Lawsuit seeks to block Washington parental rights law that critics call a 'forced outing' measure

Lawsuit seeks to block Washington parental rights law that critics call a 'forced outing' measure

Lawsuit seeks to block Washington parental rights law that critics call a 'forced outing' measure

Youth services and civil rights groups are suing to block a new Washington state parental rights law that is set to take effect next month

ByGENE JOHNSON Associated Press

May 23, 2024, 6:12 PM

    SEATTLE -- A group of youth services organizations, a school district, a counselor and others sued Thursday to block a new Washington state parental rights law that critics describe as a “forced outing” measure.

    A conservative megadonor backed the law, which is set to take effect in June. The Democratic-led Legislature overwhelmingly approved it, with progressive lawmakers wanting to keep it off the fall ballot while calculating that courts would likely block it.

    Known as Initiative 2081, the law requires schools to notify parents in advance of medical services offered to their child, except in emergencies, and of medical treatment arranged by the school resulting in follow-up care beyond normal hours. It grants parents the right to review their child’s medical and counseling records and expands cases where parents can opt their child out of sex education.

    That could jeopardize students who want to access birth control, referrals for reproductive services, counseling related to their gender identity or sexual orientation, or other sensitive topics through school clinics without their parents knowing, critics say.

    The fight is the latest iteration of a long-running, nationwide battle over how much say parents have in the schooling of their children. Many parents have joined a conservative movement pushing states to give them more oversight of schools, including over library books and course material, transgender students’ use of school bathrooms, and the instruction of topics related to race, sexual orientation and gender identity.

    Most of the rights Initiative 2081 granted to parents were already covered by state or federal law, but in some cases it expanded them.

    Minors do not need parental permission to get an abortion in Washington, and state law gives those 14 and older the right to get tested or treated for sexually transmitted diseases without their parents' consent. Those 13 and older have the right to outpatient behavioral health treatment.

    “Initiative 2081 is a forced outing law that will harm LGBTQ+ students if implemented in our schools,” Denise Diskin, an attorney for QLaw Foundation, said in a written statement. “LGBTQ+ students seek out safe and trusted school staff when they don’t have a supportive home, and the affirmation they receive can be life-saving."

    Brian Heywood, a conservative hedge fund manager who finances the Let's Go Washington political action committee, said the lawsuit seeks to “trample the rights of parents.” The measure, he said, isn’t designed to give parents veto power over their child’s decision to access counseling or medical treatment: “It’s just saying they have a right to know.”

    “The lawsuit is a frivolous but not surprising attempt to legislate through lawsuit rather than through the democratic process,” he said.

    He also noted that schools would not be required to turn over medical records to parents who are under investigation for child abuse or neglect.

    In Washington, citizen initiatives that garner enough signatures can be directed to the Legislature. Lawmakers can then pass them, let voters decide or offer voters an alternative measure. Heywood's group pushed six initiatives this year, including ones that would overturn the state’s capital gains tax and its climate law, which established a “cap and invest” carbon market.

    Democrats in the Legislature passed three of Heywood's measures, giving themselves a better chance to focus on defeating the three they considered most objectionable at the ballot box this fall.

    Those challenging the law object to it on the merits. But one of their attorneys, Adrien Leavitt of the American Civil Liberties Union of Washington, said the crux of the lawsuit rests on a procedural matter. The Washington Constitution requires that new laws not revise or revoke old laws without explicitly saying so, but Leavitt said this initiative does so in several cases.

    For example, state law ensures the privacy of medical records for young people authorized to receive care without parental consent. The measure would give parents the right to be notified before their child receives care and the ability to review school medical records, Leavitt said, but it does not specifically say that it amends the existing privacy law.

    One of the plaintiffs, the South Whidbey School District, on Whidbey Island north of Seattle, said in a resolution adopted by the school board Wednesday that the law "negatively affects the rights of youth in Washington state, including LGBTQ+ youth, youth of color, youth survivors of sexual and domestic violence, and youth seeking reproductive health care and gender affirming care.”

    Others who brought the lawsuit filed in Kings County Superior Court include an unnamed Seattle parent of a nonbinary child; Kari Lombard, a psychiatric nurse-practitioner and former West Seattle High School nurse; and several organizations dedicated to the rights of LGBTQ+ or young people.

    OTHER NEWS

    22 minutes ago

    Everything To Know About The Pontiac Banshee, And What Made It So Unique

    25 minutes ago

    Gentle giant: Great Dane in the US named Kevin recognised by Guinness as world’s tallest dog

    25 minutes ago

    No one will bet on us against Germany, says Hungary coach Rossi

    25 minutes ago

    Celebrity chef Gordon Ramsay speaks out after ‘really bad’ biking accident

    27 minutes ago

    What is the outlook for CBA shares in FY25?

    27 minutes ago

    Met Office Sunday Afternoon Weather Forecast 16/06/2024

    27 minutes ago

    Millions take holy dip in different rivers in UP on Ganga Dussehra

    27 minutes ago

    How to watch Poland vs Netherlands for FREE: TV channel and live stream for Euro 2024 game today

    27 minutes ago

    Editorial: Cruelty to animals must be punished

    27 minutes ago

    How tax-free income and the personal allowance work

    27 minutes ago

    Sweet moment Kate Middleton and Princess Charlotte try to wipe away the condensation on their carriage window during Trooping the Colour

    27 minutes ago

    'Phil Foden's on fire - he'll be playing the Germans off the park': England fans' hilarious new song set to Bruce Springsteen's 'Dancing in the Dark' ahead of Euros clash with Serbia

    30 minutes ago

    Catherine Laga’aia joins Dwayne Johnson as Moana in live-action film slated for July 2026

    32 minutes ago

    German police shoot axeman near Euros fan zone during Dutch supporters march in Hamburg after he attacked officers

    32 minutes ago

    It's easy to believe young voters could back Trump at young conservative conference

    32 minutes ago

    Protectors, confidants, supporters: readers share stories of the dads that shaped them

    32 minutes ago

    Destination weddings: Are they cost-effective as travel becomes pricier?

    35 minutes ago

    Jose Riveiro: Orlando Pirates’ three points against 14th team must have same importance as a derby

    35 minutes ago

    Virgin Atlantic chief: ‘Jews are enduring a difficult period in Britain’

    35 minutes ago

    'Fabulous' River Island top and skirt co-ord is giving 'perfect summer vibes'

    35 minutes ago

    Orlando Pirates: Top target signs from PSL Rivals!

    36 minutes ago

    Lions fullback Quan taking the Bok by the Horns

    36 minutes ago

    Rangers submit strong offer to sign 21 y/o player ahead of Wayne Rooney

    36 minutes ago

    Self-care: why looking after No 1 isn’t always best for your wellbeing

    36 minutes ago

    Report: Donovan Mitchell Doesn’t Want Cavaliers To Trade Jarrett Allen

    36 minutes ago

    This Under-the-Radar Vacation Shop Has Linen Shorts, Maxi Dresses, and More Starting at $10

    37 minutes ago

    Telethon Mega Bingo: Emotional winner Kelly Nawal Bland goes from bushfire horror to winning major cash prize

    37 minutes ago

    ST subscribers and their kids become beekeepers for the day at bee workshop

    37 minutes ago

    Video: BYD Seal electric vehicle owner's embarrassing mistake on Perth's City Beach

    37 minutes ago

    Video: Footy star fights back tears as he reveals devastating personal news in emotional post-match interview

    37 minutes ago

    Kate Middleton embraced late Queen's 'stoicism and calm' as she showed 'confident determination, reassurance and support' during Trooping the Colour, body language expert claims

    37 minutes ago

    DEAR JANE: I fell head over heels in love with a man I met online - but when we met in person for the first time I was HORRIFIED

    37 minutes ago

    Late singer Zahara’s sisters also selling her awards

    37 minutes ago

    Brian Tee Has One Huge Condition To Return As Chicago Med's Dr. Ethan Choi

    40 minutes ago

    Mystery of how Stonehenge was formed deepens as new theory emerge

    44 minutes ago

    Location behind Kate Middleton's touching Father's Day photo of Prince William and their children is revealed

    44 minutes ago

    Virgil van Dijk is 12/1 with Sky Bet to score a header - as Netherlands battle Poland in their Euro 2024 opener in Hamburg today

    44 minutes ago

    Hippy-crack driver, 24, who killed cyclist, 56, as he inhaled laughing gas from a balloon while driving BMW with his knees is jailed - as horrific CCTV shows moment car knocks down nurse

    44 minutes ago

    New video shows England fan 'leading' chorus of '10 German Bombers' in the streets of Dusseldorf ahead of Three Lions clash with Serbia - defying police and FA warnings to fans

    44 minutes ago

    'Hardest Geezer' Russ Cook arrives in Germany for Euros after running 352 miles to support England - and predicts Three Lions victory over Serbia