AFL boss Kane admits umpire error late in Pies' win

afl boss kane admits umpire error late in pies' win

North Melbourne players were devastated after their one-point loss to Collingwood.

The AFL has conceded a mistake was made, only not the umpiring decision that many people think should have happened.

North Melbourne's Bailey Scott was denied a 50m penalty late in Sunday's one-point loss to Collingwood at Marvel Stadium.

He took a mark outside 50m, then Magpies pair Steele Sidebottom and Beau McCreery immediately moved on him as he tried to kick into attack.

There's a widespread feeling that should have cost the Magpies a 50m penalty, which would have given Scott a golden chance to put North back in front with less than a minute left.

But AFL football boss Laura Kane says the crucial error was in what the umpire did immediately after Scott took the mark.

"It was a confusing situation and I understand why people ... are left wanting to understand what happened," she said on Monday.

"One of two calls could be made - it could be 'play on' immediately, or it could be 'stand', which would indicate the mark had been paid.

"Neither of those two calls occurred in the immediate moments after the whistle was blown and Bailey takes four steps or so inbound, and looks to play on.

"The correct call should have been 'play on' initially - that has caused confusion for the players in the immediate vicinity, being the Collingwood players, that there was a delay. The communication was the error, I guess."

Kane said if the umpire had called "stand" immediately and the two Collingwood players had closed on Scott, then it would have been a 50m penalty.

"The initial mistake, if you like, is that play-on wasn't called," she said on the AFL website.

"'What's next didn't come quick enough ... every objective marker of 'play on' was there."

Kane also backed how another incident was adjudicated earlier in the game, also involving Scott.

Collingwood's Jack Crisp snapped a goal, but a replay shows Scott might have touched it off the boot.

Kane said the goal was reviewed in the league's video hub.

"We need certainty in the ARC (AFL Review Centre) and our score reviewers need to see, and be certain, that the vision shows very clearly that the ball was touched," Kane said

"We didn't have that certainty - it is a line-ball call.

"We were happy with the process  - I understand how you would get to either outcome.

"They didn't have definitive vision or a definitive image to overturn the call."

OTHER NEWS

16 minutes ago

Fans Blame Richard Childress' Kyle Busch Favoritism Behind Parting Ways With NASCAR Legend

17 minutes ago

Assange steps foot on Australian soil

17 minutes ago

Huge play from Crichton puts Maroons star 'in all sorts'

17 minutes ago

Orania becomes another factor in the GNU scuffle

17 minutes ago

I tried wall squats every day for a week - and can't believe how much of a workout they are

17 minutes ago

‘Train wreck’: Tony Abbott slams Labor’s ‘economic self-harm’ over energy debate

17 minutes ago

Moment gates officially open for Glastonbury 2024 as crowds flock to Worthy Farm

17 minutes ago

Putin Dealt a Double Blow in Europe

17 minutes ago

NHS paying the price for boom in weight-loss surgery abroad, doctors warn

17 minutes ago

Lomax leaps over Taulagi for stunning try

17 minutes ago

Water bill hike to be partly offset for concession card holders, including pensioners and veterans

18 minutes ago

FDA warns maker of Sara Lee and Entenmann's not to claim foods contain allergens when they don't

18 minutes ago

The Bear season three is coming in hot – here’s how to watch

18 minutes ago

Winning goal scorer Sabitzer puts left foot forward for Austria

18 minutes ago

Misfiring Serbia's Euros debut was one to forget

18 minutes ago

Police warn of rise in bulk order scams after victims lose at least $831k

18 minutes ago

Torren Foot: Air travel trend ‘raw dogging’ takes over TikTok in bizarre throwback to pre-entertainment era

20 minutes ago

Do debates still matter? Impact wanes amid polarization, viral competition: Experts

21 minutes ago

Ask Amy: Finding the best electric rates

22 minutes ago

Julian Assange returns to Australia after being freed in plea deal 

25 minutes ago

Why 9-to-5 businesses do not meet Americans’ local necessities

26 minutes ago

Expensive Rolls Royce draws attention as it is being offloaded from a container

27 minutes ago

Pensioners 'biggest beneficiaries of tax and benefit changes' since 2010

27 minutes ago

Two US astronauts stranded in space on board Boeing’s Starliner capsule

27 minutes ago

Crichton cops early high shot

27 minutes ago

Julia Phillips' 6 favorite books that explore the beauty and brutality of life

27 minutes ago

China's EV architect says investing in Europe is a way forward

27 minutes ago

Lanes closed, traffic expected following I-290 crash that left 1 seriously injured

27 minutes ago

Texas inmate facing execution for 2001 fatal shooting as his lawyers argue he’s no longer a danger

27 minutes ago

Olympic champion swimmers tell Congress US athletes lost faith in anti-doping regulator

27 minutes ago

Paris court to decide on validity of France's arrest warrant for Syrian President Bashar Assad

27 minutes ago

AirTag-like trackers for Android phones are finally here

31 minutes ago

Verizon Launches ‘MyHome’ Plan With Discounted Streaming And Option Of YouTube TV For Bundled Pay-TV Service

31 minutes ago

Sphere Media To Buy ‘Leaving Neverland’ Seller Abacus Media Rights For $18.6M

32 minutes ago

Man United women moved out of their training centre and into PORTABLE buildings to accommodate the men's team during Carrington revamp - raising fresh concerns over Sir Jim Ratcliffe's commitment

32 minutes ago

Video: Inside the Serpentine Gallery's boozy summer soiree: Wine-swilling Maya Jama snaps selfies with Laurence Fishburne while Venus Williams dotes on Edward Enninful and Bianca Jagger pulls in Sadiq Khan for a cheeky hug!

32 minutes ago

Video: 'I'll protect what's mine at all costs': Mother (who has black belt in Taekwondo) seen launching herself through the air to tackle thief to the ground after he stole her motorbike in extraordinary CCTV

32 minutes ago

Video: Katy Perry shows off her incredible abs as she goes braless in a perilously plunging fur coat for Paris' Balenciaga show after furiously hitting back at Ozempic claims

32 minutes ago

Video: Julian Assange: Wife reveals what freed Wikileaks founder is looking forward to doing after landing in Australia

32 minutes ago

World Cup's 'sexiest fan' Ivana Knoll reacts to Croatia's crushing Euro 2024 draw against Italy after supporting her country from the stands