Robert Irwin gave Pauline Hanson EXACTLY what she wanted with his extraordinary legal threat. But there's one way he could make it even worse, writes PETER VAN ONSELEN

Robert Irwin's threat to sue Pauline Hanson over a satirical cartoon image of him that she used as part of a hit job on the Queensland government is a classic case of drawing attention to something that otherwise would have largely passed without much notice.

It is known as the Streisand effect. Barbara Streisand in 2003 sought to suppress publication of a photograph that inadvertently gave away the location of her private holiday residence in Malibu. In doing so she drew national and international attention to it.

The pictures still litter the Internet today.

The One Nation leader has what she calls a 'Please Explain' cartoon series she uses to poke fun at her political opponents. It can be marginally funny, but usually it's not. I can't imagine too many people bother to check it out all that often.

The Please Explain cartoons Pauline Hanson created have led to Robert Irwin sending a legal threat to sue. Above, their depiction of Irwin and Queensland Premier Steven Miles

The Please Explain cartoons Pauline Hanson created have led to Robert Irwin sending a legal threat to sue. Above, their depiction of Irwin and Queensland Premier Steven Miles

Robert is pictured here with his former girlfriend Rorie Buckey at the GQ Australia Men of the Year Awards in Sydney on December 6

Robert is pictured here with his former girlfriend Rorie Buckey at the GQ Australia Men of the Year Awards in Sydney on December 6

But by threatening to sue Hanson for using his image, Irwin has drawn all manner of attention to the cartoon. I, for one, would never have seen it.

And to what ends and why? For using his image in a way that wasn't even treating him as the butt of the joke? Irwin was merely the vehicle for attacks on the state Labor government.

The cartoon depicts Irwin and Bluey - showing off the very best Queensland has to offer - only to be thwarted by problems with housing, youth crime and healthcare. Irwin's character says: 'I can't believe this is the state of Queensland.'

Read More

Pauline Hanson hits back at Robert Irwin over his inclusion in One Nation cartoon featuring Bluey

article image

Honestly, the young fellow should think twice before instructing solicitors to send a letter of demand. It really is a perfect example of the Streisand effect right here in Australia.

The wildlife advocate and reality TV star - and his lawyers, for that matter - don't seem to understand the cartoon series is an example of satire and parody, creating a much higher hurdle to jump over when seeking to prove defamatory imputations.

I'm no lawyer, but what exactly was defamatory about the budget animation anyway? That Irwin would partake in a skit about Queensland without receiving a handsome fee for doing so? He doesn't want others to think they too can use his image without the dollars rolling in?

Perhaps I should sue Irwin for forcing me to write an article defending Pauline Hanson - not exactly my bread and butter.

A few years back, Sky News host Chris Kenny successfully threatened defamation against the ABC over a Chaser skit in which he was the butt of the joke and their characterisation of him was vulgar.

Pauline Hanson (pictured) won't mind the attention that Irwin's legal threat is giving her

Pauline Hanson (pictured) won't mind the attention that Irwin's legal threat is giving her

Robert Irwin (pictured) sent Pauline Hanson a 'please explain' legal threat over her cartoon

Robert Irwin (pictured) sent Pauline Hanson a 'please explain' legal threat over her cartoon

The public broadcaster apologised and paid out an undisclosed sum, even though the Chaser team certainly wasn't happy about it.

But the Irwin case is very different.

For someone who makes a living out of being a good bloke and Aussie larrikin in touch with the common folk, calling for lawyers at 30 paces doesn't necessarily fit with the public image he's is going for.

And what did he think Pauline was going to do when she received the letter? Capitulate and fall over herself to say sorry? He clearly doesn't know much about Hanson's history in politics over the last three decades.

She thrives on free media attention and controversy to prop up her minor party's capacity to get re-elected, picking fights with anyone and everyone who aligns themselves to lawfare and intimidation.

Unfortunately for Irwin, he has given Hanson exactly what she wanted in this instance. The only way he could make a bad situation even worse for himself would be to double down and follow through with his threats.

Suing Hanson would be just the sort of media circus she would enjoy in the run-up to Queensland and Federal elections, and he would be damaged by the attention, not her. And that's regardless of whether he wins or loses in court.

OTHER NEWS

14 minutes ago

Entire state of Virginia under drought warning - as farmers predict first crop failures in 10 years

15 minutes ago

2024 Rocket Mortgage Classic odds, picks, field: Surprising predictions by golf model that's called 13 majors

15 minutes ago

Moses caps off stellar return

15 minutes ago

I’m a GP – this is how to solve the UK’s appointment crisis

15 minutes ago

Jason Kelce explains why he was 'literally tearing up' while attending 'Eras Tour' with wife Kylie

15 minutes ago

LVMH’s Bernard Arnault got a letter from 93-year-old Warren Buffett saying he was making a mistake by upping his retirement age to only 80

15 minutes ago

The DA’s bid for 12 Cabinet positions sparks controversy on Twitter

15 minutes ago

Central Queensland hit with a month's worth of rain in just one day

15 minutes ago

'I do think it’s going to be his toughest challenge'

15 minutes ago

Ziggy Marley Posts Rare Photo of Mom Rita, Calls Her 'My Strength'

15 minutes ago

GNU: ANC slams DA over selfish demands during negotiations

15 minutes ago

Bruce Whitfield is leaving Primedia to start new venture

15 minutes ago

Travis Kelce's gesture to Taylor Swift at London show is 'motivating' and 'inspiring'

15 minutes ago

Soccer club ordered to invite in Traveller children after turning away boys aged 8 and 9

15 minutes ago

Royal Mail raid to deliver nearly £150m in fees to bankers and lawyers

15 minutes ago

Jason Kelce Says He Wanted to Retire Every Year for the Last 4 Seasons but 'Still Had It in Me' (Exclusive)

15 minutes ago

Latimer Beats Bowman in Pricey NY Primary Shaped by Gaza War

15 minutes ago

LVMH boss Bernard Arnault reportedly buys stake in Cartier owner, sparking takeover rumors

15 minutes ago

The original Resident Evil trilogy is re-releasing on PC free of DRM on GOG, with the first title being available right now

15 minutes ago

Barcelona come up with new plan for Ansu Fati

15 minutes ago

'Many Accolades' in Graham Barton's Bucs Future

15 minutes ago

Single woman shares she's searching for a serious relationship

15 minutes ago

New England Patriots DL Addresses Contract Dispute on Social Media

15 minutes ago

'It Never Gets Old Looking At This': Auston Matthews Featured in New Fanatics Maple Leafs Jersey Reveal by NHL (PHOTOS)

15 minutes ago

A Mistake in the 1970s Still Haunts Supreme Court Ethics

15 minutes ago

Proteas hope cricket gods will keep smiling on them

15 minutes ago

New photos show Trump's 'haphazard' storage of classified documents, special counsel says

15 minutes ago

Crypto industry super PAC is 33-2 in primaries, with $100 million for House, Senate races

17 minutes ago

Glastonbury festival kicks off as thousands stream in

19 minutes ago

55-year-old Americans are ‘critically underprepared' for retirement, survey finds

19 minutes ago

U.S. Rep. Troy Nehls defends military record amid badge scandal

19 minutes ago

Feds charge 5, including man acquitted at trial, for attempting to bribe Minnesota juror with $120K

19 minutes ago

What to know about the Volkswagen-Rivian partnership

19 minutes ago

NHL and Fanatics unveil new jerseys for the 2024-25 season

19 minutes ago

Feds charge five, including man acquitted at trial, for attempting to bribe Minnesota juror with $120K in cash

19 minutes ago

Alex Morgan off USA Olympics women's soccer team as era ends

19 minutes ago

Bahrain human rights activist granted British citizenship after three year delay

19 minutes ago

Morgan left out of U.S. soccer squad, likely ending international career

23 minutes ago

Sailing at the 2024 Olympics: What to know, rules, schedule

23 minutes ago

Volkswagen recalls over 271,000 SUVs because front passenger air bag may not inflate in a crash