U.S., states sue to ‘break up’ Ticketmaster parent Live Nation

amazon, u.s., states sue to ‘break up’ ticketmaster parent live nation

U.S., states sue to ‘break up’ Ticketmaster parent Live Nation

The U.S. government filed a sweeping antitrust lawsuit Thursday against Live Nation Entertainment, the parent company of Ticketmaster, seeking to break up the conglomerate over allegations that it has amassed and abused unrivaled power in the ticketing and concert industries.

The landmark case — joined by 30 state and district attorneys general — could dramatically reshape an ecosystem that has long sparked outrage from artists and fans alike, whose frustrations erupted in 2022 when high fees and site outages disrupted early sales for Taylor Swift’s “Eras” tour.

Live Nation is an entertainment titan: It is a concert promoter, artist manager, venue owner and ticket seller and reseller, constituting a sprawling empire that its executives publicly herald as the “largest live entertainment company in the world.” Last year alone, Live Nation produced more than 50,000 concerts and other musical events, and it sold more than 620 million tickets globally, the company boasted to investors in April.

But the U.S. government contends that the company’s vast power and reach have also afforded it unfair advantages over competitors, allowing Live Nation to evolve into an illegal and harmful “monopolist” — with the power to box out rivals, reduce consumer choices and raise ticket prices.

“We allege that Live Nation relies on unlawful, anticompetitive conduct to exercise its monopolistic control over the live events industry in the United States at the cost of fans, artists, smaller promoters, and venue operators,” Attorney General Merrick Garland said in a statement, later adding: “It is time to break up Live Nation.”

State and federal officials allege that Live Nation threatens to retaliate against performance venues unless they agree to use the company’s Ticketmaster service. Otherwise, these venue operators risk losing access to popular performances and tours — an unfavorable ultimatum, according to the government, that has allowed Ticketmaster to lock up more than 70 percent of sales at major concert venues.

To further entrench its dominance, Live Nation also targets artists: Performers at times must use Live Nation’s tour promotional services, or they cannot perform at company-operated venues, the complaint alleges. Live Nation owns or controls 265 concert venues in North America, including 60 of the top 100 amphitheaters in the United States, according to the government’s estimates.

State and federal antitrust watchdogs contend these arrangements ultimately have restricted artists, arrested the growth of competing ticketing services and cost audience members, who are forced to pay high, mandatory ticketing fees. In response, they asked a federal judge in New York to order structural changes to Live Nation, which could effectively force the company to break up.

A long, arduous court battle is now likely to follow, one that will see the Justice Department argue for unwinding a merger that the agency itself approved more than a decade ago.

In a statement Thursday, Live Nation sharply rebutted the charges. Dan Wall, the company’s executive vice president for corporate and regulatory affairs, said the government “ignores everything that is actually responsible for higher ticket prices,” including higher production costs, artist popularity and ticket “scalping.”

“It’s also clear that we are another casualty of this administration’s decision to turn over antitrust enforcement to a populist urge that simply rejects how antitrust law works,” he added.

The lawsuit marks only the latest federal antitrust case initiated under President Biden, who came to office promising to crack down on corporate power and profiteering. Over the past three years, federal watchdogs have sued major technology companies including Apple, Amazon, Facebook and Google for allegedly anticompetitive practices, and they have blocked major mergers involving airlines, biotech firms and grocery chains.

“Maybe it took people by surprise, but the president said [the government] wanted to do something on this, and they have,” said Sen. Amy Klobuchar (D-Minn.), the top lawmaker on the chamber’s antitrust panel. She added that Washington never should have allowed Live Nation to acquire Ticketmaster in the first place.

“However you look at it,” she said, “that’s a monopoly.”

Nearly 15 years ago, it was Washington’s blessing that paved the way for Live Nation to expand its corporate footprint: The Justice Department in 2010 gave the green light for the company to purchase Ticketmaster, combining what was already the largest concert promoter with the most prominent ticketing platform.

The deal created a powerhouse that could manage every part of a performance: It could plan and execute the logistics around an artist’s tour, handle all of their initial sales through Ticketmaster and stage some of the shows at Live Nation’s venues, including the Hollywood Palladium in Los Angeles and the Brooklyn Bowl in New York.

In a bid to preserve competition, the Obama administration approved the merger only on a conditional basis. It required Live Nation to divest some of its business, and it prohibited the combined company from retaliating against venues that opted to use other ticketing platforms. At the time, federal officials said their consent decree would pave the way “for strong competitors to Ticketmaster, allowing concert venues to have more and better choices for their ticketing needs.”

But the legally binding agreement didn’t quell broad opposition from concert venue owners and artists, who grumbled in the years to follow about the ease with which Live Nation allegedly flouted federal restrictions. The accusations are laid bare in the government’s roughly 120-page complaint, filed Thursday in a federal court in New York.

“With this vast scope of power comes influence. Live Nation and its wholly owned subsidiary, Ticketmaster, have used that power and influence to insert themselves at the center and the edges of virtually every aspect of the live music ecosystem," the complaint alleges. "This has given Live Nation and Ticketmaster the opportunity to freeze innovation and bend the industry to their own benefit.”

The state and federal lawsuit also charges that Live Nation gobbled up some of its rivals — and struck anti-competitive arrangements with others — in a bid to further establish Ticketmaster as a dominant sales platform. It offers the example of Oak View Group, described by the government as a “competitor-turned-partner” with which Live Nation brokered a deal to avoid competing with each other over artists and tours.

“The live music industry in America is broken because Live Nation-Ticketmaster has an illegal monopoly,” Assistant Attorney General Jonathan Kanter, who leads the antitrust office, said in a statement. “Our antitrust lawsuit seeks to break up the Live-Nation-Ticketmaster monopoly, which will restore competition to the benefit of fans and artists alike.”

In response, Live Nation said in a blog post that its integration had actually helped concertgoers and artists alike, since it resulted in “better prices and better services than they would receive if these complementary businesses were separated.”

The Justice Department launched its latest Live Nation investigation in 2022, two years after the agency under President Donald Trump found that the company had “repeatedly” broken its promises to antitrust enforcers. As a federal lawsuit became imminent this spring, competition experts urged the Biden administration to remedy its predecessors’ mistakes by unwinding a company that they said had leveraged its dominance to the detriment of rivals.

“It’s clear what the DOJ has tried previously … has not worked,” said Sumit Sharma, a senior researcher at Consumer Reports. “Live Nation-Ticketmaster’s market share has remained the same.”

The first word of the federal probe arrived on the heels of another fiasco — a surge of demand for Taylor Swift presale tickets in 2022 that crashed Ticketmaster and left countless fans unable to buy seats for her 2023 tour. The widely documented incident put a fresh spotlight on the company, its dominance in ticketing and the fees that it charges consumers.

Policymakers around the country soon unleashed a battery of legislative proposals meant to crack down on abuse in ticketing and better highlight the fees that customers face before they reach the checkout page. On Capitol Hill, Klobuchar summoned Joe Berchtold, the president of Live Nation, for a lengthy grilling over his company’s business practices.

“We hear people say that ticketing markets are less competitive today than they were at the time of the Live Nation-Ticketmaster merger,” Berchtold said in his testimony. “That is simply not true.”

But the company’s critics and competitors swiped at Live Nation for issuing ultimatums to concert halls and sports venues that could not afford to lose the company’s business. Jack Groetzinger, the chief executive of SeatGeek, a competing platform, said the fears of retaliation had allowed Live Nation to grow unchecked: He estimated that Ticketmaster came to amass a market share exceeding 70 percent in primary ticket sales, especially for professional basketball, hockey and football games.

“Major venues in the United States know that if they move their primary ticketing business from Ticketmaster to a competitor, they risk losing the substantial revenue they earn from Live Nation concerts,” Groetzinger said.

The heightened scrutiny promoted Live Nation to scale up its political operation dramatically in recent years: The company spent $2.3 million to influence Washington policymakers in 2023, more than double the year prior, according to OpenSecrets, a money-in-politics watchdog.

Live Nation has continued its spending spree into 2024, helping to host a party around the annual White House correspondents’ dinner — a swanky performance that touted the company’s bona fides on cocktail napkins.

“We’ve seen an uptick in their lobbying spending,” acknowledged Morgan Harper, the director of policy and advocacy at the American Economic Liberties Project, a left-leaning group that has advocated for Live Nation to be broken up. “It’s not surprising an entity like Live Nation, whose business model has allowed them to engage in anti-competitive conduct, would be bringing to bear all the resources it has.”

OTHER NEWS

14 minutes ago

Springbok reality hit home for Sharks star Aphelele Fassi

14 minutes ago

Mason Greenwood: LaLiga giants bid to make Man Utd winger fourth-most expensive signing in club history

14 minutes ago

Review: 'Umro Ayyar: A New Beginning' is a good introduction to Pakistan's first superhero

14 minutes ago

National Assembly sitting proceeds despite warnings over legality

14 minutes ago

Going camping off the grid is getting harder. But admit it: You don’t mind.

15 minutes ago

ADC’s exclusive investor event in Abu Dhabi to showcase high-growth investment opportunities in Jordan’s Aqaba

15 minutes ago

Fallen black professionals feel betrayed by ANC

15 minutes ago

Simone Ashley triumphs at Monte-Carlo Television Festival

19 minutes ago

‘You’re not that important’: Joe Hildebrand shoots down CCP critics’ claims

19 minutes ago

$450 million plan to provide rental relief for essential workers

19 minutes ago

Patrick and Yolande endure blistering row as cracks grow deeper in EastEnders

19 minutes ago

Amy Dowden congratulated by fellow Strictly stars on ‘deserved’ MBE

19 minutes ago

Beijing uses panda diplomacy to repair ties with Australia

19 minutes ago

Sabrina Carpenter and boyfriend Barry Keoghan make rare public appearance for a date night at Chiltern Firehouse in London - after appearing together in singer's VERY steamy music video

22 minutes ago

Two people killed, multiple injured in shooting during Juneteenth celebration in Round Rock, Texas

25 minutes ago

Chelsea are 'willing to offer two first team stars' to Crystal Palace in exchange for Michael Olise... as Blues step up interest in the £60m-rated attacker

25 minutes ago

Steve Borthwick urges his England players to attract a new dynasty of rugby fans on summer tour of Japan and New Zealand... as he hails 'incredible' Three Lions boss Gareth Southgate ahead of Euro 2024

25 minutes ago

NFL insider hints at Aaron Rodgers’ location amid Jets absence: ‘Open your mind’

26 minutes ago

The anti-abortion movement is making a big play to thwart citizen initiatives on reproductive rights

26 minutes ago

Canon offers new firmware and applications for 4K remote PTZ camera systems

29 minutes ago

TSB quits City base as staff insist on working at home

29 minutes ago

Terrifying turbulence videos shared by plane passengers

29 minutes ago

The 20 best places to retire in Britain: From the Highlands and an average house price of £200,000, to the historic town within 90 miles of London

29 minutes ago

Kieran Culkin says 'Succession' made him realise his passion for acting

29 minutes ago

Dutton edges out Albo as preferred PM

29 minutes ago

Emma Raducanu snubs Olympic wildcard as Andy Murray learns Paris 2024 fate

29 minutes ago

Albania fans snapping spaghetti at Italy supporters is already the best thing from the Euros

29 minutes ago

DUP founding Wallace Thompson says nationalists need to reach out to unionists over unity

29 minutes ago

Bulls to host Glasgow Warriors in UFC final: Here’s when

29 minutes ago

Legendary coach highlights one aspect that will ‘pay huge dividends’ for Jannik Sinner on grass

29 minutes ago

Nasreddine Nabi confirms he’s held talks with Kaizer Chiefs, but has other offers as well — report

29 minutes ago

Finder survey shows nearly 50 per cent of Aussies are reluctant to travel abroad

29 minutes ago

Today in Politics: Amit Shah to chair high-level huddle on J-K security, Amarnath Yatra preps

29 minutes ago

Wells Fargo Bet on a Flashy Rent Credit Card. It Is Costing the Bank Dearly.

29 minutes ago

Swiss right-wing leader calls Ukraine summit an 'embarrassment'

34 minutes ago

Emma Raducanu REJECTS Team GB wildcard for the Paris Olympics as she continues to ease her way back after injury hell... while Andy Murray is set for a fairytale send-off at the Games

34 minutes ago

Video: 'Hardest Geezer' Russ Cook arrives in Germany for Euros after running 352 miles to support England - and predicts Three Lions victory over Serbia

34 minutes ago

Former sub-postmaster slams 'buffoonery' of Ed Davey's stunt-laden election campaign as Lib-Dem leader faces questions over lack of help during Horizon scandal when he was a minister

34 minutes ago

John Farnham's newly married son Rob shares first photos of his music legend father following cancer surgery that saw 26 doctors reconstruct his jaw

34 minutes ago

Anne is praised as 'outstanding horsewoman' after Princess Royal managed to keep control of her horse during Trooping the Colour