Lawsuit seeks to block Washington parental rights law that critics call a 'forced outing' measure

Lawsuit seeks to block Washington parental rights law that critics call a 'forced outing' measure

Lawsuit seeks to block Washington parental rights law that critics call a 'forced outing' measure

Youth services and civil rights groups are suing to block a new Washington state parental rights law that is set to take effect next month

ByGENE JOHNSON Associated Press

May 23, 2024, 6:12 PM

    SEATTLE -- A group of youth services organizations, a school district, a counselor and others sued Thursday to block a new Washington state parental rights law that critics describe as a “forced outing” measure.

    A conservative megadonor backed the law, which is set to take effect in June. The Democratic-led Legislature overwhelmingly approved it, with progressive lawmakers wanting to keep it off the fall ballot while calculating that courts would likely block it.

    Known as Initiative 2081, the law requires schools to notify parents in advance of medical services offered to their child, except in emergencies, and of medical treatment arranged by the school resulting in follow-up care beyond normal hours. It grants parents the right to review their child’s medical and counseling records and expands cases where parents can opt their child out of sex education.

    That could jeopardize students who want to access birth control, referrals for reproductive services, counseling related to their gender identity or sexual orientation, or other sensitive topics through school clinics without their parents knowing, critics say.

    The fight is the latest iteration of a long-running, nationwide battle over how much say parents have in the schooling of their children. Many parents have joined a conservative movement pushing states to give them more oversight of schools, including over library books and course material, transgender students’ use of school bathrooms, and the instruction of topics related to race, sexual orientation and gender identity.

    Most of the rights Initiative 2081 granted to parents were already covered by state or federal law, but in some cases it expanded them.

    Minors do not need parental permission to get an abortion in Washington, and state law gives those 14 and older the right to get tested or treated for sexually transmitted diseases without their parents' consent. Those 13 and older have the right to outpatient behavioral health treatment.

    “Initiative 2081 is a forced outing law that will harm LGBTQ+ students if implemented in our schools,” Denise Diskin, an attorney for QLaw Foundation, said in a written statement. “LGBTQ+ students seek out safe and trusted school staff when they don’t have a supportive home, and the affirmation they receive can be life-saving."

    Brian Heywood, a conservative hedge fund manager who finances the Let's Go Washington political action committee, said the lawsuit seeks to “trample the rights of parents.” The measure, he said, isn’t designed to give parents veto power over their child’s decision to access counseling or medical treatment: “It’s just saying they have a right to know.”

    “The lawsuit is a frivolous but not surprising attempt to legislate through lawsuit rather than through the democratic process,” he said.

    He also noted that schools would not be required to turn over medical records to parents who are under investigation for child abuse or neglect.

    In Washington, citizen initiatives that garner enough signatures can be directed to the Legislature. Lawmakers can then pass them, let voters decide or offer voters an alternative measure. Heywood's group pushed six initiatives this year, including ones that would overturn the state’s capital gains tax and its climate law, which established a “cap and invest” carbon market.

    Democrats in the Legislature passed three of Heywood's measures, giving themselves a better chance to focus on defeating the three they considered most objectionable at the ballot box this fall.

    Those challenging the law object to it on the merits. But one of their attorneys, Adrien Leavitt of the American Civil Liberties Union of Washington, said the crux of the lawsuit rests on a procedural matter. The Washington Constitution requires that new laws not revise or revoke old laws without explicitly saying so, but Leavitt said this initiative does so in several cases.

    For example, state law ensures the privacy of medical records for young people authorized to receive care without parental consent. The measure would give parents the right to be notified before their child receives care and the ability to review school medical records, Leavitt said, but it does not specifically say that it amends the existing privacy law.

    One of the plaintiffs, the South Whidbey School District, on Whidbey Island north of Seattle, said in a resolution adopted by the school board Wednesday that the law "negatively affects the rights of youth in Washington state, including LGBTQ+ youth, youth of color, youth survivors of sexual and domestic violence, and youth seeking reproductive health care and gender affirming care.”

    Others who brought the lawsuit filed in Kings County Superior Court include an unnamed Seattle parent of a nonbinary child; Kari Lombard, a psychiatric nurse-practitioner and former West Seattle High School nurse; and several organizations dedicated to the rights of LGBTQ+ or young people.

    OTHER NEWS

    9 minutes ago

    Jim Cramer says investors should stick with Nvidia post decline

    13 minutes ago

    The Tory record on welfare: PIP changes, child poverty and pensioner protection

    13 minutes ago

    'Long lasting legacy': Cricket icon dies aged 84

    14 minutes ago

    Tom Hanks and Robin Wright have a de-aged “Forrest Gump ”reunion in first “Here” photos

    14 minutes ago

    Rashid Khan's post with Rohit Sharma confirms India-Afghanistan joint force to knock Australia out of T20 World Cup

    14 minutes ago

    Jets Send Message to Roster After Tae Hayes' Release

    14 minutes ago

    Brooks: Five WRs with best shot at breaking Megatron's single-season receiving yards record in '24 'The Insiders'

    14 minutes ago

    ‘Everyone adores him’: fans watch England’s Jude Bellingham in his home town

    14 minutes ago

    Where do the 49ers rank in pre-camp power rankings?

    14 minutes ago

    Social media bans are unlikely to work. So how can we keep young people safe online?

    14 minutes ago

    FDA warns maker of Sara Lee and Entenmann's not to claim foods contain allergens when they don't

    14 minutes ago

    South Korea’s military says North Korea’s latest missile test likely ended in failure

    14 minutes ago

    Federal regulators warn major US baker: Stop saying foods contain allergens when they don't

    14 minutes ago

    Israel's courts say the military must enlist the ultra-Orthodox. What could that mean for Netanyahu?

    14 minutes ago

    US military delivers supplies to Gaza via pier, but there's no one to distribute them

    15 minutes ago

    Woman injured in Fort Worth arrest, police investigating use of force

    15 minutes ago

    Chemical burn-off was not necessary after Ohio train derailment, NTSB concludes

    16 minutes ago

    Illinois and Midwest athletes to watch at the 2024 US Gymnastics Olympic Trials

    16 minutes ago

    Groundbreaking KABC-TV Executive Tom Van Amburg Has Passed Away At Age 83

    18 minutes ago

    Video: Cardi B gets a surprise ear piercing while splurging at upscale jewelry shop in LA: 'I came here for one thing!'

    18 minutes ago

    Video: 'It's inevitable the house is going to go': Rapidan Dam disaster forces family to flee home of 50 years as staggering image shows it hanging on cliff edge

    19 minutes ago

    NYC’s East Village has gone back in time to the bad old days of ‘Rent’

    20 minutes ago

    Ken Bruce makes major dig at BBC admitting it was a 'privilege' to move on

    20 minutes ago

    Chelsea pushing to sign exciting Olise alternative who's a "pace demon"

    20 minutes ago

    Labour ‘will change the law to officially declare Iran’s Revolutionary Guard a terrorist group’

    20 minutes ago

    Chiefs will be featured in Hallmark film 'Holiday Touchdown: A Chiefs Love Story'

    20 minutes ago

    Chelsea make decision over Nico Williams transfer amid Arsenal interest

    20 minutes ago

    Stephen Nolan: Lawsuit filed against individual journalist ‘feels like attempt to intimidate and silence’

    20 minutes ago

    Haitians wary as Kenyan police arrive on latest US-backed mission

    21 minutes ago

    Princess Diana’s Family Home Won’t Be Going to Prince Harry or Prince William

    21 minutes ago

    Taylor Swift and Travis Kelce inspire Hallmark romance film in partnership with Kansas City Chiefs

    21 minutes ago

    Volkswagen to Invest Up to $5 Billion Into EV Maker Rivian

    21 minutes ago

    Billy Ray Cyrus accusing estranged wife Firerose of abuse

    21 minutes ago

    Tori Spelling sneaked off to get breast augmentation at strip mall surgery

    21 minutes ago

    Jonathan Toews lists his Lincoln Park penthouse condo for $4.7 million: Report

    21 minutes ago

    Additional charges filed against couple accused of creating videos of children using hidden cameras

    21 minutes ago

    HISD gives tour of campuses they aim to rebuild if $4.4B bond proposal is approved

    21 minutes ago

    NBA Rumors: Latest on free agency, Paul George, Brandon Ingram and more

    21 minutes ago

    Sean Penn and Robin Wright took ‘quite a while’ to repair friendship post-divorce

    24 minutes ago

    Stock futures are little changed after S&P 500 ends three-day decline: Live updates