A college degree can lead to higher earnings—but 29% of Americans say it's not worth the cost

A college degree can lead to higher earnings—but 29% of Americans say it's not worth the cost

A bachelor's degree can run close to $100,000 a year at some colleges.

Most Americans agree it's still worth it, but the bulk of those believers say so only if you don't have to take out loans, according to a new survey from Pew Research. Just 22% of U.S. adults say the cost of college is worth it if you have to take out student loans, Pew finds.

The financial arguments in favor of going to college remain strong. Bachelor's degree-holders tend to earn higher salaries, have lower unemployment rates and hold more wealth than their less-educated peers. But the cost of college continues to rise and millions of Americans are still struggling with student debt long after graduating.

All considered, 29% of U.S. adults say college isn't worth the cost, according to Pew.

On top of that, workers with only some college education or a high school diploma alone have made notable strides toward closing the financial gaps between themselves and degree-holders, Pew finds.

Here's a look at why the benefits of getting a college degree aren't necessarily shrinking, but the reasons to skip higher education may be growing.

The difference a degree can make

Outcomes may be improving for American workers who forego college or don't finish their bachelor's degrees. But the vast difference between the net worth of young adults with degrees compared with those without is difficult to ignore.

Households headed by a college graduate ages 25 to 34 had a median net worth of $120,200 in 2022, compared with $30,700 among high school graduates and $52,900 for those with some college, according to Pew.

All three groups saw their wealth grow significantly in the last decade, due in part to the explosion in home values in the last few years and the stock market's recent strong performance. But college graduates stood to benefit the most from both of these broader economic conditions.

"[College graduates] are more likely to be homeowners, so they probably have more home equity," Richard Fry, a senior researcher at Pew who co-authored the survey, tells CNBC Make It. "Their employers are more likely to offer defined contribution retirement plans and the college-educated are more likely to participate in those retirement plans."

Their stronger homeownership and retirement plan contribution rates and may be due to the fact that college graduates earn more.

However, since student loans historically have gotten in the way of many college graduates buying homes and even saving for retirement, the question of whether the benefits outweigh the cost — especially if you have to take on debt — still stands.

While nearly half of Americans say a college degree is less important today than it was 20 years ago, according to Pew, only 34% say it's very or extremely likely someone without a degree could get a well-paying job today.

'The bleeding has stopped'

College degree-holders have been out-earning their less-educated peers for decades. Those with degrees have seen their wages rise fairly steadily — outside of recessions — since the 1970s, Pew finds.

On the other hand, those who either never started or didn't finish college saw their wages fall from the 1970s through the Great Recession in the mid-aughts.

In the last 10 years, however, the situation has started to improve. "The bleeding has stopped," Fry says.

He calls out young men (ages 25 to 34) as an example of the growth those without degrees have experienced over the last decade.

The inflation-adjusted median annual earnings among young men who work full-time and only have high school diplomas was $45,000 in 2023, up from $39,300 in 2014, according to Pew's analysis of Current Population Survey data.

"Their inflation-adjusted earnings are at least finally starting to grow," Fry says. "That's noteworthy because with the exception of the late 1990s, once you adjust for inflation, their earnings have been pretty steadily falling."

Young women (ages 25 to 34) without college degrees experienced similar growth over the last decade, but still earn less than their male peers. The inflation-adjusted median annual earnings among working young women with only high school diplomas were $36,000 in 2023 compared with $30,900 in 2014..

While earnings have also continued to grow for those with college degrees, the improvement for less-educated workers is good news for those who may not be able to afford college, even if they think it would be worth the cost.

"[Those without degrees] haven't really narrowed the gaps, but this still is somewhat of an exceptional period because they have really gained from the tight labor markets where employers have had trouble finding less skilled workers," Fry says. "The less-educated young workers really benefited from the tight labor markets of the last 10 years."

Want to be a successful, confident communicator? Take CNBC's new online course Become an Effective Communicator: Master Public Speaking. We'll teach you how to speak clearly and confidently, calm your nerves, what to say and not say, and body language techniques to make a great first impression. Register today and use code EARLYBIRD for an introductory discount of 30% off through July 10, 2024.

Plus, sign up for CNBC Make It's newsletter to get tips and tricks for success at work, with money and in life.

OTHER NEWS

12 minutes ago

Princess Charlotte's touching act during carriage ride to stop rain ruining Trooping parade

12 minutes ago

Gareth Southgate sends England stars message that leaves no doubt over Euro 2024 plans

20 minutes ago

PepsiCo announces plans to triple size of its electric fleet: 'Good for the planet, good for our business'

20 minutes ago

Elon Musk vs BJP's Rajeev Chandrashekhar on whether EVMs can be hacked

20 minutes ago

Euro 2024: Kylian Mbappé and France aim to start with a win over on-form Austria

20 minutes ago

I'm a female breadwinner who retired my husband. I was worried I'd resent him, but I'm a better leader and wife because of it.

20 minutes ago

Ukraine opens its Euro 2024 campaign against Romania amid backdrop of war back home

20 minutes ago

Poland vs. Netherlands Euro 2024 time, live stream, TV channel, lineups to watch Group D match in Australia

20 minutes ago

I'm nearly 90, worth more than £200 million and still starting new businesses. Here's how I did it - and my eight tips for getting rich

23 minutes ago

Woman shot by police in public park after allegedly wielding knife

24 minutes ago

Pennsylvania waste management facility collects millions of dollars worth of tossed out coins

24 minutes ago

Jon Bon Jovi teams up with *NSYNC star to open Nashville honky-tonk

24 minutes ago

Charcoal company gives away 50K free barbecues to Americans in food-insecure communities

24 minutes ago

Brian Cox rails against Brexit and Nigel Farage on BBC politics programme

24 minutes ago

Hamburg police shoot man near Euro 2024 fan park ‘threatening officers with pickaxe’

25 minutes ago

Nations discuss children, nuclear safety at talks on peace in Ukraine taking place without Russia

25 minutes ago

Ludvig Aberg career earnings: How much money has golfer made on PGA Tour?

25 minutes ago

US Open live updates: Leaderboard, Sunday tee times for final round at Pinehurst

25 minutes ago

SpaceX's Inspiration4 astronauts got genetically younger in space: study

25 minutes ago

When Are Trump Supporters Complicit?

25 minutes ago

Coach and son's defibrillator plea after fundraising

25 minutes ago

St Helens' Agnatious Paasi opens up on injury battle and emotional playing return

25 minutes ago

Wanna be a good dad? A 'School for Men' teaches diapering, ponytail making

31 minutes ago

Revealed: How scores of patients taking antidepressants suffer such severe withdrawal symptoms they are hooked on them for life

31 minutes ago

'I know I'll get Alzheimer's... but when?' One woman's story of how a DNA test changed the course of her life for ever

31 minutes ago

I'm nearly 90, worth more than £200 million and still starting new businesses. Here's how I did it - and my eight tips for getting rich

31 minutes ago

DR ELLIE CANNON: What a strange taste in your mouth can tell you about your health

31 minutes ago

POLL: Which 2023 Lions rookie will have the biggest Year 2 leap?

31 minutes ago

"We knew we weren't playing too many minutes" - Scottie Pippen admitted he and Michael Jordan drank beers before exhibition games

31 minutes ago

Foreign Ministry follows up on death of 6 Jordanian pilgrims

31 minutes ago

Amazon Is Our Pitstop for Cute and Comfy Travel Outfits Going Into Summer — Shop 13 New Arrivals From $20

31 minutes ago

'My boyfriend is trying to stop me from going to the gym – it feels so unfair'

31 minutes ago

Are EastEnders stars Lacey Turner and Lillia Turner related?

31 minutes ago

UK's new £18,000,000 rollercoaster 'breaks down' leaving people stuck 236ft up

31 minutes ago

Arsenal transfers: £60m striker ditched after one meeting as Arteta ‘didn’t want him around’

31 minutes ago

Charley Hull: What's In The Bag | Golf Monthly

31 minutes ago

Video: Giovanni Pernice looks 'blissfully happy' as he returns to the stage alongside supportive pal Anton Du Beke - but fails to mention Strictly following shock exit amid workplace 'misconduct' probe

35 minutes ago

Police confirm person with ‘incendiary device’ shot near fanzone hours before Euro 2024 match

35 minutes ago

Cyprus records a second death from heatstroke as temperatures soar

35 minutes ago

NYC considers ending broker fees for tenants, angering real estate industry