Concern over oil exploration on the West Coast

concern over oil exploration on the west coast

Concern over oil exploration on the West Coast

Cape Town - The Green Connection and Natural Justice submitted comments on the revised Environmental Impact Assessment report (EIA) concerning the offshore oil and gas Exploration Right for Block 3B/4B on the West Coast.

The comments were supported by Masifundise Development Trust.

Located off the West Coast, this project raises significant concerns regarding the potential risks and negative impacts to some of South Africa's most precious marine ecosystems and the ripple-effect for coastal communities and their livelihoods.

The eco-justice organisations also emphasised that this is in direct contradiction with South Africa's climate commitments, which should see a reduction in the reliance on carbon-emitting fossil fuels.

The Green Connection's Liziwe McDaid stressed the catastrophic consequences of potential spills.

“The impact of spills, even minor ones, could devastate affected marine ecosystems, endangering fish species, which underpin local fisher livelihoods. There is always a threat of a spill, no matter how these may be downplayed, which could jeopardise the delicate balance of marine ecosystems and the livelihoods of coastal communities.

“Our submission outlines various scenarios of oil spills, ranging from minor to severe. Each scenario poses significant potential impacts on fisher livelihoods, which can include job losses, market disruptions and economic hardships for communities reliant on seafood trade,” said McDaid.

The revised report, compiled by Environmental Impact Management Services, comes after a public review resulted in overwhelming opposition and concerns regarding potential environmental and socio-economic impacts.

Green Connection said the revision failed to address these concerns “and exposes the stark disconnect between corporate profit motives and public interest”. The organisations also argued that the revised report all but completely avoids the urgency for South Africa to move towards a just energy transition for all.

Defending Rights Programme Manager at Natural Justice, Melissa Groenink-Groves, underscored the legal implications.

“It is imperative to consider the legal framework in evaluating the risks posed by such projects. Environmental regulations and climate commitments must be upheld to protect both ecosystems and communities.”

These sentiments are also echoed by David Mtshali who is the Defending Rights Senior Programme Officer at Natural Justice. He laments the fact that the EIA process followed in respect of the proposed project was not child friendly, did not consider children's environmental rights and contravenes the generational equity principle.

The Green Connection's Community Outreach Coordinator Neville van Rooy said that he is most concerned about how the risks associated with potential spills could completely devastate coastal communities.

“Local livelihoods and ways of life are at stake here. The risks associated with offshore drilling could irreversibly harm coastal communities, their livelihoods and even their very way of life. Furthermore, the cultural and heritage significance of the coastal and marine ecosystem cannot be overlooked.

“Any harm to these ecosystems could have profound implications for the overall well-being of coastal communities. Their way of life hangs in the balance.”

Should the project spearheaded by Africa Oil SA Corp, Ricocure (Pty) Ltd and Azinam Limited get the go ahead, TotalEnergies will be the operator.

The Green Connection says TotalEnergies is at the forefront of the onslaught on South Africa's oceans.

The organisations stress the vital need for decision-makers to prioritise both the long-term health of marine ecosystems and the well-being of communities dependent on them.

Weekend Argus

OTHER NEWS

14 minutes ago

Trump demands Fani Willis' disqualification over 'misconduct' in opening brief to appeals court

14 minutes ago

Apple shares to rally to $260 as it beats out Android in AI race, Rosenblatt says

14 minutes ago

Hostile to elated: Nurses overwhelmingly approve new pay deal

14 minutes ago

Tom Hanks and Robin Wright age backwards and forwards through time in the trailer for Robert Zemeckis' “Here”

14 minutes ago

Jason and Travis Kelce try a traditional English breakfast for the first time… but which fan favorite item do they label 'bland'?

14 minutes ago

Inside Glastonbury Festival's poshest tents worth £28k: luxury bedrooms, dining room and a pool

14 minutes ago

Video: Real Housewives of New Jersey's Margaret Josephs left 'heartbroken' following the death of her beloved dog

14 minutes ago

Urgent warning over new self-checkout scam at popular store - it went completely unnoticed by customers

14 minutes ago

Budget airline offers tickets for less than $30 this summer - and there are dozens of vacation hotspots to choose from

14 minutes ago

Watch the moment Cincinnati Reds pitcher Hunter Greene vomits all over the mound moments after starting game against the Pirates

14 minutes ago

England are the FAVOURITES to win Euro 2024 despite dour group stage performances, with Gareth Southgate's side being backed at 4/1 to be crowned champions of Europe

14 minutes ago

Man, 29, with locked-in syndrome completes 50,000 word book - using just his EYES

14 minutes ago

Video: Family of pilots with more than 100 years of experience between them expose the truth behind common flying myths - from turbulence getting worse to what really happens to waste

14 minutes ago

England fans to be hit by alcohol restrictions for Euro 2024 last-16 clash in Gelsenkirchen after decision by city officials... despite UEFA saying the measures would not return

14 minutes ago

Faster than an Uber! A hypercar maker has just launched its own robotaxi service - and it's coming to the UK soon

14 minutes ago

'It spiced it up' - Rassie reveals Zebo contacted him to clarify 'he hates the Irish' comments

17 minutes ago

Michael Phelps says athletes have lost faith in WADA over Chinese doping scandal

17 minutes ago

Cycling-Pogacar, vying for rare Giro/Tour double, is man to beat

17 minutes ago

Lauren Dickason jailed for 18 years in New Zealand

17 minutes ago

Kings of the Southeast: How the Lee Pulliam-Philip Morris rivalry engulfed Late Model Stock racing

17 minutes ago

George Stephanopoulos departs GMA after brief return as all three main anchors are replaced in biggest shake-up yet

17 minutes ago

Taylor Swift & Gracie Abrams' "Us" Lyrics, Explained

17 minutes ago

Rogers offers Disney+ to customers at no additional cost

17 minutes ago

Austin Housing Market Rocked as New Home Prices Slashed Up to 30%

18 minutes ago

Michael Jackson's son Prince pays heartfelt tribute to late singer on 15th anniversary of his death

18 minutes ago

Succession writer takes the helm for Harry Potter reboot

19 minutes ago

The ‘funflation’ effect: Why Americans are spending on travel and entertainment

19 minutes ago

Health care just as important as economy. What experts want Biden and Trump to address.

19 minutes ago

LGBTQ elders struggle with health care, housing and isolation

19 minutes ago

Jury deliberations continue in Karen Read murder trial: Latest updates

19 minutes ago

Field hockey at the 2024 Olympics in Paris explained: Scoring, format, history

19 minutes ago

Houston steakhouse Perry’s celebrates 45 years with $44 four-course dining special

19 minutes ago

Messi, Argentina will play their Copa America quarterfinal in Texas. But where is the question still to be answered.

19 minutes ago

London police drop charges for driver who had seizure and plowed into a school, killing 2 children

19 minutes ago

20-year-old injured in potential shark attack in Hawaii

19 minutes ago

British police say the driver of a 4x4 that plowed into a school, killing 2 children, will face no criminal charges

19 minutes ago

Driver who crashed into Wimbledon school killing two girls will not face charges after having epileptic fit

19 minutes ago

Suffragette Emmeline Pankurst would be troubled by rise of misogynistic influencers, great granddaughter says

19 minutes ago

Taking multivitamins regularly is not linked to a lower risk of death – study

19 minutes ago

Sunny Hostin says Jennifer Lopez flying coach to France ‘humanized’ her