‘Presumed Innocent’ suits up Jake Gyllenhaal for a pulpy courtroom drama

‘presumed innocent’ suits up jake gyllenhaal for a pulpy courtroom drama

Jake Gyllenhaal and Renate Reinsve in "Presumed Innocent," premiering on Apple TV+.

Bearing little resemblance to the 1990 movie starring Harrison Ford, “Presumed Innocent” has become an Apple TV+ limited series with an old-fashioned, pulpy feel – “old-fashioned” in the way classic courtroom dramas incorporated dramatic flourishes that would never, ever happen in a real trial. Jake Gyllenhaal stars as the accused prosecutor, in a show that works strictly as a check-your-brain-at-the-courthouse-steps exercise.

Filled with florid characters and overheated situations, writer David E. Kelley (whose credits include lots of legal dramas dating back to “L.A. Law”) teams up with producer J.J. Abrams on this adaptation of Scott Turow’s book, which capitalizes on the eight-episode format to take a longer time (too long, frankly) before getting into the courtroom.

Mostly, that provides opportunities to get to know Rusty Sabich (Gyllenhaal, having moved into pass-the-popcorn mode between this and “Road House”) and his family dynamics in a deeper way, before he’s thrown into a tailspin when accused of murdering colleague Carolyn Polhemus (Norwegian star Renate Reinsve), with whom he was having an affair and, by his own admission, obsessed.

Rusty’s wife, Barbara (Ruth Negga), doesn’t believe he killed her, but the case drags his infidelity into public view and essentially rubs her nose in it, with plenty of flashbacks of their steamy illicit trysts to put an exclamation point on that because, hey, streaming.

Other than Gyllenhaal, whose take on Rusty is decidedly less sympathetic than Ford’s was (albeit with a better haircut, although the rest of the movie feels superior), everyone else appears to be working off cue cards that say “DO IT BIGGER.” That includes Negga as the wounded wife; Gyllenhaal’s real-life brother-in-law, Peter Sarsgaard, as the prosecutor, Tommy Molto, champing at the bit to convict Rusty; and Bill Camp as Raymond Horgan, the former boss who agrees to defend him.

Notably, that tonal criticism also applies to Kelley’s other recent drama based on a novel, Netflix’s “A Man in Full,” which, in both cases, somewhat neutralizes an impressive cast.

“Presumed Innocent” nevertheless proves watchable despite – and for some, surely, because of – its excesses. Apple made seven of the eight episodes available, so how this version handles the twisty ending remains to be seen, though it’s fair to say the production takes a few liberties up until that point.

“This is nuts,” Rusty’s teenage daughter says as suspicion falls upon her dad, which makes her sound both like a legal analyst, at least in the context of this trial, and an astute TV critic.

“Presumed Innocent” does have its moments, but in terms of making a case for committing to sit through eight chapters, Kelley, Gyllenhaal and company haven’t exactly put together an open-and-shut case.

“Presumed Innocent” premieres June 12 on Apple TV+.

For more CNN news and newsletters create an account at CNN.com

OTHER NEWS

19 minutes ago

FEMA urged to treat heat as a disaster; Biden's protections for undocumented spouses

20 minutes ago

How the hated RingGo parking app made you a ‘cash cow’ for Britain’s councils

20 minutes ago

Brighton enquire about a move for Leeds winger Crysencio Summerville, with Seagulls stepping up interest in Championship Player of the Season

20 minutes ago

'Drunk' RAF serviceman sexually assaulted sleeping female colleague after a movie night while deployed in Poland, court martial told

20 minutes ago

Video: Chilling moment laughing killer, 18, filmed himself making gun sign after stabbing boy, 17, to death and pushing him into a canal as he stole Ikea bag full of knives - before writing rap song bragging about murder

20 minutes ago

Chelsea Champions League winner announces his retirement from football at 34 after struggling with injuries

20 minutes ago

A year on from the Titan disaster, OceanGate co-founder Guillermo Sohnlein vows to continue with dangerous deep sea exploration

20 minutes ago

Revealed: Why David Alaba isn't playing for Austria at Euro 2024 despite being with the team in Germany as Real Madrid star will take up unique role

20 minutes ago

Steve Borthwick has thrown down the gauntlet to Eddie Jones with his early England line-up, writes CHRIS FOY... with Marcus Smith primed to make his mark at 10 versus Japan

20 minutes ago

Footy's most magnificent mullet is BACK: Game's unluckiest star set for return in major boost... but can his torrid run of injuries finally come to an end?

20 minutes ago

Jahvid Gadd learns his fate over brutal attack of a woman in her Mildura home

22 minutes ago

Insurance provider suddenly drops pet coverage for 100,000 owners

23 minutes ago

England players hit back at criticism of Serbia win

23 minutes ago

Aston Villa told they can sign star who Pep called "brilliant" for 30m

23 minutes ago

The Three-Body Problem to Receive a New Adaptation Amid Netflix Success

24 minutes ago

ST Explains: How is Singapore responding to the recent oil spill incident?

24 minutes ago

Can Florida win Stanley Cup? Panthers vs. Oilers live stream, TV, odds, keys to Game 5

25 minutes ago

Denmark vs England: Euro 2024 prediction, kick-off time, TV, live stream, team news, h2h results, odds

25 minutes ago

Canada slaps new sanctions on Russians over Navalny’s death

25 minutes ago

John Swinney unveils discount broadband plan already offered by providers

25 minutes ago

BBC Newsnight host slaps down Reform candidate in heated row - 'let me speak'

25 minutes ago

‘Runaway items in the budget’: NDIS a ‘vast pool of money’

25 minutes ago

How Jordan Chiles' success and influence is inspiring young gymnasts

27 minutes ago

Zimbabwe consulate in South Africa rolls out e-passports

27 minutes ago

Labour council tax confusion as Starmer fails to rule out increase

27 minutes ago

Seaside town named 'UK's nimby capital' with ice cream van and dog beach ban

31 minutes ago

Chicago weather: 100-degree heat index continues, but that doesn't mean it's a ‘heat wave'

31 minutes ago

Everton's private fixture request to Premier League bosses comes to light

31 minutes ago

Who are Green Party leaders Carla Denyer and Adrian Ramsay?

31 minutes ago

Los Angeles schools to consider ban on smartphones

31 minutes ago

Rachel Morin’s family reveals touching way they celebrated murder arrest: ‘This trail belongs to Rachel again’

31 minutes ago

'I've been to hell and back': Teen who burned hole in her lung after vaping equivalent to 400 cigarettes a week issues stark warning

31 minutes ago

Adorable moment girl, 7, who beat cancer and is now in need of a lung transplant finds out she is going to Taylor Swift's Eras Tour on its 100th show

31 minutes ago

Super Mario! Former Man City striker Balotelli shows off his impressive Muay Thai skills in training video... as Italian star visits a gym in Thailand during his post-season holidays

31 minutes ago

Keir Starmer reveals real reason why wife Victoria has been absent from the election campaign trail

34 minutes ago

Springboks: Arthritis diagnosis, ruled out Ireland series! – Report

34 minutes ago

This week’s grocery deals: Who has the lowest prices?

34 minutes ago

Brad Pitt's F1 blockbuster produced by Lewis Hamilton gets 2025 release date

34 minutes ago

Collingwood cult hero Dane Swan joins Hall of Fame

34 minutes ago

Reform candidate loses cool on BBC at brutally honest question - 'Absolute garbage!'