Supreme Court's Contradicting Its Own Rulings, Justices Say

supreme court's contradicting its own rulings, justices say

Justices of the US Supreme Court pose for their official photo at the Supreme Court in Washington, DC on October 7, 2022.

Conservative U.S. Supreme Court Justice Neil Gorsuch and liberal Justice Elena Kagan joined liberal Justice Ketanji Brown Jackson in dissenting in a case involving drug and firearm convictions filed Thursday, arguing that the court is contradicting its own rulings in the majority opinion.

Brown v. United States centers around the question of whether a state drug conviction qualifies as a "serious drug offense," under the Armed Career Criminal Act (ACCA), if the drug involved was listed as a controlled substance under federal law when the crime occurred but the drug was later removed from the list.

The ACCA imposes a 15-year mandatory minimum sentence for anyone who has been convicted for the illegal possession of a firearm and has a criminal history that exhibits a tendency for violence, which includes three previous convictions for a serious drug offense.

The Supreme Court upheld lower-court decisions on Thursday, arguing that a state drug conviction is a qualification for the ACCA's mandatory minimum sentence if the drug was listed as a controlled substance under federal law at the time of the defendant's conviction of the drug crime, even if the drug was later removed from the list.

A 2011 Supreme Court ruling in McNeill v. United States was used to support the majority opinion, which was delivered by conservative Justice Samuel Alito. Chief Justice John Roberts, Justice Clarence Thomas, Justice Brett Kavanaugh and Justice Amy Coney Barrett—all of whom are conservative-leaning—joined Alito in the opinion, as did liberal Justice Sonia Sotomayor.

"As we explained in McNeill, ACCA requires sentencing courts to examine the law as it was when the defendant violated it, even if that law is subsequently amended," the majority opinion read.

However, the dissenting opinion, filed by Jackson, argued that "McNeill asked what state crime the defendant committed, while today's cases ask how ACCA assesses that conviction," adding that "the majority's opinion not only misconstrues McNeill, it also flatly contradicts other precedents from this Court outlining how to determine whether a prior state conviction qualifies as an ACCA predicate."

"As the majority only scantly mentions, to determine whether a state crime is a 'serious drug offense,' courts are not supposed to rely on the actual or alleged facts related to the prior state drug crime. Rather, they ask 'if the State's definition of the drug in question 'matche[s]' the definition under federal law,'" the dissenting opinion read, citing Shular v. United States, a 2020 ruling from the court.

Gorsuch joined Parts I, II and III of Jackson's dissenting opinion but not Part IV. The quotes above from the dissenting opinion are from Part III.

Newsweek reached out to the Supreme Court via email for comment.

Start your unlimited Newsweek trial

OTHER NEWS

17 minutes ago

New Jersey gamer flew to Florida to attack online rival with hammer, police say

17 minutes ago

Family of Afro Indigenous activist in immigration detention worries he may be deported back to danger

19 minutes ago

Lethbridge College to become a polytechnic institution

19 minutes ago

Sask. high schoolers graduate after unusual four years

21 minutes ago

Video: Abbie Chatfield reveals surprise family news after 'hard launching' new boyfriend Adam Hyde

21 minutes ago

Lakers' new coach JJ Redick is accused of calling African-American woman the N-word at Duke in early 2000s.... but ex-Blue Devils star denies claim

22 minutes ago

Seasoned Pennsylvania teacher Neil Young wants to take his ‘heart of gold’ to Congress: ‘The real deal’

22 minutes ago

Yes, They All Broke Up

22 minutes ago

More than two thirds of mothers feel their vote does not count, survey reveals

22 minutes ago

Cubs release one-time World Series champion amid career-worst season

23 minutes ago

Caucus discipline the ‘most fundamental principle’ of Labor Party

23 minutes ago

Practice Footage Of LeBron, Bronny, And Bryce Is Going Viral

23 minutes ago

Just Stop Oil Twickenham protester was ‘doing his duty as a doctor’

23 minutes ago

Wikileaks founder Julian Assange boards plane out of UK as part of plea deal with the US

23 minutes ago

Plano gymnast moved to North Texas in hopes of making Team USA

23 minutes ago

Home in south-west Sydney targeted in drive-by shooting

23 minutes ago

FlameFest set to fire up winter in Mandurah with two-day sizzling entertainment festival

23 minutes ago

GM reveals the American Holden Commodore that never was

23 minutes ago

Community donates more than $11,000 to help young Greenfields family after house fire

23 minutes ago

Rockingham: Ben Smith & Drew La Reservee mourning unexpected death of 16-month-old son Micah

23 minutes ago

Mandurah composting facility C-Wise threatens residents with legal action for ‘defamatory’ Facebook posts

23 minutes ago

Vauxhall threatens to pull plug on UK car making amid row over EV sales targets

23 minutes ago

Girls Aloud's Nadine Coyle left red-faced after very awkward stage blunder

23 minutes ago

Google announces surprise event, teases Pixel 9

26 minutes ago

Illinois Tollway unveils ‘lane blades' to help clear debris, keep drivers safe

28 minutes ago

Oleksandr Usyk vacating IBF title ahead of Joshua-Dubois bout

28 minutes ago

Source: Jim Schlossnagle leaves Texas A&M for Texas baseball job

28 minutes ago

‘Multiple people’ could be charged in Matthew Perry’s overdose death

28 minutes ago

WTA roundup: Caroline Wozniacki pulls upset in Bad Homburg

28 minutes ago

2025 BMW M5 becomes a 535kW PHEV V8 weapon

28 minutes ago

Here's how much the price of gold has dropped since May (and why you should still invest)

28 minutes ago

NRL News: Chad chats with club for Sydney swansong, Edwards primed for delayed Origin debut

28 minutes ago

Driving test fail rates rise as young people race to book test slots anywhere they can

28 minutes ago

Gadecki leads big Aussie charge at Wimbledon qualifying

28 minutes ago

Sánchez could earn up to $54.5M with Phillies from 2025-30 if he wins 2 Cy Young Awards

28 minutes ago

Elly De La Cruz hit a long homer and drives in 3 runs as Reds rout Pirates 11-5

28 minutes ago

A Shopper Who Bought This Retinol Serum 6x Calls It 'an Eraser' for Wrinkles

28 minutes ago

BTS' V ‘TYPE 1' Is Coming, Katy Perry Previews Lyrics At Paris Fashion Week & More | Billboard News

28 minutes ago

Slater and DCE on cusp of joining Maroons great duos

28 minutes ago

Camila Cabello name checks Cristiano Ronaldo and prompts an awkward exchange with the audience; 'Don't boo me'