Apple wins appeal to continue sales of smartwatches

amazon, apple wins appeal to continue sales of smartwatches

Apple wins appeal to continue sales of smartwatches

Apple’s primary smartwatch sales can now continue, as a U.S. appeals court postponed the government commission’s import ban on the devices on Wednesday. The ban was imposed in connection with a patent dispute over Apple’s medical monitoring technology.

In an emergency request, the tech giant requested that the U.S. Court of Appeals for the Federal Circuit revoke an order issued by the U.S. International Trade Commission (ITC), which had declared that Apple had violated the patents of Masimo, a company located in Irvine, California.

According to analysts, a final ruling might cost both companies millions of dollars and might even require a settlement or some sort of technological workaround by Apple. Ultimately, they said, the negative publicity the lawsuit is creating is probably going to outweigh any financial loss for Apple.

Masimo shares closed 4.6% lower at $115.11 following the decision on Wednesday, and Apple shares closed flat at $193.15.

“We are thrilled to return the full Apple Watch lineup to customers in time for the new year,” Apple said in a statement. “Apple Watch Series 9 and Apple Watch Ultra 2, including the blood oxygen feature, will become available for purchase again in the United States at Apple Stores starting today and from apple.com tomorrow by 12 pm PT.”

Masimo declined to comment on the court decision.

The ITC barred imports and sales of Apple Watches with technology for reading blood-oxygen levels. Starting with its Series 6 model in 2020, Apple included a pulse oximeter feature in its smartwatches.

Masimo has accused Apple of hiring away its employees, stealing its pulse oximetry technology and incorporating it into Apple Watches. Apple has countersued, calling Masimo’s legal actions a “maneuver to clear a path” for its own competing smartwatch.

“Apple can easily develop their own blood monitoring software, it is just a matter of time … The software development costs are not something that will be too concerning for a company as wealthy as Apple,” said Stuart Cole, chief macro economist at Equiti Capital.

“The bigger issue is that this is not very good PR for Apple, suggesting as it does that Apple is stealing technology from competitors rather than developing its own. Apple is fighting this lawsuit more with an eye on what it means for their future health-wearable products rather than this specific blood oxygen monitoring piece of software,” he said.

In a four-paragraph ruling on Wednesday, the appeals court said it would halt the ban while it considers Apple’s motion for a longer-term pause during the appeals process. The court gave the ITC until Jan. 10 to respond to Apple’s request.

U.S. President Joe Biden’s administration declined to veto the ban on Tuesday, allowing it to take effect. Apple asked for a pause of the ban later that day.

Apple has said it is working on a range of legal and technical options.

On Tuesday, the company told the court that U.S. Customs and Border Protection is considering whether redesigned versions of its watches infringe Masimo’s patents and can be imported. The customs agency has set a target date of Jan. 12 for its decision, Apple said.

Apple had paused sales of the affected devices from its website and retail locations last week in the United States due to the ITC decision. They remained available at retailers including Amazon (AMZN.O), Best Buy (BBY.N), Costco (COST.O) and Walmart (WMT.N).

The ban did not affect the Apple Watch SE, a less-expensive model without a pulse oximeter. Previously sold watches also were not be affected by the ban.

A jury trial on Masimo’s allegations against Apple in California federal court had ended with a mistrial in May.

Apple’s wearables, home and accessory business, which includes the Apple Watch, AirPods earbuds and other products, brought in $8.28 billion in revenue during the third quarter of 2023, according to a company report.

(with inputs from Reuters)

OTHER NEWS

21 minutes ago

UK royals unite on palace balcony, with Kate back at her first public event since cancer diagnosis

21 minutes ago

The Real Reason Batman Has A No-Killing Rule

21 minutes ago

Judge rejects religious leaders' challenge of Missouri abortion ban

24 minutes ago

Video: Doctor Who fans are left in hysterics as villain Susan Triad recreates Theresa May's iconic viral dance ahead of shocking twist

24 minutes ago

Video: Moment thrill-seekers scream with terror as they are left dangling upside down after ride breaks down: 'People were saying their last words'

24 minutes ago

Video: Bill Maher issues stark warning to Joe Biden that the Democrats' immigration policy is 'going to get them 'f***ed on Election Day'

25 minutes ago

Kate Middleton shares amazing behind-the-scenes video at King's birthday parade

25 minutes ago

Ian Wright fights back tears on live TV in emotional tribute to Kevin Campbell

25 minutes ago

My fair Kate! Princess channels Eliza Doolittle in monochrome dress

25 minutes ago

Nick Cave explains one activity that transformed his mental health

25 minutes ago

Joel Embiid, at the NBA Finals, says he's feeling well and on track for Olympics

25 minutes ago

NYT columnist admits ‘something has gone badly wrong’ in west coast states because of Democratic leadership

25 minutes ago

Taylor Swift Celebrates Chiefs Re-Signing Mecole Hardman

26 minutes ago

Why Estebana abandoned science to become a blacksmith

30 minutes ago

Marvel of Eriksen’s recovery reminds us that glory comes in many forms

30 minutes ago

10 PHEVs With the Best Electric Range for 2024

30 minutes ago

'It was a stark contrast': Teams Trump & Biden pitch CEOs

30 minutes ago

Normani Says Embracing Her Blackness on ‘Dopamine' Felt Like ‘Showing Up for Myself'

30 minutes ago

Microsoft set to dock bosses' pay — if they haven't shown good cybersecurity performance

32 minutes ago

'I like being busy' - Footballer of the Year, teacher, restaurant owner, and coach

32 minutes ago

Opinion | The Supreme Court’s Welcome Bump Stock Ruling

32 minutes ago

Man City looking to 'blow up' Real Madrid's move for River Plate teenager

32 minutes ago

Sue Radford glams up with daughters as she treats her kids to Taylor Swift tickets

32 minutes ago

Spain unleash high-speed demolition of Croatia to put tiki-taka in the past

32 minutes ago

Lord Cameron accuses Nigel Farage of ‘trying to destroy Conservative Party’

34 minutes ago

Annecy Winners: Adam Elliot’s ’Memoir Of A Snail’ Wins Top Cristal Award

37 minutes ago

Shari Redstone’s refusal to sell Paramount to Skydance won’t keep her away from the negotiating table for long

37 minutes ago

Emma Raducanu's opponent pulls out hours before tie after blaming Brit for falling ill

37 minutes ago

U.S. Open live golf scores, results, highlights from Saturday's Round 3 leaderboard

37 minutes ago

Harry Kane will feel like he needs tournament glory more than anyone in England squad

37 minutes ago

Premier says union influence claims ‘misleading’ as extra $15m allocated for sport

37 minutes ago

Trump VP contender gets ringing endorsement from 'Shark Tank's' Kevin O'Leary: 'This guy gets stuff done'

37 minutes ago

Maple Leafs make major change to coaching staff

37 minutes ago

Charlamagne Tha God says Biden ‘doing corny, goofy stuff' because he doesn’t actually talk to his voters

37 minutes ago

Angel Reese Breaks Silence After Chicago Sky Coach's Enraged Walkout Following Loss

37 minutes ago

Lionel Messi News: Son Thiago 'would like to play' Barcelona wonderkid Lamine Yamal

37 minutes ago

Starmer hits out at ‘desperate’ Tories as he rules out tax raid on family homes

37 minutes ago

Katie Ledecky off to a strong start at US Olympic swimming trials, leads prelims of 400 free

37 minutes ago

Sars to make life easy for you

37 minutes ago

Rising violence against politicians is an attack on democracy itself