The single clue that could crack the Samantha Murphy case wide open - as expert reveals what could be on her phone

A leading criminologist believes Samantha Murphy's phone could reveal her final movements after the device was found in perfect working condition beside a dam.

Victoria Police search crews last week discovered Ms Murphy's iPhone in the mud on the water's edge at Buninyong, about 19km from her Ballarat home.

She was last seen leaving her Eureka St house in Ballarat about 7am on February 4 to go for a 14km run through the nearby Woowookarung Regional Park.

The device, protected by a teal-covered case, is undamaged and in working condition with investigators hoping it could lead to the discovery of her body.

Dr Xanthe Mallett, a criminologist from the University of Newcastle, said she was 'surprised' to hear the phone was in working condition.

'The police were searching for it obviously for almost four months, something took them to that dam,' she told Seven's Sunrise on Tuesday.

Dr Xanthe Mallett, a criminologist from the University of Newcastle, said she was 'surprised' to hear the phone was in working condition (pictured on Sunrise on Tuesday morning)

Dr Xanthe Mallett, a criminologist from the University of Newcastle, said she was 'surprised' to hear the phone was in working condition (pictured on Sunrise on Tuesday morning)

Victoria Police search crews last week discovered Ms Murphy's iPhone in the mud on the water's edge at Buninyong, about 19km from her Ballarat home (pictured)

Victoria Police search crews last week discovered Ms Murphy's iPhone in the mud on the water's edge at Buninyong, about 19km from her Ballarat home (pictured)

'That hasn't been disclosed what evidence or intelligence that was yet, but yes, this could absolutely offer new clues that will help find Samantha.

'As we know now, it is operational and downloadable.'

Dr Mallett told the program that a phone that had been underwater or in mud for four months would be 'beyond retrievable'.

'So does that indicate that it hasn't been there for the entire four months?' she said.

'That's yet to be seen. But it's that timeline that the police will be working on and it's certainly going to be essential in helping to develop that.'

She said the police would get as much information from the phone as possible.

'I think that there may be potentially more witnesses that may come forward because we now know about that dam, we know the phone is there,' she said.

'So I'm hoping that now that information is public, other people may come forward and offer information as to who may have dumped that phone and when.

'You have to commend the investigators that have worked so hard on this.

'You can see the relief and almost celebration. I know we're not at the end of this investigation yet, but it's a huge development.'

The mother-of-three was last seen leaving her Eureka St house in Ballarat about 7am to go for a 14km run through the nearby Woowookarung Regional Park

The mother-of-three was last seen leaving her Eureka St house in Ballarat about 7am to go for a 14km run through the nearby Woowookarung Regional Park

Cybersecurity expert Nigel Phair previously said results from the forensic tests could lead to a major breakthrough.

'The physical properties of the phone will obviously be damaged but what's behind it, those ones and zeros of data, will be retrievable,' he said.

'This is the game changer for the investigation.'

The device was found close to where it last made contact with a nearby tower in the Buninyong region before going silent.

The phone is believed to have been submerged in the dam since February 4 - the very day police allege Patrick Orren Stephenson, 22, murdered Ms Murphy while she was out on a Sunday jog.

Daily Mail Australia was told this week Missing Persons Unit detectives had been suspicious of the dam soon after taking charge of the investigation, questioning its owner just weeks later.

Read More

How the baffling mystery of Samantha Murphy's disappearance is starting to unravel as a new clue firms up theory on where her body was dumped

article image

Police would not return until early May when they asked the owner again if he would mind police entering his property.

Three weeks passed before Wednesday's search turned up the phone.

The location of the dam sits just around the corner from the Durham Lead Nature Conservation Reserve, which search crews descended upon on April 12. The dam had been at its lowest since the heat of summer in December.

The owner of the dam, who wished to remain anonymous, suggested police had no specific information the phone had been discarded there.

It comes as Stephenson hired top criminal defence lawyer Paul Galbally from Melbourne-based law firm Galbally O'Bryan.

Mr Galbally represented the late Catholic Cardinal George Pell, who had his conviction for historic child abuse charges overturned by the High Court.

He has previously said he is not uncomfortable acting for individuals accused of the most serious crimes.

'You either have a disposition or a personality that can deal with this work or you don't,' he said in a 2009 interview.

The Galbally O’Bryan website states Mr Galbally has 'run some of the country’s largest and most complex criminal cases'.

'His experience includes representing clients before public inquiries, royal commissions and in defence of Australian Securities and Investments Commission prosecutions,' the website adds.

'Paul is recognised throughout the legal profession for his judgment, sound strategic advice and discretion and is featured in Doyles Guide as one of Australia’s pre-eminent criminal defence lawyers.'

More to come.

OTHER NEWS

18 minutes ago

I’m a Self-Made Millionaire and Digital Nomad: 3 Best Places for Freelancers To Live Abroad

18 minutes ago

Small town residents protest as first migrant families arrive

18 minutes ago

Dog saved from river rock amid monsoon floods in India

18 minutes ago

Treasurer approves ANZ-Suncorp merger

18 minutes ago

28 People — Myself Included — Who Didn't Know The "Unusual" Things Their Bodies Do Are, In Fact, "Not Normal" After All

18 minutes ago

Padres News: How a Mistaken Phone Call Landed a Key Player for San Diego

18 minutes ago

Two pandas are preparing to head to San Diego Zoo from China

21 minutes ago

Watch: Bronny James learns of Lakers taking him in NBA draft, teaming up with dad LeBron James

23 minutes ago

Asia-Pacific markets rise as investors assess Japan economic data and await U.S. inflation reading

23 minutes ago

Presidential debate live updates: Biden and Trump arrive in Atlanta

23 minutes ago

Video: Moment fire rips through flat in Woolwich high rise causing huge emergency response and 10 engines to rush to the scene

23 minutes ago

Video: Uber customer wants action after he and his wife were terrified by a Sydney driver who tailgated another motorist then got in a fight on Western Distributor

23 minutes ago

Video: Anthony Joshua 'threatens Daniel Dubois with a CHAIR' as the pair nearly come to blows in ill-tempered sit-down interview to announce September 21 bout at Wembley, with security forced to intervene

23 minutes ago

Universal Studios’ Halloween Horror Nights Conjures ‘Ghostbusters’-Themed Haunted Houses In Hollywood And Orlando

26 minutes ago

Rare Gilded Age mansion on Upper East Side hits market for $65M

27 minutes ago

Supreme Court ruling on presidential immunity to be announced

27 minutes ago

A Family Affair review – Nicole Kidman’s hot age-gap romance quickly goes cold

27 minutes ago

Missing Jay Slater's mum confirms GoFundMe funds being withdrawn in major update

27 minutes ago

LIA announces 2024 Creative Strategy and Transformative Business Impact jury

27 minutes ago

Italian PM accuses European leaders of acting like 'oligarchs'

27 minutes ago

Uvalde school police chief indicted over mass shooting that left 19 children and two teachers dead

28 minutes ago

Custodians of the Hajj — who's to blame for heat-related deaths?

28 minutes ago

Research and innovation key to safeguarding SA’s health resiliency

28 minutes ago

Julian Assange's wife visits Australia's Parliament House to thank lawmakers

28 minutes ago

House prices in these pandemic hotspots are set to nosedive

28 minutes ago

2024 NHL Awards Tracker: Full list of winners

28 minutes ago

Broncos sit all three Origin stars out of NZ trip

28 minutes ago

After inflation jumped, a rate rise became more likely. Could the government's political fortunes be on the line?

28 minutes ago

Panama strike late to beat 10-man United States

28 minutes ago

India set to lure billions of dollars more inflows as JPMorgan bond inclusion begins

32 minutes ago

Sports Illustrated predicts Bears make playoffs in 2024. Read their explanation why

32 minutes ago

Monster 220-pound fish caught in New York's Hudson River

32 minutes ago

Junior Boks name three debutants for U20 Championship opener against Fiji

32 minutes ago

Konta 'almost bit off own tongue' at Wimbledon

32 minutes ago

Orlando Pirates have announced that midfielder Miguel Timm has signed an extension at the club

32 minutes ago

Sinkhole swallows up soccer fields in Illinois park

32 minutes ago

Knicks take Tyler Kolek after trading up in second round of 2024 NBA Draft

32 minutes ago

Video: Alec Baldwin plays a logger who learns his new employee has a dark past in the new trailer for Lionsgate's Clear Cut... after it was revealed he'll stand trial for Rust shooting

37 minutes ago

Bolivian President Luis Arce denies being behind the attempted coup and says the general acted 'on his own'

37 minutes ago

Trevor Lawrence, wife announce they are expecting first child after $275 million contract extension