Fact Check: Trump Doesn't Need a Criminal Conviction for Ballot Removal, According to Research on 14th Amendment

fact check: trump doesn't need a criminal conviction for ballot removal, according to research on 14th amendment

A rumor said that the 14th Amendment requires former US President Donald Trump to receive a criminal conviction in order to be removed from the 2024 election ballot. Scott Olson/Getty Images

Claim:

Section 3 of the 14th Amendment in the U.S. Constitution expressly specifies that a criminal conviction for insurrection is needed to disqualify a candidate from state or federal office.

Rating:

False (About this rating?)

On Dec. 28, 2023, a user on X made a post falsely claiming that a reading of the 14th Amendment of the U.S. Constitution showed that former U.S. President Donald Trump would need to be convicted of insurrection in order to be removed from the ballot for the 2024 election.

fact check: trump doesn't need a criminal conviction for ballot removal, according to research on 14th amendment

A rumor said that the 14th Amendment requires former US President Donald Trump to receive a criminal conviction in order to be removed from the 2024 election ballot.

The post in question read as follows:

In order to be removed from the ballot under the 14th amendment, there needs to be a CRIMINAL conviction for the crime of insurrection.

That has never happened.

Therefore, you cannot remove Trump from the ballot under the 14th amendment.

Continuously saying the opposite of that makes you sound like a person who never stopped eating paste when you left kindergarten.

The user’s post and its incorrect information ended with a last line that apparently remarked about users who post incorrect information.

The data in the post did not square with a reading of the 14th Amendment or the nonpartisan Congressional Research Service’s (CRS) study of the text.

What Is This About?

Trump was indicted on Aug. 1 on four felony conspiracy counts in special counsel Jack Smith’s 2020 election interference case. In a statement delivered on the same day, Smith called the Capitol riot of Jan. 6, 2021 “an unprecedented assault on the seat of American democracy.”

“As described in the indictment, it was fueled by lies,” Smith continued. “Lies by the defendant targeted at obstructing a bedrock function of the U.S. government, the nation’s process of collecting, counting and certifying the results of the presidential election.”

On Dec. 19, the Colorado Supreme Court declared Trump would be removed from the state’s ballot, citing a clause in Section 3 of the 14th Amendment.

Nine days later, Maine’s Democratic Secretary of State Shenna Bellows also removed Trump from the state’s primary ballot, citing the same clause.

What Does the 14th Amendment Say?

Section 3 of the 14th Amendment reads as follows:

No person shall be a Senator or Representative in Congress, or elector of President and Vice-President, or hold any office, civil or military, under the United States, or under any State, who, having previously taken an oath, as a member of Congress, or as an officer of the United States, or as a member of any State legislature, or as an executive or judicial officer of any State, to support the Constitution of the United States, shall have engaged in insurrection or rebellion against the same, or given aid or comfort to the enemies thereof. But Congress may by a vote of two-thirds of each House, remove such disability.

When Was the 14th Amendment Enacted?

Findings published by the CRS, that also were cited in similar reporting by NBC News, laid out more information about the history of Section 3:

Enacted in the aftermath of the Civil War, Section 3 seems specifically designed for the Reconstruction Era but may be applicable to modern times as well. Section 3 was for the most part used only for the short period between its ratification and the 1872 enactment of the Amnesty Act. The Amnesty Act removed the disqualification from most Confederates and their sympathizers and was enacted by a two-thirds majority of Congress in accordance with the terms of Section 3. Some argue the Amnesty Act operates retrospectively. In a recent case, Cawthorn v. Amalfi, discussed in this Legal Sidebar, the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Fourth Circuit found that the act does not apply to later insurrections or treasonous acts.

Is a Criminal Conviction Needed for Ballot Removal?

The report from the CRS specified, “Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment does not expressly require a criminal conviction, and historically, one was not necessary.”

Further, the report laid out the history of the usage of Section 3:

Reconstruction Era federal prosecutors brought civil actions in court to oust officials linked to the Confederacy, and Congress in some cases took action to refuse to seat Members. Congress last used Section 3 of the Fourteenth Amendment in 1919 to refuse to seat a socialist Congressman accused of having given aid and comfort to Germany during the First World War, irrespective of the Amnesty Act. The Congressman, Victor Berger, was eventually seated at a subsequent Congress after the Supreme Court threw out his espionage conviction for judicial bias.

OTHER NEWS

28 minutes ago

‘Original recipe for disaster’: Alleged drunk driver fined, faces charges after KFC drive-through mishap

28 minutes ago

2025 Mini Aceman price and specs: Electric SUV starts under $60k

28 minutes ago

"We didn't have all the publicity, we didn't have the guys with Nike" - Oscar Robertson says his 1960 Olympics team was also a Dream Team

28 minutes ago

Government is 'treading on eggshells' when dealing with China

28 minutes ago

Suho Says He "Read 'Missing Crown Prince' Script Hundred Times"

28 minutes ago

Slater's huge Gagai prediction after surprise recall

28 minutes ago

Gareth Southgate offers Kieran Trippier injury update and gives verdict on Marc Guehi

28 minutes ago

Jude Bellingham gives England winning start but Serbia make Southgate sweat

28 minutes ago

Trump and Biden offer wildly different Father’s Day messages

28 minutes ago

Meet The First Afro Hair-Textured Salon To Launch In Selfridges

30 minutes ago

Watchdog: Nuclear-armed nations are deepening reliance on nuclear weapons

32 minutes ago

Hamilton Ticats blow late lead, lose 33-30 to Roughriders

32 minutes ago

Ariana DeBose Pays Tribute To Chita Rivera At Tony Awards: “I Literally Would Not Be Here Without Chita Blazing The Trail”

34 minutes ago

Frustrated homeowner seeks advice after neighbor cuts down trees on property: 'I have spent so much time and money improving my yard'

34 minutes ago

Man Utd's next Branthwaite bid, Chelsea's Musiala hope, Arsenal's new Mudryk battle: FootballTransfers recap

34 minutes ago

NEET row: Kapil Sibal criticises PM Modi, says accept "corruption prevalent in country"

34 minutes ago

Chargers News: Quentin Johnston Earning Justin Herbert's High Praise in Offseason

34 minutes ago

Ryan Blaney: ‘Means a lot to me’ to win at Iowa

37 minutes ago

Timbergrove resident still waiting for debris pick up, roof repairs worried about flood risk

38 minutes ago

Ronwen Williams returns to Gelvandale to bring hope

38 minutes ago

Broncos roster review: Safety Tanner McCalister

38 minutes ago

Tunis plays host to seminar on "Tunisian- Indonesian Relations, Bridge of Creativity for Constructive Culture"

42 minutes ago

Chuck Schumer deletes Father’s Day photo tweet in front of grill after critics slam his spatula skills

43 minutes ago

Visma | Lease a Bike reflects in Switzerland: "The best Kelderman has to offer' and "The Uijtdebroeks process"

43 minutes ago

Some fintechs will suffer, some will gain from new Apple Pay, Wallet features

43 minutes ago

'Bridgerton' Season 3: Eloise Fan Theory Has Been Debunked

44 minutes ago

Lachie Neale clears the air on post-game kiss with Channel 7 commentator

44 minutes ago

Michelle Elman: Hours after getting engaged I discovered my fiance cheated on me with my Instagram followers

44 minutes ago

U.S. Open 2024: Bryson DeChambeau's last-minute equipment change, explained

44 minutes ago

Clash between two communities in Telangana's Medak over cow transportation, Section 144 imposed

44 minutes ago

'It's like prison' - Jacqueline Jossa talks pros and cons of school and considers homeschooling for her girls

44 minutes ago

Patrick Mahomes gets 'MVP dad' tribute on Father's Day from wife Brittany and kids Sterling and Bronze

44 minutes ago

Wild moment woman slaps man across the head as she tries to break up brawl in the middle of the street in Newtown

47 minutes ago

Benjamin Heels: Music teacher jailed after preying on students wants his sentence slashed by ‘years’, court told

47 minutes ago

Lies, bad ads, no rules - social media under scrutiny

50 minutes ago

US Open day four: Misses will haunt Rory McIlroy for life says Nick Faldo

50 minutes ago

Roughriders hit walk-off field goal to stun Tiger-Cats

50 minutes ago

After first sweep of Padres in 18 years, Mets in NL wild-card race despite 33-37 record

50 minutes ago

Bryson DeChambeau blasted for hypocrisy

50 minutes ago

Cheap electric car gets big price cut