Raisi helicopter crash: Who makes the call to fly in bad weather with VIPs?

As Iran investigates the helicopter crash that killed President Ebrahim Raisi, Foreign Minister Hossein Amirabdollahian and other government officials, a key factor has emerged: the weather.

President Raisi’s chief of staff, Gholam Hossein Esmaili, who was in one of the helicopters that did not crash, said on Tuesday that the weather was clear when the group departed, before conditions changed suddenly while they were in the air.

Rapidly changing weather is a notorious risk in mountain microclimates, where sudden gusts of wind or cloud movement can threaten helicopters.

According to the government-linked Tasnim news agency, there was an orange weather alert on the day of the flight, which warned that rainy and cloudy weather was approaching – potentially deadly conditions for mountain flying.

Given the risks, questions have arisen over who made the final judgment call to fly – and whether they were aware of the weather risks.

The National asked three specialists on military aviation about aviation incidents involving VIP passengers: Farzin Nadhimi, an Iran military expert at the Washington Institute for Near East Policy think tank, James Beldon, a former RAF squadron commander, and former US Air Force colonel Chris Pehrson.

raisi helicopter crash: who makes the call to fly in bad weather with vips?

Iranian honour guards carry President Ebrahim Raisi's coffin during a funeral procession at Mehrabad Airport in Tehran. AFP

According to Mr Nadhimi, the Iranian entourage could have waited until weather conditions were optimal in the mountains, or chosen to drive instead. Instead, he suggested that the Iranian President may have been eager to return to official business and forced them to fly.

“There has been this consistent problem with VIPs forcing pilots to fly in unfavourable conditions.

“They had the option of going back to Tabriz by road. There were quite a number of off-road SUVs in place that would gladly take the entourage of the President to Tabriz instead of riding in a helicopter in very unsafe conditions, bad weather. And they saw the consequence.”

Mr Beldon said sometimes people with a military background suffer from the need to “press on” to complete operations, even when that can raise risks.

“‘Press-on-itis’ has killed plenty of aviators in the past. The 1956 London Heathrow Vulcan air crash is an example of a senior VIP overruling pilots,” Mr Beldon said.

“The Air Marshall involved was Sir Harry Broadhurst – a wartime hero. He was acting as co-pilot, not the captain, of the aircraft, although his position as Commander-in-Chief of Bomber Command at the time made him vastly superior in rank to the captain.

“It is understood he wanted to press ahead because of the media impact of arriving back at Heathrow versus landing in better weather elsewhere. The Vulcan only had two ejection seats – only the pilots survived.”

Mr Pehrson said there were a range of factors that could have caused Sunday's crash, including “simply bad judgment”.

“Faulty spare parts or poor maintenance could have caused President Raisi's helicopter to crash but there are many other factors to consider,” said the former US Air Force colonel.

“These could include inclement weather, inadequate training or lack of aircrew proficiency, aircrew disorientation, or simply bad judgment on the part of the aircrew.”

Mr Pehrson pointed to the human factor, which was behind another air disaster involving US Air Force pilots flying a VIP in bad weather.

“I was stationed at Ramstein Air Base in Germany when Secretary of Commerce Ron Brown died in a plane crash near Dubrovnik, Croatia,” he said.

“The accident investigation revealed many contributing factors that resulted in that crash. The weather was bad, the approach into Dubrovnik wasn't certified by the USAF, and the aircraft didn't have adequate instrumentation to legally fly the approach.

“There was also tremendous pressure on the crew that was determined to have interfered with their judgment. Headquarters relayed to the crew to assume unnecessary risk and ‘press on’ with the mission.

“Factors like these or others could have contributed to the crash but without an accident investigation and willingness to share its findings we may never know.”

OTHER NEWS

22 minutes ago

‘Don’t stuff around with Mother Cricket’: Starc’s parting shot after Australia get England through

22 minutes ago

Two great cricket rivalries have fizzled out at the T20 World Cup, but there's still one to watch

22 minutes ago

Letters: In praise of the kindness of strangers at a frightening time

22 minutes ago

Serbia to green light Rio Tinto lithium mine, FT reports

22 minutes ago

Zachary Porthen captain as Junior Springboks aim to ‘create own story’ at World Cup

22 minutes ago

Staff threaten legal action against crackdown on workplace affairs at BP

22 minutes ago

Mother-of-three Chapoth Bafel Gak Paul Deng is killed in alleged hit-and-run while walking home from the shops

26 minutes ago

Singapore rushes to clean-up oil slick after boat hits stationary fuel supply ship

27 minutes ago

Flood alert for some WA regions as nation shivers

27 minutes ago

Yasmin le Bon interview: ‘Our kids are not inheriting anything. There is no trust fund’

27 minutes ago

The Observer view: manifestos reveal the gulf between the main parties

27 minutes ago

Swimming-Fire still burns for Ledecky as she makes fourth Olympics

27 minutes ago

Reliable journalist offers POSITIVE update on futures of three Liverpool stars

27 minutes ago

Khloe Kardashian shares adorable family selfie with her young kids True and Tatum... after admitting she 'isn't focused on dating'

34 minutes ago

Mother-of-three Chapoth Bafel Gak Paul Deng is killed in alleged hit-and-run while walking home from the shops

34 minutes ago

Netflix favourite Bridgerton’s off-screen couples

34 minutes ago

Where to watch Inter Miami vs. Philadelphia Union live stream, TV channel, lineups, prediction for MLS match

34 minutes ago

Arsenal legend Ray Parlour forced to apologise for 'insensitive' Kevin Campbell tribute

37 minutes ago

In South Africa, traditional healers join the fight against HIV. Stigma remains high in rural areas

40 minutes ago

England fans at Euro 2024 are a ‘trophy’ for hooligans from other nations

41 minutes ago

Fauci wrote in upcoming memoir that Trump yelled expletives at him in a phone call in 2020

41 minutes ago

La Trobe Financial CEO discusses bringing global 'investment strategies' to Australians

41 minutes ago

Cleveland Fed President Loretta Mester: Seen really progress on inflation, but we're not there yet

41 minutes ago

Portugal All-Time XI: Cristiano Ronaldo leads legendary attack

44 minutes ago

Actor Joe Alwyn breaks silence on Taylor Swift split for the first time

46 minutes ago

'All the money in the game yet...': Sunil Gavaskar, Michael Vaughan slam ICC after back-to-back abandoned games in Florida

46 minutes ago

Peter went public about his homeless situation in a desperate plea for help. His council responded, but not in the caring way you would think

46 minutes ago

Richard Wilkins uses a Woolworths basket to carry his groceries into his home after a shopping trip with his girlfriend Mia Hawkswell

50 minutes ago

Palliative care nurses share precious lessons learnt after decades working with the dying

52 minutes ago

Johannesburg woman unveils homemade juice recipe for glowing skin in video

52 minutes ago

UAE President inquires about wellbeing of UAE pilgrims in phone call with Head of Pilgrims' Affairs Office

55 minutes ago

Kipyegon targets double gold in Paris

55 minutes ago

Man Utd’s 2022 FA Youth Cup winners now – transfers, FA Cup glory, goal machine released

1 hour ago

Australian underdog Liam Paro stuns boxing world to claim world title in slugfest - and dedicates win to his best friend who died

1 hour ago

Married At First Sight's Mel Schilling shares emotional story of how she told nine-year-old daughter Maddie about her cancer diagnosis

1 hour ago

Wooden boat with nine Chinese people on board is intercepted by Australian Border Force and turned back

1 hour ago

Tedesco backs Edwards for Origin spot

1 hour ago

Five per cent of households refuse to have smart meters in their homes

1 hour ago

Doctor submitted 116 false Chas claims, duping MOH into disbursing $7,600

1 hour ago

Israeli army announces ‘tactical pause’ in part of southern Gaza