Emotional scenes as Jersey politicians debate assisted dying ahead of votes

emotional scenes as jersey politicians debate assisted dying ahead of votes

UNP Dignity in Dying 45686 Jersey

Jersey’s parliament saw emotional scenes as politicians debated ahead of voting on whether laws should be drawn up to establish an assisted dying service on the island.

Proposals for how a law in this area would work were published in March and politicians have been discussing this week whether legislation should be drafted.

The process for drafting a law could take around 18 months.

If such a law is approved, it is expected a further 18-month implementation period will then begin, meaning the earliest for it to come into effect would be summer 2027.

A series of votes were due to take place on Wednesday, including on whether the island should have a law establishing an assisted dying service for adult residents who have made a voluntary and informed decision to die.

During debate States Assembly member Deputy Tom Coles spoke of the right to choice, both for those who support assisted dying and those who do not.

With his voice breaking and pausing to compose himself, he said: “I know my wife would do anything for me. But if I get to my end… if I get to my end, I do not want her to do the things that I don’t want her to do for me.

“I want this to be my choice. And I think that, by denying anybody their right to choose, when they get into that situation, that is not fair.

“But I also respect that there are people who will not wish to do this service. There are people who do not want this to be their choice. And I also support that. So the fact that this entire process is completely opt-in and not opt-out is where I find my balance with all this.”

It would be fantastically naive to think that people won't come under some kind of indirect societal pressure

States Assembly member Dean Michael Keirle

But fellow States Assembly member, Dean Michael Keirle, warned of the risks of people coming under pressure to end their lives, especially under what is known as route two for those with an incurable physical condition which might not be terminal but is causing them unbearable suffering.

He told the Assembly: “It would be fantastically naive to think that people won’t come under some kind of indirect societal pressure, especially under route two.

“As a priest I’ve seen grooming at every level. In 35 years of ministry I’ve seen humanity at its absolute best in death and, sadly, at its absolute worst. As the old saying goes, where there’s a will, there’s a family.

“So let’s not pretend that this will not impact upon those who are vulnerable.”

He added that it is the most vulnerable who could face the greatest risks.

He said: “Yes, the argument for (a change in law) is being championed by people who are confident and articulate and in the name of personal choice. There is little risk to those people.

The risks affect those least able to speak for themselves

States Assembly member Dean Michael Keirle

“But the risks affect those least able to speak for themselves. They always do.”

Deputy Elaine Millar described the report published earlier this year containing proposals for how an assisted dying service might work as a “very detailed, thorough and thoughtful piece of work”.

But she acknowledged that, due to the divided nature of opinion on this controversial issue, whichever way the vote goes “very large numbers of people would be disappointed by the outcome”.

In 2021, just over three-quarters (78%) of the members of a citizens’ jury on Jersey agreed that assisted dying should be permitted, and later that year the States Assembly became the first parliament in the British Isles to decide “in principle” to allow assisted dying.

The proposals have been “very much influenced and informed by the views of islanders”, health and social services minister Tom Binet said ahead of this week’s debate.

He added: “I think all the indications are that a majority of people actually want this.”

To receive the best stories in your inbox every day, click here to register for one or more newsletters from The Standard.

OTHER NEWS

33 minutes ago

How much is landlord insurance – and how can you cut your costs?

33 minutes ago

NBA champion Paul Pierce weighs in on decision to leave Caitlin Clark off US Olympic team: 'It was a bad move'

33 minutes ago

Riley Herbst comes up just short of second career win at Iowa

33 minutes ago

Chinese premier promises more pandas and urges Australia to put aside differences

33 minutes ago

Joe Biden Rips Donald Trump At Start Of Star-Filled L.A. Fundraiser: “I Could Have Done Nothing And Done Better Than He Was Doing”

33 minutes ago

Crockett calls Thomas ‘corrupt’ after Supreme Court decision to upend bump stocks ban

33 minutes ago

National weather forecast for Sunday June 16

35 minutes ago

Everything to Know about Disney Lookout Cay at Lighthouse Point, Disney Cruise Line's Second Private Destination in the Bahamas

35 minutes ago

Nottingham Open: Emma Raducanu leads Katie Boulter in 'Battle of Britain' as play suspended

35 minutes ago

Sentimental: ANC reaffirms values, says only democrat values welcomed

35 minutes ago

WNBA Expected to Lose $50 Million Despite Popularity: Report

35 minutes ago

Celtics Blew a Sweep in the NBA Finals, Just Like Two of the Best Teams Ever

39 minutes ago

How To Get Cheap Amtrak Tickets: How I Find Amtrak Discounts

39 minutes ago

The ultimate guide to travel vaccinations

39 minutes ago

Independence ‘proudly on page one, line one’ of SNP manifesto – John Swinney

39 minutes ago

Orlando Pirates linked with European coach! – Report

39 minutes ago

The Barefoot Investor exposes common smartphone app that is ripping you off at the checkout

39 minutes ago

Young worker reveals the insane amount of money he makes in a week for his entry level role

42 minutes ago

Shooting in Detroit suburb leaves 8 injured, including 2 children, authorities say

44 minutes ago

Kobe Bryant explained why Larry Bird is a Top 5 player of all time: "People really forget how great Larry Bird was…the guy was money"

44 minutes ago

Coach Jesse Marsch finalizes Canadian men's roster for first Copa America appearance

44 minutes ago

Euro 2024: Enjoy, but keep the TV at a healthy distance from your eyes

44 minutes ago

Andrew Findlay's body was found washed up on rocks in one of Sydney's ritziest suburbs after a boating accident. Now there's been a sad development

44 minutes ago

Diver shares video of animals leading them to 'sad' discovery floating in ocean: 'These dolphins were trying to tell me something'

44 minutes ago

‘Creeping’ corporatism touching ‘every part of government’

44 minutes ago

NSW government reveals budget measures that tackle housing crisis

44 minutes ago

Police officer describes uniform as ‘retro cargo’ as he shares fashion tips at races

49 minutes ago

Texan whose husband died by hot tub electrocution at Mexican beach resort files wrongful death suit

50 minutes ago

Massive heat dome brings dangerous heat this week across Ontario and Quebec

50 minutes ago

Australia plot to shake American swimming dominance

50 minutes ago

'I'm pressuring the Israelis': Biden says he warned Israel to follow US instructions

50 minutes ago

Angie Harmon’s daughter, 18, freed from jail without bail: report

53 minutes ago

'Are we going to censor satire?': Rita Panahi slams legal threats against Pauline Hanson

58 minutes ago

Jennifer Aniston, 55, wishes Friends co-star Courteney Cox a happy 60th birthday while sharing sweet throwback snaps

59 minutes ago

Wings' Arike Ogunbowale: 'Politics' involved in Olympics selection

59 minutes ago

Ronaldinho's Brazil Copa América criticism part of ad campaign

59 minutes ago

Spain 3-0 Croatia: Euro 2024 – as it happened

59 minutes ago

Jose Riveiro all about the prep at Orlando Pirates, says Innocent Maela

1 hour ago

J-Rod goes deep to help Mariners win for 6th time in 7 games over Rangers

1 hour ago

Julian Nagelsmann embracing Germany's blistering Euros 2024 start