SCOTUS’s power relies on public trust. What happens when that weakens?

I want to take you all the way back to May of 1788. A new nation was coming together. The Constitution had not yet been fully ratified, and a series of essays was being published in New York newspapers to rally support for its ratification, all signed with the pen name Publius. The essay published on May 28th, in fact written like most of The Federalist Papers by Alexander Hamilton, was titled The Judicial Department. It's a masterful argument for our third branch of government, the judiciary, which Hamilton referred to as the least dangerous branch to the political rights enumerated in the Constitution, because quote it will be the least in a capacity to annoy or injure them. The judiciary has no influence over either the sword or the purse, no direction either of the strength or of the wealth of the society, and can take no active resolution whatever. It may truly be said to have neither force nor will, but merely judgment. End Quote. Merely judgment. That's how Hamilton tried to thread the needle on judicial independence. He argued that Supreme Court justices should be unelected and serve lifetime appointments so that they could operate irrespective of politics. That was the check against Congress and the executive branch. The balance against unelected lifetime judges would be their inability to actually enforce their own decisions. Neither sword nor purse, neither force nor will. The idea was the justices make the rulings, but it's up to the other branches of government, the president and Congress, to actually enforce them. The power of the Supreme Court lies in a cooperative government and a trusting public. What this means is that we as a society must believe the Court is an independent arbiter of constitutional questions. Congress and the president, and the citizenry that elects them must believe that the Court's decisions are worthy of being followed and enforced. In that sense, the Court is a bit like Tinkerbell. If we stop believing in it, in its power, its legitimacy vanishes. And The Supremes court legitimacy right now is vanishing before our eyes. In a Gallup poll conducted before the Supreme Court's current term, 49% of Americans said they had a great deal or a fair amount of trust in the judicial branch of the government. Since 1972, that number has hovered around the 60s. It hit a low of 47% in 2022. Today, the Supreme Court faces dual legitimacy crises. There's the credibility crisis caused by the actions of some of the justices, from Justice Thomas's undisclosed financial relationships to Justice Alito's secret recordings and upside down flag, both of which have cast doubt on their political independence. And then there's the court's recent track record of tearing down decades old precedent with deeply unpopular decisions like the overturning of Roe versus Wade, gutting the Voting Rights Act, and dismantling affirmative action. And then there is tomorrow we will learn whether this court will say that Donald Trump was able to freely and openly commit crimes without consequence. We already have an electorate that has lost faith in Congress. The current Congress is on track to be one of the least productive in American history. If Donald Trump wins back the presidency in the fall, he literally has a 900 plus page playbook full of detailed plans to dismantle the civil service apparatus of the government, consolidate power in the executive branch, and weaponize the Justice Department and the Supreme Court. The last branch, the least dangerous, is rolling back long held personal rights. They're accepting lavish gifts from billionaire political players, refusing to even discuss with congressional leaders ethics or oversight, and at best, at the moment, seemingly helping Donald Trump delay his remaining criminal trials until after the election. And at worst, well, we'll we'll see in the next 24 hours. But here's the problem. When people stop believing in the systems that keep democracy running, those systems will cease to function.

OTHER NEWS

8 minutes ago

A King's Controversial Decision: Charles III 'in Discussions' to Travel to California to Visit Archie and Lilibet, Senior Royals in Uproar Over News

8 minutes ago

Is the F1 British Grand Prix on Channel 4? TV channel and session start times

8 minutes ago

I sold everything to travel across Australia on a school bus

8 minutes ago

A third of land set aside for restoration in worse state than before, Australian offset audit finds

8 minutes ago

Blac Chyna not encouraging daughter to have showbiz career

9 minutes ago

If you always use these 12 phrases, you're more emotionally intelligent than most

9 minutes ago

Could showers, storms impact Chicago's Fourth of July forecast?

9 minutes ago

Rep. Lloyd Doggett is first House Democrat to publicly call for Biden to step down as party's nominee

12 minutes ago

Map reveals the more than 100 beaches across the US forced to close due to high levels of bacteria - as experts reveal the cause

13 minutes ago

David Mitchell, 49, and Victoria Coren, 51, enjoy rare night out after welcoming baby girl

14 minutes ago

How to waste fewer bananas

14 minutes ago

Avalanche to sign young, high-upside defenseman

14 minutes ago

Richard Bland shares what LIV Golf has done to his quality of play since joining

14 minutes ago

Dave Grohl and Sir Cliff Richard among stars at Wimbledon

14 minutes ago

No more Nama: bad bank to shut after 16 years

14 minutes ago

Supreme Court declines to hear a series of challenges to laws barring felons and drug users from having guns

14 minutes ago

US Marshals Service finds 200 missing children in nationwide operation

14 minutes ago

Homeowners Paint Their Fence Black and the Results Speak for Themselves

15 minutes ago

Venezuela's opposition coalition welcomes President Maduro's plan to jumpstart dialogue with the US

15 minutes ago

Regina marks Canada Day with Government House event, community powwow

15 minutes ago

Windows bashed on Fairhaven School front doors: Saskatoon police

18 minutes ago

‘Supergirl’ & ‘Yellowjackets’ Actress Nicole Maines Signs With The Rosenzweig Group

19 minutes ago

Video: Chet Hanks says his past drug use was so severe that 'cokeheads' told him to 'chill' - as he discusses intervention staged by parents Tom Hanks and Rita Wilson

19 minutes ago

Video: Sarah Jessica Parker films first scene with her new And Just Like That co-star Logan Marshall-Green... and her real-life cat Lotus

20 minutes ago

Fans hail Cody Gakpo after his goal and assist for Netherlands in their 3-0 win over Romania… insisting Liverpool must play him in the same position to get the best out of him

20 minutes ago

I'm an expert at spotting narcissists - here are five 'dark psychology' tricks to watch out for when dating

20 minutes ago

Fans left baffled as Romania star Ianis Hagi wears bizarre NETTING on his head during Euro 2024 knockout clash vs Netherlands

20 minutes ago

Fans 'throw TRAINERS' onto the pitch during the Netherlands' victory over Romania - as Donyell Malen's narrowly avoids the shoes when scoring his side's third goal

21 minutes ago

Democrat calls for Biden to sit out 2024 race after debate disaster

21 minutes ago

Orlando Pirates announce fan favourite as seventh exit!

21 minutes ago

This bank just boosted its 1-year CD yield to more than 5%, even as traders await Fed rate cuts

21 minutes ago

Biden administration proposes rule for workplaces to address excessive heat

21 minutes ago

In wake of Supreme Court ruling, Biden administration tells doctors to provide emergency abortions

21 minutes ago

Utah State tells football coach Blake Anderson of intent to fire

21 minutes ago

Red Lobster attempts to lure more diners with new menu collab from Flavor Flav

21 minutes ago

Union sues Philadelphia over requirement that city workers return to the office full time

21 minutes ago

FDA approves a second Alzheimer’s drug that can slow the disease by several months

21 minutes ago

After Supreme Court decision, the Biden administration reminds doctors they must provide emergency abortions

21 minutes ago

Italian landowner is arrested after an Indian worker bled to death in accident with farm equipment

21 minutes ago

FDA approves a second Alzheimer's drug that can modestly slow disease