House of Commons launches study of controversial travel spending rule

The House of Commons has launched a study of a clause in its spending rules that has allowed MPs travelling to caucus meetings connected to party conventions to claim hundreds of thousands of dollars in expenses over the past year.

Officials are also being asked to recommend ways the rules can be tightened up or improved.

Members of the Board of Internal Economy, which oversees the operation of the House of Commons and its spending, adopted a proposal from Liberal MP Mark Gerretsen to examine the exception to the general rule that prohibits MPs from claiming expenses related to partisan events, such as political party conventions.

"I'm hoping that we could perhaps give some direction to the staff here to go back and perhaps make some recommendations on how we can tighten up these loopholes," Gerretsen told the board, which is composed of MPs from the four parties recognized in the House of Commons.

Conservative House leader Andrew Scheer took exception to the suggestion that there was a loophole in the spending rules, saying the provisions were agreed to by all parties in 2011.

"He's characterizing this as a loophole, but quite the opposite, it wasn't a loophole," said Scheer, who served as Speaker at the time and was a member of the BOIE. "It was a conscious decision that the board made to put some rules around caucus meetings and travel."

Scheer urged House of Commons officials to also study the cost of caucus meetings held outside of Ottawa that aren't held in connection with a party convention.

While the Conservatives, New Democrats and the Bloc Québécois have all held caucus meetings alongside party conventions, the Liberal Party decided in 2014 not to take advantage of that clause in the rules. It has, however, held caucus meetings outside Ottawa and its MPs have claimed travel expenses for those meetings.

house of commons launches study of controversial travel spending rule

Conservative House leader Andrew Scheer says that the committee should examine the cost of caucus meetings held outside of Ottawa. (Adrian Wyld/The Canadian Press)

"There are regularly caucus meetings for national caucuses outside of Ottawa in the form of retreats," said Scheer, citing hundreds of thousands of dollars worth of expenses claimed by Liberal MPs to travel to the party's last few caucus meetings outside Ottawa.

"If the Liberals are going to characterize that as a loophole, clearly those are also loopholes that the administration should consider and come back with options for changing the rules on that as well."

CBC News has reported that a clause in the House of Commons spending rules has allowed MPs to charge $538,314 in travel, accommodation, meals and incidental to Parliament since May 2023 to attend caucus meetings connected to party conventions, including more than $84,000 for "designated travelers," often MPs' spouses.

Under the House of Commons rules, MPs generally cannot charge expenses related to partisan political activity such as party conventions or fundraising events. But MPs can claim expenses related to national caucus meetings, which are considered part of their parliamentary functions.

If a party holds a national caucus meeting at the same time and place as its party convention, MPs, their employees and designated travelers can charge travel, two nights of accommodation, meals and incidentals to attend the caucus meeting — effectively subsidizing their travel to the convention at the same time.

Conservative MPs accounted for 79 per cent of the spending by MPs, billing their House of Commons office budgets for $426,283 to go to Quebec City in September 2023. Conservative MPs were the only ones to bill Parliament for spouses to travel to a caucus meeting connected to a convention during the past year.

house of commons launches study of controversial travel spending rule

Conservative delegate Patrick Wuori calls on the crowd prior to party leader Pierre Poilievre's speech at the Conservative Party Convention on Friday, September 8, 2023 in Quebec City. (Jacques Boissinot/Canadian Press)

New Democratic Party MPs had the second highest total, billing Parliament $83,087 from their MP office budgets to send MPs and a dozen of their employees to Hamilton in October 2023. The Bloc Québécois, whose MPs are all located in Quebec, billed their MP office budgets $28,943 for travel to Drummondville in May 2023, while Bloc Leader Yves-François Blanchet charged $594 to his House of Commons leader's budget, as did four of his employees.

While MPs agreed on asking House of Commons staff to study the rules, they criticized what they called the political tone of Gerretsen's letter and his reference to a loophole.

NDP House leader Peter Julian defended the practice, saying holding a convention at the same time as a caucus meeting can help MPs incorporate a party resolution on an issue like pharmacare into their work on Parliament Hill.

Julian said he is also concerned that Liberal MPs used their travel budgets to come to Ottawa for Parliament but it also allowed them to be in Ottawa for the weekend of their party's last convention.

Julian said the rules should not stop parties from holding caucus meetings in various parts of Canada.

"To suggest that we only encourage party conventions and caucus meetings that are held in the National Capital Region does a disservice to the vastness of this land."

OTHER NEWS

21 minutes ago

Reeves to tout Labour wealth fund plan at start of economy-focused campaign week

21 minutes ago

Australia sink brave Scots at T20 World Cup, England advance

21 minutes ago

Springboks: Another injury to top star! – UPDATE

21 minutes ago

'I was BLOWN away by this product': Give your skin the summer vacation it needs with this ultra-hydrating hyaluronic acid serum - and it's only $16!

21 minutes ago

'It looks so expensive!' Hitting the road this summer? Shoppers LOVE this two-piece carry-on and weekender set with space for your laptop, shoes, and even coffee - and you can save 20% today

21 minutes ago

No batteries, no charging! This spray mop comes with cleaning pods and a washable microfiber pad to leave your flooring SPOTLESS with no effort - and you can get it for 20% off right now

21 minutes ago

Petroleum Min Statement Re-affirms Govt's Commitment To Achieve 20% Ethanol Blending By 2025

21 minutes ago

Spare a prayer for Rishi? Britain's first PM of Indian heritage reveals he has turned to his Hindu faith to give him strength amid election campaign

25 minutes ago

Inside Out 2 fans ‘heartbroken’ over one key change from Pixar’s original

25 minutes ago

Woodward, Bernstein reflect on Watergate reporting 50 years later

27 minutes ago

12 Little Known Facts About Glen Powell

27 minutes ago

A school board reinstated Confederate names. It split the community again.

27 minutes ago

Corrie's Claire Sweeney admits nerves around filming with 'fascinating' legend

27 minutes ago

Yimbies welcome Labor’s plan for more housing in Melbourne and Geelong but question priorities

27 minutes ago

Advisors ‘wary’ of bitcoin ETFs are on a slow adoption journey, says BlackRock exec

33 minutes ago

Bec Judd reveals what really happened to THAT red dress which launched her career at the 2004 Brownlow

33 minutes ago

Gareth Southgate reveals he will make a late call on Luke Shaw as he reveals every England player trained ahead of their Euro 2024 opener against Serbia

33 minutes ago

Half of travelers are avoiding Boeing planes in wake of safety incidents

33 minutes ago

England stars 'set to pocket record bonus if they win Euro 2024', with Gareth Southgate in line for a bumper pay packet and 'two Three Lions poised to split an almost £10MILLION kitty'

33 minutes ago

David Moyes recalls awkward moment he was caught on camera singing THAT vulgar West Ham chant about Jarrod Bowen and partner Dani Dyer

33 minutes ago

Proof of Bible story about angels killing 185,000 soldiers in a night is uncovered after 2,700 years

34 minutes ago

Japan did it first. Chinese stocks with some of the biggest global upside

35 minutes ago

Gareth Southgate offers huge Luke Shaw injury update ahead of England's Euro 2024 opener

35 minutes ago

Super League: Leigh Leopards boss Adrian Lam vows his side 'can match anyone' after Catalans win

35 minutes ago

‘My mother’s death left me with an urgent mission’: Rachael Stirling on sharing Diana Rigg’s views on assisted dying

35 minutes ago

Szoboszlai RECORD, Van Dijk UPDATE, Keane on Robbo - Liverpool FC news recap

35 minutes ago

Princess Charlotte's sweet act on carriage ride to stop rain ruining Trooping parade

35 minutes ago

Here's every iPhone model that will receive Apple's iOS 18 update (and which ones can't)

35 minutes ago

2 killed and several wounded in shooting during a Juneteenth celebration in a Texas park

35 minutes ago

Steve Clarke hoping cuddles and kicked backsides lift Scotland after Germany thrashing

35 minutes ago

Bachelor stars Jimmy Nicholson and Holly Kingston announce pregnancy on Instagram

37 minutes ago

Judge could soon set trial date for Pa. man charged in killings of 4 University of Idaho students

37 minutes ago

Why student loan forgiveness sparks anger: A philosopher, attorney general, sociologist and religious thought expert weigh in

39 minutes ago

Super wealthy Americans are flocking to the U.K. to snap up royal-inspired engagement rings - as jewelry experts reveal why more clients are looking overseas

39 minutes ago

Video: David Beckham thanks wife Victoria for their 'incredible' family as former footballer leads the Father's Day tributes with Amanda Holden, Amy Dowden and Perrie Edwards

39 minutes ago

The Lilo & Stitch Scene That Changed Because Of 9/11

39 minutes ago

Ashwath Kaushik, 8, wants to be youngest chess grandmaster in Singapore

39 minutes ago

Cuddles and kicked backsides needed to lift Scots, says Clarke

39 minutes ago

Penrith gifted by clumsy work

39 minutes ago

“I was two years old but got memories about it” - 15-year-NBA veteran recalled his father passing away on the basketball court