Jonathan Dimbleby: How Stalin’s audacious deception humbled the German army

jonathan dimbleby: how stalin’s audacious deception humbled the german army

Stalin's Operation Bagration changed history - ullstein bild/ullstein bild via Getty Images

As the clock ticked down to D-Day, Churchill’s apprehension grew. He concealed his forebodings in public with a magnificent display of political chutzpah. And, as though to reassure himself in the process, he sent a cable to Roosevelt that oozed resolution: “I am becoming very hard set upon Overlord . . . I do not agree with the loose talk which has been going on, on both sides of the Atlantic about the undue heavy casualties which we shall sustain. In my view it is the Germans who will suffer very heavy casualties when our band of brothers gets among them.”

But, on the night of June 5, his final words to his wife as she bade him goodnight in the underground map room in Whitehall spoke another truth: “Do you realise that by the time you wake up in the morning, 20,000 young men may have been Killed?” Mercifully, he was overly pessimistic.*

As the Allied troops swarmed ashore on the Normandy coast, the prime minister cabled Stalin. His message was uncharacteristically succinct: ‘Everything has started well. The mines, obstacles and land batteries have been largely overcome. The air landings were very successful and on a large scale. Infantry landings are proceeding rapidly and many tanks and self-propelled guns are already ashore. Weather outlook is moderate to good.’

jonathan dimbleby: how stalin’s audacious deception humbled the german army

British troops arrive on land on D-Day on 6 June 1944 - Lt. Cdr. Norway/ Imperial War Museums via Getty Images

He had no need to tell him that D-Day was the greatest feat of amphibious warfare ever attempted, or that it was proving to be a spectacular triumph. The day before, after reading a dispatch from the prime minister informing him that the landings were about to take place, Stalin had sneered, “Yes, there will be a landing, if there is no fog. Until now there was always something to put it off.

“I suspect tomorrow it will be something else. Maybe they’ll meet with some Germans! What if they meet with some Germans! Maybe, there won’t be a landing then, but just promises as usual.”

As his interlocutor, the Yugoslav partisan leader Milovan Djilas, observed, the sneer did not so much reflect a genuine doubt as a chance to mock the failure of the Western Allies to honour similar undertakings in the past.

But, with the news that Overlord was finally underway, Stalin became far more gracious, ready to acknowledge that D-Day had been a triumph of meticulous planning, brilliant organisation and dauntless resolve.

He did not trouble to hide his admiration and relief, informing Churchill, “I have received your communication about the successes of the beginning of the Overlord operations. It gives joy to us all and hope of further success.”

jonathan dimbleby: how stalin’s audacious deception humbled the german army

Joseph Stalin (left) with British Prime Minister Winston Churchill at the Yalta conference in the Crimea in 1945, where they were joined by President Roosevelt - Paul Popper/Popperfoto

In the same message, he was unusually forthcoming about his own closely guarded plans [what came to be known as Operation Bagration]:

The Soviet summer offensive, organised in accordance with the agreement at the Tehran Conference, will begin towards the middle of June on one of the most important sectors of the front. The general offensive of the Soviet forces will develop by stages . . . At the end of June and during July offensive operations will become a general offensive of the Soviet forces.

The message inevitably concealed more than it imparted but – for the time being at any rate – it demonstrated that the Big Three were at least in harmony about the greatest joint venture of the war: the strangulation of Nazism.

In Moscow, the Stavka [Soviet high command] had achieved the near-impossible, not by chance but by design. In the space of a few weeks, hundreds of thousands of men and pieces of heavy equipment had been transferred or redeployed over huge distances without alerting German Intelligence to what might be afoot. This had required strategic and operational maskirovka [masking] measures of the most elaborate and sophisticated kind.

Initially, to ensure that no details could leak to the enemy, only four individuals aside from Stalin himself – [senior officers] Zhukov, Vasilevsky, Antonov and Shtemenko – were fully aware of the plans for the summer campaign. All correspondence, telephone conversations and telegraph messages concerning it were strictly forbidden and fiercely policed.

The Stavka had begun to put these measures in place on May 3. The commander of the 3rd Ukrainian Front, Rodion Malinovsky… received the following order:

You are charged with conducting operational maskirovka measures for the purpose of misinforming the enemy. It is necessary to show a concentration of eight to nine rifle divisions, reinforced with tanks and artillery, beyond the right flank of the front . . . The false region of concentration should be animated, showing the movement and disposition of separate groups of men, vehicles, tanks and guns, and the equipping of the region; anti-aircraft guns should be placed at the locations of tank and artillery mock-ups.

To complete the illusion of an imminent offensive, the skies were to be patrolled by Soviet fighters – though not so aggressively as to prevent German spotter planes from photographing the troop concentrations and thereby, as Shtemenko put it, confirming the “plausibility of the false objectives”.

Similar ruses were put in place all along the line. For the commander of the 1st Baltic Front, Bagramyan, maskirovka meant simulating preparations for a major assault on Vitebsk from the north while secretly moving the 6th Guards Army 120 kilometres to the south of the city, a redeployment of 100,000 troops that took three nights to complete.

jonathan dimbleby: how stalin’s audacious deception humbled the german army

Soviet Red Army soldiers on night reconnaissance on the 1st Baltic Front in June 1944 - Sovfoto/Universal Images Group via Getty Images

[Commander] Rokossovsky ordered his five armies to make sure that “all activities at the front were concealed from the enemy… He was to see only what we wanted him to see… In many places we built fake crossings and roads. Guns were concentrated on secondary lines, from which they launched artillery attacks and were then removed to the rear: dummies being left there on the firing positions.”

At night, 15-man squads carrying torches moved back and forth along the routes between mock assembly areas to simulate the secret movement of vehicles, making sure these were clearly visible to the German pilots circling above them. Meanwhile, the 1st Belorussian Front was reinforced by the 5th Guards Tank Army from the Ukraine, a redeployment that was concealed by the noisy diversion of nine rifle divisions, two artillery divisions and a tank corps, as though they were preparing to advance in an entirely different direction. The maskirovka programme was almost wholly successful in hiding the scale and ferocity of the offensive that was in preparation.

It was a logistical challenge of mind-boggling proportions to transport hundreds of thousands of men, thousands of tanks and artillery, as well as the fuel and supplies required for a huge and sustained offensive, all under cover of darkness over many hundreds of kilometres by train, along often single-track lines.

jonathan dimbleby: how stalin’s audacious deception humbled the german army

Russian soldiers waving from a train, 1944 - Hulton Archive/Getty Images

To avoid bottlenecks, the quartermasters overseeing these huge movements ran a shuttle service: the trains that transferred men and machines to the front by night returned by day loaded with mocked-up tanks and guns in clear sight of the enemy’s reconnaissance aircraft. Altogether six tank armies were transferred from the Ukraine to the Belorussian Front as well as three armies from the Stavka reserves.

None of these movements were detected by German Intelligence in time to take any avoiding action. No detail was overlooked.

Within 12 days of launching Operation Bagration, the Soviet armies had virtually annihilated Army Group Centre [the German Army groups that fought on the Eastern Front]. A once irresistible force that had stampeded through the Soviet Union in June 1941 to the gates of Moscow was broken, never again to take the offensive. The 9th Army was in tatters; the 4th Army had lost over 80 per cent of its initial strength, down from 165,000 to 35,000 men; the 3rd Panzer Army had lost ten divisions. Altogether, Army Group Centre had lost 25 divisions and more than 300,000 men. The Wehrmacht had never before suffered such a humiliating defeat. But Operation Bagration was not yet over. The seizure of Minsk was merely the end of phase one.

Early in the morning of Monday, July 17, a radio bulletin alerted the Moscow citizenry to the Parade of the Vanquished, which was to wind its way through the streets of the capital a few hours later. Huge crowds began to line the route. At the Hippodrome and the Dynamo football stadium, those POWs deemed strong enough not to collapse en route were formed up in long columns, 25 abreast, before heading out to meet their public, still dressed in their filthy uniforms.

The parade was led by 19 generals, six colonels and more than 1,000 officers of lower rank. Behind them, flanked lightly by Soviet troops, the rank-and-file prisoners, looking to neither left nor right but blankly ahead, were as force-marched trophies of victory. Their faces, etched by exhaustion, showed little emotion: “We did not look around, just marched along, detached, without thinking anything . . . like dead. All was finished . . . We had no thoughts and no feelings,” [junior liaison officer, Josef] Wimmer recalled.

The crowds who lined the pavements, six or more deep, observed this spectacle in near-silence, as though they were indeed witnessing a death march.…[Stalin’s] Moscow Parade, callous as it was, had served its purpose, both boosting his status at home and reminding his allies (and warning his adversaries) that the Red Army was now the Second World War’s most powerful and most successful military force, with which it would be exceedingly unwise to tangle…The all-conquering Red Army, as Churchill so darkly put it, was “spreading across Europe like a tide”.

*According to the US National D-Day Memorial Foundation, the total number of Allied D-Day casualties was approximately 10,000, of whom 4,415 were confirmed dead.

Endgame 1944: How Stalin Won the War by Jonathan Dimbleby (£25) is published on May 23, 2024 by Penguin Viking

Play The Telegraph’s brilliant range of Puzzles - and feel brighter every day. Train your brain and boost your mood with PlusWord, the Mini Crossword, the fearsome Killer Sudoku and even the classic Cryptic Crossword.

OTHER NEWS

18 minutes ago

Young pitch invader at Euro 2024 got away with a warning, claims father

18 minutes ago

PSL champions Mameloidi Sundowns and Nedbank title-holders Orlando Pirates stood tall at the PSL Awards

18 minutes ago

11 conclusions from the weekend’s rugby league including Leeds Rhinos, Salford Red Devils

18 minutes ago

Jonathon Cooper named Broncos' most underrated player

18 minutes ago

Why has the cost of home insurance suddenly gone through the roof?

18 minutes ago

I'm a consultant in my mid-20s. Here's what a day in my life is like and how I use AI in my job.

18 minutes ago

No quarter given: Who will remain in the hunt for Sam Maguire after the last-eight ties?

18 minutes ago

Princess Anne hospitalised with concussion

18 minutes ago

Hochul on NY social media law: ‘You cannot turn a blind eye to trauma that has been inflicted on our children’

18 minutes ago

'Gorgeous' M&S sandals 'butter soft from day one' now in the sale

18 minutes ago

"We didn't get the chance to do that" - Kevin Garnett breaks down what Boston needs to do next to stay elite

18 minutes ago

Peter Andre pulled over for drink-driving after cops mistook coffee for pint of Guinness

18 minutes ago

Shebeshxt pays tribute to daughter in wheelchair at funeral service, amid health battle

18 minutes ago

London Tunnels tourist attraction snubs London Stock Exchange in favour of Amsterdam IPO

18 minutes ago

Gary Lineker and Micah Richards left red-faced over Scotland comment before Euro 2024

18 minutes ago

Princess Anne in hospital with minor injuries and concussion after incident

18 minutes ago

Steve Clarke on referee who failed to award Scotland a penalty

18 minutes ago

Countdown begins to French snap elections, with discouraging headlines for Macron

19 minutes ago

Umpires fire back at AFL, claim they're 'decoys'

19 minutes ago

Tamayo Perry Dies In Shark Attack: ‘Pirates Of The Caribbean’ Actor Was Aged 49

19 minutes ago

Myer proposes merger with Premier Investments’ apparel business

19 minutes ago

'A prayer answered': American detained for ammo in Turks and Caicos says of flight home

19 minutes ago

Blaming Trump for 'combustible atmosphere,' prosecutors to push for gag order in classified docs case

19 minutes ago

Princess Anne sustains minor injuries and concussion in an 'incident,' Buckingham Palace says

19 minutes ago

Max Verstappen fires back at British Grand Prix chief: ‘It’s not my fault’

19 minutes ago

You can enjoy this vegan protein powder hot as well as cold

19 minutes ago

Giants news, 7/24: Weekend review, vulnerable Cowboys, more

19 minutes ago

Nugent-Hopkins plays for the Stanley Cup 13 years to the day since being drafted by the Oilers

19 minutes ago

Fact check: Videos of politicians playing Minecraft are likely AI-generated

19 minutes ago

‘My studio costs half my income’: can British art survive soaring rents and property developers?

19 minutes ago

Kaizer Chiefs: FIVE new coaches! – LIST

19 minutes ago

Sunday's severe outbreak prompted 6 concurrent tornado warnings in Saskatchewan

19 minutes ago

Biden takes fresh immigration moves into debate with Trump

19 minutes ago

As far as I'm concerned, backless dresses are the only way to survive the heatwave

19 minutes ago

Georgia vs Portugal lineups: Predicted XIs, confirmed Euro 2024 team news and injury latest

19 minutes ago

Thousands of Ukrainians mark pagan festival with bonfire jumping and air raid notifications

19 minutes ago

China wants EU to remove tariffs on EVs by July 4 as talks resume

19 minutes ago

PGA Tour star tackled by security guard makes 18-word statement on protestor chaos

19 minutes ago

Stocks making the biggest moves before the bell: Nvidia, Ferrari, Planet Fitness, Cinemark and more

19 minutes ago

Fast fashion retailer Shein confidentially files for London IPO