has weighed in on everything from the appointment of ministers to the conditions attached to welfare transfers to the location of Israel’s West Bank separation fence.

Netanyahu’s most recent efforts to enact reforms are the culmination of nearly a decade of campaign promises.

As early as 2015, Netanyahu had proposed two of the more controversial reforms: the override clause, which would allow the Knesset (Israel’s legislature) to override a court ruling via a simple majority, and changing the composition of the Judicial Selection Committee to ensure the court doesn’t squash the Knesset’s voice.

Despite Netanyahu’s decision last week to whittle down his reform ambitions to just eliminating judges’ veto over their own colleagues on the Selection Committee, the demonstrations continued unabated. That’s telling.

The protests’ persistence suggests that for many protesters, it is not about the reforms but about “resisting” the newly elected government, even if doing so would disenfranchise millions of Israeli voters.

opinion, benjamin netanyahu, courts, democracy, israel, protests, supreme court, israel’s protesters are enemies, not heroes, of democracy

For 25 years, Israel’s Supreme Court has operated entirely without democratic constraints. Chris Emil

It also reveals the pro-reformers’ diagnosis was largely correct.

It is precisely because the court wields vast, self-judging and self-perpetuating power that ideologically sympathetic elites have been willing to foment chaos and even threaten civil war to preserve that power.

Contrast the Israeli reaction to reform discussion with the American reaction to the Supreme Court’s Dobbs decision.

The case was highly contentious, but no one blocked highways for months or closed national airports. That Israeli anti-reformers would shut down the country rather than let rotating elected governments fill judicial vacancies reveals the court is no so much a court as a Supreme Governing Council.

What is unfolding in Israel is not a Bibi problem — it is a democracy problem. And those portraying themselves as heroes of democracy may actually be hurting it.

Erielle Davidson is an attorney in New York City. Eugene Kontorovich is a professor at George Mason University’s Scalia Law School and director of its Center for the Middle East and International Law.

News Related


Border crisis is Biden’s fault, and only the GOP is trying to fix it

Since the start of Biden’s presidency, 85,000 migrant children have been lost, and over 5 million illegal crossings occurred at the southern border. AP President Joe Biden’s border crisis is ... Read more »

Tina Turner dead: Queen of rock ‘n’ roll was 83

Tina Turner — the Queen of Rock ‘n’ Roll who famously fled her abusive ex, Ike Turner, before staging a massive, solo career comeback — has died. The legendary performer, ... Read more »

Fetterman’s return to hoodies is a bad sign — despite the spin

Pennsylvania Democratic Sen. John Fetterman’s staff is pitching his sudden return to his signature hoodies and shorts as a sign he’s “making a robust recovery” from the clinical depression that ... Read more »

A 2nd 1st impression for DeSantis, the Dodgers’ anti-Catholic insult and other commentary

The Sisters of Perpetual Indulgence will receive a “Community Hero Award” from the Los Angeles Dodgers. AP Neocon: A 2nd 1st Impression for DeSantis? A “peculiar problem” for Gov. Ron ... Read more »

Parents paying $10K to get kids ‘published’ is just more college admissions BS

Parents who can afford the bill are paying to get their children published in peer-reviewed journals to boost their college admissions odds. Shutterstock Parents willing to write a big check ... Read more »

Only thing shocking about machete attack was a college actually firing a woke professor

Professor Shellyne Rodríguez is out of a job. Hunter College fired the art professor after she held a machete to the throat of a New York Post reporter and threatened ... Read more »

How to get to MetLife Stadium to see Taylor Swift, per NY Post locals

Getty Images Here’s a hypothetical situation. You’ve bought your Taylor Swift ‘Eras Tour’ tickets for one, two or three of her MetLife Stadium concerts in East Rutherford, NJ on Friday, ... Read more »

The escalating madness of woke dogma on college campuses

Shellyne Rodriguez threatened a Post reporter with a machete. Robert Miller for the N.Y. Post Once an arena of dueling beliefs, colleges have been taken over by a woke left ... Read more »

NYC Mayor Eric Adams needs to tell President Joe Biden to seal the border

Mayor Eric Adams has been heavily criticized over his handling of the migrant crisis. Matthew McDermott Watching Mayor Adams get attacked by The New York Times and other left-wing Democrats ... Read more »

The biggest threat to our military just might be DEI indoctrination

Kevin McCarthy (R-CA) speaks to reporters outside the West Wing. REUTERS Sometimes I look at the destructive things done in the name of DEI — diversity, equity and inclusion — ... Read more »

Is Steve Buscemi God’s gift to television in ‘Miracle Workers’?

Steve Buscemi has starred in “Miracle Workers” as God and then a peasant. WireImage Actor writer director producer Steve Buscemi, who has decorated TBS’ series “Miracle Workers”: “I loved most ... Read more »

Enough with the ‘Karen’ calling — the term insults and ignores women

May has shaped up to be a real Karen-a-palooza. First, there was “Hospital Karen,” the white pregnant physician assistant at Bellevue wrongfully accused of stealing a black teen’s Citi Bike. ... Read more »

NAACP’s Florida warning: Letters to the Editor — May 24, 2023

Derrick Johnson, President and CEO of the NAACP, speaks onstage during the 54th NAACP Image Awards. Getty Images The Issue: The NAACP’s advisory that African Americans not travel to Florida ... Read more »

Hunter College freakout proves left loves violence and hates speech

The new credo of the American left is: Speech I don’t like is violence; violence I like is speech. Look no farther for proof than Hunter College adjunct Shellyne Rodriguez, ... Read more »

Shoplifters must be jailed or our cities will be destroyed

In New York City, nearly one third of shoplifting incidents that led to arrests last year were committed by the same 327 people who were taken into custody a total ... Read more »

Fresh evidence Justice is sweeping Biden family crimes under the rug

An IRS whistleblower claimed that Justice Department officials attempted to protect Hunter Biden during an investigation. AP Photo/Patrick Semansky Fresh whistleblower revelations sure make the Justice Department look to be ... Read more »

Boris Johnson tells Republicans why they must support Ukraine

Former United Kingdom Prime Minister Boris Johnson was in Dallas to make the case for continued US assistance to Ukraine to a heavily Republican crowd Monday. “I just urge you ... Read more »

Let NY grocery stores sell wine: Tell liquor-store lobby to soak off

Supermarkets and other large grocers are allowed to sell wine in 40 other states. Getty Images With the Legislature nearing the end of this year’s session, the liquor-store lobby is ... Read more »

IRS coverup of Hunter Biden could be scandal that sinks a presidency

In his “Beautiful Things” memoir, Hunter Biden wrote: “I still have a ton of work to do . . . clearing the wreckage of my past.” And Attorney General Merrick ... Read more »

Real disinfo on CRT, Tim Scott’s path to victory and other commentary

U.S. Senator Tim Scott (R-SC) announces his run for the 2024 Republican presidential nomination at a campaign event on May 22, 2023. Getty Images/Allison Joyce From the right: Real Disinfo ... Read more »

The surprising ways ‘migrant buses’ are transforming US politics

“Build the wall” hasn’t been a sentiment often heard in South Side Chicago. But someone held a sign calling for the barrier, while other residents shouted “Close the border” and ... Read more »

Big Tech promises a utopia, but delivers more takeout than innovation

Nolan the robot is very clever at weaving his way through homeless encampments. He doesn’t stop for crime scenes; just keeps trundling along regardless. Nolan is a bot on a ... Read more »

Lockdowns fostered rampant truancy in NYC public schools — drastic action is required

A new report – titled “School’s Out Forever” – gives a demographic breakdown showing chronic absenteeism is especially severe among kids of color, seniors and students with special needs. Helayne ... Read more »

The films to watch at Tribeca Film Festival: ‘Bucky F*cking Dent’ ‘The Sperm Bank,’ ‘Cinnamon’

The highly anticipated premiere of the Tubi original “Cinnamon” will take place at the 2023 Tribeca Film Festival. Tribeca Film Festival Moving images June 7. Tribeca Film Festival. David Duchovny wrote-directed ... Read more »

Why my GOP competitors should take my lead and visit America’s inner cities: Ramaswamy

Vivek Ramaswamy spoke to a crowd in the South Side of Chicago. Getty Images When I first decided to make the trip to Chicago’s South Side, my political advisers fervently ... Read more »

Sorry: Title 8 is NOT halting the madness at the border

The Biden administration’s reliance on Title 8 has been condemned as not enough to handle the migrant crisis. AFP via Getty Images Border Patrol officials report fewer illegal migrants entering ... Read more »

Biden’s indecisive Ukraine policy risks defeat and humiliation

President Joe Biden decided to provide F-16 fighters to Ukraine after months of refusal. AP/Alex Brandon Whether you’re a gung-ho supporter of American military aid to Ukraine or skeptical about ... Read more »

Fare hikes to cover for fare evaders: The cost of progressive ‘reform’

Farebeaters stole around $690 million last year, an outrageous amount and up $190 million from the year before. Paul Martinka What an insult to the law-abiding: The MTA’s looking at ... Read more »

Tim Scott says America is land for all races, and Dems hate him for it

Tim Scott formally announced his candidacy for president on Monday. Getty Images I’m a firm believer that however different someone may appear superficially, you can always find that commonality underneath ... Read more »

Any deal for migrant workers MUST include shutting the border to more

Mayor Eric Adams called on the Biden administration to expedite work permits for asylum seekers after more than 5,800 migrants arrived in the Big Apple last week. Twitter / @NYCMayorsOffice ... Read more »
Kênh kiến thức kỹ năng, phát triển bản thân, hướng nghiệp, blog nhân sự