Concern over oil exploration on the West Coast

concern over oil exploration on the west coast

Concern over oil exploration on the West Coast

Cape Town - The Green Connection and Natural Justice submitted comments on the revised Environmental Impact Assessment report (EIA) concerning the offshore oil and gas Exploration Right for Block 3B/4B on the West Coast.

The comments were supported by Masifundise Development Trust.

Located off the West Coast, this project raises significant concerns regarding the potential risks and negative impacts to some of South Africa's most precious marine ecosystems and the ripple-effect for coastal communities and their livelihoods.

The eco-justice organisations also emphasised that this is in direct contradiction with South Africa's climate commitments, which should see a reduction in the reliance on carbon-emitting fossil fuels.

The Green Connection's Liziwe McDaid stressed the catastrophic consequences of potential spills.

“The impact of spills, even minor ones, could devastate affected marine ecosystems, endangering fish species, which underpin local fisher livelihoods. There is always a threat of a spill, no matter how these may be downplayed, which could jeopardise the delicate balance of marine ecosystems and the livelihoods of coastal communities.

“Our submission outlines various scenarios of oil spills, ranging from minor to severe. Each scenario poses significant potential impacts on fisher livelihoods, which can include job losses, market disruptions and economic hardships for communities reliant on seafood trade,” said McDaid.

The revised report, compiled by Environmental Impact Management Services, comes after a public review resulted in overwhelming opposition and concerns regarding potential environmental and socio-economic impacts.

Green Connection said the revision failed to address these concerns “and exposes the stark disconnect between corporate profit motives and public interest”. The organisations also argued that the revised report all but completely avoids the urgency for South Africa to move towards a just energy transition for all.

Defending Rights Programme Manager at Natural Justice, Melissa Groenink-Groves, underscored the legal implications.

“It is imperative to consider the legal framework in evaluating the risks posed by such projects. Environmental regulations and climate commitments must be upheld to protect both ecosystems and communities.”

These sentiments are also echoed by David Mtshali who is the Defending Rights Senior Programme Officer at Natural Justice. He laments the fact that the EIA process followed in respect of the proposed project was not child friendly, did not consider children's environmental rights and contravenes the generational equity principle.

The Green Connection's Community Outreach Coordinator Neville van Rooy said that he is most concerned about how the risks associated with potential spills could completely devastate coastal communities.

“Local livelihoods and ways of life are at stake here. The risks associated with offshore drilling could irreversibly harm coastal communities, their livelihoods and even their very way of life. Furthermore, the cultural and heritage significance of the coastal and marine ecosystem cannot be overlooked.

“Any harm to these ecosystems could have profound implications for the overall well-being of coastal communities. Their way of life hangs in the balance.”

Should the project spearheaded by Africa Oil SA Corp, Ricocure (Pty) Ltd and Azinam Limited get the go ahead, TotalEnergies will be the operator.

The Green Connection says TotalEnergies is at the forefront of the onslaught on South Africa's oceans.

The organisations stress the vital need for decision-makers to prioritise both the long-term health of marine ecosystems and the well-being of communities dependent on them.

Weekend Argus

OTHER NEWS

15 minutes ago

Jude Bellingham plays like five former England captains rolled into one

15 minutes ago

Train collision in eastern India kills at least 15, injures dozens

15 minutes ago

Normani's debut album 'explores all of her layers'

15 minutes ago

Whoopi Goldberg recalls eating cat treats at 2am

15 minutes ago

Usher: I don't eat on Wednesdays

16 minutes ago

Dario G star Paul Spencer dies following a battle with cancer aged 53

16 minutes ago

Rory McIlroy rues missed putts at U.S. Open, taking time off

18 minutes ago

Fort Good Hope wildfire has not yet reached community: officials

18 minutes ago

Calgary Police Service launches hearing into 2022 arrest

18 minutes ago

NBA Draft: Blazers Need Floor Spacer

18 minutes ago

Crafty veteran poised for big year in 2nd season with Cowboys

18 minutes ago

Ten Hag says Man United owners 'flew to Ibiza to keep me'

18 minutes ago

Clodagh McKenna reveals Royal Ascot will be 'extra special' this year

18 minutes ago

Confirmed: Time for the Springboks’ team announcement

18 minutes ago

Malema the epitome of flip-flopper, says IFP

18 minutes ago

Gerrit Cole to make season debut for Yankees on Wednesday against Orioles

22 minutes ago

Willy Sagnol urges Georgia players to ‘focus’ ahead of Turkey clash

22 minutes ago

LARRY KUDLOW: This is why Trump is winning

22 minutes ago

'Inside Out 2' scores biggest box office opening day of 2024

22 minutes ago

Netanyahu Dissolves Israel’s War Cabinet

22 minutes ago

Young couple who loved each other 'beyond words' killed together in horror crash

22 minutes ago

House of the Dragon has fans switching off moments into first episode over dog kick

22 minutes ago

Nottingham Forest can forget about Awoniyi by signing "sensational" talent

22 minutes ago

Lockyer pinpoints major 'concern' for bumbling Broncos

22 minutes ago

Tyreek Hill humiliated by a young boy during drills at Dolphins star's own youth football camp

25 minutes ago

The Washington Post's leaders are taking heat for journalism in Britain that wouldn't fly in the US

25 minutes ago

Germany's biggest industrial union seeks a 7% raise for millions of workers

26 minutes ago

FDA approves Merck vaccine designed to protect adults from bacteria that can cause pneumonia, serious infections

26 minutes ago

Stock futures are little changed as investors await May retail sales data: Live updates

26 minutes ago

Chicago suburb named ‘Safest and Most Affordable' city in US in new ranking

26 minutes ago

High heat concerns at Thames Valley schools as temperatures hit 30 C

26 minutes ago

Winning $66M Lotto 6-49 ticket bought in Calgary

27 minutes ago

LCBO workers edge closer to potential strike

27 minutes ago

JPMorgan says Big Lots’ struggles could benefit this closeout-retail rival

27 minutes ago

Video: Jake Gyllenhaal and girlfriend Jeanne Cadieu are still going strong as they enjoy a casual stroll in NYC

27 minutes ago

Apple extends rally with a record-breaking stock market value

27 minutes ago

Berkshire Hathaway's BNSF ordered to pay almost $400M to Native American tribe

27 minutes ago

‘It can feel like a detective story’: birders asked to help find 126 ‘lost’ bird species

27 minutes ago

Yes, Juneteenth is a federal holiday

27 minutes ago

Several Juneteenth events canceled or postponed due to weather concerns