Emotional scenes as Jersey politicians debate assisted dying ahead of votes

emotional scenes as jersey politicians debate assisted dying ahead of votes

UNP Dignity in Dying 45686 Jersey

Jersey’s parliament saw emotional scenes as politicians debated ahead of voting on whether laws should be drawn up to establish an assisted dying service on the island.

Proposals for how a law in this area would work were published in March and politicians have been discussing this week whether legislation should be drafted.

The process for drafting a law could take around 18 months.

If such a law is approved, it is expected a further 18-month implementation period will then begin, meaning the earliest for it to come into effect would be summer 2027.

A series of votes were due to take place on Wednesday, including on whether the island should have a law establishing an assisted dying service for adult residents who have made a voluntary and informed decision to die.

During debate States Assembly member Deputy Tom Coles spoke of the right to choice, both for those who support assisted dying and those who do not.

With his voice breaking and pausing to compose himself, he said: “I know my wife would do anything for me. But if I get to my end… if I get to my end, I do not want her to do the things that I don’t want her to do for me.

“I want this to be my choice. And I think that, by denying anybody their right to choose, when they get into that situation, that is not fair.

“But I also respect that there are people who will not wish to do this service. There are people who do not want this to be their choice. And I also support that. So the fact that this entire process is completely opt-in and not opt-out is where I find my balance with all this.”

It would be fantastically naive to think that people won't come under some kind of indirect societal pressure

States Assembly member Dean Michael Keirle

But fellow States Assembly member, Dean Michael Keirle, warned of the risks of people coming under pressure to end their lives, especially under what is known as route two for those with an incurable physical condition which might not be terminal but is causing them unbearable suffering.

He told the Assembly: “It would be fantastically naive to think that people won’t come under some kind of indirect societal pressure, especially under route two.

“As a priest I’ve seen grooming at every level. In 35 years of ministry I’ve seen humanity at its absolute best in death and, sadly, at its absolute worst. As the old saying goes, where there’s a will, there’s a family.

“So let’s not pretend that this will not impact upon those who are vulnerable.”

He added that it is the most vulnerable who could face the greatest risks.

He said: “Yes, the argument for (a change in law) is being championed by people who are confident and articulate and in the name of personal choice. There is little risk to those people.

The risks affect those least able to speak for themselves

States Assembly member Dean Michael Keirle

“But the risks affect those least able to speak for themselves. They always do.”

Deputy Elaine Millar described the report published earlier this year containing proposals for how an assisted dying service might work as a “very detailed, thorough and thoughtful piece of work”.

But she acknowledged that, due to the divided nature of opinion on this controversial issue, whichever way the vote goes “very large numbers of people would be disappointed by the outcome”.

In 2021, just over three-quarters (78%) of the members of a citizens’ jury on Jersey agreed that assisted dying should be permitted, and later that year the States Assembly became the first parliament in the British Isles to decide “in principle” to allow assisted dying.

The proposals have been “very much influenced and informed by the views of islanders”, health and social services minister Tom Binet said ahead of this week’s debate.

He added: “I think all the indications are that a majority of people actually want this.”

To receive the best stories in your inbox every day, click here to register for one or more newsletters from The Standard.

OTHER NEWS

26 minutes ago

Swinney: Govt should remove barrier to passing Gender Reform bill

28 minutes ago

Sha'Carri Richardson will race for spot in Olympics after winning semifinals at US trials in 10.86

28 minutes ago

Remain alert as severe storms target southern Ontario on Sunday

28 minutes ago

Son seeks advice after parents install controversial landscaping method: 'I wasn't in favor of the idea'

28 minutes ago

Nuclear a ‘100-year’ plan unlike Labor’s ’15-to-20-year’ renewables

28 minutes ago

With the British summer as unpredictable as ever, here’s how you can bag a bargain holiday

28 minutes ago

Rains, cooler weather help firefighters gain ground on large wildfires in southern New Mexico

37 minutes ago

Noah Lyles wins opening round of men's 100m at US Olympic track and field trials

42 minutes ago

Boy, 12, dies at water park following ‘medical-related incident’: cops

43 minutes ago

What Happened To Kate Winslet After Titanic Is Heartbreaking & Gross

43 minutes ago

‘Genius move’: Coalition will ‘win’ next election off of nuclear policy announcement

43 minutes ago

DOJ Should Do 4 Things if Aileen Cannon Dismisses Trump Case—Ex-Prosecutor

43 minutes ago

Rory McIlroy choke explained by sports psychologist as he skips £3.1m payday

43 minutes ago

Government to challenge native title claim over famous Aussie island

47 minutes ago

3 men die after becoming distressed while swimming at Florida beach

49 minutes ago

Trump blasts Biden’s America as ‘worst’ moment in US history during Philly rally

49 minutes ago

What Factors Influence The Planes That Airlines Order?

49 minutes ago

Steve Kerr on why LeBron James is more like Scottie Pippen than Michael Jordan: "That's what Michael did in his sleep"

49 minutes ago

Crichton stands out from pack to be on cusp of history

49 minutes ago

Trump in Philadelphia for Temple University rally ahead of debate in latest blue city stop

49 minutes ago

Khaadem has triumphed once again at Royal Ascot claiming Jubilee honours

49 minutes ago

Lando Norris reveals McLaren disruption extent following hospitality fire

53 minutes ago

Wheeler gets 9th win, Harper among 3 homers as Phillies rout Diamondbacks 12-1

53 minutes ago

Christopher Bell stays undefeated in NASCAR Xfinity Series at New Hampshire with 4th straight win

53 minutes ago

Blanco throws 7 strong innings and McCormick homers twice as Astros beat Orioles 5-1

54 minutes ago

Thousands of Michigan Residents Weather Days Without Power During Heat Wave

54 minutes ago

Ex-Devil Adam Henrique Continues to Add to Postseason Resume

60 minutes ago

Iran overturns rapper Toomaj Salehi's death sentence for criticizing the government

60 minutes ago

Video: Tom Cruise leads huge names including Ashton Kutcher, Mila Kunis and Hugh Grant in the crowds at Taylor Swift's second Eras tour Wembley show

60 minutes ago

Video: Gillian McKeith is 'scammed' out of hundreds of pounds after she and her daughter Afton try to buy Taylor Swift tickets

1 hour ago

Older People Who Use Psychedelics Show Fascinating Brain Functions

1 hour ago

This major champion made it to the weekend of 2024 KPMG Women's PGA playing with broken toe

1 hour ago

6 Best Neighborhoods to Stay in Paris—According to In-the-Know Locals

1 hour ago

Ultramarathon athlete awarded more than $13 million after falling on ‘perennially' wet Seattle sidewalk

1 hour ago

Climate activists are scaring children, former head of OFSTED warns

1 hour ago

Samsung Galaxy Buds 3 leak shows off AirPods-like design

1 hour ago

Lewis Hamilton ‘focused’ on fighting for a victory at F1 Spanish Grand Prix

1 hour ago

The power of theatre in helping young refugees process trauma

1 hour ago

Hospice nurse reveals three most SURPRISING things about death

1 hour ago

Namibian Pride: activists hail overturning of law that banned same-sex acts between men.