Barking up the wrong tree: The internet wants you to believe this is the dog Kristi Noem shot. It isn’t.

The photo of the dog believed to be the one South Dakota Gov. Kristi Noem shot and killed has been seen millions of times on social media. It’s been published by one of the United Kingdom’s biggest newspapers. It was even distributed by a Washington, DC, animal rights group in a memo blasting Noem. Indeed, when I Googled “Kristi Noem’s dog” this morning, it was one of the first pictures that popped up.

But the dog in the photo isn’t Noem’s.

In an era of deepfakes and artificial intelligence, the photo is an important reminder in this election year that we can all still fall for far less sophisticated types of misinformation — especially when they come in the form of an adorable puppy.

And while the dog’s mistaken identity is undoubtedly good news for the dog in the picture (we are told he is alive and well), it’s a not so good reflection of the way we can all easily encounter and share unchecked viral misinformation.

Individual forums on Reddit are known as “subreddits,” and there is an endless universe of them devoted to dogs.

It was on the “Puppy” subreddit where user “LukeWarm273” posted a photo of their dog “Blue” last year.

The Reddit post was identified in a recent report by NewsGuard, a journalism organization that rates the reliability of news websites and tracks online disinformation campaigns.

“This is Blue, he’s 3/4 German Wirehaired pointer and 1/4 shorthair pointer!” LukeWarm273 wrote.

“He’s a cutie,” one Reddit user responded. “He’s adorable! I love his little nose,” wrote another.

The next day, LukeWarm273 posted more, equally adorable pictures of Blue, writing, “Everyone’s kind words made me want to share some more photos of my Blue! Honestly love this community!”

But last month — more than a year after LukeWarm273 posted their first picture of Blue on Reddit — Blue’s photo started showing up across the internet.

An inevitable mix of shock and outrage had followed Noem revealing in her book that she had shot and killed her dog Cricket (because Cricket had allegedly attacked some chickens, bit her and was “untrainable”). Noem had once been considered a contender for former President Donald Trump’s pick for vice president, but CNN previously reported that the South Dakota governor had already fallen off the presumptive GOP nominee’s shortlist long before this controversy began.

Still, the story quickly entered the national conversation and the internet kicked into high gear.

“Please join me in wishing Cricket (the dog Kristi Noem shot to death) a blessed journey to the land of beautiful puppy dog souls. 💔,” one user on X posted after the story emerged.

But the picture the user posted with the message wasn’t of Cricket; it was a picture of Blue. The post has been seen almost 600,000 times on X.

Even the actor Mark Hamill weighed in on X, sharing a broken heart emoji in response to the photo.

It is unclear how the X user found the photo of Blue, and it isn’t clear who the first person was to falsely link the photo of Blue to Noem. The image was also shared on X by at least two prominent users with about 900,000 followers each — they have both since removed it.

It showed up in a story about Noem on the website of The Telegraph, one of Britain’s oldest and biggest newspapers. That Telegraph story, along with the photograph, was syndicated through Yahoo! News, bringing it to an even wider audience.

barking up the wrong tree: the internet wants you to believe this is the dog kristi noem shot. it isn’t.

This screengrab shows a story from The Telegraph about Noem defending her decision to kill her dog. The story shows a photo of Reddit user LukeWarm273's dog, Blue, next to Noem. - From the Telegraph

The picture, along with the caption, “The Dog Murdered By Trump’s Potential Vice Presidential Running Mate Choice,” also appeared on the “community” page of Daily Kos, a popular progressive website with more than a million followers on Facebook.

Staff at NewsGuard tracked the spread of the image and found a Washington, DC-based animal rights group had mistakenly used the picture in a press release blasting Noem’s actions.

But the group, Animal Wellness Action, used a press release distribution service that automatically publishes releases to websites of local news outlets across the country. That meant the release and the photo of the dog showed up on the websites of at least 11 local TV stations in places like Florida, Nevada and South Carolina, according to NewsGuard.

Joseph Grove, senior director of communications for Animal Wellness Action, told CNN: “Our writer relied on extensive news coverage of the dog and the proliferation of that photo and took as fact that the photo was of Cricket. She had seen the image used, for example, on Yahoo News and the Daily Kos, as well as on numerous other platforms that shared the story. In retrospect, given the importance of credibility to Animal Wellness Action and the Center for a Humane Economy, we should have done our own due diligence. Lesson learned.”

Grove said Animal Wellness Action has asked the press release service to issue a clarification.

CNN has reached out to The Telegraph for comment. Daily Kos added a correction to its post after it was contacted by NewsGuard. The image “was not in fact a picture of [Noem’s] late dog,” the correction reads.

LukeWarm273 didn’t respond to CNN’s request for comment. The user, who told NewsGuard they want to remain anonymous, did confirm to NewsGuard that the picture that went all over the world is indeed their dog.

“This story shows how fake photos can go viral without the need for Photoshop, AI, or any high-tech tools,” NewsGuard enterprise editor Jack Brewster told CNN. “It also highlights how any photo, post, or comment can become the source of a viral false narrative, regardless of intent. In this case, a random Reddit post on a forum for cute puppy photos became the source of a viral false narrative that misled a major news site, local television stations, and dozens of prominent social media commentators.”

That spread of such false information can be especially problematic when the topic is controversial. “Oftentimes content emerges in a controversial news cycle that reinforces the narrative,” Ben Decker, the CEO of Memetica, a threat analysis company that tracks disinformation online, told CNN. “These types of emotive responses muddy the waters of truth, reinforcing true narratives with false context.”

Joan Donovan, an assistant professor of journalism and emerging media studies at Boston University, explained how online incentive structures reward peddlers of viral content. X, for example, now shares revenue with its users who create content that goes viral (though X says that content shouldn’t be false). Videos and images that pull on our heartstrings (like a cute puppy) are perfect fodder for virality.

“Who you trust is paramount because there are massive rewards (money and clout) for attention and amplification online. That incentivizes manipulators to twist or invent stories to make it seem like they got a scoop,” Donovan wrote in an email to CNN.

“[I] didn’t appreciate the misuse of my dog’s image because even though it is recorded that she [Noem] did in fact kill her dog, it doesn’t make it right to use an image of some cute dog on the internet to make people even more upset than they are now,” LukeWarm273 told NewsGuard.

LukeWarm273 confirmed Blue is alive and said he is a “good and protective dog.”

For more CNN news and newsletters create an account at CNN.com

OTHER NEWS

25 minutes ago

Prostate surgeon MR DECLAN CAHILL: The five key things I consider every day to keep my prostate healthy... and could even help me avoid cancer

25 minutes ago

Yellow teeth? Shoppers are wowed by bestselling £24.99 teeth whitening powder leaves smiles whiter FAST (and wait until you see the photos!)

25 minutes ago

Saasha was on the phone when she overheard a chilling threat made to her daughter Jessica Geddes on the other end of the line. Days later, her loved one was found dead

27 minutes ago

‘I’m ready to win’: Jeremy Corbyn attacks Labour for ‘strategy of austerity’

27 minutes ago

Putin promises ‘immediate’ ceasefire if Ukraine drops Nato bid I Ukraine: The Latest, Podcast

28 minutes ago

Flooding hits China’s south, temperatures sizzle elsewhere

30 minutes ago

2025 Mini Cooper 4 Door Arrives With More Space, Less Style

30 minutes ago

Father Jason Ferreira: $100 doesn't get you much

30 minutes ago

Ryan Tubridy's London Diary: Supervet Noel thanked me as he held a scalpel in his bloodied glove

30 minutes ago

‘I was rejected for PIP because I had a degree and smiled during my assessment’

36 minutes ago

Celtic eyeing cut-price move for 26-year-old who scored more than Maeda

36 minutes ago

NASCAR Cup Iowa: Kyle Larson beats Ryan Blaney to pole

37 minutes ago

Clement could boldly ditch Dessers in Rangers move for 6m machine

37 minutes ago

Love, loyalty and friendship: Everything to know about the Claddagh Ring

37 minutes ago

Australia break Scotland hearts with last-over victory in T20 World Cup thriller

37 minutes ago

John Cale’s lockdown music fuelled by rage

37 minutes ago

Katie Ledecky heading to her fourth Olympics, wins 400 freestyle at US swimming trials

37 minutes ago

Liverpool ASK for information about 19-year-old Juventus wonderkid

37 minutes ago

Pies pull off stunning AFL comeback to deny Kangaroos

37 minutes ago

NRL Highlights: Sea Eagles v Dragons - Round 15

37 minutes ago

World’s bestselling lash serum launches new advanced formula with results in 6 weeks

37 minutes ago

Lucien Laviscount: 'Being an actor isn't all red carpets and flights'

37 minutes ago

‘Carry On’ film franchise getting ‘non-woke’ reboot

38 minutes ago

Saudi FM Holds Talks with High-level Officials on Sidelines of Ukraine Peace Summit

38 minutes ago

Aussie boxer Paro stuns 'bogeyman' to claim world title

38 minutes ago

Pregnant Mandy Moore is effortlessly classy in a floral dress as Julia Fox flashes her toned midriff in a stylish look at 2024 Las Culturistas Culture Awards in NYC

38 minutes ago

A wobbly left and a wary right could cut the Labour vote with low turnout

38 minutes ago

What time is Poland vs. Netherlands on today? TV channel, live streams for Euro 2024 match

38 minutes ago

Angel Reese Took A Direct Shot At Caitlin Clark Over Social Media Before WNBA Meeting

38 minutes ago

Luke Littler shakes off 'rust' to win second World Series title at Poland Darts Open

38 minutes ago

England vs. Serbia Euro 2024 time, live stream, TV channel, lineups to watch Group C match in Australia

38 minutes ago

They survived 1997’s landslide, but some Tory veterans think the party is doomed

38 minutes ago

6 transported to hospitals amid shooting in Round Rock, Texas, officials say

38 minutes ago

Texas A&M robs homer in ninth, tops Florida in MCWS thriller

40 minutes ago

Italy v Albania: Azzurri recover from disastrous start to win Euro 2024 opener

44 minutes ago

‘Don’t stuff around with Mother Cricket’: Starc’s parting shot after Australia get England through

44 minutes ago

Two great cricket rivalries have fizzled out at the T20 World Cup, but there's still one to watch

44 minutes ago

Letters: In praise of the kindness of strangers at a frightening time

44 minutes ago

Serbia to green light Rio Tinto lithium mine, FT reports

44 minutes ago

Zachary Porthen captain as Junior Springboks aim to ‘create own story’ at World Cup