The Hidden Costs of Living in Shrinking Cities

Lake Charles, Louisiana

Living in a city experiencing a population decline comes with a unique set of challenges that can significantly impact residents’ quality of life and financial stability. According to Michael Broadway, published to Rural Insights recently in 2024, noted, “The decade between 2010 and 2020 was the slowest period of US population growth since the Great Depression of the 1930s. The primary cause: a falling birth rate.” While some might find lower housing prices and less congestion appealing, the hidden costs of living in shrinking cities often outweigh these perceived benefits. Here are some of the critical issues residents face in these declining urban areas, supported by data from recent studies and reports.

Expert Advice: I’m an Economist: Here Are My Predictions for Inflation If Biden Wins Again

Try This: Become a Real Estate Investor for Just $1K Using This Bezos-Backed Startup

Economic Decline

As people leave a city, businesses often follow suit. With a shrinking customer base, local businesses struggle to stay afloat, leading to closures and a reduced job market. This economic downturn can create a vicious cycle where the lack of job opportunities drives more residents to leave, further exacerbating the city’s decline. For example, St. Louis, Missouri, experienced a population decline of 4.62% between 2020-2022, significantly impacting its economic landscape.

Key Impact: Limited job opportunities and business closures reduce economic vitality, making it harder for remaining residents to find employment and essential services.

Find Out: Here’s How Much the Definition of Middle Class Has Changed in Every State

Decreased Property Values

One of the most immediate effects of population decline is the drop in property values. As demand for housing decreases, so do property prices. This can be a double-edged sword; while housing becomes more affordable, homeowners see the value of their investments plummet. In extreme cases, this can lead to homeowners abandoning properties they can no longer sell, contributing to urban blight. San Francisco, California, saw a population decline of 7.11% between 2020-2022, leading to significant decreases in property values.

Key Impact: Falling property values reduce homeowner equity and can lead to increased vacancies and neighborhood decline.

Strain on Public Services

With fewer residents contributing to the tax base, cities face budget shortfalls that can lead to cuts in essential services such as public safety, education, and infrastructure maintenance. Schools may struggle to maintain programs and staff, and public transportation systems might reduce routes and frequency, further isolating residents. For instance, New York City experienced a population decline of 4.63% between 2020-2022, putting pressure on its extensive public service systems.

Key Impact: Reduced public services diminish the quality of life and can make the city less attractive to potential new residents.

Infrastructure Deterioration

Maintaining infrastructure like roads, bridges, and public buildings becomes increasingly difficult as the population declines. With fewer people to share the tax burden, necessary repairs and upgrades are often delayed or canceled, leading to deteriorating conditions that can pose safety hazards. Lake Charles, Louisiana, which saw a 6.78% decline in population, faces significant challenges in maintaining its infrastructure.

Key Impact: Deteriorating infrastructure can increase commute times, damage vehicles, and pose safety risks to residents.

Increased Social Isolation

As the population dwindles, social networks can fragment, leading to increased feelings of isolation among remaining residents. This can be particularly challenging for the elderly and other vulnerable populations who rely on community support and social services. Revere City, Massachusetts, with a population decline of 5.39%, has experienced increased social isolation among its residents.

Key Impact: Increased social isolation can negatively impact mental health and reduce community cohesion.

Higher Cost of Living

While housing costs might decrease, other living expenses can rise. Utilities, for example, often become more expensive per capita as the fixed costs of maintaining services are spread across fewer people. Additionally, residents might have to travel farther for work, shopping, and healthcare, increasing transportation costs. In Jackson, Mississippi, which topped the list with a 2.5% population decline, residents face higher costs for basic services.

Key Impact: Unexpected increases in utility and transportation costs can strain household budgets.

Political and Social Consequences

Declining populations can shift the political landscape, often resulting in reduced representation at the state and federal levels. This can limit the city’s influence in securing funding and support for revitalization efforts. Additionally, shrinking cities often experience heightened political and social tensions as residents and leaders grapple with the realities of decline. For example, the political impact of population decline is significant in cities like St. Louis and New Orleans.

Key Impact: Reduced political clout and increased social tensions can hinder efforts to address the challenges of population decline.

Conclusion

Living in a shrinking city presents numerous hidden costs that can significantly impact residents’ financial stability, quality of life, and overall well-being. While lower housing prices might seem like an advantage, the broader economic, social, and infrastructural challenges often outweigh these benefits. Understanding these hidden costs is crucial for anyone considering moving to or continuing to live in a declining urban area. Addressing these challenges requires coordinated efforts from community leaders, policymakers, and residents to create sustainable solutions and support the city’s revitalization.

Editor's note: This article was produced via automated technology and then fine-tuned and verified for accuracy by a member of GOBankingRates' editorial team.

More From GOBankingRates

This article originally appeared on GOBankingRates.com: The Hidden Costs of Living in Shrinking Cities