Security law watchdog urges reform as Assange freed

security law watchdog urges reform as assange freed

The arrival of Julian Assange and a new report have energised debate over whistleblower protections.

Urgent reform is needed to shield journalists and whistleblowers handling sensitive and secret information, the security law watchdog has found amid a push for stronger legal protections.

Among recommendations of the Independent National Security Legislation Monitor is scrapping the reliance on using a security classification, such as 'top secret', as a basis for an offence.

The current regime was heavy-handed and in some instances it conflicted with the rule of law, Jake Blight said in his review of secrecy laws handed down on Thursday.

An offence should apply to information deemed to harm the operations, capabilities, technologies, methods or sources an agency uses to obtain information rather than a blanket penalty, his review found.

"Disclosure of information about the core intelligence operations, capabilities, technologies, methods and sources of Australia's six main intelligence agencies will almost always be harmful to the national interest," the report said.

"But it does not follow that all information to do with those agencies will always be harmful.

"This is particularly so for agencies whose functions have expanded beyond traditional intelligence functions and now include assisting other bodies - such as the Department of Home Affairs - with their functions."

This includes broad cybersecurity information, commercial mapping and routine administration, the report goes on to say.

There were also problems with the proportionality and uncertainty surrounding some offences, Mr Blight found.

Broad terms such as information relating to "the functioning of government" should be avoided, the watchdog recommended.

"Excessively wide or uncertain secrecy laws can undermine trust in government and unreasonably impact the important role of a free press and civil society groups," he said.

Human Rights Law Centre senior lawyer Kieran Pender said unnecessary and disproportionate levels of secrecy were bad for democracy.

"There is no public interest in punishing and criminalising whistleblowers who play a crucial role in exposing government wrongdoing," he said.

He called on the government to implement the recommendations - branding them "a step in the right direction" - and set up a dedicated whistleblower protection authority.

The report came out as Greens senator David Shoebridge also pushed to have the government commit to setting up a whistleblower protection authority and affirm its support to protect whistleblowers.

He seized on the arrival of Julian Assange back in Australia after pleading guilty to espionage charges in the US as the reason why whistleblowers needed to be protected.

"We must stand with them, and we must ensure that the legal structures we put in place are there to protect them, to tell truth to power and ... not go to jail for the privilege," he told the Senate as he moved a motion.

Assistant Minister Jenny McAllister said the government was committed to reforming whistleblower protections in a staged process and consultation about the next steps was ongoing.

OTHER NEWS

29 minutes ago

John Hunter Nemechek forges his way to Xfinity Series victory at Nashville

29 minutes ago

England 'not good enough' despite comfortable France win as absent coach sends message

29 minutes ago

Chelsea Transfer News: Fabrizio Romano confirms Aaron Anselmino will be next wonderkid signing after Omari Kellyman

29 minutes ago

‘I know no-one gave us a prayer’ – Padraic Joyce revels in famous scalp for Galway

29 minutes ago

Columbus Blue Jackets 2024 Upper Deck NHL Draft Recap

29 minutes ago

Coldplay joined by Michael J Fox for Glastonbury set

29 minutes ago

Vikings Links: Which defensive tackles do you like for the Vikings in 2025?

29 minutes ago

Club pro makes history at US Senior Open with consecutive holes-in-one: 'I just couldn’t believe it'

29 minutes ago

Paul George free agency: 76ers to pursue All-Star forward after he declines Clippers option, per report

29 minutes ago

Fred Richard headlines a U.S. men's gymnastics team that will head to Paris with a shot to medal

29 minutes ago

Turkish opposition leader publicly terms Hamas terror organization, condemns Oct. 7 attack

29 minutes ago

NT Major Events 'fully committed' to 2024 Alice Springs Masters Games despite sluggish registrations in lead up

29 minutes ago

Golfer's defies insane odds to make successive holes-in-one

29 minutes ago

Novak Djokovic insists he can win an eighth Wimbledon title as knee injury rehab has given him 'enough optimism to compete on the highest level' - while Andy Murray admits he's 'willing' to risk playing in his SW19 swansong

29 minutes ago

Tropical Storm Beryl becomes major hurricane forecast to bring life-threatening conditions to the Caribbean

29 minutes ago

Shohei Ohtani: Dodgers Bat Boy Javier Herrera A ‘Hero’

29 minutes ago

Starmer won’t bulldoze local government, says Burnham after Glastonbury speech

29 minutes ago

Explainer: are mushroom gummies part of the ‘healthy high’ industry and how is it regulated?

29 minutes ago

Severe thunderstorm threat resumes Sunday for tri-state area

29 minutes ago

Wimbledon Odds: Who are the betting favourites for SW19 glory?

29 minutes ago

Starship Flight 3 Highlights As SpaceX Prepares For Next Launch

29 minutes ago

Growing concern over Ukraine aid as Orban takes over EU presidency

29 minutes ago

Fabrizio Romano confirms £70m-rated ace is ‘keen on the move’ to Man United

29 minutes ago

Argentina vs. Peru live score: Copa America 2024 updates, result as Scaloni's side starts without Lionel Messi

33 minutes ago

Biden tries to recapture his mojo in appeals to donors

33 minutes ago

Shilese Jones will miss Paris Olympics after injury at gymnastics trials

33 minutes ago

Gabby Thomas wins 200 at Olympic track trials, Sha'Carri Richardson finishes fourth

33 minutes ago

Fallout 4: Where to Get Oil

33 minutes ago

Motor racing-Piastri angered by 'embarrassing' Austrian grid drop

33 minutes ago

Today in Politics: Amit Shah kicks off BJP’s Assembly poll preparations with Haryana meeting

33 minutes ago

Carrot Nutrition: Unlocking the Benefits with Professional Advice

33 minutes ago

Anthony Joshua finally moves out of his mother's flat

33 minutes ago

Cricket-India edge S Africa in thriller to win T20 World Cup title

33 minutes ago

Argentina vs. Peru live stream: Copa America prediction, TV channel, how to watch online, time, news, odds

33 minutes ago

Belarus tests border defence with powerful polonez missile system

33 minutes ago

Why Jacinta Allan has sparked outrage over a very short Facebook post about two major Aussie cities: 'Cringeworthy'

38 minutes ago

Boston Celtics Pick Up Team Option on Important Depth Piece

38 minutes ago

Kohli and Rohit retire from T20 internationals after India triumph

38 minutes ago

What Canada needs to advance to knockout stage at Copa America 2024

38 minutes ago

How Seahawks' Mike Macdonald plans to unlock Dre'Mont Jones