Takeaways: How intelligence agencies' are cautiously embracing generative AI

Microsoft

Takeaways: How intelligence agencies' are cautiously embracing generative AI

U.S. intelligence agencies are scrambling to embrace the AI revolution, convinced they’ll otherwise be smothered in data as sensor-generated surveillance tech further blankets the planet

ByFRANK BAJAK AP technology writer

May 23, 2024, 5:23 AM

    ARLINGTON, Virginia -- U.S. intelligence agencies are scrambling to embrace the AI revolution, convinced they’ll otherwise be smothered in data as sensor-generated surveillance tech further blankets the planet. They also need to keep pace with competitors, who are already using AI to seed social media platforms with deepfakes.

    But the tech is young and brittle, and officials are acutely aware that generative AI is anything but tailor-made for a trade steeped in danger and deception.

    Years before OpenAI's ChatGPT set off the current generative AI marketing frenzy, U.S. intelligence and defense officials were experimenting with the technology. One contractor, Rhombus Power, used it to uncover fentanyl trafficking in China in 2019 at rates far exceeding human-only analysis. Rhombus would later predict Russia’s full-scale invasion of Ukraine four months in advance with 80% certainty.

    CIA director William Burns recently wrote in Foreign Affairs that U.S. intelligence requires “sophisticated artificial intelligence models that can digest mammoth amounts of open-source and clandestinely acquired information.”

    But the agency's inaugural chief technology officer, Nand Mulchandani, cautions that because generative AI models “hallucinate” they are best treated as a “crazy, drunk friend” — capable of incredible insight but also bias-prone fibbers.

    There are also security and privacy issues. Adversaries could steal and poison them. They may contain sensitive personal data agents aren't authorized to see.

    Gen AI is mostly good as a virtual assistant, says Mulchandani, looking for "the needle in the needle stack.” What it won’t ever do, officials insist, is replace human analysts.

    While officials won't say whether they are using generative AI for anything big on classified networks, thousands of analysts across the 18 U.S. intelligence agencies now use a CIA-developed generative AI called Osiris. It ingests unclassified and publicly or commercially available data — what's known as open-source — and writes annotated summaries. It includes a chatbot so analysts can ask follow-up questions.

    Osiris uses multiple commercial AI models. Mulchandani said the agency is not committing to any single model or tech vendor. “It’s still early days,” he said.

    Experts believe predictive analysis, war-gaming and scenario brainstorming will be among generative AI's most important uses for intel workers.

    Even before generative AI, intel agencies were using machine learning and algorithms. One use case: Alerting analysts during off hours to potentially important developments. An analyst could instruct an AI to ring their phone no matter the hour. It couldn't describe what happened - that would be classified - but could say “you need to come in and look at this.”

    AI bigshots vying for U.S. intelligence agency business include Microsoft, which announced on May 7 that it was offering OpenAI’s GPT-4 for top-secret networks, though the product is not yet accredited on classified networks.

    A competitor, Primer AI, lists two intelligence agencies among its customers, documents posted online for recent military AI workshops show. One Primer product is designed to “detect emerging signals of breaking events" using AI-powered searches of more than 60,000 news and social media sources in 100 languages including Twitter, Telegram, Reddit and Discord.

    Like Rhombus Power's product, it helps analysts identify key people, organizations and locations and also uses computer vision. At a demo just days after the Oct. 7 Hamas attack on Israel, Primer executives described how their technology separates fact from fiction in the flood of online information from the Middle East.

    The most important near-term AI challenges for U.S. intelligence officials are apt to be counteracting how adversaries use it: To pierce U.S. defenses, spread disinformation and attempt to undermine Washington's ability to read their intent and capabilities.

    The White House is also concerned that generative AI models adopted by U.S. agencies could be infiltrated and poisoned.

    Another worry: Ensuring the privacy of people whose personal data may be embedded in an AI model. Authorities say it is not currently possible to guarantee that's all removed from an AI model.

    That's one reason the intelligence community is not in "move-fast-and-break-things” mode on generative AI, says John Beieler, the top AI official at the Office of the Director of National Intelligence.

    Model integrity and security are a concern if government agencies end up using AIs to explore bio- and cyberweapons tech.

    How AI gets adopted will vary widely by intelligence agency according to mission. The National Security Agency mostly intercepts communications. The National Geospatial-Intelligence Agency (NGA) is charged with seeing and understanding every inch of the planet.

    Supercharging those missions with Gen AI is a priority — and much less complicated than, say, how the FBI might use the technology given its legal limitations on domestic surveillance.

    The NGA issued in December a request for proposals for a completely new type of AI model that would use imagery it collects — from satellites, from ground-level sensors – to harvest precise geospatial intel with simple voice or text prompts. Gen AI applications also make a lot of sense for cyberconflict.

    Generative AI won't easily match wits with rival masters of deception.

    Analysts work with “incomplete, ambiguous, often contradictory snippets of partial, unreliable information,” notes Zachery Tyson Brown, a former defense intelligence officer. He believes intel agencies will invite disaster if they embrace generative AI too enthusiastically, swiftly or completely. The models don't reason. They merely predict. And their designers can't entirely explain how they work.

    Linda Weissgold, a former CIA deputy director of analysis, doesn't see AI replacing human analysts any time soon.

    Quick decisions are often required based on incomplete data. Intelligence "customers'' - the most important being the president of the United States — want human insight and experience central to the decision options they're offered, she says.

    “I don’t think it will ever be acceptable to some president for the intelligence community to come in and say, ‘I don’t know, the black box just told me so.’”

    OTHER NEWS

    31 minutes ago

    Mets RHP Kodai Senga to throw batting practice on Sunday in Florida

    31 minutes ago

    Jared Jones strikes out 8, Oneil Cruz hits the ball into the Allegheny as Pirates edge Rays 4-3

    34 minutes ago

    SAG-AFTRA Names Recipients Of George Heller Memorial Award Gold Cards

    35 minutes ago

    Free-agent focus for the Edmonton Oilers

    35 minutes ago

    Stoinis delivers bizarre send-off after unwanted stat

    35 minutes ago

    Soccer-Belgian De Bruyne not ready to talk retirement after Euros masterclass

    35 minutes ago

    Iranian rapper Tomaj Salehi spared death penalty, faces retrial amid international outcry

    35 minutes ago

    Egypt blames Hajj deaths on 'unregistered' Mecca arrivals

    35 minutes ago

    Hill adds 100m backstroke silver to 50m gold at European Championships

    35 minutes ago

    Analysis of resigning MPs reveals upcoming demographic shift in parliament

    35 minutes ago

    What matters to Welsh voters?

    35 minutes ago

    Nelson’s HMS Victory gives scientists vital DNA for battle against deathwatch beetle

    35 minutes ago

    Everton make offer to sign "incredible" ace who's the perfect Gueye upgrade

    35 minutes ago

    15 heatwave-proof dresses to suit all shapes and sizes

    35 minutes ago

    Travelers Championship: Scottie Scheffler and Xander Schauffele blitz TPC River Highlands to set up a Sunday shootout with leader Tom Kim... leaving Cam Young's 59 in the dust

    35 minutes ago

    Family of Audrey Wallace struggles for support while daughter in palliative care

    38 minutes ago

    David Crisafulli determined to ‘snatch defeat from the jaws of victory’

    38 minutes ago

    Queensland family call for housing assistance for 6-year-old daughter in palliative care

    42 minutes ago

    Video: Joanna Gaines excitedly throws her youngest son Crew a 'fossil dig' party to celebrate his sixth birthday

    42 minutes ago

    Parliamentary inquiry begins investigating new Spirit of Tasmania ships

    42 minutes ago

    The Bikeriders thinks masculinity is a curse — but it looks cool on a motorcycle

    42 minutes ago

    Dressel and Ledecky win again at U.S. Olympic swimming trials. Keep an eye on Kate Douglass, too

    42 minutes ago

    Former NRL star Chris Walker opens up on cheating death and how steroids saved his life: 'It makes you feel superhuman'

    44 minutes ago

    "A black athlete criticizing the society" - Kareem Abdul-Jabbar had a 'scary feeling' transitioning into post-basketball life

    44 minutes ago

    Donald Trump Says He's Decided on VP Pick

    44 minutes ago

    A's pitcher records win without facing batter in statistical anomaly

    51 minutes ago

    Lakers News: Lakers May Consider Reuniting with Former Players in Free Agency

    52 minutes ago

    Growth Stocks vs. Value Stocks: Which Should You Choose?

    52 minutes ago

    Fortnite could finally be getting its Five Nights at Freddy’s crossover

    52 minutes ago

    Post wildfire brings destruction for some as lucky neighbors survive

    52 minutes ago

    New pro-Palestinian encampment sets up in downtown Montreal public square

    52 minutes ago

    PM used ‘churlish view’ to ‘put out memes’ criticising nuclear: David Littleproud

    52 minutes ago

    ‘Dead weight’: Woman’s chilling text to son before elderly mum’s death in ‘putrid’, faeces-covered house of horror

    52 minutes ago

    Restoring kampung houses to keep Pulau Ubin’s rustic charm

    56 minutes ago

    Sacre bleu! Former Commonwealth Games swimmer left with a French accent after suffering a stroke whilst training

    56 minutes ago

    How depressing? Junk food is bad for your mental health, study warns

    56 minutes ago

    Labour pledge to give people suffering from brittle bone disease access to vital scans in victory for the Mail on Sunday's War On Osteoporosis campaign

    56 minutes ago

    ERIC KAUFMANN: Be warned...Labour will turbo charge the woke revolution

    56 minutes ago

    SUSIE DENT: Rhyming slang isn't brown bread - and it's all down to Kylie and Miley

    56 minutes ago

    Cameron Young hits 59 as Tom Kim leads Travellers Championship